Shweta A. Raina

Enhancements and Limits in Drug Membrane Transport Using Supersaturated Solutions of Poorly Water Soluble Drugs

Amorphous solid dispersions (ASDs) give rise to supersaturated solutions (solution concentration greater than equilibrium crystalline solubility). We have recently found that supersaturating dosage forms can exhibit the phenomenon of liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS). Thus, the high supersaturation generated by dissolving ASDs can lead to a two-phase system wherein one phase is an initially nanodimensioned and drug-rich phase and the other is a drug-lean continuous aqueous phase. Herein, the membrane transport of supersaturated solutions, at concentrations above and below the LLPS concentration has been evaluated using a side-by-side diffusion cell. Measurements of solution concentration with time in the receiver cell yield the flux, which reflects the solute thermodynamic activity in the donor cell. As the nominal concentration of solute in the donor cell increases, a linear increase in flux was observed up to the concentration where LLPS occurred. Thereafter, the flux remained essentially constant. Both nifedipine and felodipine solutions exhibit such behavior as long as crystallization is absent. This suggests that there is an upper limit in passive membrane transport that is dictated by the LLPS concentration. These results have several important implications for drug delivery, especially for poorly soluble compounds requiring enabling formulation technologies.

Classification of the Crystallization Behavior of Amorphous Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients in Aqueous Environments

ABSTRACTPurposeTo classify the crystallization behavior of amorphous active pharmaceutical ingredients (API) exposed to aqueous environments.MethodsA set of approximately 50 chemically and physically diverse active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) was selected for this study. Two experimental setups were employed to characterize the crystallization behavior of the amorphous API in an aqueous environment. For the first approach, precipitation, as evidenced by the development of turbidity, was induced using the solvent shift method, by mixing concentrated API solutions in DMSO with an aqueous buffer in a capillary. Subsequently, crystallization was monitored in situ over time using synchrotron radiation (simultaneous SAXS/WAXS beamline 12-ID-B at the Advanced Photon Source, Argonne National Laboratories, Argonne, IL). In the second approach, amorphous films were prepared by melt quenching; after adding buffer, crystallization was monitored with time using polarized light microscopy.ResultsIn general, the crystallization behavior of a given compound was similar irrespective of the experimental method employed. However, the crystallization behavior among different compounds varied significantly, ranging from immediate and complete crystallization to no observable crystallization over biorelevant time scales. Comparison of the observed behavior with previous studies of crystallization tendency in non-aqueous environments revealed that the crystallization tendency of individual APIs was somewhat similar regardless of the crystallization environment.ConclusionsAPI properties, rather than the method by which amorphous materials are generated, tend to dictate crystallization behavior in aqueous media.

Impact of polymers on the crystallization and phase transition kinetics of amorphous nifedipine during dissolution in aqueous media.

The commercial and clinical success of amorphous solid dispersions (ASD) in overcoming the low bioavailability of poorly soluble molecules has generated momentum among pharmaceutical scientists to advance the fundamental understanding of these complex systems. A major limitation of these formulations stems from the propensity of amorphous solids to crystallize upon exposure to aqueous media. This study was specifically focused on developing analytical techniques to evaluate the impact of polymers on the crystallization behavior during dissolution, which is critical in designing effective amorphous formulations. In the study, the crystallization and polymorphic conversions of a model compound, nifedipine, were explored in the absence and presence of polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP), hydroxypropylmethyl cellulose (HPMC), and HPMC-acetate succinate (HPMC-AS). A combination of analytical approaches including Raman spectroscopy, polarized light microscopy, and chemometric techniques such as multivariate curve resolution (MCR) were used to evaluate the kinetics of crystallization and polymorphic transitions as well as to identify the primary route of crystallization, i.e., whether crystallization took place in the dissolving solid matrix or from the supersaturated solutions generated during dissolution. Pure amorphous nifedipine, when exposed to aqueous media, was found to crystallize rapidly from the amorphous matrix, even when polymers were present in the dissolution medium. Matrix crystallization was avoided when amorphous solid dispersions were prepared, however, crystallization from the solution phase was rapid. MCR was found to be an excellent data processing technique to deconvolute the complex phase transition behavior of nifedipine.

