Roger Bofill

Molecular water oxidation mechanisms followed by transition metals: state of the art.

One clean alternative to fossil fuels would be to split water using sunlight. However, to achieve this goal, researchers still need to fully understand and control several key chemical reactions. One of them is the catalytic oxidation of water to molecular oxygen, which also occurs at the oxygen evolving center of photosystem II in green plants and algae. Despite its importance for biology and renewable energy, the mechanism of this reaction is not fully understood. Transition metal water oxidation catalysts in homogeneous media offer a superb platform for researchers to investigate and extract the crucial information to describe the different steps involved in this complex reaction accurately. The mechanistic information extracted at a molecular level allows researchers to understand both the factors that govern this reaction and the ones that derail the system to cause decomposition. As a result, rugged and efficient water oxidation catalysts with potential technological applications can be developed. In this Account, we discuss the current mechanistic understanding of the water oxidation reaction catalyzed by transition metals in the homogeneous phase, based on work developed in our laboratories and complemented by research from other groups. Rather than reviewing all of the catalysts described to date, we focus systematically on the several key elements and their rationale from molecules studied in homogeneous media. We organize these catalysts based on how the crucial oxygen-oxygen bond step takes place, whether via a water nucleophilic attack or via the interaction of two M-O units, rather than based on the nuclearity of the water oxidation catalysts. Furthermore we have used DFT methodology to characterize key intermediates and transition states. The combination of both theory and experiments has allowed us to get a complete view of the water oxidation cycle for the different catalysts studied. Finally, we also describe the various deactivation pathways for these catalysts.

A new insight into the Ag+ and Cu+ binding sites in the metallothionein β domain

Abstract The copper( I ) and silver( I ) binding properties of the β fragment of recombinant mouse metallothionein 1 have been studied by electronic absorption and circular dichroism spectroscopy. When possible, the stoichiometry of the species formed was confirmed by electrospray mass spectrometry. The behaviour observed differs from that reported for the native protein. Titration of either Zn 3 -βMT at pH 7 or apo-βMT at pH 3 with Cu + leads to the formation of species having the same stoichiometry and structure: Cu 6 -βMT, Cu 7 -βMT and Cu 10 -βMT. In the first stage of the titration of Zn 3 -βMT with Cu + at pH 7 one additional species of formula Cu 4 Zn 1 -βMT was detected. In contrast, the titration of Zn 3 -βMT at pH 7.5 and of apo-βMT at pH 2.5 with Ag + proceeds through different reaction pathways, affording Zn x Ag 3 -βMT, Ag 6 -βMT and Ag 9 -βMT or Ag 3 -βMT, Ag 6 -βMT and Ag 9 -βMT, respectively. The CD envelope corresponding to species with the same stoichiometric ratio, Ag 6 -βMT and Ag 9 -βMT, indicates that they have a different structure at each pH value. On the basis of the differences observed, the postulated similarity between copper and silver binding to metallothionein may be questioned.

Drosophila MTN: a metazoan copper-thionein related to fungal forms

Two Drosophila metallothioneins (MT) have been reported: MTN, a 40 residue peptide including 10 Cys, and MTO, a 43 residue peptide including 12 Cys. However, neither functional nor evolutionary analyses for either of the Drosophila MT are available. Here, heterologous expression of Mtn in Escherichia coli is reported. The metal binding abilities of the Cu‐ and Zn‐MTN complexes conformed in vivo, as well as the features of the Cd‐ and Cu‐aggregates produced by metal replacement in vitro, have been determined by atomic emission spectrometry, circular dichroism and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. Primary structure relationships with other MT have been examined. The results indicate a close resemblance of MTN to fungal copper‐thioneins.

Zinc(II) is required for the in vivo and in vitro folding of mouse copper metallothionein in two domains

We postulate that zinc(II) is a keystone in the structure of physiological mouse copper metallothionein 1 (Cu-MT 1). Only when Zn(II) is coordinated does the structure of the in vivo- and in vitro-conformed Cu-MT species consist of two additive domains. Therefore, the functionally active forms of the mammalian Cu-MT may rely upon a two-domain structure. The in vitro behaviour of the whole protein is deduced from the Cu titration of the apo and Zn-containing forms and compared with that of the independent fragments using CD, UV-vis, ESI-MS and ICP-AES. We propose the formation of the following Cu,Zn-MT species during Zn/Cu replacement in Zn7-MT: (Zn4)α(Cu4Zn1)β-MT, (Cu3Zn2)α(Cu4Zn1)β-MT and (Cu4Zn1)α(Cu6)β-MT. The cooperative formation of (Cu3Zn2)α(Cu4Zn1)β-MT from (Zn4)α(Cu4Zn1)β-MT indicates that the preference of Cu(I) for binding to the β domain is only partial and not absolute, as otherwise accepted. Homometallic Cu-MT species have been obtained either from the apoform of MT or from Zn7-MT after total replacement of zinc. In these species, copper distribution cannot be inferred from the sum of the independent α and β fragments. The in vivo synthesis of the entire MT in Cu-supplemented media has afforded Cu7Zn3-MT [(Cu3Zn2)α(Cu4Zn1)β-MT], while that of αMT has rendered a mixture of Cu4Zn1-αMT (40%), Cu5Zn1-αMT (20%) and Cu7-αMT (40%). In the case of βMT, a mixture of Cu6-βMT (25%) and Cu7-βMT (75%) was recovered [1]. These species correspond to some of those conformed in vitro and confirm that Zn(II) is essential for the in vivo folding of Cu-MT in a Cu-rich environment. A final significant issue is that common procedures used to obtain mammalian Cu6-βMT from native sources may not be adequate.

