Sally M. Farley

Fluoride therapy for osteoporosis: characterization of the skeletal response by serial measurements of serum alkaline phosphatase activity.

Optimum use of fluoride therapy for osteoporosis requires a sensitive and convenient index of the skeletal response to fluoride. Since previous studies had shown that serum alkaline phosphatase activity (SALP) was increased in response to fluoride therapy, we examined serial measurements of SALP in 53 osteoporotics treated with 66 to 110 mg of sodium fluoride (NaF) for 12 to 91 months. SALP was increased in 87% of the subjects during therapy with fluoride. The increase in SALP was thought to reflect the osteogenic action of fluoride based on the findings that SALP correlated with both trabecular bone area (r = .81, P less than .001) and osteoid length (r = .67, P less than .01) in iliac crest biopsies, predicted increased bone density on spinal radiographs in response to fluoride therapy with an 87% accuracy, and predicted decreased back pain in response to fluoride with a 91% accuracy. In addition, the SALP response to fluoride was seen earlier than other therapeutic responses as indicated by the findings that the tau 1/2 for the SALP response (ie, time for 1/2 of the patients to show a significant response) was significantly less (1.2 +/- 0.3 yr) than that for the pain response (1.6 +/- 0.3 yr, P less than .05) or that for the radiographic response (3.7 +/- 0.5 yr, P less than .001). Although most patients responded to fluoride with an increase in SALP, evaluation of the kinetics of the SALP response to fluoride revealed marked interpatient variation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Monofluorophosphate Physiology: The Effects of Fluoride on Bone

Fluoride is an effective agent in the treatment of osteoporosis and is the only available agent that is capable of producing a large increment in bone mass. Fluoride stimulates bone formation largely

Fluoride therapy for osteoporosis: a review of dose response, duration of treatment, and skeletal sites of action.

SummaryOsteoporosis is a disease characterized by a reduction in bone density which predisposes to fracture after even minimal trauma. Fluoride, because it has consistently been shown to stimulate bone formation and increase trabecular bone density, has been widely studied for the treatment of osteoporosis. The article focuses on the dose response, duration of treatment, and skeletal sites of action of fluoride; we also include comments on the effect of fluoride on vertebral and appendicular fracture rates. The skeletal response to fluoride doses, ranging from 15 to 43 mg elemental fluoride per day, included a linear increase in spinal bone density at an average rate of 1.25±0.91 mg/cm3 per month. The rate of increase in spinal bone density was related to the dose of fluoride (r=0.34,P<0.03). Spinal bone density had increased above the fracture threshold in 44% of patients treated with fluoride for 32±10 months. The time required to achieve this goal was, however, influenced by the pretreatment spinal bone density and interpatient variation in response to fluoride treatment. Patients whose spinal bone density remained below the fracture threshold had lower pretreatment bone densities and/or slower rates of increase in spinal bone density (P<0.001). The osteogenic effect of fluoride was not limited to the spine. After 2 years of fluoride therapy, we found bone density in the femoral condyle (measured by QCT) to have increased by 13±2.6 mg/cm3 (n=38,P<0.001); bone density in the hip (measured by DPA) was increased by 0.0261±0.015 g/cm2 (n=55,P<0.025). The efficacy of fluoride therapy to reduce fractures is not well established. Recently, investigators from the Mayo Clinic and Henry Ford Hospital reported fluoride had no effect on the vertebral fracture rate despite a significant increase in spinal bone density, but this finding has not been supported by findings in other studies. Moreover, our preliminary analysis of over 500 fluoride-treated patients found a time-dependent decrease in vertebral fracture rate related to a corresponding increase in spinal bone density. We conclude that these data, together with the many other positive international findings related to fluoride, justify continued investigation of this potent agent for the treatment of osteoporosis.

The increase in spinal bone density that occurs in response to fluoride therapy for osteoporosis is not maintained after the therapy is discontinued

In 44 osteoporotic subjects who had been treated with fluoride for 37±16 months, the fluoride was discontinued because they had shown fluoride-dependent increases in trabecular spinal bone densities from low initial levels (below the fracture threshold) to values that were equivalent to normal peak bone densities in the spines of young adults. During the subsequent period, after discontinuation of the fluoride therapy (i.e. 19±9 months), spinal bone density decreased in 73% of the subjects (i.e. 32 of 44,p<0.03), at a rate that was comparable to the rate of the previous gain that had occurred during the treatment with fluoride (i.e. −3.23±2.39 mg/cm3 per month, compared with +3.91±1.96 mg/cm3 per month in this subgroup of patients,p<0.001). Although 9 of the 44 subjects showed continuing increases in spinal bone density after discontinuation of the fluoride therapy, spinal bone density decreased in the entire group of 44 at an average rate of −1.02±4.72 mg/cm3 per month (p<0.001, compared with the rate of the previous gain during the treatment with fluoride; i.e. +3.83±1.82 mg/cm3 per month). Surprisingly, our data showed that the rate of decrease in spinal bone density during the post-fluoride period was not affected by concurrent (undesigned) treatment with calcium, calcium plus estrogen, or calcium plus calcitriol. The cessation of fluoride therapy was also associated with a decrease in serum alkaline phosphatase activity (i.e. a decrease from the elevated levels that were observed during the period of fluoride therapy, back to the original, pre-treatment levels;p<0.001), and that the rate of spinal bone loss after cessation of fluoride could be correlated with the prior rate of increase in serum alkaline phosphatase activity that had occurred during the treatment with fluoride (n=44,r=0.312,p=0.039). Together, the observations from this retrospective analysis of data obtained from our clinical subjects suggest that fluoride-treated osteoporotic subjects who have exhibited increases in trabecular spinal bone density are at risk for bone loss after discontinuation of the fluoride therapy.

