Robert J. Brooker

Importance of conserved acidic residues in mntH, the Nramp homolog of Escherichia coli.

A bioinformatic approach was used for the identification of residues that are conserved within the Nramp family of metal transporters. Site-directed mutagenesis was then carried out to change six conserved acidic residues (i.e., Asp-34, Glu-102, Asp-109, Glu-112, Glu-154, and Asp-238) in the E. coli Nramp homolog mntH. Of these six, five of them, Asp-34, Glu-102, Asp-109, Glu-112, and Asp-238 appear to be important for function since conservative substitutions at these sites result in a substantial loss of transport function. In addition, all of the residues within the signature sequence of the Nramp family, DPGN, were also mutated in this study. Each residue was changed to several different side chains, and of ten site-directed mutations made in this motif, only P35G showed any measurable level of 54Mn2+ uptake with a Vmax value of approximately 10% of wild-type and a slightly elevated Km value. Overall, the data are consistent with a model where helix breakers in the conserved DPGN motif in TMS-1 provide a binding pocket in which Asp-34, Asn-37, Asp-109, Glu-112 (and possibly other residues) are involved in the coordination of Mn2+. Other residues such as Glu-102 and Asp238 may play a role in the release of Mn2+ to the cytoplasm or may be involved in maintaining secondary structure.

Evidence That Transmembrane Segment 2 of the Lactose Permease Is Part of a Conformationally Sensitive Interface between the Two Halves of the Protein

A conserved motif, GXXX(D/E)(R/K)XG(R/K)(R/K), is found in a large group of evolutionarily related membrane proteins involved in the transport of small molecules across the membrane. This motif is located within the cytoplasmic side of transmembrane domain 2 (TM-2) and extends through the hydrophilic loop that connects transmembrane domains 2 and 3. The motif is repeated again in the second half of the protein. In a previous study concerning the loop 2/3 motif (Jessen-Marshall, A. E., Paul, N. J., and Brooker, R. J.(1995) J. Biol. Chem. 270, 16251-16257), it was shown that the conserved aspartate at the fifth position in the motif is critical for transport activity since a variety of site-directed mutations were found to greatly diminish the rate of transport. In the current study, two of these mutations, in which the conserved aspartate was changed to threonine or serine, were used as parental strains to isolate second site suppressor mutations that restore transport function. A total of 10 different second site mutations were identified among a screen of 19 independent mutants. One of the suppressors was found within loop 1/2 in which Thr-45 was changed to arginine. Since the conserved aspartate and position 45 are at opposite ends of TM-2, these results suggest that the role of the conserved aspartate residue in loop 2/3 is to influence the topology of TM-2. Surprisingly, the majority of suppressor mutations were found in the second half of the permease. All of these are expected to alter helix topology in either of two ways. Some of the mutations involved residues within transmembrane segments 7 and 11 that produced substantial changes in side chain volume: TM-7 (Cys-234 Trp or Phe, Gln-241 Leu, and Phe-247 Val) and TM-11 (Ser-366 Phe). Alternatively, other mutations were highly disruptive substitutions at the ends of transmembrane segments or within hydrophilic loops (Gly-257 Asp, Val-367 Glu, Ala-369 Pro, and a 5-codon insertion into loop 11/12). It is hypothesized that the effects of these suppressor mutations are to alter the helical topologies in the second half of the protein to facilitate a better interaction with the first half. Overall, these results are consistent with a transport model in which TM-2 acts as an important interface between the two halves of the lactose permease. According to our tertiary model, this interaction occurs between TM-2 and TM-11.