Caenorhabditis elegans metallothionein isoform specificity – metal binding abilities and the role of histidine in CeMT1 and CeMT2

Two metallothionein (MT) isoforms have been identified in the model nematode Caenorhabditis elegans: CeMT1 and CeMT2, comprising two polypeptides that are 75 and 63 residues in length, respectively. Both isoforms encompass a conserved cysteine pattern (19 in CeMT1 and 18 in CeMT2) and, most significantly, as a result of their coordinative potential, CeMT1 includes four histidines, whereas CeMT2 has only one. In the present study, we present a comprehensive and comparative analysis of the metal [Zn(II), Cd(II) and Cu(I)] binding abilities of CeMT1 and CeMT2, performed through spectroscopic and spectrometric characterization of the recombinant metal–MT complexes synthesized for wild‐type isoforms (CeMT1 and CeMT2), their separate N‐ and C‐terminal moieties (NtCeMT1, CtCeMT1, NtCeMT2 and CtCeMT2) and a ΔHisCeMT2 mutant. The corresponding in vitro Zn/Cd‐ and Zn/Cu‐replacement and acidification/renaturalization processes have also been studied, as well as protein modification strategies that make it possible to identify and quantify the contribution of the histidine residues to metal coordination. Overall, the data obtained in the present study are consistent with a scenario where both isoforms exhibit a clear preference for divalent metal ion binding, rather than for Cu coordination, although this preference is more pronounced towards cadmium for CeMT2, whereas it is markedly clearer towards Zn for CeMT1. The presence of histidines in these MTs is revealed to be decisive for their coordination performance. In CeMT1, they contribute to the binding of a seventh Zn(II) ion in relation to the M(II)6–CeMT2 complexes, both when synthesized in the presence of supplemented Zn(II) or Cd(II). In CeMT2, the unique C‐terminal histidine abolishes the Cu‐thionein character that this isoform would otherwise exhibit.

Comparative insight into the Zn(II)-, Cd(II)- and Cu(I)-binding features of the protozoan Tetrahymena pyriformis MT1 metallothionein

Tetrahymena pyriformis MT1 (TpyMT1) is a model among ciliate metallothioneins (MTs). Here, we report on the analytic (ICP-AES, GC-FPD), spectroscopic (CD, UV-Vis, Raman) and spectrometric (ESI-MS) characterization of its recombinant Cd(II)-, Zn(II)- and Cu(I)-complexes, and of those formed during in vitro Zn/Cd and Zn/Cu replacement. In the presence of Cd(II), TpyMT1 renders a major Cd 11-TpyMT1 species, which is also the final step reached in the in vitro Zn/Cd exchange process in Zn 11-TpyMT1. Spectroscopic data supports a different folding of the isostoichiometric Cd 11- and Zn 11-TpyMT1 complexes. Unexpectedly, TpyMT1 biosynthesis in Zn(II)-rich cultures was sensitive to the aeration degree, so that high oxygenation rendered undermetalated, partially-oxidized, complexes (Zn9-TpyMT1). Biosynthesis in Cu(I)-rich media rendered extremely heterogeneous mixtures of CuxZny-species (x+y=8-20), where the higher the aeration, the higher the Zn(II) content. The complexity of these samples was reproduced during the Zn/Cu replacement, as the number of generated species increased gradually with the addition of copper to Zn(11)-TpyMT1. According to our results, a clear preference of TpyMT1 for Cd(II) binding, rather than for Zn(II), and especially Cu(I) can be postulated. This character is totally consistent with the induction pattern of the TpyMT1 gene and the postulated role of TpyMT1 in Cd-detoxification.

