Roberto Ligrone

The dawn of symbiosis between plants and fungi

The colonization of land by plants relied on fundamental biological innovations, among which was symbiosis with fungi to enhance nutrient uptake. Here we present evidence that several species representing the earliest groups of land plants are symbiotic with fungi of the Mucoromycotina. This finding brings up the possibility that terrestrialization was facilitated by these fungi rather than, as conventionally proposed, by members of the Glomeromycota. Since the 1970s it has been assumed, largely from the observation that vascular plant fossils of the early Devonian (400 Ma) show arbuscule-like structures, that fungi of the Glomeromycota were the earliest to form mycorrhizas, and evolutionary trees have, until now, placed Glomeromycota as the oldest known lineage of endomycorrhizal fungi. Our observation that Endogone-like fungi are widely associated with the earliest branching land plants, and give way to glomeromycotan fungi in later lineages, raises the new hypothesis that members of the Mucoromycotina rather than the Glomeromycota enabled the establishment and growth of early land colonists.

Bryophyte phylogeny: Advancing the molecular and morphological frontiers

Abstract Revolutionary new concepts of bryophyte relationships have emerged from molecular phylogenetic analyses conducted since the onset of the 21st century. For example, sequence data contradict the historical notion that isophylly in leafy liverworts is plesiomorphic and that simple thalloid liverworts are monophyletic. Also contrary to traditional views are the concepts that Leiosporoceros is genetically distinct from other hornworts and that Oedipodium is sister to the peristomate mosses. Substantial increases in ultrastructural and anatomical data likewise have provided new insights on interrelationships. Because of this recent deluge in evolutionary studies on bryophytes, it is an opportune time to co-examine contemporary morphological knowledge and novel molecular hypotheses. An understanding of bryophyte evolution and biology is essential to identify structural innovations that accompanied early land colonization and to illuminate the evolution of more complicated body plans in tracheophytes. In this review, we examine the progress that has been made since the 1999 International Botanical Congress in clarifying the evolutionary history of the three groups of bryophytes. The state of our knowledge on interrelationships is discussed, with poorly-known, genetically divergent taxa illustrated for each group. Our review of bryophyte evolution includes a reëvaluation of the evolution of sperm cells, sporogenesis, stomata, symbioses, conducting cells and chloroplast ultrastructure in hornworts. We explore the prospects for future discoveries and advances with an emphasis on fundamental evolutionary problems that remain and the challenges that must be met to resolve them.

Glomeromycotean associations in liverworts: a molecular, cellular, and taxonomic analysis

Liverworts form endophytic associations with fungi that mirror mycorrhizal associations in tracheophytes. Here we report a worldwide survey of liverwort associations with glomeromycotean fungi (GAs), together with a comparative molecular and cellular analysis in representative species. Liverwort GAs are circumscribed by a basal assemblage embracing the Haplomitriopsida, the Marchantiopsida (except a few mostly derived clades), and part of the Metzgeriidae. Fungal endophytes from Haplomitrium, Conocephalum, Fossombronia, and Pellia were related to Glomus Group A, while the endophyte from Monoclea was related to Acaulospora. An isolate of G. mosseae colonized axenic thalli of Conocephalum, producing an association similar to that in the wild. Fungal colonization in marchantialean liverworts suppressed cell wall autofluorescence and elicited the deposition of a new wall layer that specifically bound the monoclonal antibody CCRC-M1 against fucosylated side groups associated with xyloglucan and rhamnogalacturonan I. The interfacial material covering the intracellular fungus contained the same epitopes present in host cell walls. The taxonomic distribution and cytology of liverwort GAs suggest an ancient origin and multiple more recent losses, but the occurence in widely separated liverwort taxa of fungi related to glomeromycotean lineages that form arbuscular mycorrhizas in tracheophytes, notably the Glomus Group A, is better explained by host shifting from tracheophytes to liverworts.

The Gametophyte-Sporophyte Junction in Land Plants

Publisher Summary The chapter presents a comparative analysis of the placenta in land plants. The gametophyte–sporophyte junction is termed as the placental region. Systematic survey of bryophytes, pteridophytes, and placental analogues in seed plants are also explained. The gametophyte–sporophyte junctions in bryophyte groups are distinguished by the presence or absence of cell wall labyrinths in the placental cells, cell wall structure, shape, and arrangement of wall ingrowths and plastid morphology. Two stages of sporophyte development, the pre–meiotic stage and post–meiotic stage are discussed. Studies carried out by using the representatives of bryophyte groups namely mosses, liverworts, and anthocerotes are explained. The chapter also explains characteristic features of placenta like the distribution of transfer cells, distribution of wall ingrowth and time of ingrowth for different organisms belonging to mosses and liverworts. Cytoplasmic features of placental cells like shape, membrane system, plastoglobuli, and starch for sporophyte and gametophyte in mosses and liverworts are described. The anthocerotes are distinguished based on cytological, anatomical, and developmental characteristics. The taxonomic significance of placenta in bryophytes and the implications on phylogeny are also discussed. Differences in the placental regions, cell wall ingrowths, and intercellular spaces between bryophytes and pteridophytes are explained. These differences are related to the transient nature of sporophytic dependence on the gametophyte in pteridophytes. Transfer cell morphology has been described at every site of solute exchange via the apoplast of angiosperms.

