Stephen J. Cringle

Oxygen distribution and consumption within the retina in vascularised and avascular retinas and in animal models of retinal disease

Maintenance of an adequate oxygen supply to the retina is critical for retinal function. In species with vascularised retinas, such as man, oxygen is delivered to the retina via a combination of the choroidal vascular bed, which lies immediately behind the retina, and the retinal vasculature, which lies within the inner retina. The high-oxygen demands of the retina, and the relatively sparse nature of the retinal vasculature, are thought to contribute to the particular vulnerability of the retina to vascular disease. A large proportion of retinal blindness is associated with diseases having a vascular component, and disrupted oxygen supply to the retina is likely to be a critical factor. Much attention has therefore been directed at determining the intraretinal oxygen environment in healthy and diseased eyes. Measurements of oxygen levels within the retina have largely been restricted to animal studies in which oxygen sensitive microelectrodes can be used to obtain high-resolution measurements of oxygen tension as a function of retinal depth. Such measurements can immediately identify which retinal layers are supplied with oxygen from the different vascular elements. Additionally, in the outer retinal layers, which do not have any intrinsic oxygen sources, the oxygen distribution can be analysed mathematically to quantify the oxygen consumption rate of specific retinal layers. This has revealed a remarkable heterogeneity of oxygen requirements of different components of the outer retina, with the inner segments of the photoreceptors being the dominant oxygen consumers. Since the presence of the retinal vasculature precludes such a simple quantitative analysis of local oxygen consumption within the inner retina, our understanding of the oxygen needs of the inner retinal components is much less complete. Although several lines of evidence suggest that in the more commonly studied species such as cat, pig, and rat, the oxygen demands of the inner retina as a whole is broadly comparable to that of the outer retina, exactly which cell layers within the inner retina have the most stringent oxygen demands is not known. This may be a critical issue if the cell types most at risk from disrupted oxygen supply are to be identified. This paper reviews our current understanding of the oxygen requirements of the inner and outer retina and presents new data and mathematical models which identify three dominant oxygen-consuming layers in the rat retina. These are the inner segments of the photoreceptors, the outer plexiform layer, and the deeper region of the inner plexiform layer. We also address the intriguing question of how the oxygen requirements of the inner retina are met in those species which naturally have a poorly vascularised, or even totally avascular retina. We present measurements of the intraretinal oxygen distribution in two species of laboratory animal possessing such retinas, the rabbit and the guinea pig. The rabbit has a predominantly avascular retina, with only a narrow band of retinal vasculature, and the guinea pig retina is completely avascular. Both these animals demonstrate species adaptations in which the oxygen requirement of their inner retinas are extremely low when compared to that of their outer retinas. This finding both uncovers a remarkable ability of the inner retina in avascular species to function in a low-oxygen environment, and also highlights the dangers of extrapolating findings from avascular retinas to infer metabolic requirements of vascularised retinas. Different species also demonstrate a marked diversity in the manner in which intraretinal oxygen distribution is influenced by increases in systemic oxygen level. In the vascularised rat retina, the inner retinal oxygen increase is muted by a combination of increased oxygen consumption and a reduction of net oxygen delivery from the retinal circulation. The avascular retina of the guinea pig demonstrated a novel and powerful regulatory mechanism that prevents any dramatic rise in choroidal oxygen levels and keeps retinal oxygen levels within the normal physiological range. In contrast, in the avascular regions of the rabbit retina the choroidal oxygen level passively follows the increase in systemic oxygenation, and there is a dramatic rise in oxygen level in all retinal layers. The presence or absence of oxygen-regulating mechanisms may well reflect important survival strategies for the retina which are not yet understood. Intraretinal oxygen measurements in rat models of retinal disease are also presented. We describe how oxygen distribution across the rat retina is influenced by manipulation of systemic blood pressure. We examine the effect of acute and chronic occlusion of the retinal vasculature, and explore the feasibility of meeting the oxygen needs of the ischemic retina from the choroid. (ABSTRACT TRUNCATED)

Correlation of Histologic and Clinical Images to Determine the Diagnostic Value of Fluorescein Angiography for Studying Retinal Capillary Detail

