Robert L. Kistner

Classification and Grading of Chronic Venous Disease in the Lower Limbs-A Consensus Statement-

Classification and grading of chronic venous disease in the lower limbs : A consensus statement

Diagnosis of Chronic Venous Disease of the Lower Extremities: The “CEAP” Classification

OBJECTIVE To test a new classification of chronic venous disease (CVD)--based on clinical, etiologic, anatomic, and pathophysiologic data (the CEAP system)--in a series of patients by using objective tests to establish all diagnoses. MATERIAL AND METHODS The CEAP classification was applied to 102 extremities in 70 consecutive patients with CVD. Diagnoses were based on objective testing with continuous-wave Doppler studies, duplex scanning, plethysmography, venous pressure, and phlebography, which were applied selectively (the more invasive methods were reserved for cases of greater severity). RESULTS Use of this classification provided an organized categorization of the key elements of the venous abnormalities in each case and clarified the interrelationships among the clinical manifestations, cause of the process, and anatomic distribution of involvement. For example, in this series of 102 extremities, 79% had primary venous disease, 18% had secondary disease, and 3% had congenital abnormalities. Ulcers were found in 7% of extremities with primary CVD and 44% with secondary CVD. Of the cases with ulceration, 43% were due to primary incompetence and 57% to postthrombotic disease. Reflux was the pathophysiologic problem in 86% of the total series and in 80% of ulcer cases. Similar relationships can be delineated for cases with varicose veins, edema, or skin changes. Study of the specific facets of the CEAP classification provided precise information about the cause and the effect of venous abnormalities that could be compared with cases in other series. CONCLUSION Use of the CEAP classification with diagnoses determined by objective testing accurately identifies categories of CVD. The objective date provide a clear description of the abnormalities in each case and may be used for analyses of meaningful relationships between categories of CVD. Adoption of this objective method of classifying CVD will facilitate interinstitutional studies.

Management of venous leg ulcers: clinical practice guidelines of the Society for Vascular Surgery ® and the American Venous Forum.

Thomas F. O’Donnell Jr, MD, Marc A. Passman, MD, William A. Marston, MD, William J. Ennis, DO, Michael Dalsing, MD, Robert L. Kistner, MD, Fedor Lurie, MD, PhD, Peter K. Henke, MD, Monika L. Gloviczki, MD, PhD, Bo G. Eklof, MD, PhD, Julianne Stoughton, MD, Sesadri Raju, MD, Cynthia K. Shortell, MD, Joseph D. Raffetto, MD, Hugo Partsch, MD, Lori C. Pounds, MD, Mary E. Cummings, MD, David L. Gillespie, MD, Robert B. McLafferty, MD, Mohammad Hassan Murad, MD, Thomas W. Wakefield, MD, and Peter Gloviczki, MD

The natural history of calf vein thrombosis: Lysis of thrombi and development of reflux

PURPOSE Although the fact is well accepted that deep venous thrombosis (DVT) of the iliac, femoral, and popliteal veins can lead to the post-thrombotic (postphlebitic) syndrome, the significance of isolated calf DVT on the development of late venous sequelae and physiologic calf dysfunction is unknown. The purpose of this study was to review the outcome of 58 limbs with isolated calf DVT and report the clinical, physiologic, and imaging results up to 6 years after the onset of DVT. METHODS The study consisted of 58 limbs of 54 patients in whom isolated calf vein DVT was diagnosed between 1990 and 1995. Proximal propagation of clot, lysis of thrombi, and development of symptomatic pulmonary emboli were examined. Of the patients, 28 received anticoagulation therapy, and 26 did not, but they had follow-up with serial duplex scans. At late follow-up 1 to 6 years later (median, 3 years), 23 patients were examined for the post-thrombotic syndrome, and all 23 underwent clinical examination, color-flow duplex scanning, and air plethysmography. RESULTS Proximal propagation of DVT from the calf veins into the popliteal or thigh veins occurred in 2 of 49 cases (4%) within 2 weeks of diagnosis. No patient had clinically overt pulmonary emboli develop regardless of whether anticoagulation therapy was received or not. The most common site for calf DVT was the peroneal vein (71%). Complete lysis of calf thrombi was found in 88% of the cases by 3 months. At 3 years, 95% of the patients were either asymptomatic or mildly symptomatic, and 5% had discoloration of the limb. No ulcers occurred. By air plethysmography, physiologic abnormalities were found in 27% of the cases, which was not significantly different from normal controls. Valvular reflux by duplex scanning of the calf vein segment with DVT was found in 2 of 23 cases (9%). However, reflux in at least one venous segment not involved with DVT was found in 7 of 23 cases (30%), which was higher than, but not statistically different from, normal controls, with reflux occurring in 5 of 26 cases (19%). CONCLUSIONS Isolated calf vein DVT leads to few early complications (ie, clot propagation, pulmonary emboli) and few adverse sequelae at 3 years. The peroneal vein is most commonly involved and should be a part of the routine screening for DVT. Lysis of clot usually occurs by 3 months. Although valvular reflux rarely is found in the affected calf vein at 3 years, reflux may be found in adjacent uninvolved veins in approximately 30% of the cases. The question of whether this will lead to future sequelae, such as ulceration, will require longer follow-up.