Isolation of lactose permease mutants which recognize arabinose

In the present study lactose permease mutants were isolated which recognize the monosaccharide, L-arabinose. Although the wild-type permease exhibits a poor recognition for L-arabinose, seven independent mutants were identified by their ability to grow on L-arabinose minimal plates. When subjected to DNA sequencing, it was found that all seven of these mutants were single-site mutations in which alanine 177 was changed to valine. The wild type and valine 177 mutant were then analyzed with regard to their abilities to recognize and transport monosaccharides and disaccharides. Free L-arabinose was shown to competitively inhibit [14C]-lactose transport yielding a Ki value of 121 mM for the Val177 mutant and a much higher value of 320 mM for the wild-type. Among several monosaccharides, D-glucose as well as L-arabinose inhibited lactose transport in the Val177 mutant to a significantly greater extent, while D-arabinose and D-xylose only caused a slight inhibition. On the other hand, kinetic studies with sugars which are normally recognized by the wild-type permease such as [14C]-galactose and [14C]-lactose revealed that the Val177 mutant and wild-type strains had similar transport characteristics for these two sugars. Overall, these results are consistent with the notion that the Val177 substitution causes an enhanced recognition for particular sugars (i.e. L-arabinose) but does not universally affect the recognition and unidirectional transport for all sugars. This idea is further supported by the observation that site-directed mutants containing isoleucine, leucine, phenylalanine, or proline at position 177 also were found to possess an enhanced recognition for L-arabinose.

An Analysis of Suppressor Mutations Suggests That the Two Halves of the Lactose Permease Function in a Symmetrical Manner

A conserved motif, GXXX(D/E)(R/K)XG[X](R/K)(R/K), is located in loop 2/3 and loop 8/9 in the lactose permease, and also in hundreds of evolutionarily related transporters. The importance of conserved residues in loop 8/9 was previously investigated (Pazdernik, N. J., Jessen-Marshall, A. E., and Brooker, R. J. (1997)J. Bacteriol. 179, 735–741). Although this loop was tolerant of many substitutions, a few mutations in the first position of the motif were shown to dramatically decrease lactose transport. In the current study, a mutant at the first position in the motif having very low lactose transport, Leu280, was used as a parental strain to isolate second-site revertants that restore function. A total of 23 independent mutants were sequenced and found to have a second amino acid substitution at several locations (G46C, G46S, F49L, A50T, L212Q, L216Q, S233P, C333G, F354C, G370C, G370S, and G370V). A kinetic analysis revealed that the first-site mutation, Leu280, had a slightly better affinity for lactose compared with the wild-type strain, but its V max for lactose transport was over 30-fold lower. The primary effect of the second-site mutations was to increase the V max for lactose transport, in some cases, to levels that were near the wild-type value. When comparing this study to second-site mutations obtained from loop 2/3 defective strains, a striking observation was made. Mutations in three regions of the protein, codons 45–50, 234–241, and 366–370, were able to restore functionality to both loop 2/3 and loop 8/9 defects. These results are discussed within the context of a C1/C2 alternating conformation model in which lactose translocation occurs by a conformational change at the interface between the two halves of the protein.

Roles of Charged Residues in the Conserved Motif, G-X-X-X-D/E-R/K-X-G-[X]-R/K-R/K, of the Lactose Permease of Escherichia coli

Abstract. The lactose permease is a polytopic membrane protein that has a duplicated conserved motif, GXXX(D/E)(R/K)XG[X](R/K)(R/K), located in cytoplasmic loops 2/3 and 8/9. In the current study, the roles of the basic residues and the acidic residue were investigated in greater detail. Neutral substitutions of two positive charges in loop 2/3 were tolerated, while a triple mutant resulted in a complete loss of expression. Neutral substitutions of a basic residue in loop 8/9 (i.e., K289I) also diminished protein stability. By comparison, neutral substitutions affecting the negative charge in loop 2/3 had normal levels of expression, but were defective in transport. A double mutant (D68T/N284D), in which the aspartate of loop 2/3 was moved to loop 8/9, did not have appreciable activity, indicating that the negative charge in the conserved motif could not be placed in loop 8/9 to recover lactose transport activity. An analysis of site-directed mutants in loop 7/8 and loop 8/9 indicated that an alteration in the charge distribution across transmembrane segment 8 was not sufficient to alleviate a defect caused by the loss of a negative charge in loop 2/3. To further explore this phenomenon, the double mutant, D68T/N284D, was used as a parental strain to isolate suppressor mutations which restored function. One mutant was obtained in which an acidic residue in loop 11/12 was changed to a basic residue (i.e., Glu-374 → Lys). Overall, the results of this study suggest that the basic residues in the conserved motif play a role in protein insertion and/or stability, and that the negative charge plays a role in conformational changes.

