Shannon L. Meeks

Nonclassical anti-C2 domain antibodies are present in patients with factor VIII inhibitors

The antihuman factor VIII (fVIII) C2 domain immune response in hemophilia A mice consists of antibodies that can be divided into 5 groups of structural epitopes and 2 groups of functional epitopes. Groups A, AB, and B consist of classical C2 antibodies that inhibit the binding of fVIII to phospholipid and von Willebrand factor. Groups BC and C contain nonclassical C2 antibodies that block the activation of fVIII by thrombin or factor Xa. Group BC antibodies are the most common and display high specific inhibitory activity and type II kinetics. The C2 epitope groups recognized by 26 polyclonal human anti-fVIII inhibitor plasmas were identified by a novel competition enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay using group-specific murine monoclonal antibodies. Most of the anti-C2 inhibitor plasmas inhibited the binding of both classical and nonclassical antibodies. These results suggest that nonclassical anti-C2 antibodies contribute significantly to the pathogenicity of fVIII inhibitors.

Epitope mapping of inhibitory antibodies targeting the C2 domain of coagulation factor VIII by hydrogen–deuterium exchange mass spectrometry

The development of anti‐factor VIII antibodies (inhibitors) is a significant complication in the management of patients with hemophilia A, leading to significant increases in morbidity and treatment cost. Using a panel of mAbs against different epitopes on FVIII, we have recently shown that epitope specificity, inhibitor kinetics and time to maximum inhibition are more important than inhibitor titer in predicting responses to FVIII and the combination of FVIII and recombinant FVIIa. In particular, a subset of high‐titer inhibitors responded to high‐dose FVIII, which would not be predicted on the basis of their inhibitor titer alone. Thus, the ability to quickly map the epitope spectrum of patient plasma with a clinically feasible assay may fundamentally change how clinicians approach the treatment of high‐titer inhibitor patients.

US Guidelines for immune tolerance induction in patients with haemophilia a and inhibitors

The development of anti‐factor VIII (FVIII) antibodies (inhibitors) is the most serious treatment‐related complication in patients with hemophilia A, rendering standard replacement therapy ineffective, heightening the risk for uncontrollable bleeding and morbidity, decreasing quality of life, and increasing healthcare costs.

Non-classical anti-factor VIII C2 domain antibodies are pathogenic in a murine in vivo bleeding model.

Summary.  Objective: The pathogenicity of anti‐human factor (F) VIII monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) was tested in a murine bleeding model. Methods: MAbs were injected into the tail veins of hemophilia A mice to a peak plasma concentration of 60 nm, followed by injection of human B domain‐deleted FVIII at 180 U kg−1, producing peak plasma concentrations of ∼2 nm. At 2 h, blood loss following a 4‐mm tail snip was measured. The following MAbs were tested: (i) 4A4, a type I anti‐A2 FVIII inhibitor, (ii) I54 and 1B5, classical type I anti‐C2 inhibitors, (iii) 2–77 and B45, non‐classical type II anti‐C2 inhibitors, and (iv) 2–117, a non‐classical anti‐C2 MAb with inhibitory activity less than 0.4 Bethesda Units per mg IgG. Results: All MAbs except 2–117 produced similar amounts of blood loss that were significantly greater than control mice injected with FVIII alone. Increasing the dose of FVIII to 360 U kg−1 overcame the bleeding diathesis produced by the type II MAbs 2–77 and B45, but not the type I antibodies, 4A4, I54, and 1B5. These results were consistent with the in vitro Bethesda assay in which 4A4 completely inhibited both 1 U mL−1 and 3 U mL−1 FVIII, while there was 40% residual activity at saturating concentrations of 2–77 at either concentration of FVIII. Conclusions: For patients with an inhibitor response dominated by non‐classical anti‐C2 antibodies both the in vivo and in vitro results suggest that treatment with high‐dose FVIII rather than bypassing agents may be warranted.