Excretion of sweat and urine pyridinoline crosslinks in healthy controls and subjects with established metabolic bone disease.

Abstract Convenient techniques for measuring rates of bone turnover have been developed in recent years with the advent of biochemical markers of bone metabolism. One recent of these techniques is a collection method and quantitative enzyme immunoassay for free pyridinoline crosslinks in human sweat. The concentrations of pyridinoline crosslinks in 5-day sweat collections and first morning void and 24-hour urine collections from healthy subjects and subjects with established metabolic bone disorders were determined. T-scores were higher in the sweat system than in the urine system by up to 10-fold in postmenopausal subjects, women with hyperparathyroidism, and subjects with postmenopausal osteoporosis. For subjects with postmenopausal osteoporosis, receiver-operating characteristic curve analysis yielded areas under the curve of 0.699, 0.629, and 0.520 for sweat pyridinoline, first morning void urine pyridinoline, and 24 hour urine pyridinoline respectively. The areas under the curve of the sweat and first morning void urine measurements were significantly greater (p﹤0.05) than the 24-hour pyridinoline measurements. Healthy postmenopausal subjects and subjects with postmenopausal osteoporosis were monitored before and during estrogen replacement therapy or alendronate therapy. Sweat pyridinoline values declined by 49.0 ±12.4％ and 19.4 ±19.9％ for estrogen and alendronate subjects respectively. We conclude that this non-invasive technique is a sensitive and specific measure of bone resorption and is appropriate as an adjunct to techniques such as bone density and may also be useful in monitoring of response to anti-resorptive therapies.

Serum fluoride and serum osteocalcin levels in response to a novel sustained-release monofluorophosphate preparation: comparison with plain monofluorophosphate.

In a previous study we found that sustained-release monofluorophosphate (MFP-SR), a novel, sustained-release MFP preparation, acutely maintained the basal therapeutic serum fluoride levels without causing the high serum peak levels associated with plain MFP administration. The objective of the present study was to determine (a) whether chronic MFP-SR administration would provide therapeutic serum fluoride levels, and (b) whether treatment with this new preparation would result in an increase in bone formation similar to that achieved with plain MFP. Bone formation was assessed by serum osteocalcin (OC) determination. We studied 17 postmenopausal women older than 60 years and suffering from primary osteoporosis. All had received a minimum of 6 months of continuous treatment with plain MFP at a dose of 152 mg/day (76 mg b.i.d.). Upon entering the study, the subjects were randomized, in a double-masked protocol, to receive either MFP-SR (76 mg b.i.d.) (n=9) or placebo (n=8) for 2 months, after which all subjects returned to the original plain MFP regimen. Serum fluoride and serum OC levels were determined monthly for 3 months. At the beginning of the study serum fluoride levels were in the accepted therapeutic range (5–10 µM) in all patients. Serum fluoride levels were maintained in the patients switched to MFP-SR. In contrast, serum fluoride levels decreased significantly (p<0.005) in the placebo-treated control subjects and returned to therapeutic levels upon switching back to plain MFP. Similarly, serum OC levels remained elevated in the subjects switched to MFP-SR but dropped significantly (p<0.001) in the placebo-treated group. Our results demonstrate that chronic MFP-SR administration, at a dose of 152 mg/day, results in maintenance of therapeutic serum fluoride levels and in stimulation of bone formation. Because we have previously reported that high, supratherapeutic post-absorptive serum fluoride levels are avoided by MFP-SR administration, this novel preparation may prevent side effects associated with plain MFP by reducing the amount of fluoride deposited in bone.

Pharmacokinetic profile of a new fluoride preparation : sustained-release monofluorophosphate

The pharmacokinetic profiles of a sustained-release monofluorophosphate (MFP-SR) preparation (76 mg) and of plain MFP (76 mg) were compared in six osteoporotic females. These studies were performed in a randomized, crossover, double-blind design to select a preparation that would result in therapeutic serum levels while avoiding high serum peak values. Following a single dose of 76 mg MFP-SR, the serum fluoride levels remained within the accepted therapeutic range (5–10 μM/liter) for 24 hours. In contrast, following a single dose of 76 mg plain MFP, serum fluoride levels exhibited a wide circadian fluctuation and serum levels approximately threefold higher than those of the MFP-SR preparation (9.5±1.6 vs 3.5±0.8 μM/liter, P<0.005). Compared with plain MFP, the sustained-release MFP had a significantly lower peak concentration (Cmax MFP-SR: 10.6 ±3 vs CmaxMFP: 18.9±5 μM/liter, P<0.005) and a significantly longer absorption lag time (TmaxMFP-SR 7.3±1.6 vs TmaxMFP: 3.0±0.6 h, P<0.05). Twenty-four-hour urinary fluoride excretion after ingestion of plain or SR fluoride was significantly increased from pretreatment values documenting absorption with either MFP formulation. Our results show that the use of sustained-release MFP preparation that we tested prevents the development of high peak levels associated with the use of plain MFP preparations. Furthermore, a single dose of MFP-SR resulted in serum fluoride levels within the accepted range of 5–10 μM/liter for 24 hours.