A Revised Model for the Structure and Function of the Lactose Permease EVIDENCE THAT A FACE ON TRANSMEMBRANE SEGMENT 2 IS IMPORTANT FOR CONFORMATIONAL CHANGES

The lactose permease is an integral membrane protein that cotransports H+ and lactose into the bacterial cytoplasm. Previous work has shown that bulky substitutions at glycine 64, which is found on the cytoplasmic edge of transmembrane segment 2 (TMS-2), cause a substantial decrease in the maximal velocity of lactose uptake without significantly affecting theK m values (Jessen-Marshall, A. E., Parker, N. J., and Brooker, R. J. (1997) J. Bacteriol.179, 2616–2622). In the current study, mutagenesis was conducted along the face of TMS-2 that contains glycine-64. Single amino acid substitutions that substantially changed side-chain volume at codons 52, 57, 59, 63, and 66 had little or no effect on transport activity, whereas substitutions at codons 49, 53, 56, and 60 were markedly defective and/or had lower levels of expression. According to helical wheel plots, Phe-49, Ser-53, Ser-56, Gln-60, and Gly-64 form a continuous stripe along one face of TMS-2. Several of the TMS-2 mutants (S56Y, S56L, S56Q, Q60A, and Q60V) were used as parental strains to isolate mutants that restore transport activity. These mutations were either first-site mutations or second-site suppressors in TMS-1, TMS-2, TMS-7 or TMS-11. A kinetic analysis showed that the suppressors had a higher rate of lactose transport compared with the corresponding parental strains. Overall, the results of this study are consistent with the notion that a face on TMS-2, containing Phe-49, Ser-53, Ser-56, Gln-60, and Gly-64, plays a critical role in conformational changes associated with lactose transport. We hypothesize that TMS-2 slides across TMS-7 and TMS-11 when the lactose permease interconverts between the C1 and C2 conformations. This idea is discussed within the context of a revised model for the structure of the lactose permease.

The conserved motif in hydrophilic loop 2/3 and loop 8/9 of the lactose permease of Escherichia coli. Analysis of suppressor mutations.

Abstract. The major facilitator superfamily (MFS) of transport proteins, which includes the lactose permease of Escherichia coli, contains a conserved motif G-X-X-X-D/E-R/K-X-G-R/K-R/K in the loops that connect transmembrane segments 2 and 3, and transmembrane segments 8 and 9. In three previous studies (Jessen-Marshall, A.E., & Brooker, R.J. 1996. J. Biol. Chem.271:1400–1404; Jessen-Marshall, A.E., Parker, N., & Brooker, R.J. 1997. J. Bacteriol.179:2616–2622; and Pazdernik, N., Cain, S.M., & Brooker, R.J. 1997. J. Biol. Chem.272:26110–26116), suppressor mutations at twenty different sites were identified which restore function to mutant permeases that have deleterious mutations in the conserved loop 2/3 or loop 8/9 motif. In the current study, several of these second-site suppressor mutations have been separated from the original mutation in the conserved motif. The loop 2/3 suppressors were then coupled to a loop 8/9 mutation (P280L) and the loop 8/9 suppressors were coupled to a loop 2/3 mutation (i.e., G64S) to determine if the suppressors could restore function only to a loop 2/3 mutation, a loop 8/9 mutation, or both.The single parent mutations changing the first position in loop 2/3 (i.e., G64S) and loop 8/9 (i.e., P280L) had less than 4% lactose transport activity. Interestingly, most of the suppressors were very inhibitory when separated from the parent mutation. Two suppressors, A50T and G370V, restored substantial transport activity when individually coupled to the mutation in loop 2/3 and also when coupled to the corresponding mutation in loop 8/9. In other words, these suppressors could alleviate a defect imposed by mutations in either half of the permease. From a kinetic analysis, these suppressors were shown to exert their effects by increasing the Vmax values for lactose transport compared with the single G64S and P280L strains. These results are discussed within the context of our model in which the two halves of the lactose permease interact at a rotationally symmetrical interface, and that lactose transport is mediated by conformational changes at the interface.

