Seth I. Rosenberg

MOSHER AWARD HONORABLE MENTION

Objectives/Hypothesis: 1) Develop a computerized technique to accurately compare acoustic neuroma size on routine computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans; 2) use this technique to determine the growth pattern in a large series of patients with acoustic neuroma who were conservatively managed; 3) describe the natural history of patients with acoustic neuromas who did not receive surgical intervention and those who underwent subtotal resection; 4) correlate the size and growth rate of acoustic neuromas to clinical presentation and auditory and vestibular testing; and 5) recommend guidelines for the management of patients with acoustic neuromas. Study Design: A retrospective study from 1974 to 1999 of patients with unilateral acoustic neuromas who had conservative treatment by serial imaging studies (80 patients) or subtotal resection (49 patients). Methods: All patient charts were evaluated for presenting symptoms, reasons for the type of management given, and clinical outcome. Charts were also reviewed with respect to serial audiological assessment, electronystagmography, and brainstem auditory evoked response. Imaging studies were analyzed using a computer technique so that serial studies could be compared to determine growth rates. Results: Rigorous computer analysis of tumor size and growth rate was statistically the same as the radiologists description of the tumor size and growth rate. Of 70 patients who were older than 65 years of age old at the time their tumor was discovered, 4 (5.7%) required intervention and 18 (26%) were dead of unrelated causes. These patients had a mean follow-up of 4.8 years (range, 0.01-17.2 y). Overall, growth rate for nonsurgical patients was 0.91 mm per year. Nonsurgical tumors did not grow or regressed in 42.3%. Overall postoperative growth rate for surgical subtotal resection patients was 0.35 mm per year. Surgical tumors did not grow or regressed after subtotal resection of acoustic neuroma in 68.5% of patients. Three patients (6.1%) required revision surgery because of tumor growth or the development of symptoms. Neither auditory nor vestibular testing was a reliable measure for determining tumor growth. Conclusion: Measurement of the maximal tumor diameter on MRI scans is a reliable method for following acoustic neuroma growth. There is no need to perform a rigorous analysis of tumor size to determine whether the tumor is growing significantly. The vast majority of patients older than 65 years with acoustic neuromas do not require intervention. The indications for intervention should be based on a combination of rapid tumor growth with the development of symptoms.Objectives/Hypothesis 1) Develop a computerized technique to accurately compare acoustic neuroma size on routine computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans; 2) use this technique to determine the growth pattern in a large series of patients with acoustic neuroma who were conservatively managed; 3) describe the natural history of patients with acoustic neuromas who did not receive surgical intervention and those who underwent subtotal resection; 4) correlate the size and growth rate of acoustic neuromas to clinical presentation and auditory and vestibular testing; and 5) recommend guidelines for the management of patients with acoustic neuromas.

Laser-assisted tympanostomy.

Laser‐assisted tympanostomy (LAT) was performed in 70 ears to ventilate the middle ear space without using a pressure‐equalizing tube. Using a CO2 laser attached to an operating microscope with a Microslad (microscope laser adaptor device), tympanostomies of 1.0 to 3.0 mm (average, 1.6 mm) in diameter were created and remained patent for an average of 3.14 weeks. Patency time was directly related to the size of the opening. Nearly all (97.9%) of the tympanostomies healed with no noticeable scarring and no persistent perforations. Seventy‐eight percent of patients at the Florida Ear & Sinus Center (FESC, Sarasota, Fla.) and 84% of patients at the Head & Neck Surgery Group (New York) showed no evidence of recurrent effusion after a minimum follow‐up of 3 months. LAT appears to be a safe, cost‐effective procedure which can easily be performed in an office setting when bloodless opening in the tympanic membrane is needed for either treatment or diagnosis using endoscopes.

An algorithm for the management of acoustic neuromas regarding age, hearing, tumor size, and symptoms.

