Robert K. McGinty

Histone H2A deubiquitinase activity of the Polycomb repressive complex PR-DUB.

Polycomb group (PcG) proteins are transcriptional repressors that control processes ranging from the maintenance of cell fate decisions and stem cell pluripotency in animals to the control of flowering time in plants. In Drosophila, genetic studies identified more than 15 different PcG proteins that are required to repress homeotic (HOX) and other developmental regulator genes in cells where they must stay inactive. Biochemical analyses established that these PcG proteins exist in distinct multiprotein complexes that bind to and modify chromatin of target genes. Among those, Polycomb repressive complex 1 (PRC1) and the related dRing-associated factors (dRAF) complex contain an E3 ligase activity for monoubiquitination of histone H2A (refs 1–4). Here we show that the uncharacterized Drosophila PcG gene calypso encodes the ubiquitin carboxy-terminal hydrolase BAP1. Biochemically purified Calypso exists in a complex with the PcG protein ASX, and this complex, named Polycomb repressive deubiquitinase (PR-DUB), is bound at PcG target genes in Drosophila. Reconstituted recombinant Drosophila and human PR-DUB complexes remove monoubiquitin from H2A but not from H2B in nucleosomes. Drosophila mutants lacking PR-DUB show a strong increase in the levels of monoubiquitinated H2A. A mutation that disrupts the catalytic activity of Calypso, or absence of the ASX subunit abolishes H2A deubiquitination in vitro and HOX gene repression in vivo. Polycomb gene silencing may thus entail a dynamic balance between H2A ubiquitination by PRC1 and dRAF, and H2A deubiquitination by PR-DUB.

Chemically ubiquitylated histone H2B stimulates hDot1L-mediated intranucleosomal methylation

Numerous post-translational modifications of histones have been described in organisms ranging from yeast to humans. Growing evidence for dynamic regulation of these modifications, position- and modification-specific protein interactions, and biochemical crosstalk between modifications has strengthened the ‘histone code’ hypothesis, in which histone modifications are integral to choreographing the expression of the genome. One such modification, ubiquitylation of histone H2B (uH2B) on lysine 120 (K120) in humans, and lysine 123 in yeast, has been correlated with enhanced methylation of lysine 79 (K79) of histone H3 (refs 5–8), by K79-specific methyltransferase Dot1 (KMT4). However, the specific function of uH2B in this crosstalk pathway is not understood. Here we demonstrate, using chemically ubiquitylated H2B, a direct stimulation of hDot1L-mediated intranucleosomal methylation of H3 K79. Two traceless orthogonal expressed protein ligation (EPL) reactions were used to ubiquitylate H2B site-specifically. This strategy, using a photolytic ligation auxiliary and a desulphurization reaction, should be generally applicable to the chemical ubiquitylation of other proteins. Reconstitution of our uH2B into chemically defined nucleosomes, followed by biochemical analysis, revealed that uH2B directly activates methylation of H3 K79 by hDot1L. This effect is mediated through the catalytic domain of hDot1L, most likely through allosteric mechanisms. Furthermore, asymmetric incorporation of uH2B into dinucleosomes showed that the enhancement of methylation was limited to nucleosomes bearing uH2B. This work demonstrates a direct biochemical crosstalk between two modifications on separate histone proteins within a nucleosome.

RAD6-Mediated Transcription-Coupled H2B Ubiquitylation Directly Stimulates H3K4 Methylation in Human Cells

H2B ubiquitylation has been implicated in active transcription but is not well understood in mammalian cells. Beyond earlier identification of hBRE1 as the E3 ligase for H2B ubiquitylation in human cells, we now show (1) that hRAD6 serves as the cognate E2-conjugating enzyme; (2) that hRAD6, through direct interaction with hPAF-bound hBRE1, is recruited to transcribed genes and ubiquitylates chromatinized H2B at lysine 120; (3) that hPAF-mediated transcription is required for efficient H2B ubiquitylation as a result of hPAF-dependent recruitment of hBRE1-hRAD6 to the Pol II transcription machinery; (4) that H2B ubiquitylation per se does not affect the level of hPAF-, SII-, and p300-dependent transcription and likely functions downstream; and (5) that H2B ubiquitylation directly stimulates hSET1-dependent H3K4 di- and trimethylation. These studies establish the natural H2B ubiquitylation factors in human cells and also detail the mechanistic basis for H2B ubiquitylation and function during transcription.