Evidence That Highly Conserved Residues of Transmembrane Segment 6 of Escherichia coli MntH Are Important for Transport Activity

Nramp (natural resistance-associated macrophage protein) family members have been characterized in mammals, yeast, and bacteria as divalent metal ion/H(+) symporters. In previous work, a bioinformatic approach was used for the identification of residues that are conserved within the Nramp family [Haemig, H. A., and Brooker, R. J. (2004) J. Membr. Biol. 201 (2), 97-107]. On the basis of site-directed mutagenesis of highly conserved negatively charged residues, a model was proposed for the metal binding site of the Escherichia coli homologue, MntH. In this study, we have focused on the highly conserved residues, including two histidines, of transmembrane segment 6 (TMS-6). Multiple mutants were made at the eight conserved sites (i.e., Gly-205, Ala-206, Met-209, Pro-210, His-211, Leu-215, His-216, and Ser-217) in TMS-6 of E. coli MntH. Double mutants involving His-211 and His-216 were also created. The results indicate the side chain volume of these residues is critically important for function. In most cases, only substitutions that are closest in side chain volume still permit transport. In addition, the K(m) for metal binding is largely unaffected by mutations in TMS-6, whereas V(max) values were decreased in all mutants characterized kinetically. Thus, these residues do not appear to play a role in metal binding. Instead, they may comprise an important face on TMS-6 that is critical for protein conformational changes during transport. Also, in contrast to other studies, our data do not strongly indicate that the conserved histidine residues play a role in the pH regulation of metal transport.

A triple mutant, K319N/H322Q/E325Q, of the lactose permease cotransports H+ with thiodigalactoside.

Abstract. In a previous study, we characterized a lactose permease mutant (K319N/E325Q) that can transport H+ ions with sugar. This result was surprising because other studies had suggested that Glu-325 plays an essential role in H+ binding. To determine if the lactose permease contains one or more auxiliary H+ binding sites, we began with the K319N/E325Q strain, which catalyzes a sugar-dependent H+ leak, and isolated third site suppressor mutations that blocked the H+ leak. Three types of suppressors were obtained: H322Y, H322R, and M299I. These mutations blocked the H+ leak and elevated the apparent Km value for lactose. The M299I and H322Y suppressors could still transport H+ with β-d-thiodigalactoside (TDG), but the H322R strain appeared uncoupled for H+/sugar cotransport.Four mutant strains containing a nonionizable substitution at codon 322 (H322Q) were analyzed. None of these were able to catalyze uphill accumulation of lactose, however, all showed some level of substrate-induced proton accumulation. The level seemed to vary based on the substrate being analyzed (lactose or TDG). Most interestingly, a triple mutant, K319N/H322Q/E325Q, catalyzed robust H+ transport with TDG. These novel results suggest an alternative mechanism of lactose permease cation binding and transport, possibly involving hydronium ion (H3O+).

Control of H+/lactose coupling by ionic interactions in the lactose permease of Escherichia coli

A combinatorial approach was used to study putative interactions among six ionizable residues (Asp-240, Glu-269, Arg-302, Lys-319, His-322, and Glu-325) in the lactose permease. Neutral mutations were made involving five ion pairs that had not been previously studied. Double mutants, R302L/E325Q and D240N/H322Q, had moderate levels of downhill [14C]-lactose transport. Mutants in which only one of these six residues was left unchanged (pentuple mutants) were also made. A Pent269− mutant (in which only Glu-269 remains) catalyzed a moderate level of downhill lactose transport. Pent240− and Pent 322+ also showed low levels of downhill lactose transport. Additionally, a Pent240− mutant exhibited proton transport upon addition of melibiose, but not lactose. This striking result demonstrates that neutralization of up to five residues of the lactose permease does not abolish proton transport. A mutant with neutral replacements at six ionic residues (hextuple mutant) had low levels of downhill lactose transport, but no uphill accumulation or proton transport. Since none of the mutants in this study catalyzes active accumulation of lactose, this is consistent with other reports that have shown that each residue is essential for proper coupling. Nevertheless, none of the six ionizable residues is individually required for substrate-induced proton cotransport. These results suggest that the H+ binding domain may be elsewhere in the permease or that cation binding may involve a flexible network of charged residues.