The diversity of the immune response to the A2 domain of human factor VIII

Approximately 30% of patients with severe hemophilia A develop inhibitory anti-factor VIII (fVIII) antibodies (Abs). We characterized 29 anti-human A2 monoclonal Abs (mAbs) produced in a murine hemophilia A model. A basis set of nonoverlapping mAbs was defined by competition enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, producing 5 major groups. The overlapping epitopes covered nearly the entire A2 surface when mapped by homolog-scanning mutagenesis. Most group A mAbs recognized a previously described epitope bounded by Arg484-Ile508 in the N-terminal A2 subdomain, resulting in binding to activated fVIII and noncompetitive inhibition of the intrinsic fXase complex. Group B and C mAbs displayed little or no inhibitory activity. Group D and E mAbs recognized epitopes in the C-terminal A2 subdomain. A subset of group D mAbs inhibited the activation of fVIII by interfering with thrombin-catalyzed cleavage at Arg372 at the A1-A2 domain junction. Other group D mAbs displayed indeterminate or no inhibitory activity despite inhibiting cleavage at Arg740 at the A2-B domain junction. Group E mAbs inhibited fVIII light-chain cleavage at Arg1689. Inhibition of cleavages at Arg372 and Arg1689 represent novel mechanisms of inhibitor function and, along with the extensive epitope spectrum identified in this study, reveal hitherto unrecognized complexity in the immune response to fVIII.

Enhancing the pharmaceutical properties of protein drugs by ancestral sequence reconstruction

Optimization of a proteins pharmaceutical properties is usually carried out by rational design and/or directed evolution. Here we test an alternative approach based on ancestral sequence reconstruction. Using available genomic sequence data on coagulation factor VIII and predictive models of molecular evolution, we engineer protein variants with improved activity, stability, and biosynthesis potential and reduced inhibition by anti-drug antibodies. In principle, this approach can be applied to any protein drug based on a conserved gene sequence.

Potentiation of Thrombin Generation in Hemophilia A Plasma by Coagulation Factor VIII and Characterization of Antibody-Specific Inhibition

Development of inhibitory antibodies to coagulation factor VIII (fVIII) is the primary obstacle to the treatment of hemophilia A in the developed world. This adverse reaction occurs in 20–30% of persons with severe hemophilia A treated with fVIII-replacement products and is characterized by the development of a humoral and neutralizing immune response to fVIII. Patients with inhibitory anti-fVIII antibodies are treated with bypassing agents including recombinant factor VIIa (rfVIIa). However, some patients display poor hemostatic response to bypass therapy and improved treatment options are needed. Recently, we demonstrated that fVIII inhibitors display widely variable kinetics of inhibition that correlate with their respective target epitopes. Thus, it was hypothesized that for antibodies that display slow rates of inhibition, supplementation of rfVIIa with fVIII would result in improved thrombin generation and be predictive of clinical responses to this novel treatment regimen. In order to test this hypothesis, 10 murine monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) with non-overlapping epitopes spanning fVIII, differential inhibition titers, and inhibition kinetics were studied using a thrombin generation assay. Of the 3 MAbs with high inhibitory titers, only the one with fast and complete (classically defined as “type I”) kinetics displayed significant inhibition of thrombin generation with no improvement upon supplementation of rfVIIa with fVIII. The other two MAbs that displayed incomplete (classically defined as “type II”) inhibition did not suppress the potentiation of thrombin generation by fVIII. All antibodies that did not completely inhibit fVIII activity demonstrated potentiation of thrombin generation by the addition of fVIII as compared to rfVIIa alone. In conclusion, fVIII alone or in combination with rfVIIa corrects the thrombin generation defect produced by the majority of anti-fVIII MAbs better than single agent rfVIIa. Therefore, combined fVIII/rfVIIa therapy may provide better hemostatic control than current therapy in some patients with anti-fVIII inhibitors.

Factor VIII A3 domain substitution N1922S results in hemophilia A due to domain-specific misfolding and hyposecretion of functional protein

A point mutation leading to amino acid substitution N1922S in the A3 domain of factor VIII (fVIII) results in moderate to severe hemophilia A. A heterologous expression system comparing N1922S-fVIII and wild-type fVIII (wt-fVIII) demonstrated similar specific coagulant activities but poor secretion of N1922S-fVIII. Immunocytochemical analysis revealed that intracellular levels of N1922S-fVIII were similar to those of wt-fVIII. The specific activity of intracellular N1922S-fVIII was 10% of that of wt-fVIII, indicating the presence of large amounts of a nonfunctional N1922S-fVIII-folding intermediate. wt-fVIII colocalized with both endoplasmic reticulum (ER)- and Golgi-resident proteins. In contrast, N1922S-fVIII colocalized only with ER-resident proteins, indicating a block in transit from the ER to the Golgi. A panel of conformation-dependent monoclonal antibodies was used to determine native or nonnative folding of N1922S-fVIII. Intracellular N1922S-fVIII but not secreted N1922S-fVIII displayed abnormal folding in the A3 and C1 domains, indicating that the A1, A2, and C2 domains fold independently into antigenically intact tertiary structures, but that folding is stalled in the mutant A3 and its contiguous C1 domain. In summary, the N1922S substitution results in poor secretion of a functional protein, and the domain-specific defect in folding and intracellular trafficking of N1922S-fVIII is a novel mechanism for secretion defects leading to hemophilia A.

