Shoshana Squires

Initial rates of DNA incision in UV-irradiated human cells differences between normal, xeroderma pigmentosum and tumour cells

Following UV-irradiation and in the presence of inhibitors of DNA synthesis (hydroxyurea and 1-beta-D-arabinofuranosylcytosine) human cells accumulate strand breaks in their DNA--as a result of enzymic incision without subsequent rejoining. We have developed a sensitive procedure which makes stringent use of these inhibitors so as to maximize the frequency of breaks detected after low levels of UV (0.25-10 Jm-2) and to permit analysis of the kinetics of break accumulation over short intervals after irradiation (up to 90 min). Since the rate of accumulation of breaks declines quickly with time of incubation (not simply as a consequence of substrate depletion), we have calculated initial rate constants by extrapolating to zero time for a range of UV doses (i.e. different substrate concentrations). Using these constants as indices of enzymic incision, we have compared a wide range of human cell types, and have (in some cases) been able to estimate the enzymatic parameters KM and Vmax for the incision step. Assessed in this way the human cells tested fall into a number of distinct categories. Fibroblasts from normal embryos and from xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) variant and Blooms syndrome show high and uniform levels of incision readily distinguishable from XP(A), in turn distinct from XP(D). Tumour-derived cells and SV40-transformed fibroblasts also fall into a group with similar incision capacity, significantly lower than that of normal diploid cells. We discuss possible reasons for this distinction, and evaluate the use of inhibitors in repair studies.

The XPD complementation group : insights into xeroderma pigmentosum, Cockayne's syndrome and trichothiodystrophy

The xeroderma pigmentosum complementation group D is defined by more than 30 unrelated individuals of whom less than half show major abnormalities of the central nervous system, once considered to be the hallmark of the group. Fibroblasts from the great majority of these individuals show very considerable sensitivity to UV light in vitro despite the fact that the cells carry out what appears to be substantial excision repair, as judged from repair synthesis and incision activity. This article reviews the XPD group and the defects in cellular DNA repair and examines the lack of correlation between repair and the appearance of neurological abnormalities. The article also discusses the recent awareness that at least some members of two other inherited conditions, trichothiodystrophy and Cockaynes Syndrome, carry mutations in the XPD gene.

p53 prevents the accumulation of double-strand DNA breaks at stalled-replication forks induced by UV in human cells.

To investigate the mechanism by which UV irradiation causes S-phase-dependent chromosome aberrations and thereby genomic instability, we have developed an assay to study the DNA structure of replication forks (RFs) in UV-irradiated mammalian cells, using pulse-field gel electrophoresis for the DNA analysis. We demonstrate that replication stalling at UV-induced pyrimidine dimers results in the formation of single-strand DNA (ssDNA) regions and incomplete RF structures. In normal and in excision-repair-defective xeroderma pimentosum (XP) cells, stalling at dimers is rapid and prolonged and recovery depends on dimer repair or bypass. By contrast, XP variant (XPV) cells, defective in replication of a UV-damaged template due to mutation of bypass-polymerase ?, fail to arrest at dimers, resulting in a much higher frequency of ssDNA regions in the stalled RFs. We show that the stability of UV-arrested RFs depends directly on functional p53, and indirectly on NER and pol ?. In p53-deficient cells, the stalled sites give rise to double-strand DNA breaks (DSBs), at a frequency inversely correlated with repair capacity of the cell. In normal cells only a fraction of the stalled sites give rise to DSBs, while in XPASV, XPDSV and also XPVSV all the sites do. XPVSV cells, although repair proficient, accumulate almost double the number of DSBs, suggesting that a high frequency of ssDNA regions in UV-arrested forks cause RF instability. These replication-associated DSBs do not accumulate in p53-proficient human cells. We propose that a major mechanism by which p53 maintains genome stability is the prevention of DSB accumulation at long-lived ssDNA regions in stalled-replication forks. Supplemental material for this paper can be found at the following link: http://www.landesbioscience.com/journals/cc/squiresCC3-12-sup.pdf

Kinetic analysis of UV-induced incision discriminates between fibroblasts from different xeroderma pigmentosum complementation groups, XPA heterozygotes and normal individuals

The capacity of a variety of human fibroblasts to incise DNA following exposure to far ultraviolet-light is determined from the rate of single-strand DNA break accumulation in the presence of DNA synthesis inhibitors. We have quantitated incision, one of the early steps in the UV excision repair pathway, in cells form normal, xeroderma pigmentosum groups C, D, G, H and variant individuals, and in the parents of one XPA patient. On the basis of the estimated initial rates of incision the different XP cells examined in this work can be ranked as follows: XP variant much greater than XPH greater than XPH greater than XPD greater than XPC greater than XPG greater than XPA. In each cell strain breaks accumulate immediately after irradiation over a range of 0.5-20 Jm-2 with the exception of the XPC strain examined, where there is an initial delay of 15 min. The rate of incision in XPA heterozygote cells is roughly half that of normal fibroblasts. Analysis of the kinetics of break accumulation over short intervals after irradiation permits estimation of the apparent enzymatic parameters, Km and Vmax, for the incision step. The approximate values of Km and Vmax for normal and XP variant are similar while for the heterozygotes of an XPA individual Km values are normal (around 1 Jm-2), but there is only half the amount of normal enzyme activity. XPD and H cells express low levels of active enzyme, between 5 and 15% of that of the normal, but while the Km of XPH is very similar to that of normal cells, that of two XPD strains examined is between 2- and 3-fold higher.

