Sherri Y. Chan

In vivo depletion of CD8+ T cells results in Th2 cytokine production and alternate mechanisms of allograft rejection.

A current hypothesis states that Th1 cytokines promote allograft rejection and that Th2 cytokines promote graft acceptance. We present data that question the tolerogenic activity of Th2 cytokines, and we suggest that Th2 cytokines may evoke allograft rejection by recruitment of alternate effector mechanisms. Unmodified rejection of mouse heterotopic cardiac allografts is associated with the accumulation of large numbers of donor-reactive CD8+ CTL within the allograft, which is indicative of a Th1-driven cellular response. However, when recipients are depleted of CD8+ CTL, rejection still occurs and is associated with an aggressive cellular infiltrate rich in eosinophils, large mononuclear cells, and fibroblast-like cells. Eosinophils, which are responsive to the Th2 cytokines IL-4 and IL-5, are not present in unmodified rejecting allografts. Differential production of Th1 versus Th2 cytokines was further suggested by altered levels of IgG2a (promoted by IFNγ) and IgG1 (promoted by IL-4) alloantibody in the sera of these mice; IgG2a dominated the alloantibody response in unmodified allograft recipients, whereas IgGl levels increased in recipients depleted of CD8+ CTL. Altered intragraft cytokine gene expression was verified by RT-PCR; Thl (IL-2, IFNγ), but not Th2 (IL-4, IL-5, IL-10), cytokine mRNAs were readily detectable in the allografts of unmodified recipients. In contrast, both Thl and Th2 cytokine genes were expressed in the allografts of mice depleted of CD8+ CTL. These data suggest that donor-reactive CD8+ CTL inhibit intragraft production of Th2 cytokines, thereby promoting a Thl domi-nated-rejection response. Elimination of CD8+ cells

Lipid-mediated gene transfer of viral IL-10 prolongs vascularized cardiac allograft survival by inhibiting donor-specific cellular and humoral immune responses.

The gene encoding the immunosuppressive cytokine viral interleukin-10 (vIL-10) was introduced into BALB/c (H-2d) vascularized cardiac allografts by perfusing the graft vasculature with DNA–liposome complexes, utilizing the experimental cationic lipid γAP DLRIE/DOPE and a plasmid encoding vIL-10 under the control of the HCMVie promoter. The DNA to lipid ratio and DNA dose were critical factors in obtaining optimal biologic effects. Gene transfer of vIL-10 with a 3:1 DNA to lipid weight ratio using 375 μg DNA significantly prolonged allograft survival in MHC-mismatched C57BL/6 (H-2b) recipients (16.00 days) compared with both unmodified allografts (8.14 days) and vIL-10 antisense controls (8.28 days). Enhanced graft survival was specific to vIL-10 expression since treatment with antisense plasmid or anti-vIL-10 monoclonal antibody (mAb) abrogated the effect. Prolonged survival was associated with a novel histology characterized by a moderate mono- nuclear infiltrate, edema, and diffuse fibrillar/collagen deposition in the interstitium. Despite these morphologic changes, myocytes remained viable and vessels were patent. Limiting dilution analysis revealed transient infiltration of IL-2 secreting, donor-reactive, helper T lymphocytes (HTL) and cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in vIL-10 expressing grafts on day 7, that decreased significantly by day 14. Similarly, vIL-10 gene transfer inhibited the accumulation of donor-specific HTL and CTL in the spleen, compared with antisense controls. Prolonged survival was also associated with a marked decrease in IgM and IgG alloantibody production, with little to no IgG isotype switching. These results show that viral IL-10 gene transfer inhibits graft rejection in a clinically relevant model by inhibiting donor-specific cellular and humoral immune responses.

TISSUE-SPECIFIC CONSEQUENCES OF THE ANTI-ADENOVIRAL IMMUNE RESPONSE: IMPLICATIONS FOR CARDIAC TRANSPLANTS

The immune response to adenoviral vectors can induce inflammation and loss of transgene expression in transfected tissues. This would limit the use of adenovirus-mediated gene transfer in disease states in which long-term gene expression is required. While studying the effect of the anti-adenoviral immune response in transplantation, we found that transgene expression persisted in cardiac isografts transfected with an adenovirus encoding β-galactosidase. Transfected grafts remained free of inflammation, despite the presence of an immune response to the vector. Thus, adenovirus-mediated gene transfer may have therapeutic value in cardiac transplantation and heart diseases. Furthermore, immunological limitations of adenoviral vectors for gene therapy are not universal for all tissue types.