An algorithm has evolved for the management of patients with acoustic neuroma. Decisions as to surgery vs. observation, surgical approach, and whether hearing preservation should be attempted depend on age, patient symptoms, size of the tumor, residual hearing, and degree of facial nerve involvement at the time of surgery. Conservative management is used for patients over 65 years of age. This consists of observation or subtotal resection through a translabyrinthine approach, depending on the absence or presence of brainstem signs or symptoms. In patients under 65 years of age, hearing preservation is attempted through the retrosigmoid approach in tumors 1.5 cm or less if pure-tone average is less than 30 dB and the discrimination score is greater than 70%. The translabyrinthine approach is our preferred approach for tumors of any size when hearing is not serviceable. A near-total excision is performed when the facial nerve cannot be separated from the tumor. The rationale for this algorithm in the management of 130 cases of acoustic neuroma over the past 17 years is presented.

Revision stapes surgery with and without laser: a comparison.

In this study, the results of 76 revision stapes surgeries performed from 1974 to 1992 were reviewed. Either the KTP or the argon laser was used in 40 operations. Prosthesis problems were the most common cause for revision (63%) followed by eroded/ necrotic incus (29%) and adhesions (29%). Overall “success” in air‐bone gap closure (air‐bone gap ≤ 10 dB) was 46% for first revisions and 33% for second or greater revisions. The “improvement” rate (air‐bone gap ≤ 20 dB) was 65% for first revisions and 53% for second or greater revisions. There was no statistically significant difference in hearing results between laser surgery and conventional technique. However, an absence of adhesions was noted when the laser had been used in the primary procedure.

A Comparison of Growth Rates of Acoustic Neuromas: Nonsurgical Patients vs. Subtotal Resection:

A conservative approach to the management of acoustic neuromas in elderly patients has been used since 1971. Elderly patients without symptoms of brain stem compression are initially treated by observation and yearly radiographic imaging. A translabyrinthine radical-subtotal resection is performed if brain stem compression is present or if tumor is growing rapidly. Twenty-three patients, ages 65 to 86 years, had initial nonsurgical management of their tumors. Growth rates could be determined for 16 patients. Thirteen patients not requiring surgery had an average tumor growth rate of 0.6 mm/yr. Three patients with an average growth rate of 6.8 mm/yr eventually required surgery. No patient whose tumor was < 15 mm at initial evaluation has experienced brain stem symptoms or demonstrated rapid tumor growth. Twenty-four patients ages 65 to 86 years underwent planned subtotal tumor excision. Eighteen patients followed postoperatively for more than 1 year demonstrated an average rate of regrowth of tumor of 0.7 mm/yr. (OTOLARYNGOL HEAD NECK SURG 1993;109:482-7.)

An evolution of approach in vestibular neurectomy.

Since introducing the retrolabyrinthine vestibular neurectomy in 1978, we have performed 78 procedures with good results. In 1985 we introduced the retrosigmoid-IAC vestibular neurectomy, which allows a more complete transection of the vestibular nerves within the internal auditory canal (IAC). Vertigo control has been excellent; however, in 75% of patients, postoperative headaches have been a significant problem. In 1987, the best aspects of the two procedures were incorporated and the combined retrolab-retrosigmoid vestibular neurectomy was developed. The procedure is similar to the RVN in that all bone covering the lateral venous sinus is removed. It differs from the RVN in that a limited mastoidectomy is performed and the dura is opened just behind the LVS. The LVS is retracted forward, exposing the cerebellopontine angle. This allows the surgeon the option to section the vestibular nerve in either the CP angle or the IAC, depending upon the presence or absence of a cochieovestibular cleavage plane in the CP angle. The results have been good and the incidence of headache has been reduced to 10%. The technique, results, and complications are reported here.