Trends in the Precipitation and Crystallization Behavior of Supersaturated Aqueous Solutions of Poorly Water-Soluble Drugs Assessed Using Synchrotron Radiation

Amorphous materials are high-energy solids that can potentially enhance the bioavailability of poorly soluble compounds. A major impediment to their widespread use as a formulation platform is the tendency of amorphous materials to crystallize. The aim of this study was to evaluate the relative crystallization tendency of six structural analogues belonging to the dihydropyridine class, in an aqueous environment in the absence and presence of polymers, using wide-angle X-ray scattering synchrotron radiation and polarized light microscopy. The crystallization behavior of precipitates generated from supersaturated solutions of the active pharmaceutical ingredients was found to be highly variable ranging from immediate to several hours in the absence of polymers. Polymers with intermediate hydrophilicity/hydrophobicity were found to substantially delay crystallization, whereas strongly hydrophilic or hydrophobic polymers were largely ineffective. Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy experiments supported the supposition that polymers need to have affinity for both the drug-rich precipitate and the aqueous phase in order to be effective crystallization inhibitors. This study highlights the variability in the crystallization tendency of different compounds and provides insight into the mechanism of inhibition by polymeric additives.

Exploiting the Phenomenon of Liquid–Liquid Phase Separation for Enhanced and Sustained Membrane Transport of a Poorly Water-Soluble Drug

Recent studies on aqueous supersaturated lipophilic drug solutions prepared by methods including antisolvent addition, pH swing, or dissolution of amorphous solid dispersions (ASDs) have demonstrated that when crystallization is slow, these systems undergo liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) when the concentration of the drug in the medium exceeds its amorphous solubility. Following LLPS, a metastable equilibrium is formed where the concentration of drug in the continuous phase corresponds to the amorphous solubility while the dispersed phase is composed of a nanosized drug-rich phase. It has been reasoned that the drug-rich phase may act as a reservoir, enabling the rate of passive transport of the drug across a membrane to be maintained at the maximum value for an extended period of time. Herein, using clotrimazole as a model drug, and a flow-through diffusion cell, the reservoir effect is demonstrated. Supersaturated clotrimazole solutions at concentrations below the amorphous solubility show a linear relationship between the maximum flux and the initial concentration. Once the concentration exceeds the amorphous solubility, the maximum flux achieved reaches a plateau. However, the duration for which the high flux persists was found to be highly dependent on the number of drug-rich nanodroplets present in the donor compartment. Macroscopic amorphous particles of clotrimazole did not lead to the same reservoir effect observed with the nanodroplets formed through the process of LLPS. A first-principles mathematical model was developed which was able to fit the experimental receiver concentration-time profiles for concentration regimes both below and above amorphous solubility, providing support for the contention that the nanodroplet phase does not directly diffuse across the membrane but, instead, rapidly replenishes the drug in the aqueous phase that has been removed by transport across the membrane. This study provides important insight into the properties of supersaturated solutions and how these might in turn impact oral absorption through effects on passive membrane transport rates.

Quantitative analysis of the inhibitory effect of HPMC on felodipine crystallization kinetics using population balance modeling

In the present paper, the effect of the polymer additive, hydroxypropylmethyl cellulose (HPMC), on inhibiting the nucleation and growth of felodipine from supersaturated aqueous solutions was investigated. To characterize the growth and nucleation kinetics, seeded and unseeded desupersaturation experiments were carried out, respectively. A mathematical model for the batch crystallization of felodipine was constructed by using empirical expressions for nucleation and growth, a population balance equation, and a material balance. An optimization algorithm was employed to obtain the kinetic parameters in the nucleation and growth expressions by fitting the simulated results to the experimental data. Population balance modeling successfully allowed for the decoupling of the separate effect of HPMC on the nucleation and growth rates. In both the absence and presence of polymer, the growth mechanism of felodipine was determined to be intermediate between mass diffusion and surface integration controlled growth. HPMC was able to inhibit nucleation and growth at very low polymer concentrations (0.2 μg mL−1). However, the inhibitory impact was much greater on nucleation as opposed to growth. At a concentration of 3.5 μg mL−1, HPMC was found to decrease felodipine nucleation by up to eight orders of magnitude while it only decreased the rate of crystal growth by a factor of two. Furthermore, at high concentrations, the inhibitory impact of HPMC on growth reached a plateau and any further increases in polymer concentration were ineffective.

