Robert L. Clark

Effects of artemisinins on reticulocyte count and relationship to possible embryotoxicity in confirmed and unconfirmed malarial patients

Rat studies suggest that artemisinin-induced decreases in reticulocyte count are a marker for embryotoxicity (in one study, r = 0.82; p < 0.05). In clinical studies, therapeutic doses of artemisinins induced decreases in reticulocyte count that were larger in five of six groups of healthy volunteers (mean decreases of 47-75%) than in 12 groups of patients with malaria (mean decreases of 0-34% and incidences of low reticulocyte count of 0.6-18%). Malaria causes hypoferremia and drug concentrates in infected red cells so, among the explanations for the lesser decreases in patients, is that malaria protects against artemisinin-induced decreases in reticulocyte count by reducing the target tissue levels of active drug and/or ferrous iron which activates the drug to toxic free radicals. The disease could also protect against embryotoxicity in which case pregnant women without malaria would be at greater risk of artemisinin-induced embryotoxicity. Malaria protection against artesunate toxicity has been observed in rats. No artemisinin-induced embryotoxicity has been identified in limited numbers of women with confirmed malaria in the first trimester. However, in large parts of tropical Africa, malaria treatment is based on fever rather than confirmation of parasitemia and many pregnant women without malaria are exposed to antimalarials. No clinical studies have been conducted on uninfected women for whom pregnancy was identified and then an artemisinin was administered subsequently. Testing in rats and/or humans is needed to determine if malaria protects against reticulocytopenia and embryotoxicity and whether the parasite is a more or less sensitive target than the embryo and reticulocyte.

Artesunate and artelinic acid: association of embryotoxicity, reticulocytopenia, and delayed stimulation of hematopoiesis in pregnant rats

The artemisinin antimalarials cause embryo death and malformations in animals by killing embryonic erythroblasts. Groups of pregnant rats (N = 4) were administered 35 and 48 µmol/kg artesunate and 17.2, 28.7, 48, 96, and 191 µmol/kg artelinic acid as a single oral dose on gestational day (GD) 12. Litters were examined on GD21. The ED(50) for embryo death with artelinic acid (23.4 µmol/kg) was just slightly lower than that for decreased reticulocyte count at 24 hr postdose (33.5 µmol/kg) and both had similarly steep dose responses (maximal effects of total litter loss and ∼60% decreases in reticulocyte count at 48 µmol/kg). Results with artesunate were similar. The correlation coefficient between embryo death and decreased reticulocyte count was 0.82 (p<0.01). The close relationship between embryotoxicity and reticulocytopenia is suggestive of a common mechanism-artemisinin-induced mitochondrial damage leading to cell death. At 9 days postdose, treatment with artesunate and artelinic acid also caused increases in counts of reticulocytes, lymphocytes, basophils, and monocytes (up to 3.7 ×, 1.7 ×, 4.7 ×, and 1.7 × control, respectively). This stimulation of hematopoiesis may have been mediated by the direct oxidative conversion of artesunate or artelinic acid to the artemisininyl hydroperoxide within the bone marrow cells or by an indirect increase in reactive oxygen species. The high correlation between embryotoxicity and reticulocytopenia further supports the assertion that therapeutic dosage regimens of artemisinins that cause decreases in reticulocyte count in pregnant women during the putative critical period (approximately postconception wk 3 to 9) are at risk of also causing adverse effects on the embryo.

Localization of artesunate and its derivatives in the pregnant rat and fetus following oral administration and relationship to developmental toxicity

BACKGROUND The antimalarial drug artesunate affects erythroid cells leading to developmental toxicity and adult reticulocytopenia. We report on a kinetic study in rats and the tissue distribution of radioactivity following oral administration of [(3)H]-artesunate to pregnant rats using quantitative whole-body autoradiography (QWBA). METHODS Rats were dosed orally with chlorproguanil/dapsone/artesunate (including 11.8 mg/kg artesunate) and plasma concentrations of artesunate and the active metabolite dihydroartemisinin (DHA) were determined. In the QWBA study, 6 rats received 13 mg/kg [(3)H]-artesunate on day 18 of gestation. Groups of 2 rats were euthanized at 1, 6, and 24 hours after dosing, rapidly frozen, and sectioned in a cryostat. Sagittal sections were freeze-dried and placed in contact with imaging plates. Tissue concentrations of radioactivity were quantified. RESULTS Systemic exposure to DHA was up to 22-fold higher than the parent compound and was higher in non-pregnant females than males. In the QWBA study, high concentrations of radioactivity were seen in maternal tissues involved in absorption and excretion, the bone marrow and spleen. Fetal blood and liver levels were 3.8- to 8.8-fold higher than maternal blood levels at all timepoints. CONCLUSIONS Excluding tissues involved in absorption and excretion, the highest concentrations of radioactivity were observed in tissues involved in hemoglobin synthesis and/or destruction in both the mother and the fetus and likely account for the maternal reticulocytopenia and embryotoxicity. Radioactivity concentrations in the fetal blood were 2.1- to 2.8-fold higher than maternal bone marrow at all timepoints and this difference could contribute to the lower dose threshold for embryotoxicity.

