Simon J Crowhurst

Evolution of Ocean Temperature and Ice Volume Through the Mid-Pleistocene Climate Transition

Cycling Down The Mid-Pleistocene Transition, which lasted from approximately 1.25 million to 700 thousand years ago, was a period during which the dominant periodicity of Earths climate cycles inexplicably changed from 41 thousand to 100 thousand years. This change is clearly apparent in the oxygen isotopic composition of many calcifying marine organisms, but changes in both ice volume and temperature affect the signal, and so exactly what the signal means has remained unclear. Elderfield et al. (p. 704; see the Perspective by Clark) separated these two effects by measuring both the oxygen isotopic makeup and the Mg/Ca (a proxy that reflects changes in temperature only) of certain benthic foraminifera. The findings reveal the contributions of ice volume and temperature to glacial cycles, suggest when and why the Mid-Pleistocene Climate Transition occurred, and clarify how carbon is lost from the ocean-atmosphere during deglaciations but also changes because of ocean circulation. The effects of changes in ice volume and ocean temperature during the mid-Pleistocene transition have now been resolved. Earth’s climate underwent a fundamental change between 1250 and 700 thousand years ago, the mid-Pleistocene transition (MPT), when the dominant periodicity of climate cycles changed from 41 thousand to 100 thousand years in the absence of substantial change in orbital forcing. Over this time, an increase occurred in the amplitude of change of deep-ocean foraminiferal oxygen isotopic ratios, traditionally interpreted as defining the main rhythm of ice ages although containing large effects of changes in deep-ocean temperature. We have separated the effects of decreasing temperature and increasing global ice volume on oxygen isotope ratios. Our results suggest that the MPT was initiated by an abrupt increase in Antarctic ice volume 900 thousand years ago. We see no evidence of a pattern of gradual cooling, but near-freezing temperatures occur at every glacial maximum.

Comparison of terrestrial and marine records of changing climate of the last 500,000 years

A broad correspondence between long pollen sequences and the deep-sea oxygen isotope record has been noted for some time, but there has been little effort to explore just how similar the two types of evidence are in terms of their overall structure on glacial-interglacial timescales and also how they may differ. These questions have profound importance both for how we view the stratigraphic record of changing climate in different regions and for our understanding of the climate system. Here we link the four longest European pollen records and derive a terrestrial sequence of vegetation events and a coherent stratigraphic scheme for the last 500,000 years. Comparison of the terrestrial and marine records shows good agreement, but it also reveals that the pollen sequences contain a higher degree of climate sensitivity than the oxygen isotope record. In addition, it suggests that neither an oxygen isotope record nor a Milankovitch-forced ice volume model may provide an appropriate template for fine-tuning the terrestrial record and that better chronologies will depend on an improved understanding of controls on sedimentation rates in individual sedimentary basins

Establishing a terrestrial chronological framework as a basis for biostratigraphical comparisons.

The palynological signature of interglacial deposits in the fragmentary European terrestrial record has often been used as the basis for determining their chronostratigraphical position and ultimately their age. This has placed emphasis on the presence/absence and abundance of certain characteristic taxa, but given the lack of continuous stratigraphies and independent chronologies, it has been difficult to assess the extent to which this strategy has produced reliable schemes. Here, an alternative approach is adopted whereby a chronological framework is developed for long and continuous pollen sequences from southern Europe. This in turn allows the emergence of a complete stratigraphical scheme of major vegetation events for the last 430 thousand years (ka) and the evaluation of the stage record of different taxa and their potential diagnostic value for biostratigraphical correlation. The comparison shows distinct similarities among some temperate stages of the terrestrial equivalent complexes of Marine Isotope Stages (MIS) 5 and 7 and also of MIS 9 and 11, but examination of combined records of taxa provides a possibility to differentiate between individual stages. A numerically-derived dichotomous key for the terrestrial stages based on the palynological records of 10 taxa is presented. Carpinus, Fagus, Abies, Pterocarya and Buxus emerge as the best ‘indicator pollen types’ because of their variable behaviour from one stage to the next, possibly a result of their late expansion within a temperate stage or reduced genetic variability. The analysis shows that the palynological signature of a temperate deposit can constrain the range of chronostratigraphical possibilities, but vegetation and palynological variability arising from local factors could result in difficulties in making a definite assignment at individual sites.

