Stéphanie Prigent

The oligomerization properties of prion protein are restricted to the H2H3 domain

The propensity of the prion protein (PrP) to adopt different structures is a clue to its pathological behavior. The determination of the region involved in the PrPC to PrPSc conversion is fundamental for the understanding of the mechanisms underlying this process at the molecular level. In this paper, the polymerization of the helical H2H3 domain of ovine PrP (OvPrP) was compared to the full‐length construct (using chromatography and light scattering). We show that the oligomerization patterns are identical, although the H2H3 domain has a higher polymerization rate. Furthermore, the depolymerization kinetics of purified H2H3 oligomers compared to those purified from the full‐length PrP reveal that regions outside H2H3 do not significantly contribute to the oligomerization process. By combining rational mutagenesis and molecular dynamics to investigate the early stages of H2H3 oligomerization, we observe a conformationally stable β‐sheet structure that we propose as a possible nucleus for oligomerization; we also show that single point mutations in H2 and H3 present structural polymorphisms and oligomerization properties that could constitute the basis of species or strain variability.—Chakroun, N., Prigent, S., Dreiss, C. A., Noinville, S., Chapuis, C., Fraternali, F., Rezaei, H. The oligomerization properties of prion protein are restricted to the H2H3 domain. FASEB J. 24, 3222–3231 (2010). www.fasebj.org

Prion fibrillization is mediated by a native structural element that comprises helices H2 and H3.

Aggregation and misfolding of the prion protein (PrP) are thought to be the cause of a family of lethal neurodegenerative diseases affecting humans and other animals. Although the structures of PrP from several species have been solved, still little is known about the mechanisms that lead to the misfolded species. Here, we show that the region of PrP comprising the hairpin formed by the helices H2 and H3 is a stable independently folded unit able to retain its secondary and tertiary structure also in the absence of the rest of the sequence. We also prove that the isolated H2H3 is highly fibrillogenic and forms amyloid fibers morphologically similar to those obtained for the full-length protein. Fibrillization of H2H3 but not of full-length PrP is concomitant with formation of aggregates. These observations suggest a “banana-peeling” mechanism for misfolding of PrP in which H2H3 is the aggregation seed that needs to be first exposed to promote conversion from a helical to a β-rich structure.

An Efficient Kinetic Model for Assemblies of Amyloid Fibrils and Its Application to Polyglutamine Aggregation

Protein polymerization consists in the aggregation of single monomers into polymers that may fragment. Fibrils assembly is a key process in amyloid diseases. Up to now, protein aggregation was commonly mathematically simulated by a polymer size-structured ordinary differential equations (ODE) system, which is infinite by definition and therefore leads to high computational costs. Moreover, this Ordinary Differential Equation-based modeling approach implies biological assumptions that may be difficult to justify in the general case. For example, whereas several ordinary differential equation models use the assumption that polymerization would occur at a constant rate independently of polymer size, it cannot be applied to certain protein aggregation mechanisms. Here, we propose a novel and efficient analytical method, capable of modelling and simulating amyloid aggregation processes. This alternative approach consists of an integro-Partial Differential Equation (PDE) model of coalescence-fragmentation type that was mathematically derived from the infinite differential system by asymptotic analysis. To illustrate the efficiency of our approach, we applied it to aggregation experiments on polyglutamine polymers that are involved in Huntington’s disease. Our model demonstrates the existence of a monomeric structural intermediate acting as a nucleus and deriving from a non polymerizing monomer (). Furthermore, we compared our model to previously published works carried out in different contexts and proved its accuracy to describe other amyloid aggregation processes.

Binding of methylene blue to a surface cleft inhibits the oligomerization and fibrillization of prion protein.