Cytokine regulation of chronic cardiac allograft rejection: evidence against a role for Th1 in the disease process.

BACKGROUND Transient depletion of CD4+ T cells in cardiac allograft recipients prolongs allograft survival; however, grafts exhibit signs of chronic rejection characterized by collagen deposition and neointima development. Although it is believed that Th1 cells promote acute graft rejection, the role of these cells in chronic rejection remains unclear. Hence, our study evaluated whether Th1 cells are associated with the development of chronic cardiac allograft rejection. METHODS Splenocytes obtained from C57BL/6 recipients bearing BALB/c hearts with signs of chronic rejection were adoptively transferred into C57BL/6 SCID cardiac allograft recipients. As a measure of Th1 function, interferon-y production was determined after restimulation of recipient splenocytes with donor alloantigens. RESULTS Transfer of splenocytes in SCID allograft recipients resulted in accelerated chronic rejection in the majority of mice. Characterization of these cells before transfer revealed hyporesponsive Th1 function. However, donor-specific proliferative responses and precursor interleukin-2 producing helper and cytotoxic T lymphocyte frequencies were comparable to that of naive splenocytes. Further, splenocytes obtained from SCID recipients with advanced signs of chronic rejection remained deficient in Th1 function, suggesting that Th1 are not involved in this disease process. This possibility was further supported by the development of chronic rejection in IL-12 knockout recipients. Finally, when splenocytes used for adoptive transfer retained Th1 function, transfer of these cells into SCID recipients resulted in acute allograft rejection. CONCLUSIONS We have established a model in which the mediators of chronic rejection may be further explored. In this system, the absence rather than the presence of donor-reactive Th1 is associated with chronic rejection. These data indicate that Th1-independent effector mechanisms are responsible for chronic rejection in this model.

DNA-liposome versus adenoviral mediated gene transfer of transforming growth factorβ1 in vascularized cardiac allografts: Differential sensitivity of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells to transforming growth factorβ1

We have developed a model of transforming growth factor (TGF)&bgr;1 gene transfer into mouse vascularized cardiac allografts to study the use of gene transfer as an immunosuppressive therapy in transplantation. Donor hearts were perfused with either DNA-liposome complexes or adenoviral vectors that encode the active form of human TGF&bgr;1. DNA-liposome mediated transfection prolonged allograft survival in approximately two-thirds of transplant recipients, while adenoviral delivery of TGF&bgr;1 was not protective. Protective TGF&bgr;1 gene transfer was associated with reduced Th1 responses and an inhibition of the alloantibody isotype switch. The protective effects of TGF&bgr;1 gene transfer were overridden by exogenous interleukin-12 administration. Interestingly, alloreactive CD4+ and CD8+ cells exhibited distinct sensitivities to TGF&bgr;1 gene transfer: CD4+ Th1 function was abrogated by this modality, although CD8+ Th1 function was not. Transient depletion of recipient CD8+ cells markedly prolonged the survival of grafts transfected with either DNA-liposome complexes or adenoviral vectors. Transgene expression persisted for at least 60 days, and Th1 responses were not detectable until CD8+ T cells repopulated the periphery. However, long-term transfected allografts appeared to exhibit exacerbated fibrosis and neointimal development. These manifestations of chronic rejection were absent in long-term transfected isografts, suggesting that long-term expression of active TGF&bgr;1 alone is not sufficient to induce fibrosis of the grafts. Collectively, these data illustrate the utility of immunosuppressive gene therapy as a treatment for transplantation when combined with additional conditioning regimens. Further, they illustrate that alloreactive CD4+ and CD8+ cells may be differentially influenced by cytokine manipulation strategies.