Evaluating the success of astronomical tuning: Pitfalls of using coherence as a criterion for assessing pre‐Pleistocene timescales

The imprint of orbital variations on the geological record of climatic variability is well documented, especially for the Plio-Pleistocene. There is considerable interest in developing very high resolution timescales through the Cenozoic and into the Mesozoic by tuning geological records to the assumed astronomical forcing. Since the precession signal is so highly amplitude modulated, it is widely believed that high coherence between record and assumed forcing in the precession band is an indication that the timescale is probably correct, because coherence is supposed to provide a measure of the degree of common amplitude modulation. We show that this is misleading; even a sinusoidal variation that has been “tuned” to an insolation record shows highly significant coherence at the 23-kyr and 19-kyr precession frequencies. Coherence is a good indication that the tuning has generated a consistent phase relationship, but complex demodulation is a better tool for assessing the relationship between amplitude modulation in the data and in the hypothetical forcing.

Benthic Foraminiferal Oxygen Isotope Offsets Over The Last Glacial-Interglacial Cycle

The oxygen isotope (?18O) offset between contemporaneous benthic foraminiferal species is often assumed constant with time and geographic location. We present an inventory of benthic foraminiferal species ?18O offsets from the major ocean basins covering the last glacial-interglacial cycle, showing that of the twenty down-core records investigated, twelve show significant temporal changes in ?18O offsets that do not resemble stochastic variability. Some of the temporal changes may be related to kinetic fractionation effects causing deglacial/interglacial enrichment or glacial depletion in mainly infaunal species, but additional research is needed to confirm this. In addition to stratigraphic implications the finding of temporally varying offsets between co-existing benthic foraminiferal species could have implications for sea-level, deep water temperature, and regional deep water ?18O estimates.

Past Carbonate Preservation Events in the Deep Southeast Atlantic Ocean (Cape Basin) and Their Implications for Atlantic Overturning Dynamics and Marine Carbon Cycling

Micropaleontological and geochemical analyses reveal distinct millennial-scale increases in carbonate preservation in the deep Southeast Atlantic (Cape Basin) during strong and prolonged Greenland interstadials that are superimposed on long-term (orbital-scale)changes in carbonate burial. These data suggest carbonate oversaturation of the deep Atlantic and a strengthened Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) during the most intense Greenland interstadials. However, proxy evidence from outside the Cape Basin indicate that AMOC changes also occurred during weaker and shorter Greenland interstadials. Here we revisit the link between AMOC dynamics and carbonate saturation in the deep Cape Basin over the last 400 kyr (sediment cores TN057-21, TN057-10 and ODP Site 1089) by reconstructing centennial changes in carbonate preservation using mm-scale X-ray fluorescence (XRF) scanning data. We observe close agreement between variations in XRF Ca/Ti, sedimentary carbonate content and foraminiferal shell fragmentation, reflecting a common control primarily through changing deep-water carbonate saturation. We suggest that the high-frequency (sub-orbital) component of the XRF Ca/Ti records indicates the fast and recurrent redistribution of carbonate ions in the Atlantic basin via the AMOC during both long/strong- and short/weak North Atlantic climate anomalies. In contrast, the low-frequency (orbital) XRF Ca/Ti component is interpreted to reflect slow adjustments through carbonate compensation, and/or changes in the deep-ocean respired carbon content. Our findings emphasize the recurrent influence of rapid AMOC variations on the marine carbonate system during past glacial periods, providing a mechanism for transferring the impacts of North Atlantic climate anomalies to the global carbon cycle via the SouthernOcean.