Sanford E. Emery

Anterior Cervical Decompression and Arthrodesis for the Treatment of Cervical Spondylotic Myelopathy. Two to Seventeen-Year Follow-up*

We reviewed the cases of 108 patients with cervical spondylotic myelopathy who had been managed with anterior decompression and arthrodesis at our institution. Operative treatment consisted of anterior discectomy, partial corpectomy, or subtotal corpectomy at one level or more, followed by placement of autogenous bone graft from the iliac crest or the fibula. At the latest follow-up examination, thirty-eight of the eighty-two patients who had had a preoperative gait abnormality had a normal gait, thirty-three had an improvement in gait, six had no change, four had improvement and later deterioration, and one had a worse gait abnormality. Of the eighty-seven patients who had had a preoperative motor deficit, fifty-four had complete recovery; twenty-six, partial recovery; six, no change; and one had a worse deficit. The average grade according to the system of Nurick improved from 2.4 preoperatively to 1.2 (range, 0.0 to 5.0) postoperatively. A pseudarthrosis developed in sixteen patients, thirteen of whom had had a multilevel discectomy. Only one of thirty-eight arthrodeses that had been performed with use of a fibular strut graft was followed by a non-union. An unsatisfactory outcome with respect to pain was significantly associated with pseudarthrosis (p < 0.001). The development of complications other than non-union was associated with a history of one previous operative procedure or more (p = 0.005). Recurrent myelopathy was rare, but when it occurred it was associated with a pseudarthrosis or stenosis at a new level. The strongest predictive factor for recovery from myelopathy was the severity of the myelopathy before the operative intervention—that is, better preoperative neurological function was associated with a better neurological outcome. Anterior decompression and arthrodesis with autogenous bone-grafting can be performed safely, and is associated with a high rate of neurological recovery, functional improvement, and pain relief, in patients who have cervical spondylotic myelopathy.

Factors affecting bone graft incorporation.

Successful graft incorporation requires that an appropriate match be made among the biologic activity of a bone graft, the condition of the perigraft environment, and the mechanical environment. The authors have studied, in a wide variety of animal models, the factors that affect the main components of bone graft incorporation: revascularization, new bone formation, and host-graft union. The principal determinant of the rate, pattern, and amount of revascularization is the presence or absence of a vascular pedicle. The nonvascularized bone graft is entirely dependent on the surrounding tissue for its revascularization, which results in a noticeable delay in vessel ingrowth. The principal determinant of the rate and amount of new bone formation on, in, or about a bone graft is the presence or absence of living, histocompatible, committed bone-forming cells. When living cells are not part of the graft at the time of implantation, the cells that form new bone are derived from host tissues, and new bone formation is delayed. The principal determinants of host-graft union are stability of the construct and contact between host bone and the graft. Factors that slow or inhibit all of these processes are reduction of the biologic activity of the graft by freezing or some other treatment, histocompatibility antigen disparities between donor and recipient, mechanical instability between the graft and the perigraft environment, and local and systemic interference with the biologic activity of the graft and surrounding tissue, for example, by irradiation or the administration of cisplatin. The task of the clinician who does a bone grafting procedure is to choose the right graft or combination of grafts for the biologic and mechanical environment into which the graft will be placed.

Robinson anterior cervical fusion : comparison of the standard and modified techniques

In 1990 the authors modified the Robinson anterior cervical interbody fusion technique by burring the endplates to expose subchondral bone. The authors compared 31 patients having the standard technique and 29 patients having the modified technique to evaluate 1) setting of the bone graft, 2) kyphotic angulation, 3) pseudarthrosis rate, and 4) pain outcome. In the standard Robinson fusion technique, the average loss of height across the fused segments was 0.8 mm and the average increase in kyphosis 4.9 degrees. Values for the modified technique were 1.9 mm and 3.1 degrees, respectively. The change in height was statistically significant (P = .01), as was the difference in angulation (P = .028), though the latter was in the opposite direction predicted. The pseudarthrosis rate using the modified technique decreased to 4.4% per level. Pain outcome for the two groups was equivalent. Burring of the endplates for anterior cervical interbody arthrodesis results in a detectable but not clinically important amount of graft settling with a higher success rate for arthrodesis.