Primary chronic venous disorders

Primary chronic venous disorders, which according to the CEAP classification are those not associated with an identifiable mechanism of venous dysfunction, are among the most common in Western populations. Varicose veins without skin changes are present in about 20% of the population while active ulcers may be present in as many as 0.5%. Primary venous disorders are thought to arise from intrinsic structural and biochemical abnormalities of the vein wall. Advanced cases may be associated with skin changes and ulceration arising from extravasation of macromolecules and red blood cells leading to endothelial cell activation, leukocyte diapedesis, and altered tissue remodeling with intense collagen deposition. Laboratory evaluation of patients with primary venous disorders includes venous duplex ultrasonography performed in the upright position, occasionally supplemented with plethysmography and, when deep venous reconstruction is contemplated, ascending and descending venography. Primary venous disease is most often associated with truncal saphenous insufficiency. Although historically treated with stripping of the saphenous vein and interruption and removal of major tributary and perforating veins, a variety of endovenous techniques are now available to ablate the saphenous veins and have generally been demonstrated to be safe and less morbid than traditional procedures. Sclerotherapy also has an important role in the management of telangiectasias; primary, residual, or recurrent varicosities without connection to incompetent venous trunks; and congenital venous malformations. The introduction of ultrasound guided foam sclerotherapy has broadened potential indications to include treatment of the main saphenous trunks, varicose tributaries, and perforating veins. Surgical repair of incompetent deep venous valves has been reported to be an effective procedure in nonrandomized series, but appropriate case selection is critical to successful outcomes.

The Influence of Obesity on Chronic Venous Disease

The authors investigate the impact of overweight in patients with chronic venous disease and determine if the eventual effect can be explained by increased venous reflux alone. Patients with chronic venous disease who underwent duplex-ultrasound scanning at the Vascular Center, Straub Clinic and Hospital during 1999 were classified according to the clinical, etiologic, anatomic, and pathophysiologic (CEAP) system and body mass index (kg/M2) was calculated. Reflux duration was measured in seconds and peak reverse flow velocity in cm/second. Multisegment reflux score (total score) was calculated for both reflux duration and peak reverse flow velocity. The reflux pattern and body mass index were correlated to the clinical presentation. Four hundred and one lower extremities (204 right, 197 left) in 272 patients (173 female) with a mean age of 60 years (range 14-90) were investigated. The mean body mass index was 28.9 (±7.76). One hundred sixty-seven patients (61%) were overweight (body mass index 25 kg/M2 or more). There was a significant association between body mass index and the clinical severity (p < 0.001). This association persisted after adjustments for total peak reverse flow velocity and total reflux score were made (p <0.001). Overweight patients were more likely to have skin changes and ulceration (p < 0.001) than patients with a body mass index less than 25 kg/m2, despite similar values for total reflux time (p = 0.92) and total peak reverse flow velocity (p = 0.98). There was an ethnic difference, with Pacific Islanders being significantly heavier and younger compared to patients of white, Asian and Filipino ancestries. The variations in the frequency of skin changes were consistent with ethnic differences in body mass index. The correlation of body mass index with clinical severity independent of reflux measurements indicates that the effect of overweight may involve a mechanism separate from local effects on venous flow. Overweight appears to be a separate risk factor for increased severity of skin changes in patients with chronic venous disease.

