Steven J. Swanson

Comparing ELISA and Surface Plasmon Resonance for Assessing Clinical Immunogenicity of Panitumumab

Evaluation of the immunogenicity of panitumumab, a fully human anti-epidermal growth factor receptor mAb approved for use in colorectal cancer patients, led to the development of two separate immunoassays for the detection of anti-panitumumab Abs. The first immunoassay used a bridging ELISA capable of detecting 10 ng/ml positive control anti-panitumumab Ab. The ELISA incorporated an acid dissociation step to reduce drug interference and tolerated the presence of ∼100-fold molar excess of drug. During eight clinical trials, the ELISA detected developing Ab responses in 2 of 612 (0.3%) subjects. In one of the ELISA positive subjects, neutralizing Abs were detected using an epidermal growth factor receptor phosphorylation bioassay. The second immunoassay used a Biacore biosensor immunoassay format capable of detecting 1 μg/ml positive control Ab while tolerating the presence of equal molar amounts of drug. Although less sensitive and less tolerant to competing drug in the assay, the Biacore assay detected developing Ab responses in 25 of the 604 (4.1%) subjects. Additionally, the Biacore assay identified eight subjects who developed neutralizing Abs. Mouse mAbs with affinities ranging from 1.1 × 10−6 to 8.4 × 10−10 M were used to characterize both assay types. The ELISA was more sensitive for the detection of higher affinity mAbs and detected high-affinity mAbs in the presence of higher molar ratio of drug to mAb. The Biacore assay was more sensitive for detection of lower affinity mAbs and detected low affinity Abs in the presence of higher molar ratios of drug to mAb.

Validation parameters for a novel biosensor assay which simultaneously measures serum concentrations of a humanized monoclonal antibody and detects induced antibodies

This report documents the validation of an assay using BIAcore 2000 that, with a single injection of mouse serum, allows the quantitation of a humanized monoclonal antibody and can also detect the presence of antibodies directed against this humanized antibody. The important components required for the validation of biosensor assays including precision, accuracy, linearity, stability of the immobilized ligand, specificity and sensitivity are addressed. The tandem assay that is used as a model for biosensor validations is accomplished by flowing each sample across the surface of two flowcells in sequence. The first flowcell has the antigen that the humanized mAb was generated against immobilized while the humanized mAb itself is immobilized on the second flowcell. The quantitation component of this assay is precise and accurate with a limit of quantitation of 1 microg/ml in mouse serum samples. Any antibodies directed against the humanized mAb can be detected and also characterized as to isotype. This unique assay can be performed with as little as 10 microl of serum which is then diluted ten-fold prior to analysis. The small sample requirement allows analysis of individual mouse serum samples rather than requiring the use of pooled samples from multiple mice. A further advantage of this assay is the automation capability which allows unattended operation.

Detection and characterization of antibodies to PEG-IFN-alpha2b using surface plasmon resonance.

Some patients treated with type I interferon (IFN) preparations develop neutralizing antibodies that may abrogate any clinical benefit. We have a new complex of polyethylene glycol12000 and IFN-alpha2b (PEG-IFN-alpha2b) in clinical trials and need to be able to detect any antibodies formed specifically against the complex. We have, therefore, devised a method based on measurement of surface plasmon resonance (SPR) in the BIACORE 2000 apparatus. PEG-IFN-alpha2b is anchored to one flow cell on the sensor chip, IFN-alpha2b to another, and PEG to a third. A 20 microl serum sample flows in turn through the three cells, which are optically scanned. Any antibodies in the serum bind to the corresponding immobilized antigen, and a change in the optical signal is generated. With appropriate specific reagents, their immunoglobulin isotype can be similarly established. The automated assay can quickly test numerous sera. Very little serum is needed, and the assay is reliable and precise and can detect low-alphaffinity antibodies.

Immunogenicity testing strategy and bioanalytical assays for antibody–drug conjugates

BACKGROUNDnImmunogenicity testing is an important component of clinical development for large-molecule biotherapeutics. New complex types of large molecules, such as antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs), require careful evaluation of the testing strategy and bioanalytical assays used to monitor the development of antitherapeutic antibodies.nnnRESULTSnAn electrochemiluminescence-based immunoassay for the detection and epitope characterization of anti-ADC antibodies was validated. Using this assay format, antibodies directed against the monoclonal antibody and linker-drug components of the ADC were successfully detected in a multiple-dose rat toxicity study.nnnCONCLUSIONnImmunogenicity assays incorporating epitope determination may provide additional information about the characteristics of induced antitherapeutic antibodies, including the magnitude and timing of the various types of antibody responses.