PURPOSE To delineate morphometric and quantitative features of the capillary image derived from high-resolution fundus fluorescein angiography (FFA) and consequently determine the diagnostic value of FFA for studying the retinal capillary circulation. METHODS Retinal capillary images obtained from healthy young subjects using high-resolution FFA were compared with confocal scanning laser microscopic capillary images derived from the retinas of age-matched human donors. Confocal microscopic images were acquired from retinal flatmount tissue after central retinal artery cannulation, perfusion fixation, and antibody labeling. Capillary images from equivalent retinal regions were morphologically and quantitatively analyzed in both groups. RESULTS Ten human subjects (mean age, 27.4 years) were used for FFA studies, and five cadaveric eyes (mean donor age, 26.5 years) were used for histologic studies. In histologic specimens the density of the superficial capillary network was significantly greater than that of the deep capillary network. Despite use of a healthy young population, only 30% of high-resolution FFA studies provided clear capillary images. The configuration of the capillary network in FFA images was comparable to the superficial capillary network in confocal microscope images; however, the density of the capillary network in FFA images was consistently lower than that of histologic images. CONCLUSIONS FFA provides incomplete morphologic information about the superficial capillary network and even less information about the deep capillary network. Caution should, therefore, be exercised when using FFA data to extrapolate information about microvascular histopathologic processes. The usefulness of newer technology for studying retinal capillary detail should be investigated.

Quantitative confocal imaging of the retinal microvasculature in the human retina.

PURPOSE We investigated quantitatively the distribution of blood vessels in different neural layers of the human retina. METHODS A total of 16 human donor eyes was perfusion-fixed and labeled for endothelial f-actin. Retinal eccentricity located 3 mm superior to the optic disk was studied using confocal scanning laser microscopy. Immunohistochemical methods applied to whole-mount and transverse sections were used to colocalize capillary networks with neuronal elements. Capillary morphometry, diameter, and density measurements were compared among networks. RESULTS Four different capillary networks were identified and quantified in the following regions: Nerve fiber layer (NFL), retinal ganglion cell (RGC) layer, border of the inner plexiform layer (IPL) and superficial boundary of the inner nuclear layer (INL), and boundary of the deep INL and outer plexiform layer. The innermost and outermost capillary networks demonstrated a laminar configuration, while IPL and deep INL networks displayed a complex three-dimensional configuration. Capillary diameter in RGC and IPL networks were significantly less than in other networks. Capillary density was greatest in the RGC network (26.74%), and was significantly greater than in the NFL (13.69%), IPL (11.28%), and deep INL (16.12%) networks. CONCLUSIONS The unique metabolic demands of neuronal sub-compartments may influence the morphometric features of regional capillary networks. Differences in capillary diameter and density between networks may have important correlations with neuronal function in the human retina. These findings may be important for understanding pathogenic mechanisms in retinal vascular disease.

Quantitative morphometry of perifoveal capillary networks in the human retina.

PURPOSE To quantify the distribution and morphometric characteristics of capillary networks in the human perifovea. To determine correlations between the location of neuronal subcellular compartments and the morphometric features of regional capillary networks in the layered retina. METHODS The perifoveal region, located 2 mm nasal to the fovea, was studied in 17 human donor eyes. Novel micropipette technology was used to cannulate the central retinal artery and label the retinal microcirculation using a phalloidin perfusate. γ-synuclein, Goα, and parvalbumin antibodies were also used to co-localize the nerve fiber layer (NFL), retinal ganglion cell layer (RGCL), inner plexiform layer (IPL), and inner nuclear layer (INL). Confocal scanning laser microscopy was used for capillary imaging. Capillary diameter, capillary density, and capillary loop area measurements were compared between networks. RESULTS Four capillary networks were identified in the following retinal layers: (1) NFL, (2) RGCL and superficial portion of IPL, (3) deep portion of IPL and superficial portion of INL, and (4) deep portion of INL. Laminar configurations were present in NFL and deep INL networks. Remaining networks demonstrated three-dimensional configurations. Capillary density was greatest in the networks serving the IPL. Capillary loop area was smallest in the two innermost networks. There was no difference in capillary diameter between networks. CONCLUSIONS Capillary networks in the human perifovea are morphometrically heterogeneous. Morphometric features of regional capillary networks in the layered retina may serve a critical role in supporting neuronal homeostasis. Improved knowledge of these features may be important for understanding pathogenic mechanisms underlying retinal vascular diseases.

