Susan Egelko

The impact of managed care on substance abuse treatment: a report of the American Society of Addiction Medicine.

Abstract This report examines the impact of managed care (MC) and related developments on substance abuse treatment, and evaluates how it has been associated with a decline in the availability of proper treatment for many addicted patients. A trend toward carve-out and for-profit MC organizations is associated with lower financial incentives for intensive treatment than in earlier staff-model and not-for-profit MC organizations. The value of substance abuse insurance coverage has declined by 75% between 1988 and 1998 for employees of mid-to large-size companies, compared with only an 11.5% decline for general health insurance. The shift towards MC has also been associated with a drastic reduction in frequency and duration of inpatient hospitalization, and there is no clear evidence that this reduction has been offset by a corresponding increase in outpatient support. In a survey of physicians treating addiction, the majority felt that MC had a negative impact on detoxification and rehabilitation, and on their ethical practice of addiction medicine.

Rational Recovery: alternative to AA for addiction?

Rational Recovery (RR) is a new self-help movement for substance abusers, with a cognitive orientation. It has been suggested as an alternative to Alcoholics Anonymous. This study was designed to examine the nature of RR and its impact on those who join. A national sample of 433 substance-abusing people attending 63 established RR groups was evaluated, using codable self-report questionnaires completed at RR meetings. Members were mostly men with college experience who had previously attended AA. Among recruits who attended their first RR meeting in the last month, 38% were abstinent in the last month. Among members who had joined 3 or more months before, 73% were abstinent in the last month; they had attended an average of 4.1 RR meetings in that month, and carried out exercises at home based on Rational Emotive Therapy. Among those who joined 6 or more months before, 58% reported at least 6 months of abstinence. Among members with a history of heavy cocaine use, the portion reporting abstinence in the last month was not significantly different from those who had never used cocaine. The minority of members who were engaged for 3 months were still drinking, though, and did so on an average of 9.9 days in the last month. RR succeeded in engaging substance abusers and promoting abstinence among many of them while presenting a cognitive orientation that is different from the spiritual one of AA. Its utility in substance abuse treatment warrants further assessment.

Can cocaine addicts with severe mental illness be treated along with singly diagnosed addicts

Large numbers of indigent cocaine abusers now present in center-city hospitals. Since many are also diagnosed for severe mental illness, options for their effective treatment are needed. The authors investigated the feasibility of treating these dually diagnosed patients along with the majority of abusers who were not severely impaired in a program that combines peerled treatment with psychiatric management and pharmacotherapy. Although group confrontation techniques were used, schizophrenics (N = 71) and patients with major depressive disorder (N = 50) experienced an outcome as good or better than the less impaired (N = 177) on retention, visit rates, and urinalysis results.

Improved Psychological Status in a Modified Therapeutic Community for Homeless MICA Men

Abstract An adaptation of the drug-free therapeutic community (TC) model to homeless men with comorbid mental illness and chemical addiction (MICA) was evaluated with respect to change in psychological status over the course of a six-month residential treatment. Psychological status was assessed by: the Symptom Checklist-90-R (SCL90-R), Beck Depression Inventory (BDI), Shortened Manifest Anxiety Scale (SMAS), and Tennessee Self-Concept Scale (TSCS). A total of 52 out of an original study cohort of 124 residents were followed in longitudinal analyses to treatment midpoint, with a subset of 34 assessed through treatment completion. Significant, widespread psychological improvements were found during both the first and second half of treatment; it would appear that distress reduction was ongoing throughout treatment, with intrapersonal preceding interpersonal relief. The premise of applying a socially-based treatment to this population is discussed in light of these findings.