Preservation of the stapedius tendon in laser stapes surgery

Objectives/Hypothesis: The stapedius tendon is routinely transected during stapes surgery. The objective of this study was to evaluate the technique of stapedial tendon preservation during stapes surgery and to compare results of these cases with cases where the stapedial tendon was not preserved. Study Design: Retrospective study. Methods: Four groups of patients were evaluated. Two groups had undergone stapes surgery with preservation of the stapedial tendon. One of these groups underwent a laser stapedotomy minus prosthesis (laser STAMP) procedure, while the other group had a prosthesis inserted. The other two groups had undergone laser stapedotomy with one of two different prostheses being used. Audiometric data were obtained and reviewed both preoperatively and at approximately 6 weeks postoperatively. Results: All groups had overall successful results demonstrating that stapedial tendon preservation is technically possible and does not compromise outcomes. Conclusions: Based on the results, it is recommended that the stapedius tendon be preserved whenever possible during laser stapes surgery. Reasons justifying its preservation are discussed. Laryngoscope, 108:1453–1458, 1998

Hearing results after posterior fossa vestibular neurectomy

The effect of posterior fossa vestibular neurectomy on postoperative hearing levels of 172 patients was studied at 1 week, 1 month, 1 year, and 18 to 24 months. According to the 1985 American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery guidelines for reporting treatment outcome, 66% of patients had improved or unchanged hearing at 18 to 24 months. One-week postoperative hearing was poorer than at 1 month or later follow-up. Permanent profound hearing loss occurred in 4.7% of patients. In patients who had worse than 80 dB pure-tone average and 20% speech discrimination score hearing loss before surgery, 68% improved above this hearing level, and 16% improved to better than 50 dB pure-tone average and 50% speech discrimination after surgery. This suggests that it may be worthwhile to preserve the cochlear nerve in certain patients who may otherwise be candidates for labyrinthectomy. These hearing results are comparable with other treatment modalities including endolymphatic sac surgery.

Pleomorphic Adenoma of the Lateral Nasal Wall

Few cases of intranasal pleomorphic adenoma have been reported in the English literature. Of those observed in the nose, the vast majority of tumors originate from the septum and <10% originate from the lateral nasal wall. 1 We present the case of a man with a unilateral nasal mass arising from the lateral nasal wall confirmed to be a pleomorphic adenoma on pathologic examination.

Hearing outcome of laser stapedotomy minus prosthesis (STAMP) versus conventional laser stapedotomy.

Objective: The objective of this study was to compare short-and long-term hearing outcomes for patients undergoing primary laser stapedotomy minus prosthesis (STAMP) versus conventional laser stapedotomy. Study Design: We conducted a retrospective case review of 167 consecutive patients from 1993 to 2002. Setting: Otology/neurotology tertiary referral center. Patients: We studied those with clinical otosclerosis without previous otologic surgery. Interventions: Patients with otosclerosis confined to the fissula ante fenestram underwent STAMP. Patients with more extensive otosclerosis or anatomic contraindications to STAMP underwent standard laser stapedotomy. Main Outcome Measures: Pure-tone audiometry was performed before surgery, postoperatively, and on routine follow-up examination. Results: Of the 183 ears in 167 patients, 128 (67.1%) underwent laser stapedotomy and 55 (32.98%) underwent STAMP. The STAMP mean air–bone gap (ABG) closed from a preoperative value of 22 dB (standard deviation [SD], 10 dB) to 6 dB (SD, 7 dB) on average follow up of 778 days. In 128 laser stapedotomy patients with an average follow up of 747 days, the preoperative mean ABG closed from 27 dB (SD, 10 dB) to 8 dB (SD, 7 dB). There was a trend toward improvement in high-frequency air conduction thresholds after STAMP versus worsening of high-frequency thresholds in the conventional stapedotomy group. There was a statistically significant improvement in most recent postoperative high-frequency (6000–8000 Hz) air conduction thresholds in the STAMP patients compared with patients who underwent conventional laser stapedotomy. Conclusion: Laser STAMP, when used for isolated anterior footplate otosclerosis, provides excellent high-frequency hearing, yields lasting results similar to conventional laser stapedotomy, and has a low incidence of refixation necessitating revision surgery.