Graft migration or displacement after multilevel cervical corpectomy and strut grafting.

Study Design. A retrospective review of consecutive patients with graft migration or displacement after anterior cervical corpectomy surgery was performed. Objectives. To examine the associated risk factors and results of treatment among patients who sustained graft displacement or migration after anterior cervical corpectomy surgery. Summary of Background Data. Graft migration or displacement after anterior cervical corpectomy is a potential complication that may require revision surgery, but because of the low incidence, the factors associated with graft movement and the results of treatment are not well defined. Methods. All patients who had undergone a cervical corpectomy were examined for graft migration or displacement. None of the patients had a previous cervical laminectomy or prior posterior cervical surgery. All the patients were treated with autogenous strut grafting after decompression. Results. Over a 25-year period, 249 consecutive patients underwent one- to five-level anterior cervical corpectomies and strut grafting. All the patients were fused using autogenous bone grafts (iliac crest or fibula). During the postoperative period, 16 of the patients (10 women and 6 men; average age, 61.4 years) experienced migration of their grafts. The average follow-up period was 4.7 years (range, 2–12 years). The graft migration rates increased with more levels of fusion (odds ratio of 1.65 for having a displaced graft with each additional level): 4 of 95 single-level grafts, 4 of 76 two-level grafts, 7 of 71 three-level grafts, and 1 of 6 for four-level grafts. Of the 16 patients with graft migration, 14 had procedures involving a corpectomy of C6 with a fusion inferiorly extending to the C7 vertebral body (P = 0.001, statistically significant difference). Of these 16 patients, 5 underwent revision surgeries acutely for displacement and associated fracture of the inferior graft and vertebral body junction. None of the patients sustained a neurologic or respiratory complication as a result of graft migration ordisplacement. All of the patients went on to successfulfusion. Conclusions. This study demonstrated that a greater number of vertebral bodies removed and a longer graft are directly related to an increased frequency of graft displacement. Graft displacement may require revision surgery, but no patient in this study experienced a permanent adverse result from this complication. Corpectomies involving a fusion ending at the C7 vertebral body were associated with a higher rate of graft migration.

Increased rate of arthrodesis with strut grafting after multilevel anterior cervical decompression

Study Design. Reconstruction techniques after multilevel anterior cervical decompression were retrospectively compared. Objective. To compare radiographic and clinical outcomes of multiple interbody grafting with strut grafting. Summary of Background Data. Previous studies have reported lower fusion rates for anterior cervical decompressions reconstructed with multiple interbody grafts as opposed to a single strut graft, although these techniques have never been directly compared in a consecutive series of patients who underwent surgery by a single surgeon. Methods. Over a 20-year period, 190 patients underwent anterior cervical decompression and autogenous grafting without internal fixation and were followed for an average of 68 months. There were 98 two-level and 33 three-level discectomies with interbody grafting. These were compared with 16 one-level, 21 two-level, 20 three-level, and 2 four-level corpectomies with strut grafting. Radiographic and clinical outcomes were compared between the groups by &khgr;2 and rank-sum analysis, respectively. Results. Of the 59 patients who underwent strut grafting, 55 achieved a solid arthrodesis (93%), as compared with 87 of the 131 patients who underwent multiple interbody grafting (66%) (P = 0.0002). There were six cases of graft displacement or extrusion among the 59 patients who had strut grafts, as compared with no graft-related complications among the 131 patients who had interbody grafts (P < 0.0001). More “good” and “excellent” clinical outcomes were found among patients who underwent strut-grafting (88%vs 84%), although the difference was not statistically significant (P = 0.73). However, patients with a pseudarthrosis had significantly poorer clinical outcomes (P < 0.0001). Conclusions. A much higher fusion rate was achieved after corpectomy and strut grafting than after multilevel discectomy and interbody grafting. Although there were strut graft-related complications, four of these six complications occurred among patients who had a postlaminectomy kyphosis. Because pseudarthrosis resulted in poorer clinical outcomes, strut grafting should be considered after multilevel anterior cervical decompression to increase the likelihood of successful fusion.