DNA Repair Under Stress

SUMMARY When the excision repair process of eukaryote cells is arrested by inhibitors of repair synthesis including hydroxyurea (HU), 1-β-d-arabinofuranosylcytosine (araC) or aphidicolin, major cellular changes follow the accumulation of repair-associated DNA breaks. These changes, each of which reflects more or less severe cellular stress, include cycle delay, chromosome behaviour, fall in NAD level, the development of double-stranded DNA breaks, rapid chromosome fragmentation and cell killing. Disruption of the repair process by agents such as araC after therapeutic DNA damage may, therefore, have some potential value in cancer treatment. The extreme cellular problems associated with the artificial arrest of repair may have their subtler counterparts elsewhere, and we discuss several systems where delays in the completion of excision repair in the absence of repair synthesis inhibitors have marked repercussions on cell viability. We also show that the average completion time of an excision repair patch varies according to the state of cell culture, and that completion time is extended after treatment with insulin or following trypsin detachment. Under certain growth conditions ultraviolet irradiation followed by mitogenic stimulation results in double-stranded DNA breakage and additional cell killing, and we discuss these data in the light of protocols that have been used successfully to transform human or rodent cells in vitro. Finally, we consider whether the rejoining of DNA breaks accumulated by repair synthesis inhibitors is a valid model system for studying ligation, and show that this protocol provides an extremely sensitive assay for most incision events and, thereby, a means for discriminating between normal human cells on the one hand, and Cockayne’s Syndrome cells and their heterozygotes on the other.

Lack of complementation between xeroderma pigmentosum complementation groups D and H

SummaryThe construction of permanent hybrid cell lines between xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) cells from different complementation groups allows analysis not only of the degree of repair correction but also of the restoration of biological activity to the UV-irradiated cells. With use of an immortal human cell line (HD2) that expresses excision repair defects typical of XP group D, a series of permanent hybrid cells has been produced with XP cells from groups A to H. Excision repair, as measured by incision analysis and unscheduled DNA synthesis, is restored to normal or near normal levels in crosses involving HD2 and cells from XP groups A, B, C, E, F, G, and I. All these hybrids show complementation for the recovery of normal UV restistance. As expected, hybrids expressing poor incision and hypersensitivity to UV were produced in crosses between HD2 and XPD fibroblasts, but they were also produced without exception when XPH was the partner. In the permanent HD2 x XPD or XPH hybrids, analysis of incision capacity reveals abnormally low activity and therefore that there has been no complementation. The true hybrid nature of HD2 x XPH cells has been confirmed by HL-A and -B tissue typing; moreover, detailed kinetic analysis of incision in these cells shows that the XPH phenotype, rather than the XPD, is expressed, i.e. breaks accumulate at low UV fluence of 1 J/m2. To help confirm these findings, another immortal XPD cell line was used in fusions involving HD2, XPH, or XPI. Cells resistant to ultraviolet were produced only with XPI fibroblasts. These data are discussed in terms of whether XPD and H mutations are likely to be allelic with respect to incision.

Cockayne's syndrome fibroblasts are characterized by hypersensitivity to deoxyguanosine and abnormal DNA precursor pool metabolism in response to deoxyguanosine or ultraviolet light

New cellular traits of Cockaynes syndrome (CS) associated with DNA precursor metabolism have been identified, namely, hypersensitivity to the toxicity of low concentrations of deoxyguanosine (dG) and abnormal changes in deoxyribonucleotide (dNTP) pools in response to dG or UV. dG treatment results in similar ribonucleotide pool changes in wild-type and CS cells, i.e., GTP levels increase at least twofold. However, the changes in the pool size of the purine deoxyribonucleotides are significantly different; in wild-type cells dATP and dGTP pools increase threefold, but remain unchanged in CS. The mechanism by which dG kills CS cells is not clear, but unlike the inherited purine nucleoside phosphorylase deficiency disease, the toxicity of dG is not due to the accumulation of dGTP and the consequent feedback inhibition of ribonucleotide reductase. UV induces different dNTP pool changes in CS and wild-type cells. In wild-type cells dTTP, dCTP, and dATP pools increase three- to fivefold within 4 h of irradiation, while the dGTP pool contracts. In CS cells, only the dGTP pool expands (four- to sixfold), while the other three contract. Each of these new phenotypic traits, together with UV sensitivity, is coordinately corrected in the complementing proliferating CSA × CSB hybrid cells.