Stephen T. Quay

Buffer insertion with accurate gate and interconnect delay computation

Buffer insertion has become a critical step in deep submicron design, and several buffer insertion/sizing algorithms have been proposed in the literature. However, most of these methods use simplified interconnect and gate delay models. These models may lead to inferior solutions since the optimized objective is only an approximation for the actual delay. We propose to integrate accurate wire and gate delay models into Van Ginnekens buffer insertion algorithm (1990) via the propagation of moments and driving point admittances up the routing tree. We have verified the effectiveness of our approach on an industry design.

Buffer insertion for noise and delay optimization

Interconnect-driven optimization is an increasingly important step in high-performance design. Algorithms for buffer insertion have been successfully utilized to reduce delay in global interconnect paths; however, existing techniques only optimize delay and timing slack, With the continually increasing ratio of coupling capacitance to total capacitance and the use of aggressive dynamic logic circuit families, noise analysis and avoidance is becoming a major design bottleneck. Hence, timing and noise must be simultaneously optimized to achieve maximum performance. This paper presents comprehensive buffer insertion techniques for noise and delay optimization. Three algorithms are presented, the first for noise avoidance for single sink trees, the second for avoidance for multiple sink trees, and the last for simultaneous noise and delay optimization. We prove the optimality of each algorithm (under various assumptions) and present other theoretical results as well. We ran experiments on a high-performance microprocessor design and show that our approach fixes all noise violations, Our approach was separately verified by a detailed, simulation-based noise analysis tool. Further, we show that optimizing delay alone cannot fix all of the noise violations and that the performance penalty induced by optimizing both delay and noise as opposed to only delay is less than 2%.

Techniques for Fast Physical Synthesis

The traditional purpose of physical synthesis is to perform timing closure , i.e., to create a placed design that meets its timing specifications while also satisfying electrical, routability, and signal integrity constraints. In modern design flows, physical synthesis tools hardly ever achieve this goal in their first iteration. The design team must iterate by studying the output of the physical synthesis run, then potentially massage the input, e.g., by changing the floorplan, timing assertions, pin locations, logic structures, etc., in order to hopefully achieve a better solution for the next iteration. The complexity of physical synthesis means that systems can take days to run on designs with multimillions of placeable objects, which severely hurts design productivity. This paper discusses some newer techniques that have been deployed within IBMs physical synthesis tool called PDS that significantly improves throughput. In particular, we focus on some of the biggest contributors to runtime, placement, legalization, buffering, and electric correction, and present techniques that generate significant turnaround time improvements

Buffer insertion with adaptive blockage avoidance

Buffer insertion is a fundamental technology for very large scale integration interconnect optimization. This work presents the repeater insertion with adaptive tree adjustment (RIATA) heuristic that directly extends van Ginnekens classic algorithm to handle blockages in the layout. Given a Steiner tree containing a Steiner point that overlaps a blockage, a local adjustment is made to the tree topology that enables additional buffer insertion candidates to be considered. This adjustment adapts to the demand on buffer insertion and is incurred only when it facilitates the maximal slack solution. RIATA can be combined with any performance-driven Steiner tree algorithm and permits various solution search schemes to achieve different solution quality and runtime tradeoffs. Experiments on several large nets confirms that high-quality solutions can be obtained through this technique with greater efficiency than simultaneous approaches.

Interconnect synthesis without wire tapering

Interconnect synthesis techniques, such as wire sizing and buffer insertion/sizing, have proven to be critical for reducing interconnect delays in deep submicron design. Consequently, the past few years have seen several works that study buffer insertion, wire sizing, and their simultaneous optimization. For long interconnect, wire tapering, i.e., reducing the wire width as the distance from the driver increases, can yield better solutions than uniform wire sizing. However, despite its obvious benefits, tapering is not widely used in practice since it is difficult to integrate into a coherent routing methodology. This paper studies the benefits of wire sizing with tapering when combined with buffer insertion. We first present a theoretical result that shows wire tapering is at most 3.5% faster than uniform wire sizing when maximal buffer insertion is applied. We then present detailed experiments that support this result. Consequently, we conclude that it is generally not worthwhile to perform tapering for signal nets. Finally, we present a general formulation and optimal polynomial time algorithm for simultaneous wire sizing and buffer insertion that forbids wire tapering, but incorporates layer assignment and wire spacing.

Steiner tree optimization for buffers, blockages, and bays

Timing optimization is a critical component of deep submicrometer design and buffer insertion is an essential technique for achieving timing closure. This work studies buffer insertion under the constraint that the buffers either: (1) avoid blockages or (2) are contained within preassigned buffer bay regions. We propose a general Steiner-tree formulation to drive this application and present a maze-routing-based heuristic that either avoids blockages or finds buffer bays. We show that the combination of our Steiner-tree optimization with leading-edge buffer-insertion techniques leads to effective solutions on industry designs.

Buffered Steiner trees for difficult instances

Buffer insertion has become an increasingly critical optimization in high performance design. The problem of finding a delay-optimal buffered Steiner tree has been an active area of research, and excellent solutions exist for most instances. However, current approaches fail to adequately solve a particular class of real-world “difficult” instances which are characterized by a large number of sinks, variations in sink criticalities, and varying polarity requirements. We propose a new Steiner tree construction called C-Tree for these instance types. When combined with van Ginneken style buffer insertion, C-Tree achieves higher quality solutions with fewer resources compared to traditional approaches.

Fast interconnect synthesis with layer assignment

As technology scaling advances beyond 65 nanometer node, more devices can fit onto a chip, which implies continued growth of design size. The increased wire delay dominance due to finer wire widths makes design closure an increasingly challenging problem. Interconnect synthesis techniques, such as buffer insertion/sizing and wire sizing, have proven to be the critical part of a successful timing closure optimization tool. Layer assignment, which was traditionally treated as same as wire sizing, is more effective and friendly in the design flow than wire sizing in the advanced technologies. Techniques for simultaneous layer assignment and buffer insertion with resource control are increasingly important for the quality of results of interconnect synthesis. This paper outlines the importance of layer assignment over wire sizing, and presents efficient techniques to perform concurrent buffer insertion and layer assignment to fix the electrical and timing problems, while maintaining speed and efficient use of resources

Fast and flexible buffer trees that navigate the physical layout environment

Buffer insertion is an increasingly critical optimization for achieving timing closure, and the number of buffers required increases significantly with technology migration. It is imperative for an automated buffer insertion algorithm to be able to efficiently optimize tens of thousands of nets. One must also be able to effectively navigate the existing layout, including handling large blockages, blockages with holes specifically for buffers, specially allocated buffer blocks, placement porosity, and routing congestion. The algorithm must also be flexible enough to know when to use and when not to use expensive layout resources. Although several previous works have addressed buffer insertion in the presence of blockages, this is the first to present a complete solution that can manage the physical layout environment.

A fast algorithm for identifying good buffer insertion candidate locations

Van Ginnekens algorithm [18] for performing buffer insertion is a classic in the field, since it optimally solves the problem subject to a set of fixed buffer insertion candidate locations for a given Steiner topology. The generation of these candidate locations is typically performed by dividing the routed wires into small uniformly sized pieces [1]. However, certain regions of the layout are generally more attractive to place buffers than others, e.g., sparse regions are preferred to dense ones. This work presents a fast, shortest path based algorithm to identify good candidate buffer insertion locations to be passed to van Ginnekens algorithm. Our experiments show that the buffers inserted significantly improve the overall design density with virtually no impact on either CPU time or buffered net delays.