Histone H2B ubiquitylation disrupts local and higher-order chromatin compaction

Regulation of chromatin structure involves histone post-translational modifications which can modulate intrinsic properties of the chromatin fiber to change the chromatin state. We used chemically defined nucleosome arrays to demonstrate that H2B ubiquitylation (uH2B), a modification associated with transcription, interferes with chromatin compaction and leads to an open and biochemically accessible fiber conformation. Importantly, these effects were specific for ubiquitin, as compaction of chromatin modified with a similar ubiquitin-sized protein, Hub1, was only weakly affected. Applying a fluorescence based method we found that uH2B acts through a mechanism distinct from H4 tail acetylation (acH4), a modification known to disrupt chromatin folding. Finally, incorporation of both uH2B and acH4 in nucleosomes resulted in synergistic inhibition of higher order chromatin structure formation, possibly a result of their distinct mode of action.

Recognition of a Mononucleosomal Histone Modification Pattern by BPTF via Multivalent Interactions.

Little is known about how combinations of histone marks are interpreted at the level of nucleosomes. The second PHD finger of human BPTF is known to specifically recognize histone H3 when methylated on lysine 4 (H3K4me2/3). Here, we examine how additional heterotypic modifications influence BPTF binding. Using peptide surrogates, three acetyllysine ligands are indentified for a PHD-adjacent bromodomain in BPTF via systematic screening and biophysical characterization. Although the bromodomain displays limited discrimination among the three possible acetyllysines at the peptide level, marked selectivity is observed for only one of these sites, H4K16ac, in combination with H3K4me3 at the mononucleosome level. In support, these two histone marks constitute a unique trans-histone modification pattern that unambiguously resides within a single nucleosomal unit in human cells, and this module colocalizes with these marks in the genome. Together, our data call attention to nucleosomal patterning of covalent marks in dictating critical chromatin associations.

Disulfide-directed histone ubiquitylation reveals plasticity in hDot1L activation

We have developed a readily accessible disulfide-directed methodology for the site-specific modification of histones by ubiquitin and ubiquitin-like proteins. The disulfide-linked analog of mono-ubiquitylated H2B stimulated the H3K79 methyltransferase activity of hDot1L to a similar extent as the native isopeptide linkage. This permitted structure-activity studies of ubiquitylated mononucleosomes that revealed plasticity in the mechanism of hDot1L stimulation and identified surfaces of ubiquitin important for activation.

Structure-activity analysis of semisynthetic nucleosomes: mechanistic insights into the stimulation of Dot1L by ubiquitylated histone H2B.

Post-translational modification of histones plays an integral role in regulation of genomic expression through modulation of chromatin structure and function. Chemical preparations of histones bearing these modifications allows for comprehensive in vitro mechanistic investigation into their action to deconvolute observations from genome-wide studies in vivo. Previously, we reported the semisynthesis of ubiquitylated histone H2B (uH2B) using two orthogonal expressed protein ligation reactions. Semisynthetic uH2B, when incorporated into nucleosomes, directly stimulates methylation of histone H3 lysine 79 (K79) by the methyltransferase, disruptor of telomeric silencing-like (Dot1L). Although recruitment of Dot1L to the nucleosomal surface by uH2B could be excluded, comprehensive mechanistic analysis was precluded by systematic limitations in the ability to generate uH2B in large scale. Here we report a highly optimized synthesis of ubiquitylated H2B bearing a G76A point mutation u(G76A)H2B, yielding tens of milligrams of ubiquitylated protein. u(G76A)H2B is indistinguishable from the native uH2B by Dot1L, allowing for detailed studies of the resultant trans-histone crosstalk. Kinetic and structure-activity relationship analyses using u(G76A)H2B suggest a noncanonical role for ubiquitin in the enhancement of the chemical step of H3K79 methylation. Furthermore, titration of the level of uH2B within the nucleosome revealed a 1:1 stoichiometry of Dot1L activation.

