Steve Reed

Targeting TLRs Expands the Antibody Repertoire in Response to a Malaria Vaccine

The use of TLR agonists in vaccination broadens the range of polymorphic variants against which the antibodies can be effective. Help! Sometimes one very talented athlete can carry a team to a championship. Yet, not even the best athletes can reach their full potential without the support of their teammates. Similarly, successful vaccines require strong and specific pathogen-derived antigens, but frequently, one of these essential players is not multitalented enough to elicit a protective immune response. To do so, these stars require help—which comes in the form of adjuvants. Whereas specific antigens induce a slower but pathogen-restricted immune response, adjuvants activate the faster but more general innate immune system. The addition of adjuvants to vaccine formulations is known to improve the quality, strength, and duration of the immune response by somewhat nebulous mechanisms. Now, Wiley et al. use massively parallel sequencing to quantify the immune response to a malarial antigen and find that a little help from an adjuvant results in added antibody diversity. The authors showed that adding a Toll-like receptor 4 agonist, which turns on a pattern-recognition receptor that activates innate immune cells, to a commonly used oil-in-water adjuvant in an antimalaria vaccine formulation greatly increased the diversity of antibodies made in response to the vaccine. These antibodies were better able to neutralize and could respond to more variants of the antigen. Therefore, in the context of an infection, these adjuvanted vaccines should be able to successfully fight more strains of a pathogen. What’s more, the sequencing method used by Wiley et al. should be broadly applicable to the characterization of immune responses to other vaccines and to infections, thus leading to improvements in the detection, diagnosis, and treatment of various diseases. Furthermore, this strategy can be used to scout out adjuvants that make the best teammates for pathogen-specific antigens in vaccine formulations. Vaccination with an isolated antigen is frequently not sufficient to elicit a protective immune response. The addition of adjuvants to the antigen can increase the magnitude and breadth of the response generated, but quantification of this increase as a function of adjuvant has been intractable. We have directly determined the variation of the immunoglobulin G variable-chain repertoire of an entire organism as a function of vaccination. Using the well-established Plasmodium vivax antigen, PvRII, and massively parallel sequencing, we showed that the use of a Toll-like receptor (TLR) agonist in the vaccine formulation increased the diversity of the variable region sequences in comparison to the use of an oil-in-water emulsion adjuvant alone. Moreover, increased variable domain diversity in response to the use of TLR agonist–based adjuvants correlated with improved antigen neutralization. The use of TLR agonists also broadened the range of polymorphic variants against which these antibodies could be effective. In addition, a peptide microarray demonstrated that inclusion of adjuvants changed the profile of linear epitopes from PvRII that were recognized by serum from immunized animals. The results of these studies have broad implications for vaccine design—they may enable tailored adjuvants that elicit the broad spectrum of antibodies required to neutralize drifted and polymorphic pathogen strains as well as provide a method for rapid determination of correlates of adjuvant-induced humoral immunity.

Adjuvants for malaria vaccines

There is a renewed enthusiasm about subunit vaccines for malaria coincident with the formation of new alliances and partnerships raising international public awareness, attracting increased resources and the re‐focusing of research programs on adjuvant development for infectious disease vaccines. It is generally accepted that subunit vaccines for malaria will require adjuvants to induce protective immune responses, and availability of suitable adjuvants has in the past been a barrier to the development of malaria vaccines. Several novel adjuvants are now in licensed products or in late stage clinical development, while several others are in the earlier development pipeline. Successful vaccine development requires knowing which adjuvants to use and knowing how to formulate adjuvants and antigens to achieve stable, safe, and immunogenic vaccines. For the majority of vaccine researchers this information is not readily available, nor is access to well‐characterized adjuvants. In this minireview, we outline the current state of adjuvant research and development as it pertains to effective malaria vaccines.

Leishmania vaccine development: exploiting the host–vector–parasite interface

Visceral leishmaniasis (VL) is a disease transmitted by phlebotomine sand flies, fatal if untreated, and with no available human vaccine. In rodents, cellular immunity to Leishmania parasite proteins as well as salivary proteins of the sand fly is associated with protection, making them worthy targets for further exploration as vaccines. This review discusses the notion that a combination vaccine including Leishmania and vector salivary antigens may improve vaccine efficacy by targeting the parasite at its most vulnerable stage just after transmission. Furthermore, we put forward the notion that better modeling of natural transmission is needed to test efficacy of vaccines. For example, the fact that individuals living in endemic areas are exposed to sand fly bites and will mount an immune response to salivary proteins should be considered in pre-clinical and clinical evaluation of leishmaniasis vaccines. Nevertheless, despite remaining obstacles there is good reason to be optimistic that safe and effective vaccines against leishmaniasis can be developed.