Neurodegenerative protein misfolding diseases, including prionopathies, share the common feature of accumulating specific misfolded proteins, with a molecular mechanism closely related. Misfolded prion protein (PrP) generates soluble oligomers that, in turn, aggregate into amyloid fibers. Preventing the formation of these entities, crucially associated with the neurotoxic and/or infectious properties of the resulting abnormal PrP, represents an attractive therapeutic strategy to ameliorate prionopathies. We focused our attention into methylene blue (MB), a well-characterized drug, which is under study against Alzheimers disease and other neurodegenerative disorders. Here, we have undertaken an in vitro study on the effects of MB on oligomerization and fibrillization of human, ovine and murine PrP. We demonstrated that MB affects the kinetics of PrP oligomerization and reduces the amount of oligomer of about 30%, in a pH-dependent manner, by using SLS and DSC methodologies. Moreover, TEM images showed that MB completely suppresses fiber formation at a PrP:MB molar ratio of 1:2. Finally, NMR revealed a direct interaction between PrP and MB, which was mapped on a surface cleft including a fibrillogenic region of the protein. Our results allowed to surmise a mechanism of action in which the MB binding to PrP surface markedly interferes with the pathway towards oligomers and fibres. Therefore MB could be considered as a general anti-aggregation compound, acting against proteinopathies.

Cross-talk between prion protein and quadruplex-forming nucleic acids: a dynamic complex formation

Prion protein (PrP) is involved in lethal neurodegenerative diseases, and many issues remain unclear about its physio-pathological role. Quadruplex-forming nucleic acids (NAs) have been found to specifically bind to both PrP cellular and pathological isoforms. To clarify the relevance of these interactions, thermodynamic, kinetic and structural studies have been performed, using isothermal titration calorimetry, surface plasmon resonance and circular dichroism methodologies. Three quadruplex-forming sequences, d(TGGGGT), r(GGAGGAGGAGGA), d(GGAGGAGGAGGA), and various forms of PrP were selected for this study. Our results showed that these quadruplexes exhibit a high affinity and specificity toward PrP, with KD values within the range 62÷630 nM, and a weaker affinity toward a PrP-β oligomer, which mimics the pathological isoform. We demonstrated that the NA quadruplex architecture is the structural determinant for the recognition by both PrP isoforms. Furthermore, we spotted both PrP N-terminal and C-terminal domains as the binding regions involved in the interaction with DNA/RNAs, using several PrP truncated forms. Interestingly, a reciprocally induced structure loss was observed upon PrP–NA interaction. Our results allowed to surmise a quadruplex unwinding-activity of PrP, that may have a feedback in vivo.

Decrypting Prion Protein Conversion into a β-Rich Conformer by Molecular Dynamics.

Prion diseases are fatal neurodegenerative diseases characterized by the formation of β-rich oligomers and the accumulation of amyloid fibrillar deposits in the central nervous system. Understanding the conversion of the cellular prion protein into its β-rich polymeric conformers is fundamental to tackling the early stages of the development of prion diseases. In this paper, we have identified unfolding and refolding steps critical to the conversion into a β-rich conformer for different constructs of the ovine prion protein by molecular dynamics simulations. By combining our results with in vitro experiments, we show that the folded C-terminus of the ovine prion protein is able to recurrently undergo a drastic conformational change by displacement of the H1 helix, uncovering of the H2H3 domain, and formation of persistent β-sheets between H2 and H3 residues. The observed β-sheets refold toward the C-terminus exposing what we call a “bending region” comprising residues 204–214. This is strikingly coincident with the region harboring mutations determining the fate of the prion oligomerization process. The β-rich intermediate is used here for the construction of a putative model for the assembly into an oligomeric aggregate. The results presented here confirm the importance of the H2H3 domain for prion oligomer formation and therefore its potential use as molecular target in the design of novel prion inhibitors.

PrP assemblies: spotting the responsible regions in prion propagation.