A multi-layer model of retinal oxygen supply and consumption helps explain the muted rise in inner retinal Po2 during systemic hyperoxia

A multi-layer mathematical model of oxygen supply and consumption in the rat retina is described. The model takes advantage of the highly layered structure of the retina and the compartmentalisation of the available oxygen sources. The retina is divided into eight layers, each with a distinct oxygen consumption or supply rate. When applied to the available data from intraretinal oxygen measurements in the rat under normal physiological conditions, a close fit between the model and the data was achieved (r(2)=0.98+0.005, n=6). The model was then used to investigate recent evidence of oxygen regulating mechanisms in the rat retina during systemic hyperoxia. Fitting our model to the experimental data (r(2)=0.988+0.004, n=25) allowed the relative oxygen delivery or consumption of the key retinal layers to be determined. Two factors combine to produce the relative stability of inner retinal oxygen levels in hyperoxia. The retinal layer containing the outer plexiform layer/deep retinal capillaries, switches from a net source to a net consumer of oxygen, and the oxygen consumption of the outer region of the inner plexiform layer increases significantly. The model provides a useful tool for examining oxygen consumption and supply in all retinal layers, including for the first time, those layers within the normally perfused inner retina.

Microstructure and Network Organization of the Microvasculature in the Human Macula

PURPOSE To characterize the topography and cellular structure of the macular microvasculature using a recently developed technique of arterial cannulation, perfusion, fixation, and staining of human donor eyes. METHODS Sixteen human donor eyes were used. The central retinal artery was cannulated and perfused with Ringers, then fixative, membrane permeabilizing, and selected labeling solutions. The eyes were immersion fixed, and the retina was flat mounted for confocal microscopy. The macular area, including the foveola, fovea, and parafovea, was sampled. The intracellular cytoskeleton of vascular endothelial and smooth muscle cells was studied in different orders of arterioles and venules and in the capillaries. To evaluate the degree of asymmetry within vascular networks, the distribution of generation numbers and the Horton-Strahler approach to vessel naming were compared. RESULTS The distribution of the microvascular network in the macular region was complex but followed a general theme. The parafoveal region was supplied by dense vasculature with approximately nine closely arranged pairs of arterioles and venules. Each arteriole had abundant branches and a high degree of asymmetry (∼10 generations and 3.5 orders within 1.2-mm length). Only a few arterioles (average ∼2.9) supplied the terminal capillary ring. Very long spindle endothelial cells were seen in the superficial and deep capillaries. Significant heterogeneity of distribution and shape of the endothelial and smooth muscle cells was evident in different orders of the macular vasculature. CONCLUSIONS The authors have demonstrated for the first time the cellular structure and topographic features of the macular microvasculature in human donor eyes.

Isolated preparations of ocular vasculature and their applications in ophthalmic research.

The purpose of this review is to outline the techniques and applications for isolated ocular vascular preparations and their significance to ophthalmic research. Various isolated ocular vascular preparations have been utilized in studies of ocular vascular biology, physiology and pharmacology, including work in both normal and diseased conditions. However, there is still significant potential for further studies to improve our understanding of the ocular circulation and its regulation. Experience has shown that there is no single preparation capable of addressing all of the questions that must be answered if a complete understanding of mechanisms of vascular regulation in the eye is to be achieved. Rather, it is necessary to select the appropriate preparation and techniques to address each individual question in the most appropriate manner. In this review, particular emphasis is placed on the applications for isolated ocular preparations and the relevance of such studies to our understanding of the pathogenesis of eye diseases involving the vasculature. Examples are given where therapeutic approaches in diabetes and glaucoma are assessed in terms of their impact on the vasoactive properties of the ocular vasculature.A significant heterogeneity is present in the different parts of the ocular vasculature, not only in the structural and functional properties of vessel itself, but also in terms of the tissue environment and innervation. A single vasoactive agent may also have different effects when applied to the inside or the outside of the same region of a vessel. The vasoactive response of the vascular system as a whole is what determines the rate of blood flow through the system, but this is regulated by a multitude of factors in different regions of the vascular network. Isolating individual components of the ocular vasculature is readily achievable for the extraocular vessels such as the ophthalmic or ophthalmocilliary arteries, which can be studied in myograph type systems measuring the mechanical vasoactive force generated by the vessel. Retinal vessels from very large animals can also be studied in this way, but the small diameter of the retinal vessels in most species requires a perfusion rather than myograph based technique. Perfusion based studies of vessel diameter in response to vasoactive stimuli can be applied to individual retinal arteries and their branches. Perfusion of more complex elements of the ocular vasculature such as isolated segments of the retina or ciliary body, or whole isolated perfused eyes may use the perfusate pressure as the determinant of vasoactive state. However, when several components of the ocular vasculature are being perfused simultaneously it may be difficult to separate out the contribution from the different vascular elements. The advantage of isolated preparations is that systemic influences can be eliminated, and vascular components can be studied that are inaccessible in vivo. The disadvantage is that no matter how well controlled the in vitro environment may be, it will always be a relatively poor mimic of the in vivo conditions. However, such in vitro work has certainly improved our understanding of the vasoactive properties of different regions of the ocular vasculature in both health and disease.

