Salvador Casares

Cooperative propagation of local stability changes from low-stability and high-stability regions in a SH3 domain

Site‐directed mutagenesis has been used to produce local stability changes at two regions of the binding site surface of the α‐spectrin SH3 domain (Spc‐SH3) differing in their intrinsic stability. Mutations were made at residue 56, located at the solvent‐exposed side of the short 310 helix, and at residue 21 in the tip of the flexible RT‐loop. NMR chemical‐shift analysis and X‐ray crystallography indicated negligible changes produced by the mutations in the native structure limited to subtle rearrangements near the mutated residue and at flexible loops. Additionally, mutations do not alter importantly the SH3 binding site structure, although produce significant changes in its affinity for a proline‐rich decapeptide. The changes in global stability measured by differential scanning calorimetry are consistent the local energy changes predicted by theoretical models, with the most significant effects observed for the Ala‐Gly mutations. Propagation of the local stability changes throughout the domain structure has been studied at a per‐residue level of resolution by NMR‐detected amide hydrogen–deuterium exchange (HX). Stability propagation is remarkably efficient in this small domain, apparently due to its intrinsically low stability. Nevertheless, the HX‐core of the domain is not fully cooperative, indicating the existence of co‐operative subunits within the core, which is markedly polarized. An equilibrium ϕ‐analysis of the changes in the apparent Gibbs energies of HX per residue produced by the mutations has allowed us to characterize structurally the conformational states leading to HX. Some of these states resemble notably the folding transition state of the Spc‐SH3 domain, suggesting a great potential of this approach to explore the folding energy landscape of proteins. An energy perturbation propagates more effectively from a flexible region to the core than in the opposite direction, because the former affects a broader region of the energy landscape than the latter. This might be of importance in understanding the special thermodynamic signature of the SH3‐peptide interaction and the relevance of the dual character of SH3 binding sites. Proteins 2007.

The high-resolution NMR structure of the R21A Spc-SH3:P41 complex: Understanding the determinants of binding affinity by comparison with Abl-SH3

BackgroundSH3 domains are small protein modules of 60–85 amino acids that bind to short proline-rich sequences with moderate-to-low affinity and specificity. Interactions with SH3 domains play a crucial role in regulation of many cellular processes (some are related to cancer and AIDS) and have thus been interesting targets in drug design. The decapeptide APSYSPPPPP (p41) binds with relatively high affinity to the SH3 domain of the Abl tyrosine kinase (Abl-SH3), while it has a 100 times lower affinity for the α-spectrin SH3 domain (Spc-SH3).ResultsHere we present the high-resolution structure of the complex between the R21A mutant of Spc-SH3 and p41 derived from NMR data. Thermodynamic parameters of binding of p41 to both WT and R21A Spc-SH3 were measured by a combination of isothermal titration and differential scanning calorimetry. Mutation of arginine 21 to alanine in Spc-SH3 increases 3- to 4-fold the binding affinity for p41 due to elimination at the binding-site interface of the steric clash produced by the longer arginine side chain. Amide hydrogen-deuterium experiments on the free and p41-bound R21A Spc-SH3 domain indicate that binding elicits a strong reduction in the conformational flexibility of the domain. Despite the great differences in the thermodynamic magnitudes of binding, the structure of the R21A Spc-SH3:P41 complex is remarkably similar to that of the Abl-SH3:P41 complex, with only few differences in protein-ligand contacts at the specificity pocket. Using empirical methods for the prediction of binding energetics based on solvent-accessible surface area calculations, the differences in experimental energetics of binding between the two complexes could not be properly explained only on the basis of the structural differences observed between the complexes. We suggest that the experimental differences in binding energetics can be at least partially ascribed to the absence in the R21A Spc-SH3:P41 complex of several buried water molecules, which have been proposed previously to contribute largely to the highly negative enthalpy and entropy of binding in the Abl-SH3:P41 complex.ConclusionBased on a deep structural and thermodynamic analysis of a low and high affinity complex of two different SH3 domains with the same ligand p41, we underline the importance of taking into account in any effective strategy of rational design of ligands, factors different from the direct protein-ligand interactions, such as the mediation of interactions by water molecules or the existence of cooperative conformational effects induced by binding.