Treatment of Perinatal Cocaine Addiction: Use of the Modified Therapeutic Community

Treatment outcome was evaluated for perinatal cocaine addicts admitted to a hospital-based day treatment clinic, organized as a modified therapeutic community (TC) modality. The perinatal program consisted of a specialized track for women embedded within this larger coed day treatment clinic. A total of 87 perinatal women (28 pregnant at intake, the remaining 59 postpartum) were compared with cohorts of nonperinatal women (N = 63) and men (N = 158) admitted during the period of evaluation (September 1989 through December 1993). In logistic regression analysis, successful discharge urine status (last three urines prior to discharge drug-free) was associated with current child custody involvement (odds ratio = 2.80, 95% C.I. = 1.16-6.72), entering treatment when not postpartum (odds ratio = 0.15, 95% C.I. = 0.05-0.42), and taking psychiatric medication (odds ratio = 2.04, 95% C.I. = 1.11-3.72). Both pregnant and postpartum perinatal women showed a similar pattern of shorter treatment as compared with nonperinatal women and male clients, averaging 2 months of treatment as compared with 4 months for nonperinatal clients. Factoring out pregnancy and postpartum status, the women in treatment fared as well as men with respect to both retention and discharge urine standings. This finding indicates that programmatic modifications need to address specific perinatal issues and not gender issues per se. Also, a differential pattern in discharge urine status of women who enter treatment while pregnant vs. those who enter when postpartum suggests that outreach and recruitment be targeted, but not limited, to pregnant women.

Evaluation of a Multisystems Model for Treating Perinatal Cocaine Addiction

Two stages of a gender-specific treatment program for perinatal cocaine-addicted women were introduced into a coed peer-led day treatment program and evaluated for outcomes. Stage I (N = 21) targeted gender-specific needs, but did not expressly promote family reintegration. Stage II (N = 27) augmented the gender-specific program with a multisystems model for family reintegration. As a control for historical effects, nonperinatal clients whose treatment remained the same during the periods corresponding to the two stages, were evaluated for outcomes (N = 66 for Stage I, N = 75 for Stage II). As hypothesized, urine toxicology and retention data were significantly improved for perinatal clients treated in Stage II, as compared with those treated in Stage I; no such improvements were noted for non-perinatal clients. The data support a conclusion that introducing a multisystems framework into a gender-specific program selectively improves clinical outcomes for inner-city perinatal cocaine-addicted women.

Developmental Risk Factors in Postpartum Women with Urine Tests Positive for Cocaine

The aim of the study was to ascertain whether there was a difference in developmental experiences between two groups of inner city postpartum patients, those who used cocaine during pregnancy and those who did not. A retrospective structured interview was administered to 80 postpartum women examining demographic characteristics, adaptive function, drug use patterns, and selected risk factors for adult substance abuse encountered before age 16. The sample was divided into two cohorts of women: 40 women identified by urine tests of their babies as using cocaine shortly before delivery and a comparison group of 40 women not identified by positive urines. Comparisons between the two cohorts revealed that the cocaine identified women had significantly higher overall past and present use of a broad range of drugs, particularly crack and other forms of cocaine, as well as lower levels of general adaptive functioning despite the fact that they were demographically comparable. When compared to the nonusers, they displayed markedly elevated scores on measures of developmental risk factors for adult substance use. This study highlights the importance of early developmental risk factors on later drug use during pregnancy and general adult adaptive functioning. Further study and intervention targeted at persons with these risk factors are warranted.

Schizophrenic patients and cocaine use: Antecedents to hospitalization and course of treatment

This study was designed to assess whether cocaine abuse was associated with a different set of antecedents and course for hospitalized schizophrenic patients. Forty-three cocaine-using and 27 non-cocaine-using patients with schizophrenia admitted to a dual diagnosis unit were compared with regard to antecedents to hospitalization such as prior treatment episodes, reliance on drugs for pleasure and tension reduction, and criminal history as well as course of hospital treatment. Cocaine-using patients were more likely to have had a history of prior inpatient drug treatment and to rely on drugs to a greater extent for tension reduction and pleasure. There was a trend for cocaine users to have a history of arrests for violent crimes. Although cocaine-using patients exhibited lower levels of global distress during the first week of hospitalization, they were no different from their counterparts who abused nonpsychostimulant drugs with regard to outcome of hospital treatment. These findings suggest that the lifetime course of illness among schizophrenic patients presenting for hospitalization who abuse cocaine may be characterized by episodes of repeated inpatient drug treatment and impaired impulse control. More rigorous discharge planning and aftercare program monitoring in the community as well as stress management interventions directed to tension reduction are therefore warranted.