Stefan Knoppe

Chirality in thiolate-protected gold clusters.

Over recent years, research on thiolate-protected gold clusters Au(m)(SR)n has gained significant interest. Milestones were the successful determination of a series of crystal structures (Au102(SR)44, Au25(SR)18, Au38(SR)24, Au36(SR)24, and Au28(SR)20). For Au102(SR)44, Au38(SR)24, and Au28(SR)20, intrinsic chirality was found. Strong Cotton effects (circular dichroism, CD) of gold clusters protected by chiral ligands have been reported a long time ago, indicating the transfer of chiral information from the ligand into the cluster core. Our lab has done extensive studies on chiral thiolate-protected gold clusters, including those protected with chiral ligands. We demonstrated that vibrational circular dichroism can serve as a useful tool for the determination of conformation of the ligand on the surface of the cluster. The first reports on crystal structures of Au102(SR)44 and Au38(SR)24 revealed the intrinsic chirality of these clusters. Their chirality mainly arises from the arrangement of the ligands on the surface of the cluster cores. As achiral ligands are used to stabilize the clusters, racemic mixtures are obtained. However, the separation of the enantiomers by HPLC was demonstrated which enabled the measurement of their CD spectra. Thermally induced inversion allows determination of the activation parameters for their racemization. The inversion demonstrates that the gold-thiolate interface is anything but fixed; in contrast, it is rather flexible. This result is of fundamental interest and needs to be considered in future applications. A second line of our research is the selective introduction of chiral, bidentate ligands into the ligand layer of intrinsically chiral gold clusters. The ligand exchange reaction is highly diastereoselective. The bidentate ligand connects two of the protecting units on the cluster surface and thus effectively stabilizes the cluster against thermally induced inversion. A minor (but significant) influence of chiral ligands to the CD spectra of the clusters is observed. The studied system represents the first example of an intrinsically chiral gold cluster with a defined number of exchanged ligands, full control over their regio- and stereochemistry. The methodology allows for the selective preparation of mixed-ligand cluster compounds and a thorough investigation of the influence of single ligands on the clusters properties. Overall, the method enables even more detailed tailoring of properties. Still, central questions remain unanswered: (1) Is intrinsic chirality a ubiquitous feature of thiolate-protected gold clusters? (2) How does chirality transfer work? (3) What are the applications for chiral thiolate-protected gold clusters? In this Account, we summarize the main findings on chirality in thiolate-protected gold cluster of the past half decade. Emphasis is put on intrinsically chiral clusters and their structures, optical activity, and reactivity.

Size exclusion chromatography for semipreparative scale separation of Au38(SR)24 and Au40(SR)24 and larger clusters.

Size exclusion chromatography (SEC) on a semipreparative scale (10 mg and more) was used to size-select ultrasmall gold nanoclusters (<2 nm) from polydisperse mixtures. In particular, the ubiquitous byproducts of the etching process toward Au(38)(SR)(24) (SR, thiolate) clusters were separated and gained in high monodispersity (based on mass spectrometry). The isolated fractions were characterized by UV-vis spectroscopy, MALDI mass spectrometry, HPLC, and electron microscopy. Most notably, the separation of Au(38)(SR)(24) and Au(40)(SR)(24) clusters is demonstrated.

Separation of Enantiomers and CD Spectra of Au40(SCH2CH2Ph)24: Spectroscopic Evidence for Intrinsic Chirality

Chirality unveiled: Thiolate-protected Au40(SR)24 clusters were enantioenriched using an HPLC approach. CD spectra show strong mirror-image responses, indicating the intrinsic chirality of a cluster of unknown structure protected with achiral ligands.

Chiral Phase Transfer and Enantioenrichment of Thiolate-Protected Au102 Clusters

The Au102(p-MBA)44 cluster (p-MBA: para-mercaptobenzoic acid) is observed as a chiral compound comprised of achiral components in its single-crystal structure. So far the enantiomers observed in the crystal structure are not isolated, nor is the circular dichroism spectrum known. A chiral phase transfer method is presented which allows partial resolution of the enantiomers by the use of a chiral ammonium bromide, (-)-1R,2S-N-dodecyl-N-methylephedrinium bromide ((-)-DMEBr). At sufficiently low concentration of (-)-DMEBr, the phase transfer from water to chloroform is incomplete. Both the aqueous and organic phases show optical activity of near mirror image relationship. Differences in the spectra are ascribed to the formation of diastereomeric salts. At high concentrations of (-)-DMEBr, full phase transfer is observed. The organic phase, however, still displays optical activity. We assume that one of the diastereomers has very strong optical activity, which overrules the cancelation of the spectra with opposite sign. Comparison with computations further corroborates the experimental data and allows a provisional assignment of handedness of each fraction.

