Susan M. Nicholls

Immune cell infiltration and persistence in the mouse trigeminal ganglion after infection of the cornea with herpes simplex virus type 1

Following inoculation of the mouse cornea with herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1), the spread of virus was investigated and the types of immune cell infiltrating the trigeminal ganglion (TG) were identified in low temperature paraffin wax sections. Virus antigen was first found on day 3 and was absent after day 14. Early presentation of antigen to T cells may occur since increased expression of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II antigens, including de novo expression on satellite and Schwann cells, was detected in foci of such antigen on day 3. A second large peak of such expression was detected on day 10 together with increasing numbers of B and T cells. Large numbers of these lymphocytes and extensive expression of MHC class II were seen in the TG well into the phase of virus latency; the significance of this is discussed.

Immune cell infiltration in corneas of mice with recurrent herpes simplex virus disease

Reactivation of latent herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) infection was induced by UV irradiation of the corneas of latently infected mice. On days 1-4 after stimulation, infectious virus was sought in nervous and ocular tissue. On days 4, 7 and 10, eyes with either recurrent epithelial or stromal disease and appropriate controls were stained to identify immune cells and HSV-1 antigens. The maximum incidence of infectious virus was on day 2 when 5/10 ophthalmic parts of the trigeminal ganglion yielded HSV. Thus in this mouse model, as in humans, reactivation of virus in the trigeminal ganglion is the likely source of virus producing recurrent disease and shedding in the tear film. On day 4, when virus antigens were still present, granulocytes were the predominant infiltrating cell in corneas with either type of disease. Small numbers of T cells, dendritic cells and cells expressing MHC class II were also present. In stromal disease, the granulocyte infiltrate persisted and T cells remained sparse. In contrast, in epithelial disease, granulocyte numbers rapidly declined and both CD4+ and CD8+ T cells (present at a ratio of 1:1) increased significantly. The secondary immune response to virus antigen is more rapid and vigorous than that during primary corneal infection. Granulocytes may play a role in the initial clearance of virus, however, the other types of cells present early on provide the potential for a local secondary immune response. The high proportion of CD8+ cells in epithelial disease compared with stromal disease suggests that they may be acting as suppressors.

Immunohistochemical detection of cytokines in paraffin-embedded mouse tissues.

We have successfully developed a method for the immunohistochemical detection of interleukin 2 (IL-2), IL-4, IL-6, IL-10O, IFNgamma and TNFalpha using monoclonal antibodies (MAb), in sections of mouse tissue embedded in paraffin wax. The method involved fixation in periodate-lysine-paraformaldehyde (PLP), rapid dehydration and infiltration under vacuum with paraffin wax at 54 degrees C. Comparative observations demonstrated that the method gives equivalent or better results than formaldehyde fixed, frozen sections. Since reliable controls, both positive and negative, are paramount for interpretation of immunohistochemical staining, such controls were determined. The following tissues were shown to be suitable as positive controls when using paraffin-embedding: spleen for the detection of TNFalpha, small intestine for IL-2, IL-4 and IL-10, and HSV-1 infected eyes for IL-6 and IFNgamma. We conclude that PLP fixation and low temperature paraffin-embedding is a method which provides both preservation of excellent tissue morphology and reliable immunohistochemical identification of cytokines. These attributes will be invaluable in a wide variety of experimental situations.

Development of organised conjunctival leucocyte aggregates after corneal transplantation in rats

Aim: To investigate the development of lymphoid aggregates in the conjunctiva after corneal transplantation in rats. Methods: LEW or PVG strain corneas were transplanted orthotopically to PVG rats. Cornea and conjunctiva were examined clinically for up to 42 days. Eyes were removed with attached conjunctiva on days 10 and 15 after transplantation (before and during rejection), together with normal eyes, fixed, paraffin embedded, and examined immunohistochemically. Results: Clinically, the temporal half of the upper palpebral conjunctiva of recipients of 10/19 allografts and 1/10 isografts developed pronounced swelling, correlating with inflammation and rejection. Histologically, the swelling comprised leucocytic aggregates with an altered overlying epithelium. Aggregates contained granulocytes, macrophages, and cells expressing major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II, CD4, and CD8, all more numerous in allograft associated conjunctiva. Class II+ cells were more abundant at the surface, whereas macrophages and T cells were more numerous in the deeper stroma. There were few B cells. There was greater CD54 expression by vascular endothelium in allograft associated aggregates. Cells expressing TNFα and IFNγ but not IL1β were present in stromal and superficial areas. Conclusions: Corneal transplantation in rats induces the development of organised conjunctival leucocytic aggregates in a fixed location that are significantly more pronounced in recipients of allografts compared with isografts and show characteristics of a Th1 type immune response. These aggregates have characteristics of conjunctiva associated lymphoid tissue and may be sites of presentation of graft antigens and lymphocyte proliferation at the ocular surface.

