Ross E. A. Kelly

New ab initio potential energy surface and the vibration-rotation-tunneling levels of (H2O)2 and (D2O)2

We report a new full-dimensional potential energy surface (PES) for the water dimer, based on fitting energies at roughly 30,000 configurations obtained with the coupled-cluster single and double, and perturbative treatment of triple excitations method using an augmented, correlation consistent, polarized triple zeta basis set. A global dipole moment surface based on Moller-Plesset perturbation theory results at these configurations is also reported. The PES is used in rigorous quantum calculations of intermolecular vibrational frequencies, tunneling splittings, and rotational constants for (H2O)2 and (D2O)2, using the rigid monomer approximation. Agreement with experiment is excellent and is at the highest level reported to date. The validity of this approximation is examined by comparing tunneling barriers within that model with those from fully relaxed calculations.

An investigation into the interactions between self-assembled adenine molecules and a Au(111) surface

Two molecular phases of the DNA base adenine (A) on a Au(111) surface are observed by using STM under ultrahigh-vacuum conditions. One of these phases is reported for the first time. A systematic approach that considers all possible gas-phase two-dimensional arrangements of A molecules connected by double hydrogen bonds with each other and subsequent ab initio DFT calculations are used to characterize and identify the two phases. The influence of the gold surface on the structure of A assemblies is also discussed. DFT is found to predict a smooth corrugation potential of the gold surface that will enable A molecules to move freely across the surface at room temperature. This conclusion remains unchanged if van der Waals interaction between A and gold is also approximately taken into account. DFT calculations of the A pairs on the Au(111) surface show its negligible effect on the hydrogen bonding between the molecules. These results justify the gas-phase analysis of possible assemblies on flat metal surfaces. Nevertheless, the fact that it is not the most stable gas-phase monolayer that is actually observed on the gold surface indicates that the surface still plays a subtle role, which needs to be properly addressed.

Adenine monolayers on the Au(111) surface: Structure identification by scanning tunneling microscopy experiment and ab initio calculations

From an interplay between scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and ab initio density functional theory (DFT) we have identified and characterized two different self-assembled adenine (A) structures formed on the Au(111) surface. The STM observations reveal that both structures have a hexagonal geometry in which each molecule forms double hydrogen bonds with three nearest neighbors. One of the A structures, with four molecules in the primitive cell, has p2gg space group symmetry, while the other one, with two molecules in the cell, has p2 symmetry. The first structure is observed more frequently and is found to be the dominating structure after annealing. Experimental as well as theoretical findings indicate that the interaction of A molecules with the gold surface is rather weak and smooth across the surface. This enabled us to unequivocally characterize the observed structures, systematically predict all structural possibilities, based on all known A-A dimers, and provisionally optimize positions of the A molecules in the cell prior to full-scale DFT calculations. The theoretical method is a considerable improvement compared to the approach suggested previously by Kelly and Kantorovich [Surf. Sci. 589, 139 (2005)]. We propose that the less ordered p2gg symmetry structure is observed more frequently due to kinetic effects during island formation upon deposition at room temperature.

Specificity of Watson–Crick Base Pairing on a Solid Surface Studied at the Atomic Scale

by hydrogen bonds is thought to be the crucial factor for the recognition of nucleobases, and base pairing probably also played an important role in the polymerization of the first oligonucleotide. It has been shown that short RNA strands can act as templates that catalyze the polymerization of complementary RNA strands from activated nucleotides in

Understanding the disorder of the DNA base cytosine on the Au(111) surface

Using ultrahigh vacuum scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and ab initio density functional theory, we have investigated in detail structures formed by cytosine on the Au(111) surface in clean ultrahigh vacuum conditions. In spite of the fact that the ground state of this DNA base on the surface is shown to be an ordered arrangement of cytosine one-dimensional branches (filaments), this structure has never been observed in our STM experiments. Instead, disordered structures are observed, which can be explained by only a few elementary structural motifs: filaments, five- and sixfold rings, which randomly interconnect with each other forming bent chains, T junctions, and nanocages. The latter may have trapped smaller structures inside. The formation of such an unusual assembly is explained by simple kinetic arguments as a liquid-glass transition.

Prochiral Guanine Adsorption on Au(111): An Entropy‐Stabilized Intermixed Guanine‐Quartet Chiral Structure

The interdisciplinary convergence of two scientific branches, design of low-dimensional systems on the nanoscale in condensed matter physics and the controlled growth of nucleotide sequence in molecular biology, has the potential to lead to new routes for the nucleation and growth of directed self-assembled molecular nanostructures at surfaces. Among the variety of self-assembly processes stereochemistry, that is, the relative arrangement of atoms in a molecule including its chirality, oftenplaysacrucial role incontrolling the molecular recognition and interaction. It has also been demonstrated to be important in recent studies of molecular

Supramolecular Porous Network Formed by Molecular Recognition between Chemically Modified Nucleobases Guanine and Cytosine