Impact of Smoking on the Outcome of Anterior Cervical Arthrodesis with Interbody or Strut-Grafting

Background: An increased rate of pseudarthrosis has been documented following posterolateral lumbar spine grafting in patients who smoke. This same relationship has been assumed for anterior cervical interbody grafting, but to our knowledge it has never been proven. This study compared the long-term radiographic and clinical results of smokers and nonsmokers who had undergone arthrodesis with autogenous bone graft following multilevel anterior cervical decompression for the treatment of cervical radiculopathy or myelopathy, or both. Methods: One hundred and ninety patients were followed clinically and radiographically for at least two years (range, two to fifteen years). Fifty-nine of the patients had corpectomy with strut-grafting, and 131 patients had multiple discectomies and interbody grafting. Fifty-five of the 190 patients had a history of active cigarette-smoking; fifteen of the fifty-five had corpectomy with strut-grafting, and forty had multilevel discectomies and interbody grafting. Internal fixation was not used in any patient. The reconstruction techniques and postoperative bracing regimen were similar between smokers and nonsmokers. Osseous union was judged on dynamic lateral radiographs made at least two years following surgery, and clinical outcomes were judged on the basis of pain level, medication usage, and daily activity level. Results: Of the forty smokers who had undergone multilevel interbody grafting, twenty had a solid fusion at all levels, whereas sixty-nine of the ninety-one nonsmokers had solid fusion at all levels (p < 0.02; chi-square test). This difference was especially pronounced among patients who had had a two-level interbody grafting procedure (p < 0.002; chi-square test). With the numbers available, there was no difference in the rate of fusion between smokers (fourteen of fifteen) and nonsmokers (forty-one of forty-four) who had undergone corpectomy and strut-grafting, as 93% of both groups had a solid union. In addition, clinical outcomes were significantly worse among smokers when compared with nonsmokers (p < 0.03; rank-sum analysis). Conclusions: Smoking had a significant negative impact on healing and clinical recovery after multilevel anterior cervical decompression and fusion with autogenous interbody graft for radiculopathy or myelopathy. Since smoking had no apparent effect upon the healing of autogenous iliac-crest or fibular strut grafts, subtotal corpectomy and autogenous strut-grafting should be considered when a multilevel anterior cervical decompression and fusion is performed in patients who are unable or unwilling to stop smoking prior to surgical treatment.

Degenerative Spondylolisthesis : Does Fusion Method Influence Outcome? Four-Year Results of the Spine Patient Outcomes Research Trial

Study Design. Clinical trial subgroup analysis. Objective. To compare outcomes of different fusion techniques treating degenerative spondylolisthesis (DS). Summary of Background Data. Surgery has been shown to be more effective than nonoperative treatment out to 4 years. Questions remain regarding the differential effect of fusion technique. Methods. Surgical candidates from 13 centers in 11 states with at least 12 weeks of symptoms and confirmatory imaging showing stenosis and DS were studied. In addition to standard decompressive laminectomy, 1 of 3 fusion techniques was employed at the surgeon’s discretion: posterolateral in situ fusion (PLF); posterolateral instrumented fusion with pedicle screws (PPS); or PPS plus interbody fusion (360°). Main outcome measures were the SF-36 bodily pain (BP) and physical function (PF) scales and the modified Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) assessed at 6 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, and yearly to 4 years. The as-treated analysis combined the randomized and observational cohorts using mixed longitudinal models adjusting for potential confounders. Results. Of 380 surgical patients, 21% (N = 80) received a PLF; 56% (N = 213) received a PPS; 17% (N = 63) received a 360°; and 6% (N = 23) had decompression only without fusion. Early outcomes varied, favoring PLF compared to PPS at 6 weeks (PF: 12.73 vs. 6.22, P < 0.020) and 3 months (PF: 25.24 vs.18.95, P < 0.025) and PPS compared to 360° at 6 weeks (ODI: −14.46 vs. −9.30, P < 0.03) and 3 months (ODI: −22.30 vs. −16.78, P < 0.02). At 2 years, 360° had better outcomes: BP: 39.08 versus 29.17 PLF, P < 0.011; and versus 29.13 PPS, P < 0.002; PF: 31.93 versus 23.27 PLF, P < 0.021; and versus 25.29 PPS, P < 0.036. However, these differences were not maintained at 3- and 4-year follow-up, when there were no statistically significant differences between the 3 fusion groups. Conclusion. In patients with DS and associated spinal stenosis, no consistent differences in clinical outcomes were seen among fusion groups over 4 years.