Interleukin-12 (IL-12)-driven alloimmune responses in vitro and in vivo : Requirement for β1 subunit of the IL-12 receptor

BACKGROUND Interleukin-12 (IL-12) mediates its biologic activities via binding high-affinity receptors on T and natural killer cells. Although emphasis has been placed on the requirement for IL-12Rbeta2 in IL-12 bioactivity, the role of IL-12Rbeta1 is less well defined. The current study evaluated the effects of exogenous IL-12 on alloantigen-specific immune responses and determined the requirement for IL-12Rbeta1 in IL-12-mediated alloimmunity. METHODS The mouse heterotopic cardiac transplant model was employed to evaluate the effects of IL-12 on alloantigen-specific immune responses in vivo. In addition, IFN-gamma production in mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC) supplemented with IL-12 was measured to assess the effects of IL-12 on Th1 function in vitro. Mice deficient in IL-12Rbeta1 (IL-12Rbeta1-/-) were used to determine the requirement for this receptor component in IL-12-driven alloimmune responses. RESULTS Addition of IL-12 to MLC consisting of wild-type splenocytes enhanced alloantigen-specific proliferative responses and Th1 development. In contrast, IL-12 did not alter these in vitro immune parameters in IL-12Rbeta1-/- MLC. Treatment of wild-type cardiac allograft recipients with IL-12 resulted in high concentrations of serum interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) and a 10-fold increase in IFN-gamma production by recipient splenocytes after restimulation in vitro. However, this fulminate Th1 response did not accelerate allograft rejection. Importantly, IL-12 had no effect on serum IFN-gamma or in vivo priming of Thl in IL-12Rbeta1-/- recipients. Finally, administration of IL-12 to WT allograft recipients resulted in a bimodal alloantibody response: antibody production was suppressed at high doses of IL-12, and enhanced at lower doses. CONCLUSIONS IL-12 markedly enhances alloantigen-specific immune function; however, these exaggerated Th1-driven responses do not culminate in accelerated allograft rejection. Further, these data indicate that IL-12Rbeta1 is essential for the enhancement of both in vitro and in vivo alloimmune responses by exogenous IL-12.

Allogeneic class I MHC requirement for alloantigen-reactive helper T-lymphocyte responses in vivo : Evidence for indirect presentation of alloantigen

The mechanisms by which host T cells recognize transplant-associated alloantigens in vivo have not been established. Two alloantigen presentation pathways may be used: (1) allogeneic class I and class II MHC molecules may be recognized directly by host CD8+ and CD4+ cells, respectively, or (2) allogeneic MHC molecules may be processed as foreign peptide and presented by host antigen-presenting cells to CD4+ cells in the context of self class II proteins. In this study, the sponge matrix allograft model was used to examine the relative contributions of these alloantigen presentation pathways to CD4+ T-cell activation in vivo. Limiting dilution analysis was used to quantify the localization of interleukin-2-producing helper T lymphocytes (HTL) following implantation of sponge allografts. Allografts either were disparate at both class I and class 11, or were derived from beta2-microglobulin knockout (beta2M-/-) mice, which express class II but are deficient in class I. Two measures of in vivo HTL function were monitored: (1) the accumulation of HTL within the allograft (a process that is dependent upon antigen-driven cytokine production), and (2) the development of cytolytic alloantibodies. After implantation of sponge allografts expressing both class I and class II, HTL were readily detectable in the allograft, and cytolytic alloantibodies were present in the serum. When mice were implanted with beta2M-/- sponge allografts, HTL failed to infiltrate these class I-deficient allografts, and alloantibodies were not detectable in the sera of recipients of beta2M-/- sponge allografts. This in vivo requirement for class I expression was not reflected by traditional in vitro measures of HTL function; cells obtained from lymphoid tissues mounted a mixed lymphocyte response and produced interleukin-2 when stimulated with beta2M-/- splenocytes in vitro. One possible interpretation of these data is that in vivo HTL functions are dependent upon the presence of class I-reactive CD8+ T cells. However, HTL readily infiltrated grafts expressing both class I and class II when recipients depleted of CD8+ T cells, and alloantibodies were produced. These observations support the idea that indirect presentation of allogeneic class I molecules plays a critical role in regulating CD4+ HTL functions associated with allograft rejection in vivo.