Specific IgG antibody responses may be used to monitor leprosy treatment efficacy and as recurrence prognostic markers

Although curable, leprosy requires better diagnostic and prognostic tools to accompany therapeutic strategies. We evaluated the serum samples of leprosy patients from Venezuela and Brazil for reactivity against the specific recombinant proteins, ML0405 and ML2331, and the LID-1 fusion protein that incorporates both of these antigens. Antigen-specific IgG was highest in lepromatous leprosy patients (LL) and decreased across the disease spectrum, such that only a small subset of true tuberculoid patients (TT) tested positive. The impact of multidrug therapy (MDT) on these antibody responses was also examined. Several years after treatment, the vast majority of Venezuelan patients did not possess circulating anti-LID-1, anti-ML0405, and anti-ML2331 IgG, and the seropositivity of the remaining cases could be attributed to irregular treatment. At discharge, the magnitude and proportion of positive responses of Brazilian patients against the proteins and phenolic glycolipid (PGL)-I were lower for most of the clinical forms. The monthly examination of IgG levels in LL patient sera after MDT initiation indicated that these responses are significantly reduced during treatment. Thus, responses against these antigens positively correlate with bacillary load, clinical forms, and operational classification at diagnosis. Our data indicate that these responses could be employed as an auxiliary tool for the assessment of treatment efficacy and disease relapse.

Comparison of multiple adjuvants on the stability and immunogenicity of a clade C HIV-1 gp140 trimer

Immunogens based on the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) Envelope (Env) glycoprotein have to date failed to elicit potent and broadly neutralizing antibodies against diverse HIV-1 strains. An understudied area in the development of HIV-1 Env-based vaccines is the impact of various adjuvants on the stability of the Env immunogen and the magnitude of the induced humoral immune response. We hypothesize that optimal adjuvants for HIV-1 gp140 Env trimers will be those with high potency but also those that preserve structural integrity of the immunogen and those that have a straightforward path to clinical testing. In this report, we systematically evaluate the impact of 12 adjuvants on the stability and immunogenicity of a clade C (CZA97.012) HIV-1 gp140 trimer in guinea pigs and a subset in non-human primates. Oil-in-water emulsions (GLA-emulsion, Ribi, Emulsigen) resulted in partial aggregation and loss of structural integrity of the gp140 trimer. In contrast, alum (GLA-alum, Adju-Phos, Alhydrogel), TLR (GLA-aqueous, CpG, MPLA), ISCOM (Matrix M) and liposomal (GLA-liposomes, virosomes) adjuvants appeared to preserve trimer integrity as measured by size exclusion chromatography. However, multiple classes of adjuvants similarly augmented Env-specific binding and neutralizing antibody responses in guinea pigs and non-human primates.

Perioperative treatment with the new synthetic TLR-4 agonist GLA-SE reduces cancer metastasis without adverse effects

The use of TLR agonists as an anti‐cancer treatment is gaining momentum given their capacity to activate various host cellular responses through the secretion of inflammatory cytokines and type‐I interferons. It is now also recognized that the perioperative period is a window of opportunity for various interventions aiming at reducing the risk of cancer metastases—the major cause of cancer related death. However, immune‐stimulatory approach has not been used perioperatively given several contraindications to surgery. To overcome these obstacles, in this study, we used the newly introduced, fully synthetic TLR‐4 agonist, Glucopyranosyl Lipid‐A (GLA‐SE), in various models of cancer metastases, and in the context of acute stress or surgery. Without exerting evident adverse effects, a single systemic administration of GLA‐SE rapidly and dose dependently elevated both innate and adaptive immunity in the circulation, lungs and the lymphatic system. Importantly, GLA‐SE treatment led to reduced metastatic development of a mammary adenocarcinoma and a colon carcinoma by approximately 40–75% in F344 rats and BALB/c mice, respectively, at least partly through elevating marginating‐pulmonary NK cell cytotoxicity. GLA‐SE is safe and well tolerated in humans, and currently is used as an adjuvant in phase‐II clinical trials. Given that the TLR‐4 receptor and its signaling cascade is highly conserved throughout evolution, our current results suggest that GLA‐SE may be a promising immune stimulatory agent in the context of oncological surgeries, aiming to reduce long‐term cancer recurrence.

Antigenicity and immunogenicity of a novel chimeric peptide antigen based on the P. vivax circumsporozoite protein.