Deep axial reflux, an important contributor to skin changes or ulcer in chronic venous disease ☆

OBJECTIVE We undertook this cross-sectional study to investigate the distribution of venous reflux and effect of axial reflux in superficial and deep veins and to determine the clinical value of quantifying peak reverse flow velocity and reflux time in limbs with chronic venous disease. PATIENTS AND METHODS Four hundred one legs (127 with skin changes, 274 without skin changes) in 272 patients were examined with duplex ultrasound scanning, and peak reverse flow velocity and reflux time were measured. Both parameters were graded on a scale of 0 to 4. The sum of reverse flow scores was calculated from seven venous segments, three in superficial veins (great saphenous vein at saphenofemoral junction, great saphenous vein below knee, small saphenous vein) and four in deep veins (common femoral vein, femoral vein, deep femoral vein, popliteal vein). Axial reflux was defined as reflux in the great saphenous vein above and below the knee or in the femoral vein to the popliteal vein below the knee. Reflux parameters and presence or absence of axial reflux in superficial or deep veins were correlated with prevalence of skin changes or ulcer (CEAP class 4-6). RESULTS The most common anatomic presentation was incompetence in all three systems (superficial, deep, perforator; 46%) or in superficial or perforator veins (28%). Isolated reflux in one system only was rare (15%; superficial, 28 legs; deep, 14 legs; perforator, 18 legs). Deep venous incompetence was present in 244 legs (61%). If common femoral vein reflux was excluded, prevalence of deep venous incompetence was 52%. The cause, according to findings at duplex ultrasound scanning, was primary in 302 legs (75%) and secondary in 99 legs (25%). Presence of axial deep venous reflux increased significantly with prevalence of skin changes or ulcer (C4-C6; odds ratio [OR], 2.7; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.56-4.67). Of 110 extremities with incompetent popliteal vein, 81 legs had even femoral vein reflux, with significantly more skin changes or ulcer, compared with 29 legs with popliteal reflux alone (P =.025). Legs with skin changes or ulcer had significantly higher total peak reverse flow velocity (P =.006), but the difference for total reflux time did not reach significance (P =.084) compared with legs without skin changes. In contrast, presence of axial reflux in superficial veins did not increase prevalence of skin changes (OR, 0.73; 95% CI, 0.44-1.2). Incompetent perforator veins were observed as often in patients with no skin changes (C0-C3, 215 of 274, 78%) as in patients with skin changes (C4-C6, 106 of 127, 83%; P =.25). CONCLUSION Continuous axial deep venous reflux is a major contributor to increased prevalence of skin changes or ulcer in patients with chronic venous disease compared with segmental deep venous reflux above or below the knee only. The total peak reverse flow velocity score is significantly higher in patients with skin changes or ulcer. It is questionable whether peak reverse flow velocity and reflux time can be used to quantify venous reflux; however, if they are used, peak reverse flow velocity seems to reflect venous malfunction more appropriately.