Non-MHC antigens and their relative resistance to immunosuppression after corneal transplantation

We have used a high responder rat model to examine the role that non-MHC antigens play in corneal graft rejection. Recipients were backcross animals derived from a cross between two inbred strains, which mimicked the human outbred population in that donor and recipient could be matched or mismatched for MHC antigens, while non-MHC mismatches were variable and unknown. All mismatched grafts and 87% of matched grafts were rejected (median survival 11 and 17 days respectively). The high incidence of rejection of matched grafts indicates that several independently segregating non-MHC genes play a role in rejection. Moreover, the immune response to matched grafts appeared resistant to immunosuppression, suggesting that matching does not permit reduced dosage of immunosuppressants. A mechanism is discussed whereby matching at the class II locus may enhance presentation of mismatched histocompatibility antigens or viral peptides derived from infected graft cells, thereby prejudicing graft survival.

A Model of Corneal Graft Rejection in Semi-Inbred NIH Miniature Swine: Significant T-Cell Infiltration of Clinically Accepted Allografts

PURPOSE The purpose of our study is to develop a pre-clinical model of corneal graft rejection in the semi-inbred NIH minipig as a model of human rejection. METHODS NIH minipigs received corneal allografts with MHC and minor mismatches, or minor mismatches alone. Clinical rejection was monitored, and major subsets of leukocytes and ingress of vessels were quantified post-mortem by automated digital methods. Spectratypes of recipient T-cell receptor β-subunit variable region (TRβV) were analyzed. The capacity of pig corneal endothelial cells to proliferate in vivo was assessed. RESULTS Autografts (n = 5) and SLA(cc) to SLA(cc) allografts (minor mismatches, n = 5) were not rejected. Median graft survival of SLA(dd) and SLA(bb) allografts in SLA(cc) strain recipients (major and minor mismatches) was 57 (n = 10) and 67 (n = 6) days, respectively. Rejected grafts did not recover clarity in vivo, and corneal endothelial cells did not proliferate in organ culture after cryo-injury. There were significantly more leukocytes in clinically rejected versus accepted grafts (P < 0.0001) and in transplanted versus contralateral eyes (P < 0.0001). Numbers of T-cells were significantly greater in clinically accepted grafts versus autografts and in rejected grafts versus accepted (P < 0.005 for most subsets). There were significant differences in TRβV spectratype between graft groups in cornea, but not in draining lymph node or blood (P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS The NIH minipig offers a robust model of human rejection suitable for immunological or therapeutic studies. In particular, there is limited capacity for corneal endothelial repair in vivo, and histological evidence suggests that allosensitization of the recipient may develop in the absence of clinical rejection.

MHC matching and mechanisms of alloactivation in corneal transplantation.

Background. In human corneal transplantation the value of matching, particularly for MHC class II, is unclear and controversial. The contribution of the direct pathway to T cell activation is also uncertain. We have determined the relative contribution of class I, II and non-MHC antigens to graft rejection and of the direct and indirect pathways to T cell activation in a rat model mimicking human incompatibilities. Methods. DA (RT1a) strain recipients received fully mismatched PVG (RT1c) strain grafts or grafts from one of three recombinant strains bearing DA MHC genes on a PVG background. Graft survival was assessed and the specificity of T cells generated in the draining lymph nodes was determined in mixed lymphocyte (MLR) proliferation assays. To assess the contribution of the direct pathway, fully mismatched graft were performed and allospecific proliferation was measured after depletion of recipient APC from the MLR reaction. Results. There was no significant difference in survival of grafts between the four grades of mismatch, which ranged from a full mismatch to non-MHC mismatches alone (median survival 12.5, 11, 13 and 12.5 days respectively). In conformity with clinical results, strong secondary responses were generated against targets matched for MHC with the recipient. Depletion of recipient APC from a fully allogeneic secondary MLR did not fully abrogate donor-specific proliferation. Conclusions. Class II matching is of no benefit in this model. Strong indirect responses to non-MHC mismatches are sufficient to induce the rapid rejection, but the small numbers of class II+ cells in the donor appear sufficient to generate a direct response.

Lack of IFN-gamma synthesis in aqueous humor during corneal graft rejection correlates with suppressed nitric oxide production by macrophages.