Using Environment-Sensitive Fluorescent Probes to Characterize Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation in Supersaturated Solutions of Poorly Water Soluble Compounds

PurposeHighly supersaturated aqueous solutions of poorly soluble compounds can undergo liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) when the concentration exceeds the “amorphous solubility”. This phenomenon has been widely observed during high throughput screening of new molecular entities as well as during the dissolution of amorphous solid dispersions. In this study, we have evaluated the use of environment-sensitive fluorescence probes to investigate the formation and properties of the non-crystalline drug-rich aggregates formed in aqueous solutions as a result of LLPS.MethodsSix different environment-sensitive fluorophores were employed to study LLPS in highly supersaturated solutions of several model compounds, all dihydropyridine derivatives.ResultsEach fluoroprobe exhibited a large hypsochromic shift with decreasing environment polarity. Upon drug aggregate formation, the probes partitioned into the drug-rich phase and exhibited changes in emission wavelength and intensity consistent with sensing a lower polarity environment. The LLPS onset concentrations determined using the fluorescence measurements were in good agreement with light scattering measurements as well as theoretically estimated amorphous solubility values.ConclusionsEnvironment-sensitive fluorescence probes are useful to help understand the phase behavior of highly supersaturated aqueous solutions, which in turn is important in the context of developing enabling formulations for poorly soluble compounds.

Impact of Micellar Surfactant on Supersaturation and Insight into Solubilization Mechanisms in Supersaturated Solutions of Atazanavir

PurposeThe goals of this study were to determine: 1) the impact of surfactants on the “amorphous solubility”; 2) the thermodynamic supersaturation in the presence of surfactant micelles; 3) the mechanism of solute solubilization by surfactant micelles in supersaturated solutions.MethodsThe crystalline and amorphous solubility of atazanavir was determined in the presence of varying concentrations of micellar sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS). Flux measurements, using a side-by-side diffusion cell, were employed to determine the free and micellar-bound drug concentrations. The solubilization mechanism as a function of atazanavir concentration was probed using fluorescence spectroscopy. Pulsed gradient spin-echo proton nuclear magnetic resonance (PGSE-NMR) spectroscopy was used to determine the change in micelle size with a change in drug concentration.ResultsChanges in the micelle/water partition coefficient, Km/w, as a function of atazanavir concentration led to erroneous estimates of the supersaturation when using concentration ratios. In contrast, determining the free drug concentration using flux measurements enabled improved determination of the thermodynamic supersaturation in the presence of micelles. Fluorescence spectroscopic studies suggested that Km/w changed based on the location of atazanavir solubilization which in turn changed with concentration. Thus, at a concentration equivalent to the crystalline solubility, atazanavir is solubilized by adsorption at the micelle corona, whereas in highly supersaturated solutions it is also solubilized in the micellar core. This difference in solubilization mechanism can lead to a breakdown in the prediction of amorphous solubility in the presence of SDS as well as challenges with determining supersaturation. PGSE-NMR suggested that the size of the SDS micelle is not impacted at the crystalline solubility of the drug but increases when the drug concentration reaches the amorphous solubility, in agreement with the proposed changes in solubilization mechanism.ConclusionsMicellar solubilization of atazanavir is complex, with the solubilization mechanism changing with differences in the degree of (super)saturation. This can result in erroneous predictions of the amorphous solubility and thermodynamic supersaturation in the presence of solubilizing additives. This in turn hinders understanding of the driving force for phase transformations and membrane transport, which is essential to better understand supersaturating dosage forms.

Origin of Nanodroplet Formation Upon Dissolution of an Amorphous Solid Dispersion: A Mechanistic Isotope Scrambling Study

It has been observed that certain amorphous solid dispersions (ASDs), upon dissolution, generate drug-rich amorphous nanodroplets. These nanodroplets, present as a dispersed phase, can potentially enhance oral bioavailability of poorly soluble drugs by serving as a drug reservoir that efficiently feeds the continuous aqueous solution phase following absorption of drug. The purpose of this study is to probe the formation mechanism of the nanodroplets. The model system studied was nifedipine (NFD) formulated as an ASD with hydroxypropyl methylcellulose E5 Premium LV or polyvinylpyrrolidone/vinyl acetate. Dissolution of ASDs prepared with proteated nifedipine (H-NFD) was carried out in a medium saturated with deuterated nifedipine (D-NFD) at the amorphous solubility. Upon dissolution, the H/D composition of NFD aqueous solution was determined using nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. The results suggested that isotopic scrambling (equilibrium in the distribution of deuterated and proteated form of the drug) had occurred. Thus, as the H-NFD was brought into the aqueous solution via ASD dissolution, the drug concentration in solution exceeded the amorphous solubility. Subsequent precipitation of the drug, a process which does not differentiate H-NFD from D-NFD, generated NFD nanodroplets and resulted in redistribution of the isotopes. Thus, nanodroplets of NFD are formed due to dissolution of these homogenous ASDs followed by precipitation of the drug from aqueous solutions.