Shinsuke Seki

The dominance of warming rate over cooling rate in the survival of mouse oocytes subjected to a vitrification procedure.

The formation of more than trace amounts of ice in cells is lethal. The two contrasting routes to avoiding it are slow equilibrium freezing and vitrification. The cryopreservation of mammalian oocytes by either method continues to be difficult, but there seems a slowly emerging consensus that vitrification procedures are somewhat better for mouse and human oocytes. The approach in these latter procedures is to load cells with high concentrations of glass-inducing solutes and cool them at rates high enough to induce the glassy state. Several devices have been developed to achieve very high cooling rates. Our study has been concerned with the relative influences of warming rate and cooling rate on the survival of mouse oocytes subjected to a vitrification procedure. Oocytes suspended in an ethylene glycol-acetamide-Ficoll-sucrose solution were cooled to -196 degrees C at rates ranging from 37 to 1827 degrees C/min between 20 and -120 degrees C, and for each cooling rate, warmed at rates ranging from 139 to 2950 degrees C/min between -70 and -35 degrees C. The results are unambiguous. If the samples were warmed at the highest rate, survivals were >80% over cooling rates of 187-1827 degrees C/min. If the samples were warmed at the lowest rate, survivals were near 0% regardless of the cooling rate. We interpret the lethality of slow warming to be a consequence of it allowing time for the growth of small intracellular ice crystals by recrystallization.

Survival of mouse oocytes after being cooled in a vitrification solution to −196 °C at 95° to 70,000 °C/min and warmed at 610° to 118,000 °C/min: A new paradigm for cryopreservation by vitrification

There is great interest in achieving reproducibly high survivals of mammalian oocytes (especially human) after cryopreservation, but the results to date have not matched the interest. A prime cause of cell death is the formation of more than trace amounts of intracellular ice, and one strategy to avoid it is vitrification. In vitrification procedures, cells are loaded with high concentrations of glass-inducing solutes and cooled to -196°C at rates high enough to presumably induce the glassy state. In the last decade, several devices have been developed to achieve very high cooling rates. Nearly all in the field have assumed that the cooling rate is the critical factor. The purpose of our study was to test that assumption by examining the consequences of cooling mouse oocytes in a vitrification solution at four rates ranging from 95 to 69,250°C/min to -196°C and for each cooling rate, subjecting them to five warming rates back above 0°C at rates ranging from 610 to 118,000°C/min. In samples warmed at the highest rate (118,000°C/min), survivals were 70% to 85% regardless of the prior cooling rate. In samples warmed at the lowest rate (610°C/min), survivals were low regardless of the prior cooling rate, but decreased from 25% to 0% as the cooling rate was increased from 95 to 69,000°C/min. Intermediate cooling and warming rates gave intermediate survivals. The especially high sensitivity of survival to warming rate suggests that either the crystallization of intracellular glass during warming or the growth by recrystallization of small intracellular ice crystals formed during cooling are responsible for the lethality of slow warming.

Effect of Warming Rate on the Survival of Vitrified Mouse Oocytes and on the Recrystallization of Intracellular Ice

Abstract Successful cryopreservation demands there be little or no intracellular ice. One procedure is classical slow equilibrium freezing, and it has been successful in many cases. However, for some important cell types, including some mammalian oocytes, it has not. For the latter, there are increasing attempts to cryopreserve them by vitrification. However, even if intracellular ice formation (IIF) is prevented during cooling, it can still occur during the warming of a vitrified sample. Here, we examine two aspects of this occurrence in mouse oocytes. One took place in oocytes that were partly dehydrated by an initial hold for 12 min at −25°C. They were then cooled rapidly to −70°C and warmed slowly, or they were warmed rapidly to intermediate temperatures and held. These oocytes underwent no IIF during cooling but blackened from IIF during warming. The blackening rate increased about 5-fold for each five-degree rise in temperature. Upon thawing, they were dead. The second aspect involved oocytes that had been vitrified by cooling to −196°C while suspended in a concentrated solution of cryoprotectants and warmed at rates ranging from 140°C/min to 3300°C/min. Survivals after warming at 140°C/min and 250°C/min were low (<30%). Survivals after warming at ≥2200°C/min were high (80%). When warmed slowly, they were killed, apparently by the recrystallization of previously formed small internal ice crystals. The similarities and differences in the consequences of the two types of freezing are discussed.