Dihydroartemisinin (DHA) Treatment Causes an Arrest of Cell Division and Apoptosis in Rat Embryonic Erythroblasts in Whole Embryo Culture

Within 24 hr after oral administration of the antimalarial artesunate to rats on Day 10 or 11 postcoitum (pc), there is depletion of embryonic erythroblasts (EEbs), leading to embryo malformation and death. The proximate agent is dihydroartemisinin (DHA), the primary metabolite. We investigated the causes of EEb depletion by evaluating effects of DHA on EEbs in whole embryo culture (WEC). Rat embryos cultured starting on Day 9 pc were treated with 1 or 7 μM DHA for 24 hr starting after 19 hr of culture (∼Day 10 pc) and for 2 to 12 hr starting after 43 hr of culture (∼Day 11 pc). DHA effects indicating the depletion of EEbs were paling of the visceral yolk sac and reductions in visible blood cells, H&E-stained normal (Type II or III) EEbs, and dividing (BrdU-stained) EEbs. DHA-induced abnormal cell division was indicated by increases in symmetric and asymmetric binuclear cells. DHA-induced apoptosis was indicated by increases in TUNEL- and Caspase-3-positive cells and EEbs with fragmented nuclei. In addition, although the overall number of EEbs was decreasing, DHA caused increases in the numbers of circulating early-stage (Type I or earlier) EEbs that could not be accounted for by cell division, suggesting the release of new, less sensitive erythroblasts from the yolk sac. In summary, treatment of Day 10 or 11 pc rat embryos with DHA in WEC resulted in defective and arrested cell division in EEbs followed by apoptosis, suggesting a mechanism for their depletion after artesunate treatment in vivo.

Developmental toxicity studies of lumefantrine and artemether in rats and rabbits

The combination of artemether plus lumefantrine is a type of artemisinin-based combination therapy (ACT) recommended by the World Health Organization for uncomplicated falciparum malaria except in the first trimester of pregnancy. The first trimester restriction was based on the marked embryotoxicity in animals (including embryo death and cardiac and skeletal malformations) of artemisinins such as artesunate, dihydroartemisinin, and artemether. Before recommending ACTs for use in the first trimester, the World Health Organization has requested that all information relevant to the assessment of risk of ACTs to the embryo be made available to the public. This report describes the results of embryo-fetal development studies of artemether alone, lumefantrine alone, and the combination in rats and rabbits as well as toxicokinetic studies of lumefantrine in pregnant rabbits. The developmental no-effect levels for lumefantrine were 300 mg/kg/day in rats (based on a 25% decrease in litter size at 1000 mg/kg/day) and 1000 mg/kg/day in rabbits. The calculated safety margins based on human equivalent dose and plasma Cmax and AUC values were in the range of 2.5- to 17-fold. The developmental no-effect levels for artemether were 3 mg/kg/day in rats and 25 mg/kg/day in rabbits. Lumefantrine caused no teratogenicity and was not a potent embryotoxin in rats and rabbits. Expected artemisinin-like findings were seen with artemether alone and with artemether/lumefantrine combined except that no malformations were observed. There were no findings in pregnant rats and rabbits that would cause increased concern for the use of artemether-lumefantrine in the first trimester compared to other ACTs.

The Potential Role for Corticosterone in the Induction of Cleft Palate in Mice After Treatment With a Selective NK‐1 Receptor Antagonist, Casopitant (GW679769B)

BACKGROUND Casopitant is a potent and selective NK-1 receptor antagonist that has shown clinical efficacy in the prevention of chemotherapy-induced and postoperative-induced nausea and vomiting. METHODS In an embryo-fetal development study, pregnant mice were given vehicle (sterile water) or doses of 30, 100, or 300 mg/kg/day casopitant on Gestation Day (GD) 6 to 15. Fetuses were evaluated for external, visceral, and skeletal abnormalities on GD 18. In a follow-on study to investigate casopitant-induced hormonal changes during the developmental period for palate formation, pregnant mice were given vehicle (sterile water) or 300 mg/kg/day casopitant once daily on GD 6 to 13. Blood was collected on GD 13 at various time-points for measurement of plasma adrenocorticotropic hormone and corticosterone (CRT) concentrations. RESULTS There was no evidence of developmental toxicity in mice at 30 or 100 mg/kg/day but 9% of fetuses at 300 mg/kg/day had cleft palate. Mice are sensitive to glucocorticoid-induced cleft palates, and NK-1 antagonists are known to modulate the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis leading to increases in corticosterone. On GD 13, mean plasma adrenocorticotropic hormone levels at 300 mg/kg/day were elevated by approximately twofold from vehicle-treated levels at 1 hr post-dose and mean plasma CRT levels were elevated by 3, 5, and 10-fold at 0.5, 1, and 2 hr post-dose, respectively. CONCLUSIONS The increased level of CRT was in the range previously shown in the literature to cause cleft palates in mice and was likely the underlying mechanism behind casopitant-induced cleft palate in mice.