Immunocytochemical detection of lignin-related epitopes in cell walls in bryophytes and the charalean alga Nitella

Lignins are complex phenolic heteropolymers present in xylem and sclerenchyma cell walls in tracheophytes. The occurrence of lignin-like polymers in bryophytes is controversial. In this study two polyclonal antibodies against homoguaiacyl (G) and guaiacyl/syringyl (GS) synthetic lignin-like polymers that selectively labelled lignified cell walls in tracheophytes also bound to cell walls in bryophytes, the GS antibody usually giving a stronger labelling than the G antibody. In contrast to tracheophytes, the antibody binding in liverworts and mosses was not tissue-specific. In the hornworts Megaceros flagellaris and M. fuegiensis the pseudoelaters and spores were labelled more intensely than the other cell types with the GS antibody. The cell walls in Nitella were labelled with both antibodies but no binding was observed in Coleochaete. The results suggest that the ability to incorporate G or GS moieties in cell walls is a plesiomorphy (primitive character) of the land plant clade.

A highly differentiated glomeromycotean association with the mucilage-secreting, primitive antipodean liverwort Treubia (Treubiaceae): clues to the origins of mycorrhizas

Thallus anatomy in three species of the primitive liverwort genus Treubia (Metzgeriidae, Treubiales) was studied by light and electron microscopy. The thallus exudes copious mucilage, a feature shared elsewhere in liverworts only with the mycotrophic subterranean axes of the allied genus Haplomitrium. The central strand in the thallus midrib has a unique histological organization and harbors an intra- and intercellular infection by a glomeromycotean fungus that is far more highly differentiated than most of the glomeromycotean associations described to date. The fungus enters the thallus via clefts in the ventral epidermis along the midrib and colonizes the parenchyma above, forming intracellular coils and prominent, relatively short-lived, hyphal swellings. Above the zone with intracellular colonization is a tissue area containing mucilage-filled intercellular spaces; here the fungus is entirely intercellular and forms abundant pseudoparenchymatous structures and, in more mature parts of the thalli, large hyphae with thick multistratose walls. Mucilage in Treubia differs in histochemistry and origin from that produced by apical papillae, via hypertrophied Golgi, in all other bryophytes. Remarkable parallels between fungal associations in Treubia, Haplomitrium, and Lycopodium, all members of very ancient lineages, suggest that these associations epitomize very early stages in the evolution of glomeromycotean symbioses.

Cellular Differentiation in Moss Protonemata: A Morphological and Experimental Study

BACKGROUND AND AIMS Previous studies of protonemal morphogenesis in mosses have focused on the cytoskeletal basis of tip growth and the production of asexual propagules. This study provides the first comprehensive description of the differentiation of caulonemata and rhizoids, which share the same cytology, and the roles of the cytoskeleton in organelle shaping and spatial arrangement. METHODS Light and electron microscope observations were carried out on in vitro cultured and wild protonemata from over 200 moss species. Oryzalin and cytochalasin D were used to investigate the role of the cytoskeleton in the cytological organization of fully differentiated protonemal cells; time-lapse photography was employed to monitor organelle positions. KEY RESULTS The onset of differentiation in initially highly vacuolate subapical cells is marked by the appearance of tubular endoplasmic reticulum (ER) profiles with crystalline inclusions, closely followed by an increase in rough endoplasmic reticulum (RER). The tonoplast disintegrates and the original vacuole is replaced by a population of vesicles and small vacuoles originating de novo from RER. The cytoplasm then becomes distributed throughout the cell lumen, an event closely followed by the appearance of endoplasmic microtubules (MTs) in association with sheets of ER, stacks of vesicles that subsequently disperse, elongate mitochondria and chloroplasts and long tubular extensions at both poles of the nucleus. The production of large vesicles by previously inactive dictysomes coincides with the deposition of additional cell wall layers. At maturity, the numbers of endoplasmic microtubules decline, dictyosomes become inactive and the ER is predominantly smooth. Fully developed cells remain largely unaffected by cytochalasin; oryzalin elicits profound cytological changes. Both inhibitors elicit the formation of giant plastids. The plastids and other organelles in fully developed cells are largely stationary. CONCLUSIONS Differentiation of caulonemata and rhizoids involves a remarkable series of cytological changes, some of which closely recall major events in sieve element ontogeny in tracheophytes. The cytology of fully differentiated cells is remarkably similar to that of moss food-conducting cells and, in both, is dependent on an intact microtubule cytoskeleton. The disappearance of the major vacuolar apparatus is probably related to the function of caulonema and rhizoids in solute transport. Failure of fully differentiated caulonema and rhizoid cells to regenerate is attributed to a combination of endo-reduplication and irreversible tonoplast fragmentation. The formation of giant plastids, most likely by fusion, following both oryzalin and cytochalasin treatments, suggests key roles for both microtubules and microfilaments in the spatial arrangement and replication of plastids.