The Structural Relationship between the Microvasculature, Neurons, and Glia in the Human Retina

PURPOSE To develop a new technique for detailed study of the spatial distribution of retinal and choroidal microvasculature and their relationship to neurons and glial cells at the cellular level in human cadaveric eyes. METHODS Twenty-six human donor eyes were used. Wherever possible, the central retinal artery and a branch of the posterior ciliary artery were individually cannulated and perfused with oxygenated Ringers solution with 0.5% bovine serum albumin. The perfusion pressure was continuously monitored. Once residual blood was washed out, the perfusate solutions were switched to fixative, membrane-permeabilizing solution and selected labeling solutions. The eyes were then immersion fixed and the retina and choroid flat-mounted for immunolabeling and confocal imaging before cryosectioning. The microstructures of vascular, glial, and neuronal cells in the retina and the stroma in the choroid were studied. RESULTS The retinal microvasculature was fully perfused and stained by cannulation of the central retinal artery. Regional distribution of choroidal vasculature perfusion was dependent on the specific feeder artery cannulated. The detailed spatial relationship between endothelial cells, glial cells, and neurons at the cellular and subcellular levels was identified with confocal microscopy and immunohistochemical labeling of retinal sections. In the choroid, endothelial cells were clearly identifiable down to the level of the intracellular cytoarchitecture of the choriocapillaris, along with their relationship to Bruchs membrane and the feeding and drainage vessels. CONCLUSIONS A microperfusion fixation and staining technique has been developed that allows studies of the structural relationships of vascular, glial, and neuronal elements at the cellular level in human donor eyes.

Value of retinal vein pulsation characteristics in predicting increased optic disc excavation

Background: Retinal vein pulsation is often absent in glaucoma, but can be induced by applying a graded ophthalmodynamometric force (ODF) to the eye, which is elevated in glaucoma. Aim: To assess whether ODF has a predictive value in determining glaucoma progression. Methods: 75 patients with glaucoma and suspected glaucoma were examined prospectively in 1996, and then re-examined at a mean of 82 months later. All subjects had intraocular pressure, visual fields, stereo optic disc photography and ODF measured on their initial visit. When venous pulsation was spontaneous, the ODF was said to be 0 g. At re-examination, central corneal thickness and blood pressure were also measured. Initial and subsequent optic disc photographs were compared and graded into those that had increased excavation and those that had remained stable. The relationship between increased excavation (recorded as a binary response) and the measured variables was modelled using a multiple mixed effects logistic regression. Results: ODF at the initial visit was strongly predictive of increased excavation (p = 0.004, odds ratio 1.16/g, range 0–60 g), with greater predictive value in women than in men (p = 0.004). Visual field mean deviation was predictive of increased excavation (p = 0.044), as was optic nerve haemorrhage in association with older age (p = 0.038). Central corneal thickness was not significantly predictive of increased excavation (p = 0.074) after having adjusted for other variables. Conclusion: ODF measurement seems to be strongly predictive of the patient’s risk for increased optic disc excavation. This suggests that ODF measurement may have predictive value in assessing the likelihood of glaucoma progression.

Vitreal and retinal oxygenation

This paper reports the results of experiments carried out to understand the oxygenation of the normal retina in response to alterations in physiological conditions such as inspired oxygen concentration, elevated IOP, luminance changes and occlusion of the retinal circulation. Measurements of vitreal and intraretinal PO2 in vivo in the cat using oxygen-sensitive microelectrodes demonstrated that large PO2 gradients were set up preretinally and that arterial, venous and tissue PO2 increased when inspired PO2 was raised to 100% O2. Results showed that with an occluded retinal circulation, it was possible to oxygenate fully the whole retina with oxygen supplied from a hyperoxic choroidal circulation. With alterations in background luminance from photopic to scotopic, preretinal PO2 was unaffected for air breathing, whereas for 100% O2, breathing vitreal PO2 fell quickly and reversibly on a switch from photopic to scotopic conditions, reflecting an increase in retinal oxygen consumption in a dark environment. During acute rises of IOP, the PO2 at the choriocapillaris fell and an anoxic region developed in the middle retinal layers. The inner retina was relatively resistant to rises in IOP. The implications of these data for autoregulation of the retinal circulation are discussed.