Susan Short

LOW-DOSE HYPERSENSITIVITY: CURRENT STATUS AND POSSIBLE MECHANISMS

PURPOSE To retain cell viability, mammalian cells can increase damage repair in response to excessive radiation-induced injury. The adaptive response to small radiation doses is an example of this induced resistance and has been studied for many years, particularly in human lymphocytes. This review focuses on another manifestation of actively increased resistance that is of potential interest for developing improved radiotherapy, specifically the phenomenon in which cells die from excessive sensitivity to small single doses of ionizing radiation but remain more resistant (per unit dose) to larger single doses. In this paper, we propose possible mechanisms to explain this phenomenon based on our data accumulated over the last decade and a review of the literature. CONCLUSION Typically, most cell lines exhibit hyper-radiosensitivity (HRS) to very low radiation doses (<10 cGy) that is not predicted by back-extrapolating the cell survival response from higher doses. As the dose is increased above about 30 cGy, there is increased radioresistance (IRR) until at doses beyond about 1 Gy, radioresistance is maximal, and the cell survival follows the usual downward-bending curve with increasing dose. The precise operational and activational mechanism of the process is still unclear, but we propose two hypotheses. The greater amount of injury produced by larger doses either (1) is above a putative damage-sensing threshold for triggering faster or more efficient DNA repair or (2) causes changes in DNA structure or organization that facilitates constitutive repair. In both scenarios, this enhanced repair ability is decreased again on a similar time scale to the rate of removal of DNA damage.

Effects of cell cycle phase on low-dose hyper-radiosensitivity

Purpose : To examine the low-dose radiation response of human glioma cell lines separated into different cell-cycle phases and to determine if low-dose hyper-radiosensitivity (HRS) differs in populations defined by cell-cycle position. To assess whether predictions of the outcome of multiple low-dose regimens should take account of cell-cycle effects. Materials and methods : The clonogenic survival of G1, G2 and S phase cells was measured after exposure to single doses of X-rays in two human glioma cell lines. One cell line (T98G) showed marked HRS when asynchronous cells were irradiated, while the other (U373) did not. Separation of populations and high-resolution cell counting was achieved using a fluorescence activated cell sorter. Sorted cell populations were irradiated with 240 kVp X-rays to doses between 0.05 and 5Gy. The resulting cell-survival versus dose data were comparatively fitted using the linear-quadratic and induced-repair models in order to assess the degree of HRS. Results : In both cell lines the low-dose response was altered when different populations were irradiated. In T98G cells, all populations showed HRS, but this was most marked in G2 phase cells. In U373 cells, no HRS was found in G1 or S phase cells, but HRS was demonstrable in G2 phase cells. Conclusions : HRS was expressed by the whole cell population of T98G cells but the size of the effect varied with cell-cycle phase and was most marked in the G2 population. In U373 cells, the effect could only be demonstrated in G2 cells. This implies that HRS is primarily a response of G2 phase cells and that this response dominates that seen in asynchronous populations. Actively proliferating cell populations may therefore demonstrate a greater increase in radiosensitivity to very low radiation doses compared with quiescent populations.

Low dose hypersensitivity in the T98G human glioblastoma cell line

PURPOSE To examine the low dose-response of a human radioresistant glioblastoma cell line (T98G) using two different methods to measure surviving fraction and to define the influence of cell cycle phase on this response. MATERIALS AND METHODS The survival of cells following exposure to single very low doses of X-rays in vitro was measured using either the Dynamic Microscopic Image Processing Scanner (DMIPS) or a Cell Sorter (CS). The DMIPS was also used to measure the low dose survival response of T98G cells following manipulation of their progression through the cell cycle. RESULTS With both methods, T98G demonstrated marked low dose hyper-radiosensitivity (HRS) and the two methods produced very similar data in the low dose region of the survival curve. However, the CS protocol produced less variable results and was the more efficient method of generating low dose data. HRS was also demonstrated when these cells were irradiated while held in reversible arrest in the G1 phase of the cell cycle, but the effect was less marked than in the asynchronous population. CONCLUSIONS T98G glioblastoma cells demonstrate marked HRS, which is a characteristic of the whole population rather than being due to the influence of a small subpopulation of hyper-radiosensitive cells within a particular phase of the cell cycle.

The response of human glioma cell lines to low-dose radiation exposure.