A novel ascomycetous endophytic association in the rhizoids of the leafy liverwort family, Schistochilaceae (Jungermanniidae, Hepaticopsida).

Liverworts form diverse associations with endophytic fungi similar to mycorrhizas in vascular plants. Whereas the widespread occurrence of glomeromycotes in the basal liverwort lineages is well documented, knowledge of the distribution of ascomycetes and basidiomycetes in derived thalloid and leafy clades is more fragmented. Our discovery that the ramified and septate rhizoids of the Schistochilaceae, the sister group to all other ascomycete-containing liverworts, are packed with fungal hyphae prompted this study on the effects of the fungi on rhizoid morphology, host specificity, the cytology of the association, and a molecular analysis of the endophytes. Two species of Pachyschistochila and their fungi were grown axenically. Axenic rhizoids were unbranched and nonseptate. Reinfected with their own fungus and that from the other species, both Pachyschistochila species produced branched and septate rhizoids identical to those in nature. Woronin bodies and simple septa identified the fungus as an ascomycete referable, according to phylogenetic analyses of ITS sequences, to the Rhizoscyphus (Hymenoscyphus) ericae aggregate, also found in other liverwort-ascomycete associations and in mycorrhizas in the Ericales. Healthy hyphae and host cytoplasm suggest that the Schistochila-fungus association reflects a balanced mutualistic relationship. The recent dating of the divergence of the Jungermanniales from the fungus-free Porellales in the Permian and the origins of the Schistochilaceae in the Triassic indicate that these associations in liverworts predate the appearance of the Ericales.

Novel localization of callose in the spores of Physcomitrella patens and phylogenomics of the callose synthase gene family

BACKGROUND AND AIMS Callose involvement in spore development is a plesiomorphic feature of land plants. Correlated light, fluorescence and immuno-electron microscopy was conducted on the developing spores of Physcomitrella patens to probe for callose. Using a bioinformatic approach, the callose synthase (PpCalS) genes were annotated and PpCalS and AtCalS gene families compared, testing the hypothesis that an exine development orthologue is present in P. patens based on deduced polypeptide similarity with AtCalS5, a known exine development gene. METHODS Spores were stained with aniline blue fluorescent dye. Capsules were prepared for immuno-light and immuno-electron microscopy by gold labelling callose epitopes with monoclonal antibody. BLAST searches were conducted using the AtCalS5 sequence as a query against the P. patens genome. Phylogenomic analysis of the CalS gene family was conducted using PAUP (v.4.1b10). KEY RESULTS Callose is briefly present in the aperture of developing P. patens spores. The PpCalS gene family consists of 12 copies that fall into three distinct clades with AtCalS genes. PpCalS5 is an orthologue to AtCalS5 with highly conserved domains and 64 % similarity of their deduced polypeptides. CONCLUSIONS This is the first study to identify the presence of callose in moss spores. AtCalS5 was previously shown to be involved in pollen exine development, thus making PpCalS5 a suspect gene involved in moss spore exine development.

The origin of the sporophyte shoot in land plants: a bryological perspective

BACKGROUND Land plants (embryophytes) are monophyletic and encompass four major clades: liverworts, mosses, hornworts and polysporangiophytes. The liverworts are resolved as the earliest divergent lineage and the mosses as sister to a crown clade formed by the hornworts and polysporangiophytes (lycophytes, monilophytes and seed plants). Alternative topologies resolving the hornworts as sister to mosses plus polysporangiophytes are less well supported. Sporophyte development in liverworts depends only on embryonic formative cell divisions. A transient basal meristem contributes part of the sporophyte in mosses. The sporophyte body in hornworts and polysporangiophytes develops predominantly by post-embryonic meristematic activity. SCOPE This paper explores the origin of the sporophyte shoot in terms of changes in embryo organization. Pressure towards amplification of the sporangium-associated photosynthetic apparatus was a major driver of sporophyte evolution. Starting from a putative ancestral condition in which a transient basal meristem produced a sporangium-supporting seta, we postulate that in the hornwort-polysporangiophyte lineage the basal meristem acquired indeterminate meristematic activity and ectopically expressed the sporangium morphogenetic programme. The resulting sporophyte body plan remained substantially unaltered in hornworts, whereas in polysporangiophytes the persistent meristem shifted from a mid-embryo to a superficial position and was converted into an ancestral shoot apical meristem with the evolution of sequential vegetative and reproductive growth. CONCLUSIONS The sporophyte shoot is interpreted as a sterilized sporangial axis interpolated between the embryo and the fertile sporangium. With reference to the putatively ancestral condition found in mosses, the sporophyte body plans in hornworts and polysporangiophytes are viewed as the product of opposite heterochronic events, i.e. an anticipation and a delay, respectively, in the development of the sporangium. In either case the result was a pedomorphic sporophyte permanently retaining juvenile characters.