2014 White Paper on recent issues in bioanalysis: a full immersion in bioanalysis (Part 3 - LBA and immunogenicity)

The 2014 8th Workshop on Recent Issues in Bioanalysis (8thxa0WRIB), a 5-day full immersion in the evolving field of bioanalysis, took place in Universal City, California, USA. Close to 500 professionals from pharmaceutical and biopharmaceutical companies, contract research organizations and regulatory agencies worldwide convened to share, review, discuss and agree on approaches to address current issues of interest in bioanalysis. The topics covered included both small and large molecules, and involved LCMS, hybrid LBA/LCMS, LBA approaches and immunogenicity. From the prolific discussions held during the workshop, specific recommendations are presented in this 2014 White Paper. As with the previous years editions, this paper acts as a practical tool to help the bioanalytical community continue advances in scientific excellence, improved quality and better regulatory compliance. Due to its length, the 2014 edition of this comprehensive White Paper has been divided into three partsxa0for editorial reasons. This publication (Part 3) covers the recommendations for Large molecules bioanalysis using LBA and Immunogenicity. Part 1 (Small molecules bioanalysis using LCMS) and Part 2 (Hybrid LBA/LCMS, Electronic Laboratory Notebook and Regulatory Agencies Input) were published in the Bioanalysis issues 6(22) and 6(23), respectively.

Assessing specificity for immunogenicity assays

Developing sensitive and specific bioanalytical assays for measuring the immunogenicity of biological therapeutics has become an integral component of the drug-development process. The strategy for measuring these immune responses involves performing sensitive screening assays that are capable of detecting low levels of both low- and high-affinity antibodies. However, having sensitive assays inherently results in a certain rate of false-positivity. Hence, developing steps to determine specificity in these assays is important to confirm the presence of antidrug antibodies. The specificity assays are defined by the ability of an assay to score a positive result if the serum sample contains an antibody that can bind and/or neutralize the therapeutic protein. Here, we discuss the methodologies for determining specificity in the bioanalytical assays used for measuring antidrug antibodies. These methods will provide investigators and regulators with guidelines to develop and review assays to measure antidrug antibodies, which can specifically interfere with the actions of the drug and/or influence the safety profile of the therapeutic proteins.

Impact of matrix-associated soluble factors on the specificity of the immunogenicity assessment

BACKGROUNDnSpecificity and sensitivity are essential in assays for immunogenicity assessment of biotherapeutics. Nonspecific interactions from excess therapeutic or anti-therapeutic antibody, soluble ligands (e.g., target receptor), or serum proteins associated with autoimmune conditions (e.g., rheumatoid factor) in samples can impact the detection of a true anti-therapeutic response.nnnRESULTSnElectrochemiluminescence-based bridging assay formats could eliminate the interference due to rheumatoid factor with no pretreatment with Melon Gel™ or aggregated IgG. The interference due to soluble factors was not platform specific for the four therapeutics evaluated in this study.nnnCONCLUSIONnMelon Gel pretreatment and avidin high-bind (Meso Scale Discovery) plates can effectively reduce interference due to rheumatoid factor in ELISA- and electrochemiluminescence-based assays, respectively. Excess levels of therapeutic and anti-therapeutic antibodies in bridging assays can impact assay specificity.

Strategic characterization of anti-drug antibody responses for the assessment of clinical relevance and impact.

All therapeutic proteins have the potential to induce anti-drug antibodies (ADA). Clinically relevant ADA can impact efficacy and/or safety of a biological therapeutic. Immunogenicity assessment strategy evaluates binding and neutralizing ADA, and the need for additional characterization (e.g., epitope, titer and so on) is determined using a risk-based approach. The choice of characterization assays depends on the type, application and immunogenicity of the therapeutic. ADA characterization can impact the interpretation of the risk profile of a given therapeutic, and offers insight into opportunities for risk mitigation and management. This article describes common ADA characterization methods. Strategic assessment and characterization of clinically relevant ADA are discussed, in order to support clinical options for safe and effective patient care and disease management.