PURPOSE To examine the low-dose radiation response of a series of radioresistant human glioma cell lines and determine if low-dose hypersensitivity is a characteristic of these cells. MATERIALS AND METHODS The clonogenic survival of six radioresistant human glioma cell lines was measured following exposure to graded, single, very low doses of X-rays in vitro. High resolution was achieved using either a Dynamic Microscopic Image Processing Scanner (DMIPS) or a cell sorter (CS). RESULTS In five of the six cell lines tested, low-dose hypersensitivity (HRS) was demonstrated although in the sixth, a grade III astrocytoma line, it was not. These results are consistent with previous data indicating that low-dose hypersensitivity is more marked in more radioresistant cell lines although the difference between the glioblastoma cell lines with differing SF2 is not marked. CONCLUSION Low-dose hypersensitivity is common in radioresistant glioma cell lines. This may have implications for the treatment of these tumours if further studies confirm that HRS translates to increased effectiveness per gray in vivo when very low doses per fraction are used.

Low-Dose Reduction in Transformation Frequency Compared to Unirradiated Controls: The Role of Hyper-radiosensitivity to Cell Death

Abstract Redpath, J. L., Short, S. C., Woodcock, M. and Johnston, P. J. Low-Dose Reduction in Transformation Frequency Compared to Unirradiated Controls: The Role of Hyper-radiosensitivity to Cell Death. Radiat. Res. 159, 433–436 (2003). Calculations based on plausible parameters taken from the existing experimental database, and new measurements on the cell cycle dependence of low-dose hyper-radiosensitivity (HRS) of non-tumorigenic HeLa × skin fibroblast human hybrid cells, provide the first experimental evidence that the selective killing of a transformation-sensitive G2/M-phase subpopulation as a consequence of low-dose HRS could account in part for the observed reduction of induced transformation frequencies at low doses to values below that observed spontaneously. However, it is clear that other mechanisms associated with classical adaptive response, such as induced DNA repair, are also likely to be involved.

Rad51 inhibition is an effective means of targeting DNA repair in glioma models and CD133+ tumor-derived cells

High grade gliomas (HGGs) are characterized by resistance to radiotherapy and chemotherapy. Targeting Rad51-dependent homologous recombination repair may be an effective target for chemo- and radiosensitization. In this study we assessed the role of Rad51-dependent repair on sensitivity to radiation and temozolomide (TMZ) as single agents or in combination. Repair protein levels in established glioma cell lines, early passage glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) cell lines, and normal human astrocytes (NHAs) were measured using western blot. Viability and clonogenic survival assays were used to measure the effects of Rad51 knockdown with radiation (XR) and TMZ. Immunocytochemistry was used to evaluate kinetics of Rad51 and γ-H2AX repair foci. Immunohistochemistry was used to assess Rad51 protein levels in glioma specimens. Repair proteins including Rad51 are upregulated in HGG cells compared with NHA. Established glioma cell lines show a dose-dependent increase in Rad51 foci formation after XR and TMZ. Rad51 levels are inversely correlated with radiosensitivity, and downregulation markedly increases the cytotoxicity of TMZ. Rad51 knockdown also promotes more residual γ-H2AX foci 24 h after combined treatment. Newly established GBM cell lines also have high Rad51 levels and are extremely sensitive to Rad51 knockdown. Clinical samples from recently resected gliomas of varying grades demonstrate that Rad51 levels do not correlate with tumor grade. Rad51-dependent repair makes a significant contribution to DNA repair in glioma cells and contributes to resistance to both XR and TMZ. Agents targeting Rad51-dependent repair would be effective adjuvants in standard combination regimens.

DNA Damage Responses at Low Radiation Doses

Abstract Short, S. C., Bourne, S., Martindale, C., Woodcock, M. and Jackson, S. P. DNA Damage Responses at Low Radiation Doses. Radiat. Res. 164, 292–302 (2005). Increased cell killing after exposure to low acute doses of X rays (0–0.5 Gy) has been demonstrated in cells of a number of human tumor cell lines. The mechanisms underlying this effect have been assumed to be related to a threshold dose above which DNA repair efficiency or fidelity increases. We have used cells of two radioresistant human tumor cell lines, one that shows increased sensitivity to low radiation doses (T98G) and one that does not (U373), to investigate the DNA damage response at low doses in detail and to establish whether there is a discontinuous dose response or threshold in activation of any important mediators of this response. In the two cell lines studied, we found a sensitive, linear dose response in early signaling and transduction pathways between doses of 0.1 and 2 Gy with no evidence of a threshold dose. We demonstrate that ATM-dependent signaling events to downstream targets including TP53, CHK1 and CHK2 occur after doses as low as 0.2 Gy and that these events promote an effective damage response. Using chemical inhibition of specific DNA repair enzymes, we show that inhibition of DNA-PK-dependent end joining has relatively little effect at low (<1 Gy) doses in hyper-radiosensitive cells and that at these doses the influence of RAD51-mediated repair events may increase, based on high levels of RAD51/BRCA2 repair foci. These data do not support a threshold model for activation of DNA repair in hyper-radiosensitive cells but do suggest that the balance of repair enzyme activity may change at low doses.