Nucleosome Structure and Function

When fully extended, one copy of the three billion base pair human genome reaches a length of over two meters. Yet, it must be packaged into the nucleus of a cell with an average diameter of less than 10 μm. Within this context, specific segments of the genome must be transcriptionally active or repressed in a coordinated fashion to allow a cell to react to its ever-changing environment. This is akin to arranging 30 miles of thread inside a basketball such that at moment’s notice key segments can be accessed. To establish such compaction while maintaining coordinated accessibility, organisms ranging from yeast to man organize their genomes in a polymeric complex called chromatin. The fundamental unit of the chromatin polymer is the nucleosome, which repeats every 160 to 240 bp across the genome.1 Each nucleosome contains a nucleosome core, composed of an octameric complex of the core histone proteins, which forms a spool to wrap 145 to 147 bp of DNA. The nucleosome core is connected to the adjacent nucleosome core through a segment of linker DNA, which often associates with the linker histone protein (H1 or H5). The nucleosome core with ∼165 bp of DNA together with the linker histone is called the chromatosome.2 The chromatosome and the additional linker DNA constitutes a nucleosome.2 Despite these technical definitions, the nucleosome core particle is often colloquially referred to as the nucleosome. The nucleosome serves three primary functions. First, it brings about the first level of genomic compaction, organizing ∼200 bp of DNA. Second, the nucleosome acts as a signaling hub for chromatin-templated processes by providing a scaffold for the binding of chromatin enzymes and displaying a combinatorial array of post-translational modifications (PTMs). This array of PTMs further regulates the recruitment of chromatin enzymes3 and tunes both nucleosome stability4 and the higher-order compaction of chromatin.5−7 Third, the nucleosome can self-assemble into higher-order chromatin structures, allowing for further compaction of the genome. The first level of higher-order compaction is the 30 nm chromatin fiber for which several models have been created based on experimental data using cryogenic-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) and X-ray crystallography.8 This review focuses on recent advances in our understanding of the structure and function of the nucleosome and is divided into four parts. First, we present a primer covering the fundamentals of the nucleosome core particle structure determined at atomic scale by X-ray crystallography in 1997.9 Next we discuss recent insights into the role of DNA sequence in the structure of nucleosomal DNA based on structure–function studies of nucleosome core particles containing derivatives of the Widom 601 nucleosome positioning sequence.10 We then introduce patterns of nucleosome recognition by chromatin factors using recent crystal structures and NMR and cryo-EM models of peptide and protein macromolecular chromatin factors bound to the nucleosome core particle. Finally, we will compare a recent cryo-EM model for the 30 nm chromatin fiber11 to two previous models based on crystallographic and cryo-EM data.12,13

The n-SET Domain of Set1 Regulates H2B Ubiquitylation-Dependent H3K4 Methylation

Past studies have documented a crosstalk between H2B ubiquitylation (H2Bub) and H3K4 methylation, but little (if any) direct evidence exists explaining the mechanism underlying H2Bub-dependent H3K4 methylation on chromatin templates. Here, we took advantage of an in vitro histone methyltransferase assay employing a reconstituted yeast Set1 complex (ySet1C) and a recombinant chromatin template containing fully ubiquitylated H2B to gain valuable insights. Combined with genetic analyses, we demonstrate that the n-SET domain within Set1, but not Swd2, is essential for H2Bub-dependent H3K4 methylation. Spp1, a homolog of human CFP1, is conditionally involved in this crosstalk. Our findings extend to the human Set1 complex, underscoring the conserved nature of this disease-relevant crosstalk pathway. As not all members of the H3K4 methyltransferase family contain n-SET domains, our studies draw attention to the n-SET domain as a predictor of an H2B ubiquitylation-sensing mechanism that leads to downstream H3K4 methylation.

A Semisynthetic Strategy to Generate Phosphorylated and Acetylated Histone H2B

Proteins are subject to numerous post-translational modifications (PTMs) that can alter the chemical structure, and hence function, of the molecule.[1] The astonishing diversity of PTMs possible on proteins is exemplified by histones, nuclear proteins that form the protein core of the nucleosome particle.[2] Histones can be modified in a variety of ways including acetylation, phosphorylation, methylation, ADP-ribosylation and ubiquitylation.[3] Moreover, many, if not all, of these modifications can occur in combination.[4, 5] Indeed, there is growing evidence that functional cross-talk between histone PTMs is essential for the regulation of gene expression[3] and ultimately cell fate and identity.[6] Biochemical studies into the role of histone PTMs are often confounded by the difficulty associated with obtaining large quantities of homogeneously modified proteins. For this reason chemical approaches to obtaining post-translationally modified histones have received considerable attention in recent years.[7–9] Among the available strategies, the protein ligation approach, expressed protein ligation (EPL), offers the most flexibility in terms of the number and type of PTMs that can be incorporated.[10] To date, EPL has been used to generate phosphorylated,[8] acetylated, and methylated forms of histone H3,[7] acetylated H4,[11] and ubiquitylated H2B.[12] Nonetheless, many modified histones have yet to be accessed using semi-synthesis. A notable case in point is the N-terminal region of H2B, which has been described to possess several PTMs, including (poly)lysine acetylation and serine 14 phosphorylation, which have been implicated in transcription[13] and apoptotic chromatin compaction,[14] respectively. Differentially modified semi-synthetic H2B analogs would be useful to assess the affect of acetylation on both antibody recognition as well as on the efficiency of phosphorylation. In this report, we describe a general semi-synthetic route to H2B that allows the installation of PTMs into an otherwise native polypeptide background.