Ultra-Rapid Warming Yields High Survival of Mouse Oocytes Cooled to −196°C in Dilutions of a Standard Vitrification Solution

Intracellular ice is generally lethal. One way to avoid it is to vitrify cells; that is, to convert cell water to a glass rather than to ice. The belief has been that this requires both the cooling rate and the concentration of glass-inducing solutes be very high. But high solute concentrations can themselves be damaging. However, the findings we report here on the vitrification of mouse oocytes are not in accord with the first belief that cooling needs to be extremely rapid. The important requirement is that the warming rate be extremely high. We subjected mouse oocytes in the vitrification solution EAFS 10/10 to vitrification procedures using a broad range of cooling and warming rates. Morphological survivals exceeded 80% when they were warmed at the highest rate (117,000°C/min) even when the prior cooling rate was as low as 880°C/min. Functional survival was >81% and 54% with the highest warming rate after cooling at 69,000 and 880°C/min, respectively. Our findings are also contrary to the second belief. We show that a high percentage of mouse oocytes survive vitrification in media that contain only half the usual concentration of solutes, provided they are warmed extremely rapidly; that is, >100,000°C/min. Again, the cooling rate is of less consequence.

Development of a reliable in vitro maturation system for zebrafish oocytes

In zebrafish oocytes, it has been reported that a 60 or 75% Leibovitz L-15 medium or simple balanced saline solution containing 17alpha, 20beta-dihydroxy-4-pregnen-3-one (DHP) is effective for nuclear maturation. However, most of the oocytes that matured under these conditions were not fertilized and did not hatch. Thus, these in vitro maturation methods could not support the cytoplasmic maturation of zebrafish oocytes. Therefore, we tried to develop a reliable in vitro maturation method for zebrafish oocytes, which supports their ability to be fertilized and to develop till hatching. When zebrafish oocytes at stage III were cultured in 50-100% Leibovitz L-15 medium supplemented with DHP, the highest rates of cleavage (24%) and hatching (12%) were obtained from oocytes matured in 90% Leibovitz L-15 medium. When we examined the suitable pH (7.5-9.5) of the 90% medium, higher rates of cleavage (45%) and hatching (33%) were obtained in oocytes matured at pH 9.0 than at pH 7.5, 8.5, or 9.5 (cleavage rate, 16-29%; hatching rate, 8-21%). In oocytes matured in 90% Leibovitz L-15 medium at pH 9.0, high rates of cleavage (70%) and hatching (63%) were obtained when oocytes were cultured for 270 min with 0.5 mg/ml BSA. Thus, 90% Leibovitz L-15 medium at pH 9.0 containing 0.5 mg/ml BSA was effective for normal maturation of zebrafish oocytes. This method will become a powerful tool for understanding the mechanism of in vitro maturation in zebrafish oocytes and for the practical use of immature oocytes.

The Role of Aquaporin 3 in the Movement of Water and Cryoprotectants in Mouse Morulae

Abstract The permeability to water and cryoprotectants of the plasma membrane is crucial to the successful cryopreservation of embryos. Previously, we have shown in mouse morulae that water and glycerol move across the plasma membrane by facilitated diffusion, and we have suggested that aquaporin 3 plays an important role in their movement. In the present study, we clarify the contribution of aquaporin 3 to the movement of water and various cryoprotectants in mouse morulae by measuring the Arrhenius activation energies for permeability to cryoprotectants and water, through artificial expression of aquaporin 3 using Aqp3 cRNA in mouse oocytes, and by suppressing the expression of aquaporin 3 in morulae by injecting double-stranded RNA of Aqp3 at the one-cell zygote stage. The results show that aquaporin 3 plays an important role in the facilitated diffusion of water, glycerol, and ethylene glycol, but not of acetamide and dimethylsulfoxide. On the other hand, in a propylene glycol solution, aquaporin 3 in morulae transported neither propylene glycol nor water by facilitated diffusion, probably because of strong water-solute interactions. These results provide important information for understanding the permeability of the plasma membrane of the mouse embryo.

Pathway for the Movement of Water and Cryoprotectants in Bovine Oocytes and Embryos

The permeability of cells is important for cryopreservation. Previously, we showed in mice that the permeability to water and cryoprotectants of oocytes and embryos at early cleavage stages (early embryos) is low because these molecules move across the plasma membrane predominantly by simple diffusion through the lipid bilayer, whereas permeability of morulae and blastocysts is high because of a water channel, aquaporin 3 (AQP3). In this study, we examined the pathways for the movement of water and cryoprotectants in bovine oocytes/embryos and the role of AQP3 in the movement by determining permeability, first in intact bovine oocytes/embryos, then in bovine morulae with suppressed AQP3 expression, and finally in mouse oocytes expressing bovine AQP3. Results suggest that water moves through bovine oocytes and early embryos slowly by simple diffusion, as is the case in mice, although channel processes are also involved in the movement. On the other hand, water appears to move through morulae and blastocysts predominantly by facilitated diffusion via channels, as in mice. Like water, cryoprotectants appear to move through bovine oocytes/early embryos mostly by simple diffusion, but channel processes could also be involved in the movement of glycerol and ethylene glycol, unlike that in mice. In bovine morulae, although glycerol and ethylene glycol would move predominantly by facilitated diffusion, mostly through AQP3, as in mice, dimethylsulfoxide appears to move predominantly by simple diffusion, unlike in mice. These results indicate that permeability-related properties of bovine oocytes/embryos are similar to those of mouse oocytes/embryos, but species-specific differences do exist.