Magnetic resonance imaging of posttraumatic spinal ligament injury

We evaluated the role of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in the detection of ligament injury in 37 patients after acute traumatic spinal injury. Thirty-five patients had fractures, one had neurologic deficit with normal x-rays, and one had evidence of cervical instability on flexion/extension plain films. MRI examinations were performed acutely (average 10.8 d after injury) using T1- and T2-weighted multiplanar imaging. Two radiologists blindly evaluated all MRI examinations. Subsequently, 35 plain films, 16 tomograms, and 30 computed tomography (CT) scans were also evaluated. Nineteen patients were considered to have torn posterior ligaments on the basis of their clinical, radiographic and surgical findings. MRI detected ligament damage in 17. All patients considered to have intact posterior ligament complexes clinically and radiographically had no evidence of ligament damage on MRI. T2-weighted sequences were essential for detection of ligament injury. We conclude that MRI is an accurate method for assessment of the integrity of spinal ligaments after acute trauma.

The biological and biomechanical effects of irradiation on anterior spinal bone grafts in a canine model

We evaluated the effects of irradiation on the healing of anterior vertebral strut grafts with use of a canine model. Through a left thoracotomy, a partial corpectomy of the seventh thoracic vertebra and autogenous iliac strut-grafting from the sixth to the eighth thoracic levels were performed in twenty-two adult beagles. Four groups were established: Group I (control) received no irradiation, Group II received preoperative irradiation, Group III received postoperative irradiation that began on the third postoperative day, and Group IV received postoperative irradiation that began on the twenty-first postoperative day. The irradiation protocol was five treatments of 500 centigray three times a week for a total of 2500 centigray. Fluorochromes were administered at regular intervals postoperatively. The beagles were killed three months postoperatively, and non-destructive biomechanical testing was done to evaluate the stiffness of the construct. The quality of healing at the junctions of the graft with the sixth and eighth thoracic vertebrae, the degree of revascularization of the graft, and the amount of new-bone formation were evaluated histologically. Statistical evaluation of the biomechanical data revealed no significant difference in the stiffness of the construct between Groups I, II, and IV. The specimens from Group III were significantly less stiff than those from Group I (the control group) in torsion (p = 0.03) and left lateral bending (p = 0.04) and than those from Group II in flexion (p = 0.02) and left lateral bending (p = 0.005).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Pseudoarthrosis of the Cervical Spine: A Comparison of Radiographic Diagnostic Measures

STUDY DESIGN A retrospective review was conducted. OBJECTIVE To compare the accuracy of two objective radiographic techniques in identifying nonunion after anterior cervical discectomy and fusion. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA The accuracy of diagnostic methods for detecting pseudarthrosis has been poorly documented. Radiographic criteria mentioned in the literature include perceived motion or change in the Cobb angles between the involved segments on flexion-extension views. METHODS The participants in this study were 27 patients with 29 cervical fusions ranging from one to three levels. Patients were examined and radiographs obtained. The mean follow-up period was 39 months. Two measurements were obtained from lateral flexion-extension radiographs: Cobb angle and the distance between the tips of the spinous processes of the surgically managed levels. The measurements were obtained independently by three physicians in a blinded fashion. RESULTS The reliability among the observers, as measured by Cronbachs alpha, was 0.95 for the spinous process method and 0.74 for the Cobb angle method. A measurement of more than 2 mm between spinous processes was noted in patients with a known pseudarthrosis. The Pearson correlation between pseudarthrosis and use of the spinous process method was 0.77 ( < 0.001). The Pearson correlation between pseudarthrosis and use of the Cobb angle method was 0.28 ( > 0.10). The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve for the spinous process method was found to be 0.980, as compared with 0.662 for the Cobb angle method, for the measurement of pseudarthrosis. CONCLUSIONS Measurement of the change in distance between spinous processes is more reproducible and accurate than the Cobb method for making the diagnosis of pseudarthrosis. The authors believe that the measurement of distances between spinous processes on lateral flexion-extension radiographs should be used as a method for evaluating radiographic fusion in patients with pseudarthrosis.