Characterization and Solution Structure of the Factor VIII C2 Domain in a Ternary Complex with Classical and Non-Classical Inhibitor Antibodies

Background: The development of antibodies against coagulation factor VIII (fVIII) is a serious complication of hemophilia A. Results: Small angle x-ray scattering reveals a molecular envelope solution structure of two inhibitor antibodies bound to the C2 domain of fVIII. Conclusion: Multiple inhibitor antibodies can bind to the fVIII C2 domain simultaneously, and modeling suggests the localization of key epitopes. Significance: Understanding fVIII-inhibitor interactions is crucial for developing more effective hemophilia A therapies. The most significant complication for patients with severe cases of congenital or acquired hemophilia A is the development of inhibitor antibodies against coagulation factor VIII (fVIII). The C2 domain of fVIII is a significant antigenic target of anti-fVIII antibodies. Here, we have utilized small angle x-ray scattering (SAXS) and biochemical techniques to characterize interactions between two different classes of anti-C2 domain inhibitor antibodies and the isolated C2 domain. Multiple assays indicated that antibodies 3E6 and G99 bind independently to the fVIII C2 domain and can form a stable ternary complex. SAXS-derived numerical estimates of dimensional parameters for all studied complexes agree with the proportions of the constituent proteins. Ab initio modeling of the SAXS data results in a long kinked structure of the ternary complex, showing an angle centered at the C2 domain of ∼130°. Guided by biochemical data, rigid body modeling of subunits into the molecular envelope of the ternary complex suggests that antibody 3E6 recognizes a C2 domain epitope consisting of the Arg2209–Ser2216 and Leu2178–Asp2187 loops. In contrast, antibody G99 recognizes the C2 domain primarily through the Pro2221–Trp2229 loop. These two epitopes are on opposing sides of the fVIII C2 domain, are consistent with the solvent accessibility in the context of the entire fVIII molecule, and provide further structural detail regarding the pathogenic immune response to fVIII.

High-affinity, noninhibitory pathogenic C1 domain antibodies are present in patients with hemophilia A and inhibitors

Inhibitor formation in hemophilia A is the most feared treatment-related complication of factor VIII (fVIII) therapy. Most inhibitor patients with hemophilia A develop antibodies against the fVIII A2 and C2 domains. Recent evidence demonstrates that the C1 domain contributes to the inhibitor response. Inhibitory anti-C1 monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) have been identified that bind to putative phospholipid and von Willebrand factor (VWF) binding epitopes and block endocytosis of fVIII by antigen presenting cells. We now demonstrate by competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry that 7 of 9 anti-human C1 mAbs tested recognize an epitope distinct from the C1 phospholipid binding site. These mAbs, designated group A, display high binding affinities for fVIII, weakly inhibit fVIII procoagulant activity, poorly inhibit fVIII binding to phospholipid, and exhibit heterogeneity with respect to blocking fVIII binding to VWF. Another mAb, designated group B, inhibits fVIII procoagulant activity, fVIII binding to VWF and phospholipid, fVIIIa incorporation into the intrinsic Xase complex, thrombin generation in plasma, and fVIII uptake by dendritic cells. Group A and B epitopes are distinct from the epitope recognized by the canonical, human-derived inhibitory anti-C1 mAb, KM33, whose epitope overlaps both groups A and B. Antibodies recognizing group A and B epitopes are present in inhibitor plasmas from patients with hemophilia A. Additionally, group A and B mAbs increase fVIII clearance and are pathogenic in a hemophilia A mouse tail snip bleeding model. Group A anti-C1 mAbs represent the first identification of pathogenic, weakly inhibitory antibodies that increase fVIII clearance.