Sandra R. Wolman

Malignant MCF10CA1 cell lines derived from premalignant human breast epithelial MCF10AT cells

The MCF10 series of cell lines was derived from benign breast tissue from a woman with fibrocystic disease. The MCF10 human breast epithelial model system consists of mortal MCF10M and MCF10MS (mortal cells grown in serum-free and serum-containing media, respectively), immortalized but otherwise normal MCF10F and MCF10A lines (free-floating versus growth as attached cells), transformed MCF10AneoT cells transfected with T24 Ha-ras, and premalignant MCF10AT cells with potential for neoplastic progression. The MCF10AT, derived from xenograft-passaged MCF10-AneoT cells, generates carcinomas in ∼25% of xenografts. We now report the derivation of fully malignant MCF10CA1 lines that complete the spectrum of progression from relatively normal breast epithelial cells to breast cancer cells capable of metastasis. MCF10CA1 lines display histologic variations ranging from undifferentiated carcinomas, sometimes with focal squamous differentiation, to well-differentiated adenocarcinomas. At least two metastasize to the lung following injection of cells into the tail vein; one line grows very rapidly in the lung, with animals moribund within 4 weeks, whereas the other requires 15 weeks to reach the same endpoint. In addition to variations in efficiency of tumor production, the MCF10CA1 lines show differences in morphology in culture, anchorage-independent growth, karyotype, and immunocytochemistry profiles. The MCF10 model provides a unique tool for the investigation of molecular changes during progression of human breast neoplasia and the generation of tumor heterogeneity on a common genetic background.

Clonal chromosomal abnormalities in desmoid tumors. Implications for histopathogenesis.

Desmoid tumors (aggressive fibromatosis) are regarded as lesions of uncertain histopathogenesis. Cytogenetic analyses of 26 desmoid tumor specimens from abdominal or extraabdominal sites of 22 patients with or without Gardners syndrome (GS) showed clonal karyotypic abnormalities in 7 cases, random abnormalities in 14 cases, and striking telomeric fusion in 5 cases. Loss of chromosome Y, a reported feature of fibromatosis in penile and palmar locations, was detected as a clonal aberration in two patients. Additionally, involvement of 5q was observed in six patients, two of whom had GS. Clonal interstitial deletions of 5q were observed in three patients, one with and two without GS. These findings confirm a clonal and probable neoplastic origin for desmoid tumor and suggest that abnormalities of the Y chromosome and 5q may be important in the genesis of this neoplasm.

Chromosome aberrations in individuals occupationally exposed to ethylene oxide, and in a large control population☆

Chromosome aberration frequencies in 61 employees potentially exposed to ethylene oxide (ETO) were compared with those in unexposed control groups. We studied 3 worksites with differing historical ambient levels of ETO. Within worksites, groups were classified as high potential exposed, low potential exposed, or controls. Further control groups including an off-site community control group were added to give a total of 304 control individuals. Blood samples were drawn several times over a 24-month period. Aberrations were analyzed in 100 cells per sample after culture for 48-51 h. Worksites I, II and III respectively represented increasing levels of potential ETO exposure. At worksites I and II, no consistent differences in aberration frequencies were found among groups. At worksite III aberration frequencies in potentially exposed individuals were significantly increased compared with controls. The frequencies of cells with aberrations were 5.6% for the 2 individuals in the high potential exposure category and 2.6% for 23 persons in the low potential exposure group. The overall frequency of cells with aberrations in the matched control individuals was 1.4%. In the total control group of 304 individuals we found significant increases in aberrations associated with smoking and with increasing age. We have also reported previously an association between sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) frequency and ETO exposure (Stolley et al., 1984). When aberration frequencies were compared with levels of SCEs there was only a weak overall association. The correlation was found in potentially exposed but not in control groups, and for any individual, one observation could not be used to predict the other.