BACKGROUND Plasmodium vivax circumsporozoite (PvCS) protein is a major sporozoite surface antigen involved in parasite invasion of hepatocytes and is currently being considered as vaccine candidate. PvCS contains a dimorphic central repetitive fragment flanked by conserved regions that contain functional domains. METHODS We have developed a chimeric 137-mer synthetic polypeptide (PvCS-NRC) that includes the conserved region I and region II-plus and the two natural repeat variants known as VK210 and VK247. The antigenicity of PvCS-NRC was tested using human sera from PNG and Colombia endemic areas and its immunogenicity was confirmed in mice with different genetic backgrounds, the polypeptide formulated either in Alum or GLA-SE adjuvants was assessed in inbred C3H, CB6F1 and outbred ICR mice, whereas a formulation in Montanide ISA51 was tested in C3H mice. RESULTS Antigenicity studies indicated that the chimeric peptide is recognized by a high proportion (60-70%) of residents of malaria-endemic areas. Peptides formulated with either GLA-SE or Montanide ISA51 adjuvants induced stronger antibody responses as compared with the Alum formulation. Sera from immunized mice as well as antigen-specific affinity purified human IgG antibodies reacted with sporozoite preparations in immunofluorescence and Western blot assays, and displayed strong in vitro inhibition of sporozoite invasion (ISI) into hepatoma cells. CONCLUSIONS The polypeptide was recognized at high prevalence when tested against naturally induced human antibodies and was able to induce significant immunogenicity in mice. Additionally, specific antibodies were able to recognize sporozoites and were able to block sporozoite invasion in vitro. Further evaluation of this chimeric protein construct in preclinical phase e.g. in Aotus monkeys in order to assess the humoral and cellular immune responses as well as protective efficacy against parasite challenge of the vaccine candidate must be conducted.

Evaluation of various cytokines elicited during antigen-specific recall as potential risk indicators for the differential development of leprosy

Leprosy is a dermato-neurological disease caused by Mycobacterium leprae infection that manifests across a wide range of clinical and immunological outcomes. Diagnosis is still currently based on clinical manifestations and simple tests are needed. This study investigated whether biomarkers induced by defined M. leprae proteins in 24-h whole blood assays (WBA) could discriminate active leprosy patients from at-risk contacts. Newly diagnosed, untreated paucibacillary (PB; tuberculoid leprosy/borderline tuberculoid [TT/BT]) and multibacillary (MB; borderline lepromatous/lepromatous leprosy [BL/LL]) leprosy patients, as well as healthy household contacts (HHC) of MB patients, were recruited in central western Brazil (Goiânia/Goiás). Cell-based responses to the ML0276, ML1623, ML0405, ML1632, 92f, and ML1011 antigens were measured by Luminex 14-plex assays detecting eotaxin, IFNγ, IL-2, IL-4, IL-5, IL-6, IL-10, IL-12p70, IL-15, IL-17A, IL-23, IL-31, IP-10, and TNFα. Our data reinforce that IFNγ is currently the best indicator of the antigen-specific cellular immune response of TT/BT leprosy and demonstrate that the same antigens promote the secretion of IL-4 in blood from BL/LL leprosy patients. While none of the biomarkers tested could discriminate leprosy patients from HHC, our data indicate that, although most HHC antigen-specific responses are qualitatively similar to TT/BT patients, some HHC can respond similarly to BL/LL patients.

Alteration of the serum biomarker profiles of visceral leishmaniasis during treatment

Until recently, chemotherapy for visceral leishmaniasis (VL; also known as kala-azar) was severely limited by factors such as high cost, route of administration, generation of side effects and potential for resistance. Although largely effective, chemotherapies have become available with the introduction of new drugs and multi-drug regimens for VL. These could be further improved by the identification of biomarkers that are altered during effective treatment. The identification of such biomarkers in the circulation would also simplify efficacy trials. In this study, we determined immunological signatures within the serum of ethnically and geographically distinct VL patients (from Bangladesh and Brazil). Our results indicate that inflammatory and regulatory cytokines (IFNγ, TNFα, IL-10, IL-17), as well as levels of growth factors (FGF, VEGF), are elevated within the serum of VL patients from these sites. The examination of samples from Brazilian VL patients during and beyond standard treatment with meglumine antimoniate identified multiple parameters that revert to levels comparable to those of healthy endemic control individuals. The consolidation of these results provides a ‘response to treatment’ signature that could be used within efficacy trials to rapidly and simply determine successful interruption of VL.

Specific antibody responses as indicators of treatment efficacy for visceral leishmaniasis

Acute visceral leishmaniasis (VL) is caused by infection with parasites of the Leishmania donovani complex and may be fatal if not treated. Early diagnosis and efficacious treatment are the keys to effective VL management and control. Novel regimens are being developed to overcome limitations in VL treatment options, which are currently restricted by high costs, severe systemic side effects, and unresponsiveness. Although simple and accurate serological tests are available to help confirm VL, none are suitable to monitor treatment efficacy and cure. Here, we confirm that serum antibody responses to the diagnostic antigens rK39 and rK28 are unaltered by treatment, but demonstrate that antibodies produced against two antigens, rK26 and rK18, can be used as an indirect measure of parasite clearance. The levels of anti-rK18 and -rK26 antibodies were high in patients at initial diagnosis but declined in patients treated with either SSG (Ethiopia) or AmBisome™ (Bangladesh). Taken together, we propose that serological tests which measure antibodies to rK26 and rK18 merit consideration as potential markers of treatment success and cure.