Shlomo Silman

Report of the Eriksholm Workshop on Auditory Deprivation and Acclimatization

The terminology used in studies documenting changes in auditory performance following fitting of hearing aids has been diverse. Definitions for the auditory deprivation effect and auditory acclimatization are offered as a first step in rationalization. Two statements summarize current knowledge concerning auditory deprivation effects and auditory acclimatization, as well as considering the potential implications for research, field trial and clinical practice applications. Potential areas for future research are identified.

Late‐onset auditory deprivation: Effects of monaural versus binaural hearing aids

Performance on tests of pure-tone thresholds, speech-recognition thresholds, and speech-recognition scores for the two ears of each subject were evaluated in two groups of adults with bilateral hearing losses. One group was composed of individuals fitted with binaural hearing aids, and the other group included persons with monaural hearing aids. Performance prior to the use of hearing aids was compared to performance after 4-5 years of hearing aid use in order to determine whether the unaided ear would show effects of auditory deprivation. There were no differences over time for pure-tone thresholds or speech-recognition thresholds for both ears of both groups. Nevertheless, the results revealed that the speech-recognition difference scores of the binaurally fitted subjects remained stable over time whereas they increased for the monaurally fitted subjects. The findings reveal an auditory deprivation effect for the unfitted ears of the subjects with monaural hearing aids.

Long-Term Effects of Monaural, Binaural and No Amplification in Subjects with Bilateral Hearing Loss

This study expands upon our earlier work by comparing initial PB scores and audiometric thresholds with results obtained 4-17 years later for subjects with bilateral sensorineural hearing losses who were monaurally aided (n = 48), binaurally aided (n = 19), or unaided (n = 19). Thresholds decreased slightly for all groups, but aided and unaided ears did not differ significantly in this respect, revealing no acoustic trauma effect due to hearing aid use. PB scores decreased significantly only for the unaided ear of the monaurally aided subjects, but not for their aided ear, or for the binaurally aided or unaided groups. These findings suggest an auditory deprivation effect for the unaided ear of those wearing a monaural hearing aid. Changes in PB scores were not correlated with duration between the two test dates. Changes in PB scores were correlated with degree of hearing loss only for the unaided group.

Consonant recognition in quiet and in noise with aging among normal hearing listeners

Consonant recognition in quiet and in noise was investigated as a function of age for essentially normal hearing listeners 21-68 years old, using the nonsense syllable test (NST) [Resnick et al., J. Acoust. Soc. Am. Suppl. 1 58, S114 (1975)]. The subjects audited the materials in quiet and at S/N ratios of +10 and +5 dB at their most comfortable listening levels (MCLs). The MCLs approximated conversational speech levels and were not significantly different between the age groups. The effects of age group, S/N condition (quiet, S/N +10, S/N +5) and NST subsets, and the S/N condition X subset interaction were all significant. Interactions involving the age factor were nonsignificant. Confusion matrices were similar across age groups, including the directions of errors between the most frequently confused phonemes. Also, the older subjects experienced performance decrements on the same features that were least accurately recognized by the younger subjects. The findings suggest that essentially normal older persons listening in quiet and in noise experience decreased consonant recognition ability, but that the nature of their phoneme confusions is similar to that of younger individuals. Even though the older subjects met the same selection criteria as did younger ones, there was an expected shift upward in auditory thresholds with age within these limits. Sensitivity at 8000 Hz was correlated with NST scores in noise when controlling for age, but the correlation between performance in noise and age was nonsignificant when controlling for the 8000-Hz threshold. These associations seem to implicate the phenomena underlying the increased 8000-Hz thresholds in the speech recognition problems of the elderly, and appear to support the concept of peripheral auditory deterioration with aging even among those with essentially normal hearing.

Effects of small room reverberation upon the recognition of some consonant features

The effects of small room reverberation (T=0.8 s) upon phoneme recognition was studied for normal listeners. Recognition performance was significantly poorer under reverberation than in quiet, and poorer in the final position of words than initially. Relative information transmission under reverberation was poorest for place of articulation, and for stop and frication consonants; whereas sibilance, duration, and semivowel information were barely affected. The findings suggest that small room reverberation affects phoneme recognition in much the same way as a speech‐shaped masking noise. In some cases, the error distributions reflect the limited response alternatives imposed by the real word recognition test.

Effect of sensorineural hearing loss on acoustic stapedius reflex growth functions.