Karyotypic progression in human tumors

SummaryKaryotypic progression may be viewed in at least two ways. One approach seeks evidence for increasing and progressive deviation from the normal chromosome pattern in tumors. The clearest examples, found in some leukemias, are those in which successive karyotypic changes are superimposed on an already aberrant cell population. Evidence of chromosomal progression within solid tumors is far less frequent, possibly because the tumors themselves are at a relatively late stage in their evolution. An alternative approach, therefore, attempts to correlate the extent of karyotypic deviation with other aspects of tumor progression. Recent data, based on classical cytogenetic analyses and flow cytometry, are presented to determine relationships between karyotype and specific origin and morphology of tumors. The predominant theme which emerges, not surprisingly, is that the more deviant chromosome patterns are associated with other measures of increased biologic malignancy. What is surprising is the degree to which these properties are expressed in primary tumors and the relative lack of evidence for further karyotypic evolution with recurrence or metastasis.Examples of genetic instability, evolution through polyploidy, gene amplification, and selection for specific chromosomal rearrangement are found in populations of premalignant and malignant human cells. There is increasing recognition of the importance of tumor-specific chromosome aberrations in the stepwise progression from the normal to the fully neoplastic cell.

Chromosomal aneuploidy in proliferative breast disease

Although some forms of proliferative breast disease have been associated with increased risk of breast cancer, substantial confirmatory evidence that the lesions are biologically premalignant has not been presented. Our intent was to identify cytogenetic aberrations in proliferative breast disease using fluorescence in situ hybridization probes selected for their relationship to aberrations previously reported in breast cancer. Application of fluorescence in situ hybridization techniques to paraffin tissue sections using pericentromeric probes for chromosomes 1, 16, 17, 18, and X revealed chromosome aneuploidy in proliferative and malignant lesions of the breast. Sectioning artifact that may result in nuclear truncation was controlled by establishing expected baseline frequencies for gain and loss in normal tissues from the same breast. Localization of chromosomal aberrations to proliferative breast disease lesions with concomitant retention of a normal chromosome complement in corresponding normal breast tissues indicates biologic significance of the results. The similarities of losses involving chromosomes 16, 17, and 18 in hyperplastic lesions and in malignant breast lesions suggest that some hyperplasias may be part of a sequence of progression to malignancy in breast cancer. Gains of chromosome 1 in both in situ and invasive carcinoma are consistent with reports of polysomy 1q as a common cytogenetic change in breast cancer. Its localization to advanced lesions suggests that this trisomy is probably not the initial cytogenetic change in breast cancer tumorigenesis.

Common clonal origin of synchronous primary head and neck squamous cell carcinomas: Analysis by tumor karyotypes and fluorescence in situ hybridization

Two synchronously arising primary squamous cell carcinomas (SCC) originating from separate sites in the anterior floor of mouth (FOM) and the pyriform sinus (PS) were evaluated by karyotype and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) to determine whether they were of common or independent ancestry. The primary tumors were designated Henry Ford Hospital (HFH)-SCC-8a (FOM) and HFH-SCC-9a (PS), and the respective recurrent tumors after chemotherapy and radiation were designated -8b and -9b. HFH-SCC-8a and -8b were cultured and had closely related hypotetraploid karyotypes of monoclonal origin. Karyotypes could not be obtained from the second primary tumor HFH-SCC-9a or its recurrence -9b. However, we used karyotypes from HFH-SCC-8a and -8b as a guide to select FISH probes for the histological evaluation of genetic markers in tumor sections. Fluorescence in situ hybridization on metaphase chromosomes from the cell cultures was useful in modifying the tumor karyotypes. Fluorescence in situ hybridization identified a chromosome Y rearrangement that was not obvious from the HFH-SCC-8a and -8b karyotypes, and this Y rearrangement served as a unique clonal marker. Using two probes for the Y chromosome we showed that all four tumors shared the same Y rearrangement with loss of Yq (DYZ1) and retention of Ycen (DYZ3). Furthermore, FISH showed that all four tumors had the same aneuploidy patterns for chromosomes X, Y, 7, 9, 15, 16, and 17. From karyotypic and FISH analysis disomy for X and 9 centromere regions and the rearranged Y were all predicted and observed in the tumor tissue sections. Tetrasomy and trisomy for 7, 15, 16, and 17 were predicted from the karyotypes and this also was observed using FISH in all four tumors. These FISH aneuploidy patterns and the presence of a clonal Y marker in all four tumor samples indicate that the synchronous primaries and their recurrences were of monoclonal origin.

Sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) report on control subjects in a study of occupationally exposed workers.

The range and distribution of Sister-Chromatid Exchange (SCE) scores in 479 control persons were determined. All SCE readings were performed in a single laboratory according to the same protocol and regularly checked by referee readers to assure consistency. A mean SCE per cell value of 9.9 and a 95th percentile of 13.4 were established for this study sample. The range of SCE scores across all non-exposed individuals tested was 5.0-17.5 SCE per cell. Differences in SCE scores were associated with reader, smoking, sex, and, to a small extent, age. Individual test results showed reasonable consistency across the entire control group, but, as with most clinical measurements, care should be taken to avoid placing too much emphasis on a single test result when communicating with an individual. This report on the largest control group studied to date provides necessary normative data for further SCE investigations in occupational settings.

Growth of diploid cells from breast cancers

Cell cultures were derived from normal and cancerous breast tissues and from metastases by methods that selected for relatively adherent epithelial aggregates. Karyotypic analyses of first or second passage cultures yielded predominantly normal diploid cells. Nonclonal aberrations were more common in tumor-derived than in normal cultures. Three of the cultures that originated from metastases were characterized by abnormal clones. These results support observations based on DNA content, which indicate that a considerable fraction of breast cancers are composed predominantly of diploid cells. They differ greatly from chromosomal findings in long-term cultures of tumor effusions and thus emphasize the karyotypic diversity that can be found in tumors from a single tissue of origin--the breast.

Sister-chromatid exchanges in association with occupational exposure to ethylene oxide.

Sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) frequencies in employees potentially exposed to ethylene oxide (ETO) were compared with those in unexposed control groups. Three worksites where the previous environmental control of ETO was known to have differed were chosen. Within these worksites, subjects were categorized into high potential exposed, low potential exposed and control groups. An additional community control group was obtained. Blood samples for chromosome studies of peripheral lymphocytes were drawn at several time points over a period of 24 months. The effects on SCE of age, sex, smoking habits and reader variation were considered. Worksites I, II and III, respectively, represented increasing levels of exposure. At Worksite III large differences among groups persisted over 24 months. At Worksite II, the SCEs in the high potential exposed workers were higher than those in the other groups. At no time was the low potential exposed group at Worksite II statistically significantly higher in mean SCE than the worksite controls. No consistent differences among groups were noted in Worksite I.

Cytogenetics of primary prostatic adenocarcinoma: Clonality and chromosome instability

We have examined 62 prostatic adenocarcinomas by conventional cytogenetic analysis. Most were primary cultures harvested in 14 days or less. The most consistent finding was a normal male diploid karyotype, found in 87% of all cells analyzed, and as the exclusive finding in 19 tumors. Nonrandom chromosomal changes included gain of chromosome 7 and loss of the Y chromosome. In addition, clonal gains of chromosomes 8, 12, and 18, and clonal losses of chromosomes 14 and 19 were noted in individual cases. Two structural clonal aberrations, a 9p+ in one case and a t(Y;22) (q11.2;p12) in another, were also seen. Ten of 62 cultures demonstrated chromosome instability, defined herein as nonclonal gain or loss of chromosomes in more than 10% of the metaphases examined from that culture. In those cases with nonclonal numerical aberrations, loss of chromosomes was more common than gain. The distribution of apparently random numeric abnormalities was similar to that of the clonal abnormalities in that the most frequent nonclonal gain was of chromosome 7 and the most frequent nonclonal loss was of the Y chromosome. Apparently random structural aberrations were observed in less than 1% of all analyzed cells. These included a 4p-,del(3)(q13), and t(1;11). The extent of apparently random aneuploidy suggests that chromosome instability characterizes cultured prostatic adenocarcinomas. An increase in the frequency of nonclonal aberrations may be an indicator of tumor origin in a predominantly diploid cell population. The coexistence of clonally aberrant, nonclonally aberrant, and normal diploid cells in culture may reflect heterogeneity of prostate tumors in vivo.