Animal Embryotoxicity Studies of Key Non-Artemisinin Antimalarials and Use in Women in the First Trimester: Embryotoxicity of Non-Artemisinin Antimalarials

The World Health Organization currently recommends quinine+clindamycin for use against malaria in the first trimester. This may soon change to recommending artemisinin‐based combination therapies (standard duration of dosing = 3 days). The non‐artemisinin partner drugs include amodiaquine, lumefantrine, mefloquine, piperaquine, sulfadoxine+pyrimethamine, and pyronaridine. For quinine, clindamycin, and mefloquine and the combinations of sulfadoxine+pyrimethamine and artemether+lumefantrine, there are reports (including studies without internal comparison groups) that combined describe 304 to >1100 exposures of women in the first trimester for each drug with no conclusive evidence of adverse effects on pregnancy at therapeutic doses. This is despite the fact that all of these drugs or drug combinations caused embryo deaths and/or malformations in at least one animal species and all except lumefantrine had at least one exposure ratio <1.

Improved safety margin for embryotoxicity in rats for the new endoperoxide artefenomel (OZ439) as compared to artesunate: CLARK et al.

BACKGROUND Combination medicines including an artemisinin are the mainstay of antimalarial therapy. Artemisinins are potent embryotoxicants in animal species due to their trioxane moiety. METHODS As part of its development, the new synthetic trioxolane antimalarial artefenomel (OZ439) was tested in rat whole embryo culture and in rat embryo-fetal toxicity studies with dosing throughout organogenesis or with a single dose on Gestational Day (GD) 12. The single-dose studies included groups treated with artesunate to allow a direct comparison of the embryotoxicity of the two antimalarials and included toxicokinetics hematology and histological examination of embryos. In addition, the distribution of artefenomel-related material in plasma was determined after the administration of 14 C-artefenomel. RESULTS Artefenomel and artesunate showed similar patterns of embryotoxicity including cardiovascular defects and resorption with a steep dose-response. They both also caused a depletion of circulating embryonic erythroblasts both in vitro and in vivo and decreases in maternal reticulocyte count. However, artefenomel was ∼250-fold less potent than the active metabolite of artesunate (dihydroartemisinin) as an embryotoxicant in vitro. The safety margin (based on AUC) for artefenomel administered on GD 12 was approximately 100-fold greater than that for artesunate. Also, unlike artesunate, artefenomel was not a selective developmental toxicant. CONCLUSIONS The lesser embryotoxicity of artefenomel is likely linked to its original design which included two blocking side groups that had been introduced to lower the reactivity with ferrous iron. Our data support the hypothesis that artefenomels improved safety margin is linked to a lower potential for inhibiting heme biosynthesis in embryonic erythroblasts.

Hypothesized cause of delayed hemolysis associated with intravenous artesunate

In recent publications, investigators described cases in which there was a delayed hemolysis following intravenous (IV) artesunate treatment. The delayed hemolysis event occurred at the nadir of blood hemoglobin concentration, i.e., at the time when blood hemoglobin concentration was switching from a progressive decline to a progressive increase. It is hypothesized that this nadir indicates the time when red cell production is resuming after having been arrested, the delayed hemolysis event is due to lysis of the first (aberrant) reticulocytes released once production is resumed and, therefore, that the hemolysis signals the resumption of red cell production. Since this delayed hemolysis has not been associated with a significant decrease in blood hemoglobin, the hemolytic event is not of particular concern even if it could be attributed to artesunate. More important than this hemolysis event was the preceding progressive anemia that lasted for up to 19 days. Both a decrease in reticulocyte production and a shortened life span of previously infected red cells likely contributed to the anemia. The question that remains to be answered is whether the progressive anemia that lasted 2-3 weeks in these patients was attributable solely to their severe malaria or was possibly enhanced and prolonged by the high plasma concentrations of artesunate associated with IV administration. Controlled clinical studies addressing this question may be needed.