The “protein only” hypothesis states that the key phenomenon in prion pathogenesis is the conversion of the host protein (PrPC) into a b-sheet enriched polymeric and pathogenic conformer (PrPSc). However the region of PrP bearing the information for structural transfer is still controversial. In a recent report, we highlighted the role of the C terminal part i.e. the helixes H2 and H3, using mutation approaches on recombinant PrP. The H2H3 was shown to be the minimal region necessary to reproduce the oligomerisation pattern of the full-length protein. The oligomers produced from isolated H2H3 domain presented the same structural characteristics as the oligomers formed from the full-length PrP. Combining other groups’ results, this paper further discusses the relative, direct or indirect role of different PrP regions in assembly. The H2H3 region represents the core of PrP oligomers and fibrils, whereas the N terminus could explain divergences among different aggregates. Finally this review evocates the possibility to separate the domain involved in prion information transference (i.e. prion replication) from the domain bearing the cytotoxicity properties.

Dual conformation of H2H3 domain of prion protein in mammalian cells.

Background: The conversion domain of the Prion protein, responsible for its switch into an abnormal form, is not clearly characterized. Results: The H2H3 domain of the Prion protein can access two different conformations in mammalian cells, one of which is amyloid and resistant to proteinase K. Conclusion: The H2H3 domain is a conformational switch. Significance: The H2H3 domain may be the conversion domain of PrP. The concept of prion is applied to protein modules that share the ability to switch between at least two conformational states and transmit one of these through intermolecular interaction and change of conformation. Although much progress has been achieved through the understanding of prions from organisms such as Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Podospora anserina, or Aplysia californica, the criteria that qualify a protein module as a prion are still unclear. In addition, the functionality of known prion domains fails to provide clues to understand the first identified prion, the mammalian infectious prion protein, PrP. To address these issues, we generated mammalian cellular models of expression of the C-terminal two helices of PrP, H2 and H3, which have been hypothesized, among other models, to hold the replication and conversion properties of the infectious PrP. We found that the H2H3 domain is an independent folding unit that undergoes glycosylations and glycosylphosphatidylinositol anchoring similar to full-length PrP. Surprisingly, in some conditions the normally folded H2H3 was able to systematically go through a conversion process and generate insoluble proteinase K-resistant aggregates. This structural switch involves the assembly of amyloid structures that bind thioflavin S and oligomers that are reactive to A11 antibody, which specifically detects protein oligomers from neurological disorders. Overall, we show that H2H3 is a conformational switch in a cellular context and is thus suggested to be a candidate for the conversion domain of PrP.

Mechanistic insights into cellular alteration of prion by poly-d-lysine: the role of H2H3 domain

Misfolding of the prion protein (PrP) is the central feature of prion diseases. The conversion of the normal α‐helical PrPC into a pathological β‐en‐riched PrPSc constitutes an early event in the infectious process. Several hypotheses, involving different regions of the protein, endeavor to delineate the structural mechanism underlying this change of conformation. All current working hypotheses, however, are based on biophysical and modeling studies, the biological relevance of which still needs to be assessed. We have studied the effect of positively charged polymers on the conversion, using polylysine as a model system, and have investigated a possible mechanism of structural stabilization. We have shown that poly‐d‐lysine removes proteinase K‐resistant PrP from prion‐infected SN56 neuroblastoma cells without affecting PrPC. The effect is enantiospecific since the levorotary isomer, poly‐l‐lysine, has a markedly weaker effect, likely because of its higher susceptibility to degradation. In vitro cross‐linking and NMR studies confirm a direct interaction between polylysine and PrP, which mainly maps to the PrP region containing helices 2 and 3 (H2H3). Interaction prevents conformational conversion and protein aggregation. Our results establish a central role of H2H3 in PrPSc amyloidogenesis and replication and provide biological relevance for the pathological misfolding of this domain.—Xu, Z., Adrover, M., Pastore, A., Prigent, S., Mouthon, F., Comoy, E., Rezaei, H., Deslys, J. ‐P. Mechanistic insights into cellular alteration of prion by poly‐D‐lysine: the role of H2H3 domain. FASEB J. 25, 3426–3435 (2011). www.fasebj.org