Racemization of a Chiral Nanoparticle Evidences the Flexibility of the Gold–Thiolate Interface

Thiolate-protected gold nanoparticles and clusters combine size-dependent physical properties with the ability to introduce (bio)chemical functionality within their ligand shell. The engineering of the latter with molecular precision is an important prerequisite for future applications. A key question in this respect concerns the flexibility of the gold-sulfur interface. Here we report the first study on racemization of an intrinsically chiral gold nanocluster, Au38(SCH2CH2Ph)24, which goes along with a drastic rearrangement of its surface involving place exchange of several thiolates. This racemization takes place at modest temperatures (40-80 °C) without significant decomposition. The experimentally determined activation energy for the inversion reaction is ca. 28 kcal/mol, which is surprisingly low considering the large rearrangement. The activation parameters furthermore indicate that the process occurs without complete Au-S bond breaking.

Electronic structure and optical properties of the thiolate-protected Au28(SMe)20 cluster.

The recently reported crystal structure of the Au28(TBBT)20 cluster (TBBT: p-tert-butylbenzenethiolate) is analyzed with (time-dependent) density functional theory (TD-DFT). Bader charge analysis reveals a novel trimeric Au3(SR)4 binding motif. The cluster can be formulated as Au14(Au2(SR)3)4(Au3(SR)4)2. The electronic structure of the Au14(6+) core and the ligand-protected cluster were analyzed, and their stability can be explained by formation of distorted eight-electron superatoms. Optical absorption and circular dichroism (CD) spectra were calculated and compared to the experiment. Assignment of handedness of the intrinsically chiral cluster is possible.

Electronic structure and optical properties of the intrinsically chiral 16-electron superatom complex [Au20(PP3)4](4+).

The recently solved crystal structure of the [Au20(PP3)4]Cl4 cluster (PP3: tris(2-(diphenylphophino)ethyl)phosphine) is examined using density functional theory (DFT). The Au20 core of the cluster is intrinsically chiral by the arrangement of the Au atoms. This is in contrast to the chirality of thiolate-protected gold clusters, in which the protecting Au-thiolate units are arranged in chiral patterns on achiral cores. We interpret the electronic structure of the [Au20(PP3)4]Cl4 cluster in terms of the superatom complex model. The 16-electron cluster cannot be interpreted as a dimer of 8-electron clusters (which are magic). Instead, a superatomic electron configuration of 1S(2) 1P(6) 1D(6) 2S(2) is found. The 2S band is strongly stabilized, and the 1D states are nondegenerate with a large gap. Ligand protection of the (Au20)(4+) core leads to a significant increase of the HL-gap and thus stabilization. We also tested a charge of +II, which would give rise to an 18-electron superatom complex. Our results indicate that the 16-electron cluster is indeed more stable. We also investigate the optical properties of the cluster. The experimental absorption spectrum is well-reproduced by time-dependent DFT. Prominent transitions are analyzed by time-dependent density-functional perturbation theory. The intrinsic chirality of the cluster is compared to that of Au38(SR)24. We observe that the chiral arrangement of the protecting Au-SR units in Au38(SR)24 has very strong influence on the strength of the CD spectra, whereas phosphine protection in the title compound does not.

Resonance Enhancement of Nonlinear Optical Scattering in Monolayer-Protected Gold Clusters

Monolayer-protected metal clusters (MPCs) have recently gained significant research interest, since they are promising candidates for various applications in bioimaging and catalysis. Besides this, MPCs promise to aid in understanding the evolution of the metallic state from bottom-up principles. MPCs can be prepared with atomic precision, and their nonscalable properties (indicating molecule-like behavior) have been studied with a variety of techniques both theoretically and experimentally. Here, we present spectrally resolved second-order nonlinear optical scattering experiments on thiolate-protected gold clusters (Au130(SR)50, Au144(SR)60, and Au500(SR)120). The three clusters share common resonance enhancement around 490 nm, which is ascribed to an interband transition. This indicates emerging metal-like properties, and we tentatively assign the onset of metal-like behavior somewhere between 102 and 130 gold atoms.