Detection and Characterization of Partially Unfolded Oligomers of the SH3 Domain of α-Spectrin

For the purpose of equilibrium and kinetic folding-unfolding studies, the SH3 domain of α-spectrin (spc-SH3) has long been considered a classic two-state folding protein. In this work we have indeed observed that the thermal unfolding curves of spc-SH3 measured at pH 3.0 by differential scanning calorimetry, circular dichroism, and NMR follow apparently the two-state model when each unfolding profile is considered individually. Nevertheless, we have found that protein concentration has a marked effect upon the thermal unfolding profiles. This effect cannot be properly explained in terms of the two-state unfolding model and can only be interpreted in terms of the accumulation of intermediate associated states in equilibrium with the monomeric native and unfolded states. By chemical cross-linking and pulsed-field gradient NMR diffusion experiments we have been able to confirm the existence of associated states formed during spc-SH3 unfolding. A three-state model, in which a dimeric intermediate state is assumed to be significantly populated, provides the simplest interpretation of the whole set of thermal unfolding data and affords a satisfactory explanation for the concentration effects observed. Whereas at low concentrations the population of the associated intermediate state is negligible and the unfolding process consequently takes place in a two-state fashion, at concentrations above ∼0.5 mM the population of the intermediate state becomes significant at temperatures between 45°C and 80°C and reaches up to 50% at the largest concentration investigated. The thermodynamic properties of the intermediate state implied by this analysis fall in between those of the unfolded state and the native ones, indicating a considerably disordered conformation, which appears to be stabilized by oligomerization.

pH dependence of the hydrogen exchange in the SH3 domain of α-spectrin

Using nuclear magnetic resonance we have measured the hydrogen exchange (HX) in the Src homology region 3 (SH3) domain of α‐spectrin as a function of pH*. At very acidic pH* values the exchange of most residues appears to occur via global unfolding, although several residues show abnormally large Gibbs energies of exchange, suggesting the presence of some residual structure in the unfolded state. At higher pH* HX occurs mainly via local or partial unfoldings. We have been able to characterize the coupling between the electrostatic interactions in this domain and the conformational fluctuations occurring under native conditions by analyzing the dependence upon pH* of the Gibbs energy of exchange. The SH3 domain seems to be composed of a central core, which requires large structural disruptions to become exposed to the solvent, surrounded by smaller subdomains, which fluctuate independently.

Single-chain protein mimetics of the N-terminal heptad-repeat region of gp41 with potential as anti–HIV-1 drugs

Significance The envelope subunit gp41 is an attractive target for therapeutic intervention against HIV-1. Interfering with the interaction between the heptad-repeat regions of gp41 is a promising approach to inhibit HIV-1 fusion to the host cell membrane. Here, we present an alternative rational design and protein-engineering approach to produce highly stable single-chain proteins that accurately mimic the trimeric coiled-coil surface of the gp41 N-terminal heptad repeat. This approach has a strong potential for development to HIV-1 drugs, vaccines, or microbicides and could be extendable to the design of proteins interfering with other types of coiled-coil interactions. During HIV-1 fusion to the host cell membrane, the N-terminal heptad repeat (NHR) and the C-terminal heptad repeat (CHR) of the envelope subunit gp41 become transiently exposed and accessible to fusion inhibitors or Abs. In this process, the NHR region adopts a trimeric coiled-coil conformation that can be a target for therapeutic intervention. Here, we present an approach to rationally design single-chain protein constructs that mimic the NHR coiled-coil surface. The proteins were built by connecting with short loops two parallel NHR helices and an antiparallel one with the inverse sequence followed by engineering of stabilizing interactions. The constructs were expressed in Escherichia coli, purified with high yield, and folded as highly stable helical coiled coils. The crystal structure of one of the constructs confirmed the predicted fold and its ability to accurately mimic an exposed gp41 NHR surface. These single-chain proteins bound to synthetic CHR peptides with very high affinity, and furthermore, they showed broad inhibitory activity of HIV-1 fusion on various pseudoviruses and primary isolates.

Distinct ubiquitin binding modes exhibited by SH3 domains: molecular determinants and functional implications.

SH3 domains constitute a new type of ubiquitin-binding domains. We previously showed that the third SH3 domain (SH3-C) of CD2AP binds ubiquitin in an alternative orientation. We have determined the structure of the complex between first CD2AP SH3 domain and ubiquitin and performed a structural and mutational analysis to decipher the determinants of the SH3-C binding mode to ubiquitin. We found that the Phe-to-Tyr mutation in CD2AP and in the homologous CIN85 SH3-C domain does not abrogate ubiquitin binding, in contrast to previous hypothesis and our findings for the first two CD2AP SH3 domains. The similar alternative binding mode of the SH3-C domains of these related adaptor proteins is characterised by a higher affinity to C-terminal extended ubiquitin molecules. We conclude that CD2AP/CIN85 SH3-C domain interaction with ubiquitin constitutes a new ubiquitin-binding mode involved in a different cellular function and thus changes the previously established mechanism of EGF-dependent CD2AP/CIN85 mono-ubiquitination.