Multicenter assessment of venous reflux by duplex ultrasound

OBJECTIVE This prospective multicenter investigation was conducted to define the repeatability of duplex-based identification of venous reflux and the relative effect of key parameters on the reproducibility of the test. METHODS Repeatability was studied by having the same technologist perform duplicate tests, at the same time of the day, using the same reflux-provoking maneuver and with the patient in the same position. Reproducibility was examined by having two different technologists perform the test at the same time of the day, using the same reflux-provoking maneuver and with the patient in the same position. Facilitated reproducibility was studied by having two different technologists examine the same patients immediately after an educational intervention. Limits of agreement between two duplex scans were studied by changing three elements of the test: time of the day (morning vs afternoon), patients position (standing vs supine), and reflux initiation (manual vs automatic compression-decompression). RESULTS The study enrolled 17 healthy volunteers and 57 patients with primary chronic venous disease. Repeatability of reflux time measurements in deep veins did not significantly differ with the time of day, the patients position, or the reflux-provoking maneuver. Reflux measurements in the superficial veins were more repeatable (P < .05) when performed in the morning with the patient standing. The agreement between the clinical interpretations significantly depended on a selected cut point (Spearmans ρ, -0.4; P < .01). Interpretations agreed in 93.4% of the replicated measurements when a 0.5-second cut point was selected. The training intervention improved the frequency of agreement to 94.4% (κ = 0.9). Alternations of the time of the duplex scan, the patients position, and the reflux-provoking maneuver significantly decreased reliability. CONCLUSIONS This study provides evidence to develop a new standard for duplex ultrasound detection of venous reflux. Reports should include information on the time of the test, the patients position, and the provoking maneuver used. Adopting a uniform cut point of 0.5 second for pathologic reflux can significantly improve the reliability of reflux detection. Implementation of a standard protocol should elevate the minimal standard for agreement between repeated tests from the current 70% to at least 80% and with more rigid standardization, to 90%.

Reflux from Thigh to Calf, the Major Pathology in Chronic Venous Ulcer Disease: Surgery Indicated in the Majority of Patients

The aim of this study was to define the underlying anatomical and pathophysiological conditions in limbs with venous ulcers in order to get information for the most appropriate treatment selection. Ninety-eight limbs (83 patients, 59 men), with active chronic venous ulcers, were analyzed retrospectively and classified according to the CEAP (clinical, etiological, anatomical, and pathophysiological) classification. Duplex-ultrasound was performed in all patients, while air-plethysmography and venography were performed selectively on potential candidates for deep venous reconstruction. Sixty-six ulcers were primary in origin and 32 were secondary. Reflux was present in all limbs except 1. Isolated reflux in 1 system (superficial = 3, deep = 4, perforator = 3) was seen in 10 legs (10%), while incompetence in all 3 systems was seen in 51 legs (52%). Superficial reflux with or without involvement of other systems was seen in 84 legs (86%), 72 legs (73%) had deep reflux with or without involvement of other systems, and incompetent perforator veins were identified in 79 limbs (81%). Axial reflux (continuous reverse flow from the groin region to below knee) was found in 77 limbs (79%). The femoral vein was the single most common deep venous segment in which either reflux or obstruction was found. Axial distribution of disease was found in the majority of cases and no patient had isolated deep venous incompetence below knee. Primary disease was the predominant etiologic cause and reflux was the main pathophysiological finding. Practically all patients were found to have 1 or more sites of reflux or obstruction that could benefit from operative treatment.

Long-term effects of superficial femoral vein ligation: Thirteen-year follow-up

This study examines the late clinical, hemodynamic, and anatomic results of superficial femoral vein ligation performed in 35 extremities that were followed an average of 13 1/2 years (range, 5 to 22 years). Indications for interruption were to prevent recurrent embolization from distal deep venous thrombosis (14 cases), to prevent emboli in patients with contraindication to anticoagulants (eight cases), to prevent distal reflux in selected patients undergoing iliofemoral thrombectomy (11 cases), and to control reflux in failed venous reconstruction (two cases). Ligation was effective in the prevention of pulmonary emboli as indicated by no significant clinical events and 15 negative postligation ventilation-perfusion scans. Long-term clinical follow-up showed normal (class 0) or near-normal (class 1) extremities in 83%. Fourteen percent developed mild to moderate symptoms of pain or swelling but without ulceration (class 2), and only one case (3%) had ulcerative sequelae (class 3). The only two findings that correlated with worse clinical outcome were the presence of an incompetent profunda femoris or an obstructed greater saphenous vein. Profunda femoris reflux was found in 60% (3/5) of patients with class 2 or 3 sequelae, which was significantly higher than the 14% (3/22) found in those patients with class 0 or 1 results (p < 0.05). Obstruction of the greater saphenous vein was found in 50% of those patients with class 2 or 3 results as opposed to 9% with class 0 or 1 results (p = 0.05). A large collateral vessel between the profunda femoris and the distal superficial femoral or popliteal vein was associated with poor long-term results.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)