Cytotoxic effects of temozolomide and radiation are additive- and schedule-dependent

PURPOSE Despite aggressive therapy comprising radical radiation and temozolomide (TMZ) chemotherapy, the prognosis for patients with glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) remains poor, particularly if tumors express O(6)-methylguanine-DNA-methyltransferase (MGMT). The interactions between radiation and TMZ remain unclear and have important implications for scheduling and for developing strategies to improve outcomes. METHODS AND MATERIALS Factors determining the effects of combination therapy on clonogenic survival, cell-cycle checkpoint signaling and DNA repair were investigated in four human glioma cell lines (T98G, U373-MG, UVW, U87-MG). RESULTS Combining TMZ and radiation yielded additive cytotoxicity, but only when TMZ was delivered 72 h before radiation. Radiosensitization was not observed. TMZ induced G2/M cell-cycle arrest at 48-72 h, coincident with phosphorylation of Chk1 and Chk2. Additive G2/M arrest and Chk1/Chk2 phosphorylation was only observed when TMZ preceded radiation by 72 h. The ataxia-telangiectasia mutated (ATM) inhibitor KU-55933 increased radiation sensitivity and delayed repair of radiation-induced DNA breaks, but did not influence TMZ effects. The multiple kinase inhibitor caffeine enhanced the cytotoxicity of chemoradiation and exacerbated DNA damage. CONCLUSIONS TMZ is not a radiosensitizing agent but yields additive cytotoxicity in combination with radiation. Our data indicate that TMZ treatment should commence at least 3 days before radiation to achieve maximum benefit. Activation of G2/M checkpoint signaling by TMZ and radiation has a cytoprotective effect that can be overcome by dual inhibition of ATM and ATR. More specific inhibition of checkpoint signaling will be required to increase treatment efficacy without exacerbating toxicity.

Late Toxicity Is Not Increased in BRCA1/BRCA2 Mutation Carriers Undergoing Breast Radiotherapy in the United Kingdom

Purpose: To undertake the first substantial clinical study of breast radiotherapy toxicity in BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutation carriers in the United Kingdom. Experimental Design: Acute and late radiation effects were evaluated in a retrospective study of 55 BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutation carriers treated with radiotherapy for breast cancer at four centers between 1983 and 2002. Individual matching with controls who had sporadic breast cancer was undertaken for age at diagnosis, time since completion of radiation, and treatment variables. Detailed assessments were undertaken by one examiner. Median follow-up was 6.75 years for carriers and 7.75 years for controls. Rates of late events (rib fractures, lung fibrosis, necrosis of soft tissue/bone, and pericarditis) as well as LENT-SOMA scores and clinical photography scores of breast size, shape, and skin telangiectasia were the primary end points. Results: No increase in clinically significant late toxicity was seen in the mutation carriers. Conclusions: These data add substantial weight to the evidence that the outcomes in the treated breast from radiotherapy in women with BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutations are comparable with those in women with sporadic breast cancer.

DNA repair after irradiation in glioma cells and normal human astrocytes

We examined DNA damage responses and repair in four human glioma cell lines (A7, U87, T98G, and U373) and normal human astrocytes (NHAs) after clinically relevant radiation doses to establish whether we could identify differences among them that might suggest new approaches to selective radiosensitization. We used phosphorylation of histone H2AX visualized by immunocytochemistry to assess DNA double-strand break (DSB) formation and resolution. Fluorescence immunocytochemistry was used to visualize and quantify repair foci. Western blotting was used to quantify repair protein levels in the different cell lines before and after irradiation and during different cell cycle phases. Mitotic labeling was used to measure cell cycle parameters after irradiation. We found that the glioma cell lines repaired DSBs more slowly and less effectively than did NHAs in the clinically relevant dose range, as assessed by induction and resolution of H2AX phosphorylation, and this was most marked in the three TP53-mutated cell lines (T98G, A7, and U373). The glioma cells also expressed relatively high repair-protein levels compared with NHAs that were not altered by irradiation. High levels of the repair protein Rad51 in these cells persisted throughout the cell cycle, and a marked increase in Rad51 foci formation, which was not restricted to cells in G2/S phase, occurred at early time points after irradiation. TP53-mutated glioma cell lines demonstrated a very prominent dose-responsive G2 checkpoint and were sensitized to radiation by caffeine, which inhibits G2/S phase checkpoint activation. In conclusion, DNA repair events differed in these four glioma cell lines compared with NHAs. In particular, the three TP53-mutated glioma cell lines exhibited markedly increased Rad51 protein levels and marked, dose-dependent Rad51 foci formation after low radiation doses. This suggests that agents that disrupt Rad51-dependent repair or prevent G2 checkpoint activation may selectively sensitize these cells.