Structural cooperativity in the SH3 domain studied by site-directed mutagenesis and amide hydrogen exchange.

We have studied the effects produced by site‐directed mutagenesis upon energetic and structural cooperativity in the Src homology region 3 domain of α‐spectrin. The mutation of Asn47 to Gly or Ala in the distal loop brings about significant changes to the global stability of the domain in spite of not affecting its structure to any great extent. The binding affinity for a proline‐rich peptide is also largely diminished in both mutant domains. We have compared the apparent Gibbs energies of the amide hydrogen–deuterium exchange (HX) between the wild‐type and the Gly47 mutant. The observed changes in the Gibbs energy of HX indicate a remarkable energetic cooperativity in this small domain. Regions of the domains core have a high cooperativity with the position of the mutation, indicating that their HX occurs mainly in states in which the distal loop is unstructured. More flexible regions, which undergo HX mainly by local motions, show a lower but still considerable cooperativity with the distal loop. We conclude that there is an important correlation between regional stability and cooperativity in this small domain.

Thermodynamic Analysis of the Binding of 2F5 (Fab and Immunoglobulin G Forms) to Its gp41 Epitope Reveals a Strong Influence of the Immunoglobulin Fc Region on Affinity

Background: Little is known regarding the thermodynamics of binding of the broadly neutralizing anti-HIV-1 mAb 2F5 to its gp41 epitope. Results: Isothermal titration calorimetry reveals strong differences between IgG and Fab. Conclusion: Residues flanking the core epitope and the immunoglobulin Fc region contribute strongly to affinity by allosteric mechanisms. Significance: The results may help to develop new therapeutics and/or vaccines against HIV and to understanding Ag-Ab recognition. Immunotherapies and vaccines based on the induction of broadly neutralizing monoclonal antibodies (bNAbs) have become outstanding strategies against HIV-1. Diverse bNAbs recognizing different regions of the HIV-1 envelope have been identified and extensively studied. However, there is little information about the thermodynamics of binding of these bNAbs and their epitopes. We used isothermal titration calorimetry to characterize thermodynamically the interactions between bNAb 2F5 (in both the IgG and Fab forms) and its functional and core epitope peptides. We found that these interactions are enthalpically driven and opposed by a negative entropy change. The highest affinity was found for 2F5 IgG for its functional epitope, indicating that additional interactions involving residues flanking the core epitope contribute strongly to higher affinity. In addition, the strong influence of the Fc region on the binding affinity suggests long-range allosteric effects within IgG. Our results provide useful information for developing new therapeutics against HIV-1 and, in a broader scope, contribute to a better understanding of antigen-antibody recognition.

A binding event converted into a folding event

We have designed a chimeric protein by connecting a circular permutant of the α‐spectrin SH3 domain to the proline‐rich decapeptide APSYSPPPPP with a three‐residue link. Our aim was to obtain a single‐chain protein with a tertiary fold that would mimic the binding between SH3 domains and proline‐rich peptides. A comparison of the circular‐dichroism and fluorescence spectra of the purified chimera and the SH3 circular permutant showed that the proline‐rich sequence occupies the putative SH3 binding site in a similar conformation and with comparable interactions to those found in complexes between SH3 and proline‐rich peptides. Differential scanning calorimetry indicated that the interactions in the binding motif interface are highly cooperative with the rest of the structure and thus the protein unfolds in a two‐state process. The chimera is more stable than the circular permutant SH3 by 6–8 kJ mol−1 at 25°C and the difference in their unfolding enthalpy is approximately 32 kJ mol−1, which coincides with the values found for the binding of proline‐rich peptides to SH3 domains. This type of chimeric protein may be useful in designing SH3 peptide ligands with improved affinity and specificity.

The temperature dependence of the hydrogen exchange in the SH3 domain of α-spectrin

The amide hydrogen–deuterium exchange (HX) in the Src homology region 3 (SH3) domain of α‐spectrin has been measured by nuclear magnetic resonance as a function of temperature between 8 and 46°C. The analysis of the temperature dependence of HX from a statistical thermodynamic point of view has allowed us to estimate the enthalpies and entropies of the conformational processes leading to HX. The results indicate that under native conditions the domain undergoes a wide variety of conformational fluctuations, ranging from local motions, mainly located in loops, turns and chain ends and involving only low enthalpy and entropy, to extensive structural disruptions affecting its core and involving enthalpies and entropies that come fairly close to those observed during global unfolding.