The growth function of the acoustic stapedius reflex was measured in subjects with normal hearing and sensorineural hearing loss of cochlear origin. The effects of age and magnitude of hearing loss were controlled. Activating stimuli were 500, 1000, and 2000 Hz tones and broadband noise. Stapedius muscle activity was inferred from acoustic impedance measures in the contralateral ear. The mean growth functions for tones were essentially linear in log–log plots with the rate of growth equal for the two groups. The mean growth function for the noise signal was curvilinear for the normal hearing group and linear for the hearing loss group. Comparison of slope functions derived from the fitted data indicated that the rate of reflex growth for the noise signal, over a limited range above reflex threshold, is greater in ears with cochlear lesions than normal ears. For higher level noise signals, however, the rate of reflex growth is similar for normal and pathological ears. The effect of a cochlear lesion on the...

Consonant recognition in quiet as a function of aging among normal hearing subjects

Consonant recognition in quiet using the Nonsense Syllable Test (NST) [Resnick et al., J. Acoust. Soc. Am. Suppl. 1 58, S114 (1975)] was investigated in 62 normal hearing subjects 20 to 65 years of age at their most comfortable listening levels (MCLs) and at 8 dB above and below MCL. Although overall consonant recognition performance was high (as expected for normal listeners), the effects of age decade, relative presentation level, and NST subsets were all significant, as was the interaction of age X level. The interactions of age X NST subset, and age X subset X level were nonsignificant. These findings suggest that consonant recognition decreases with normal aging, particularly below MCL. However, the relative perceptual difficulty of the seven subtests is the same across age groups. Confusion matrices were similar across levels and age groups. Percent information transmitted for several consonant features was calculated from the confusion matrices. Older subjects showed decrements in performance primarily for the features recognized relatively less accurately by the younger subjects. The results suggest that normal hearing older individuals listening in quiet have decreased consonant recognition ability, but that their confusions are similar to those of younger persons.

Effect of sensorineural hearing loss on the stapedius reflex growth function in the elderly.

The effect of sensorineural hearing loss upon stapedius reflex growth functions was studied in the elderly. The reflex activators were pure tones (500, 1000, and 2000 Hz) and broadband noise; reflex magnitude was expressed in decibels relative to static acoustic impedance. When expressed in decibels relative to reflex threshold, the mean growth functions of the elderly were reduced compared to previous data for young subjects [Silman, Popelka, and Gelfand, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 64, 1406--1411 (1978)] and the noise functions differed in terms of both shape and magnitude. When expressed in SPL, the mean growth functions of the normal hearing elderly demonstrated saturation at high activator levels, whereas saturation was not observed in the mean growth functions of the hearing loss subjects. In the normal elderly, saturation was found to be frequency dependent. The saturation effect is discussed in terms of energy integration of the reflex response in the aging ear.

The effects of aging on the stapedius reflex thresholds

The acoustic reflex thresholds for broadband noise and 500-, 1000-, and 2000-Hz activating signals were measured in a group of young normal hearing adults and a group of elderly normal hearing subjects. The results indicated that the acoustic reflex thresholds for tonal activating signals in the young subjects were similar to those in the elderly subjects. However, the acoustic stapedius reflex thresholds for broadband noise activating signals is significantly higher in the elderly subjects than in the young. These differences were explained in light of Bredburgs findings [Acta Otolaryngol. Suppl. 236, 1--135 (1968)] regarding degeneration of outer hair cells as a function of aging.

The acoustic reflex threshold in aging ears

This study investigates the controversy regarding the influence of age on the acoustic reflex threshold for broadband noise, 500-, 1000-, 2000-, and 4000-Hz activators between Jerger et al. [Mono. Contemp. Audiol. 1 (1978)] and Jerger [J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 66 (1979)] on the one hand and Silman [J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 66 (1979)] and others on the other. The acoustic reflex thresholds for broadband noise, 500-, 1000-, 2000-, and 4000-Hz activators were evaluated under two measurement conditions. Seventy-two normal-hearing ears were drawn from 72 subjects ranging in age from 20-69 years. The results revealed that age was correlated with the acoustic reflex threshold for BBN activator but not for any of the tonal activators; the correlation was stronger under the 1-dB than under the 5-dB measurement condition. Also, the mean acoustic reflex thresholds for broadband noise activator were essentially similar to those reported by Jerger et al. (1978) but differed from those obtained in this study under the 1-dB measurement condition.