Kinetics and activation energy of recrystallization of intracellular ice in mouse oocytes subjected to interrupted rapid cooling

Intracellular ice formation (IIF) is almost invariably lethal. In most cases, it results from the too rapid cooling of cells to below -40 degrees C, but in some cases it is manifested, not during cooling, but during warming when cell water that vitrified during cooling first devitrifies and then recrystallizes during warming. Recently, Mazur et al. [P. Mazur, I.L. Pinn, F.W. Kleinhans, Intracellular ice formation in mouse oocytes subjected to interrupted rapid cooling, Cryobiology 55 (2007) 158-166] dealt with one such case in mouse oocytes. It involved rapidly cooling the oocytes to -25 degrees C, holding them 10 min, rapidly cooling them to -70 degrees C, and warming them slowly until thawed. No IIF occurred during cooling but intracellular freezing, as evidenced by blackening of the cells, became detectable at -56 degrees C during warming and was complete by -46 degrees C. The present study differs in that the oocytes were warmed rapidly from -70 degrees C to temperatures between -65 and -50 degrees C and held for 3-60 min. This permitted us to determine the rate of blackening as function of temperature. That in turn allowed us to calculate the activation energy (E(a)) for the blackening process; namely, 27.5 kcal/mol. This translates to about a quadrupling of the blackening rate for every 5 degrees C rise in temperature. These data then allowed us to compute the degree of blackening as a function of temperature for oocytes warmed at rates ranging from 10 to 10,000 degrees C/min. A 10-fold increase in warming rate increased the temperature at which a given degree of blackening occurred by 8 degrees C. These findings have significant implications both for cryobiology and cryo-electron microscopy.

Extreme rapid warming yields high functional survivals of vitrified 8-cell mouse embryos even when suspended in a half-strength vitrification solution and cooled at moderate rates to -196°C.

To cryopreserve cells, it is essential to avoid intracellular ice formation during cooling and warming. One way to do so is to subject them to procedures that convert cell water into a non-crystalline glass. Current belief is that to achieve this vitrification, cells must be suspended in very high concentrations of glass-inducing solutes (i.e., ≥6 molal) and cooled at very high rates (i.e., ≫1000°C/min). We report here that both these beliefs are incorrect with respect to the vitrification of 8-cell mouse embryos. In this study, precompaction 8-cell embryos were vitrified in several dilutions of EAFS10/10 using various cooling rates and warming rates. Survival was based on morphology, osmotic functionality, and on the ability to develop to expanded blastocysts. With a warming rate of 117,500°C/min, the percentages of embryos vitrified in 1×, 0.75×, and 0.5× EAFS that developed to blastocysts were 93%, 92%, and 83%, respectively. And the percentages of morphological survivors that developed to expanded blastocysts were 100%, 92%, and 97%, respectively. Even when the solute concentration of the EAFS was reduced to 33% of normal, we obtained 40% functional survival of these 8-cell embryos.

Equilibrium Vitrification of Mouse Embryos

Abstract For the cryopreservation of embryos, vitrification has various advantages, but it also has disadvantages because embryos are vitrified with a considerable supercooling (i.e., in nonequilibrium). Here, we tried to develop a novel method in which embryos are vitrified in near-equilibrium. The extent of equilibrium was assessed by examining whether vitrified embryos survive after being kept at −80°C. Two-cell embryos of ICR mice were vitrified with ethylene glycol (EG)-based solutions, either EFSa or EFSc solutions, which were mixtures of EG (30%–40%) and an FSa or FSc solution, respectively. The FSa and FSc solutions were PB1 medium containing 30% Ficoll plus 0.5 or 1.5 M sucrose, respectively. In vitro survival rate was high when embryos vitrified with 30%–40% EG (EFS30a, EFS40a, EFS30c, and EFS40c) were warmed rapidly. When embryos were vitrified and then kept at −80°C for 4 days, large proportions survived with EFS30c and EFS40c. When embryos were vitrified with EFS35c or EFS40c, the survival rate was high even for those kept at −80°C for 10 days. When embryos of ICR and C57BL/6J mice were vitrified with EFS35c or EFS40c and then kept at −80°C for 4 days, the survival rate was high even after recooling in liquid nitrogen; a high proportion (75%) of C57BL/6J embryos vitrified with EFS35c developed to term after transfer. In conclusion, we have developed a novel method by which embryos are vitrified in near-equilibrium. This will be a supreme method for cryopreservation, retaining the advantages of both current vitrification and equilibrium slow freezing.