The response of the different soybean metallothionein isoforms to cadmium intoxication

Cadmium is a highly toxic heavy metal for both plants and animals. The presence of Cd in agricultural soils is of major concern regarding its entry into the food chain, since Cd compounds are readily taken up by plants, and accumulated in edible parts due to their high solubility. In this study, we first demonstrate the high capacity for Cd concentration of soybean grains. Consequently, we considered the study and characterization of the molecular determinants of Cd accumulation -such as metallothioneins (MT)- to be of major practical importance. We report here the first characterization of the soybean MT system, with the identification of nine genes (one of which is a truncated pseudogene), belonging to the four plant MT types. The most highly expressed of each type was chosen for further function analysis. All of them are expressed at high levels in soybean tissues: GmMT1, GmMT2 and GmMT3 in roots, shoots and seeds, and GmMT4 only in seeds. The corresponding recombinant soybean MTs, synthesized in Escherichia coli cells cultured in metal supplemented media, exhibit greater cadmium than zinc binding capacity. These results suggest a definite role of GmMTs in Cd(II) accumulation as one of the main responses of soybean to an overload of this metal.

The metal-binding features of the recombinant mussel Mytilus edulis MT-10-IV metallothionein.

In contrast with the paradigmatic mammalian metallothioneins (MTs), mollusc MT systems consist at least of a high-cadmium induced form, possibly involved in detoxification, and another isoform either constitutive or regulated by essential metals and probably associated with housekeeping metabolism. With the aim of providing a deeper characterization of the coordination features of a molluscan MT peptide of the latter kind, we have analyzed here the metal-binding abilities of the recombinant MeMT-10-IV isoform of Mytilus edulis (MeMT). Also, comparison with other MTs of this type has been undertaken. A synthetic complementary DNA was constructed, cloned and expressed into two Escherichia coli systems. Upon zinc coordination, MeMT folds in vivo into highly chiral and stable Zn7 complexes, with an exceptional reluctance to fully substitute cadmium(II) and/or copper(I) for zinc(II). In vivo cadmium binding leads to homometallic Cd7 complexes that structurally differ from any of the in vitro prepared Cd7 complexes. Homometallic Cu–MeMT can only be obtained in vitro from Zn7–MeMT after a great molar excess of copper(I) has been added. In vivo, two different heterometallic Zn,Cu–MeMT complexes are recovered, which nicely correspond to two distinct stages of the in vitro zinc/copper replacement. These MeMT metal-binding features are consistent with a physiological role related to basal/housekeeping metal, mainly zinc, metabolism, and confirm the correspondence between the MeMT gene response pattern and the functional properties of the encoded protein.

Dinuclear ruthenium complexes containing a new ditopic phthalazin-bis(triazole) ligand that promotes metal–metal interactions

Much attention has been paid to heterocyclic N-containing ligands due to their applicability as bridging ligands in the synthesis of redox active dinuclear metal complexes. With this aim, we report the synthesis and full characterization of a novel phthalazine-triazole ligand (1,4-bis(1-methyl-1H-1,2,3-triazol-4-yl)phthalazine). Moreover, we show that the phthalazine nitrogen atoms of this N-heterocyclic ligand are more reactive towards alkylating agents than the triazole groups. New ruthenium(II) complexes containing this ligand have been obtained and characterized both structurally and electrochemically. The geometry imposed by the ligand allows the placement of two ruthenium centers in very close proximity so that efficient through-space interactions take place, a concept of crucial importance for electron transfer processes.

Sunflower metallothionein family characterisation. Study of the Zn(II)- and Cd(II)-binding abilities of the HaMT1 and HaMT2 isoforms.

Plant metallothioneins (MTs) constitute a family of small Cys-rich proteins capable of coordinating metal ions, significantly differing from microbial and animal MTs. They are divided into four subfamilies depending on the Cys pattern in their sequence. In this work, the MT system of the sunflower plant (Helianthus annuus) has been defined, with ten genes coding for MTs (HaMT) belonging to the four plant MT subfamilies; three HaMT1, four HaMT2, one HaMT3 and two HaMT4 isoforms. The gene expression pattern and capacity to confer metal resistance to yeast cells have been analysed for at least one member of each subfamily. The divalent metal ion-binding abilities of HaMT1-2 and HaMT2-1 (the isoforms encoded by the most abundantly expressed HaMT1 and HaMT2 isogenes) have been characterised, as HaMT3 and HaMT4 were previously studied. Those isoforms constitute an optimum material to study the effect of Cys number variability on their coordination abilities, as they exhibit additional Cys residues regarding the canonical Cys pattern of each subfamily. Our results show that the variation in the number of Cys does not drastically modify their M(II)-binding abilities, but instead modulates the degree of heterogeneity of the corresponding recombinant syntheses. Significantly, the Zn(II)-HaMT1 complexes were highly susceptible to proteolytic cleavage. The recombinant Cd-MT preparations of both isoforms exhibit significant acid-labile sulphide content-Cd6S8 or Cd7S7 species. Overall results suggest that HaMT2-1 is probably associated with Cd(II) detoxification, in contrast to HaMT1-2, which may be more related to physiological functions, such as metal ion transport and delivery.