PURPOSE To investigate cytokine production by leukocytes in aqueous humor (AH) during corneal graft rejection and nitric oxide (NO) production by macrophages as a potential mediator of graft damage. METHODS Rats received corneal allotransplants and were killed during acute rejection. Leukocytes in AH that expressed tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha, interferon (IFN)-gamma, and interleukin (IL)-10 were quantified by flow cytometry. Isograft and further allograft recipients were killed, and sectioned corneas with conjunctivae were examined by histology for production of inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS), NO, and nitrotyrosine (NT). RESULTS Between 80% and 90% of T cells, NK cells, and macrophages in AH expressed TNF-alpha, and at least 20% expressed IL-10. However, IFN-gamma was undetectable unless cells were first stimulated in vitro with PMA and ionomycin, which yielded IFN-gamma in 25% of cells. iNOS(+) macrophages were identified in donor cornea and AH, correlating precisely with rejection. Cells producing low levels of NO (NO(dim) cells) were found in donor stroma, but NT(+) cells were rare. Both NT(+) and NO(+) cells were rare in the anterior chamber (AC) or attached to corneal endothelium. NT(+) macrophages that were also NO(bright) were associated with sutures in allograft and isograft recipients and within conjunctivae, either scattered or in leukocyte aggregates. CONCLUSIONS IFN-gamma synthesis is lacking in the AC during rejection, correlating with lack of NO but not of iNOS expression. NO does not appear to mediate endothelial cell death. NT and high levels of NO production are associated with nonspecific inflammatory cells.

A murine model of interlamellar corneal transplantation

AIMS/BACKGROUND There are more reagents and information available for immunological studies in the mouse compared with other animals. Unfortunately, the mouse penetrating keratoplasty model is associated with high background inflammation which hinders study of the immune response to the graft. To mitigate this drawback, a murine orthotopic corneal interlamellar transplantation model with mild non-specific inflammation was developed. METHODS A 1.5 mm diameter full thickness donor corneal button was placed in a 2 mm diameter recipient corneal interlamellar pocket without placement of a suture. The clinical course of graft status was studied daily for 60 days in 30 allografts (donor strain CBA 101 (H-2k) to recipient NIH (H-2q)) and 30 syngeneic grafts (NIH to NIH) by slit lamp biomicroscopy and scored for neovascularisation, opacity, oedema, and granularity. In another cohort of animals, histological observation was performed after 30 minutes and on days 10, 20, 30, and 40 after transplantation (four allografts and four syngeneic grafts per time point). Histological study was also performed on grafts without donor epithelium and on interlamellar pockets without grafts. RESULTS There was significantly more neovascularisation (NV), opacity, oedema, and granularity in 24/30 allografts (80%) than in syngeneic grafts. Such grafts were defined as rejected. The median time to rejection was 21 days (range 18 to >60 days). By histology, some allografts showed moderate to heavy cell infiltration which correlated with clinical scores of NV (4–5), opacity (1–3), oedema (1–3), and granularity (1–3). Such infiltration was absent in other allografts and syngeneic grafts. CONCLUSION Surgically, corneal interlamellar transplantation could be accomplished in the mouse and rejection could be clearly defined. The model can therefore be useful for in situ study of cell and molecular aspects of corneal graft rejection.

Genome-Wide Analysis in Swine Associates Corneal Graft Rejection with Donor-Recipient Mismatches in Three Novel Histocompatibility Regions and One Locus Homologous to the Mouse H-3 Locus

In rodents, immune responses to minor histocompatibility antigens are the most important drivers of corneal graft rejection. However, this has not been confirmed in humans or in a large animal model and the genetic loci are poorly characterised, even in mice. The gene sequence data now available for a range of relevant species permits the use of genome-wide association (GWA) techniques to identify minor antigens associated with transplant rejection. We have used this technique in a pre-clinical model of corneal transplantation in semi-inbred NIH minipigs and Babraham swine to search for novel minor histocompatibility loci and to determine whether rodent findings have wider applicability. DNA from a cohort of MHC-matched and MHC-mismatched donors and recipients was analysed for single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). The level of SNP homozygosity for each line was assessed. Genome-wide analysis of the association of SNP disparities with rejection was performed using log-likelihood ratios. Four genomic blocks containing four or more SNPs significantly linked to rejection were identified (on chromosomes 1, 4, 6 and 9), none at the location of the MHC. One block of 36 SNPs spanned a region that exhibits conservation of synteny with the mouse H-3 histocompatibility locus and contains the pig homologue of the mouse Zfp106 gene, which encodes peptide epitopes known to mediate corneal graft rejection. The other three regions are novel minor histocompatibility loci. The results suggest that rejection can be predicted from SNP analysis prior to transplant in this model and that a similar GWA analysis is merited in humans.