The involvement of surfaces in the origin of the first genetic molecules on Earth has long been suggested. Prior to the emergence of nucleic acid polymerases in the prebiotic soup, the self-assembly of primitive nucleobase building blocks may have relied on surface-mediated recognition events which catalyzed the formation of a covalent backbone in prototype oligonucleotides that subsequently may have functioned as templates in a primitive copying mechanism. This initial replication process may have been catalyzed by surfaces or chemical substances in solution—including RNA itself, as postulated in the RNA world hypothesis. Today, the role and the relative importance of the basic, fundamental driving forces for nucleic acid replication such as base pairing, base stacking, and steric effects are still under intense debate. Watson–Crick hydrogen bonding has traditionally been thought to be a prerequisite for high-fidelity DNA replication. However, recent studies on nucleobase analogues with the same size and shape as the natural ones but without relevant hydrogen-bonding groups have revealed that these analogues can recognize each other with high fidelity when incorporated into DNA sequences in vivo. Watson–Crick hydrogen bonding thus seems not to be a requisite for the selectivity of base pairing in DNA replication. However, in the absence of polymerases in the prebiotic soup, Watson– Crick hydrogen bonding may have played a more crucial role in the molecular recognition between the nucleobase building blocks at surfaces and for further polymerization. In support of this postulation, molecular recognition between complementary bases, most likely driven by hydrogen bonding alone, has already been observed both at the liquid/solid (HOPG) interface and on the noble Au(111) surface under extreme ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) conditions. These previous experiments were, however, conducted with nucleobases alone, and hence did not take the presence of deoxyribose into account. It is therefore of utmost importance to explore the role that Watson–Crick hydrogen bonding plays at surfaces in chemical structures that mimic nucleotides so as to address the fundamental question of how the polymerization of nucleotides may have started in the prebiotic soup in the absence of enzymes. The development of the scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) technique has advanced our understanding of supramolecular self-assembly systems on surfaces and has allowed intermolecular interactions to be explored at the submolecular scale. Herein we show by using a combination of high-resolution STM imaging and density functional theory (DFT) that sequential co-deposition of N-aryl-modified nucleobases cytosine (C) and guanine (G) onto the Au(111) surface under UHV conditions results in the formation of highly ordered supramolecular porous networks, where Watson–Crick hydrogen bonding between chemically modified C and G molecules plays the primary role in their stabilization. As the N-arylation of the nucleobases has been performed on the nitrogen atom normally attached to the sugar moiety in DNA or RNA (Scheme 1), these N-aryl-modified nucleobases thus represent two-dimensional (2D) structural mimics of naturally occurring nucleotides. The current results outline a new route for directing the self-assembly of nucleobase-derived nanostructures at the surface. Furthermore, the observed [*] Prof. W. Xu, Dr. M. F. Jacobsen, Dr. M. Yu, Prof. E. Laegsgaard, Prof. I. Stensgaard, Prof. T. R. Linderoth, Prof. J. Kjems, Prof. K. V. Gothelf, Prof. F. Besenbacher Interdisciplinary Nanoscience Center (iNANO) and Center for DNA Nanotechnology (CDNA), Department of Physics and Astronomy, Department of Chemistry, and Department of Molecular Biology, Aarhus University 8000 Aarhus C (Denmark) E-mail: fbe@inano.au.dk

Planar nucleic acid base super-structures

The nucleic acid base molecules have demonstrated in surface probe microscopy (SPM) experiments the ability to form complex super-structures on crystal surfaces ranging from periodic to disordered structures, which are stabilised primarily by the hydrogen bonding between the molecules. Due to the molecular resolution of SPM, theoretical insight is essential in understanding the actual structures these molecules form in atomic detail. This knowledge is essential in applications, e.g. in nanotechnology. This article reviews recent advances in theoretical methodology that should assist in the understanding of atomistic structures seen in experiments. Specifically, we highlight a unified approach, when molecules are thought of as “LEGO pieces” that can be attached to each other following certain rules, so that all possible structures can be generated.

Homochiral xanthine quintet networks self-assembled on Au(111) surfaces.

Xanthine molecule is an intermediate in nucleic acid degradation from the deamination of guanine and is also a compound present in the ancient solar system that is found in high concentrations in extraterrestrial meteorites. The self-assembly of xanthine molecules on inorganic surfaces is therefore of interest for the study of biochemical processes, and it may also be relevant to the fundamental understanding of prebiotic biosynthesis. Using a combination of high-resolution scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and density functional theory (DFT) calculations, two new homochiral xanthine structures have been found on Au(111) under ultrahigh vacuum conditions. Xanthine molecules are found to be self-assembled into two extended homochiral networks tiled by two types of di-pentamer units and stabilized by intermolecular double hydrogen bonding. Our findings indicate that the deamination of guanine into xanthine leads to a very different base pairing potential and the chemical properties of the base which may be of relevance to the function of the cell and potential development of human diseases. Moreover, the adsorption of xanthine molecules on inorganic surfaces leading to homochiral assemblies may be of interest for the fundamental understanding of the emerged chirality at early stages of life.

Self-assembly of artificial nucleobase 1H-benzimidazole-4,7-dione at the liquid/solid interface.

Self-assembly at the liquid/solid interface of an electrochemically active DNA nucleobase analogue, 1H-benzoimidazole-4,7-dione (Q), has been studied by means of scanning tunneling microscopy (STM). High-resolution STM images revealed the formation of well-ordered two-dimensional (2D) supramolecular nanostructures when the Q molecules are adsorbed onto the graphite surface from a 1-octanol solution. Detailed analysis shows that the observed 2D nanostructures are mainly dominated by hydrogen-bonded Q molecules. Since Q can be considered as a molecule mimicking the nucleobase guanine (G), which is known to form Watson-Crick base pairs with its complementary nucleobase cytosine (C), we have examined the binding ability of Q with C realized by available hydrogen-bonding sites on both Q and C molecules. Upon deposition of a mixture of Q and C molecules onto a graphite surface, one might expect that hydrogen-bonded QC dimers were observed in a new 2D self-assembled structure governed by inter- and intramolecular hydrogen-bonding interactions between Q and C molecules. However, our STM experiments showed that no well-ordered structures are formed and instead phase separation occurs where large-scale homodomains are formed consisting of the individual QQ and CC dimers. To gain further insight into the possible molecular arrangements of the Q and C nucleobases in the mixture phase, the high-resolution STM images are compared with the results from ab initio density functional theory (DFT) calculations.