Suzette Béguin

Calibrated automated thrombin generation measurement in clotting plasma

Calibrated automated thrombography displays the concentration of thrombin in clotting plasma with or without platelets (platelet-rich plasma/platelet-poor plasma, PRP/PPP) in up to 48 samples by monitoring the splitting of a fluorogenic substrate and comparing it to a constant known thrombin activity in a parallel, non-clotting sample. Thus, the non-linearity of the reaction rate with thrombin concentration is compensated for, and adding an excess of substrate can be avoided. Standard conditions were established at which acceptable experimental variation accompanies sensitivity to pathological changes. The coefficients of variation of the surface under the curve (endogenous thrombin potential) are: within experiment ∼3%; intra-individual: <5% in PPP, <8% in PRP; interindividual 15% in PPP and 19% in PRP. In PPP, calibrated automated thrombography shows all clotting factor deficiencies (except factor XIII) and the effect of all anticoagulants [AVK, heparin(-likes), direct inhibitors]. In PRP, it is diminished in von Willebrand’s disease, but it also shows the effect of platelet inhibitors (e.g. aspirin and abciximab). Addition of activated protein C (APC) or thrombomodulin inhibits thrombin generation and reflects disorders of the APC system (congenital and acquired resistance, deficiencies and lupus antibodies) independent of concomitant inhibition of the procoagulant pathway as for example by anticoagulants.

Thrombin generation, a function test of the haemostaticthrombotic system

By the use of a fluorogenic thrombin substrate and continuous calibration of each individual sample, it is now possible to obtain a thrombin generation (TG) curve (or thrombogram) in plasma, with or without platelets, in an easy routine procedure at high throughput and with an acceptable experimental error (<5%). Evidence is growing that the parameters of the thrombogram, and notably the area under the curve (endogenous thrombin potential, ETP), are useful in assessing bleeding- or thrombotic risk and its modification by antithrombotic- or haemostatic treatment. Available data strongly suggest that conditions (congenital, acquired, drug-induced) that increase TG all cause a thrombotic tendency and that conditions that decrease TG prevent thrombosis but, beyond a limit, cause bleeding. Diminution of TG is a common denominator of all antithrombotic treatment, including anti-platelet drugs. The thrombogram can also be used as a tool in the search for new antithrombotics and reflects the haemorrhagic or thrombotic side effects of other drugs (e.g. oral contraceptives). The thrombogram thus is a promising new approach to clinical management of bleeding and thrombotic disease as well as a tool in drug research and epidemiology. Our experience at this moment is insufficient, however, to already clearly define its limits.

Evaluation of thrombin generating capacity in plasma from patients with haemophilia A and B

In haemophilia patients, a relationship is usually observed between the clinical expression of the disease and plasmatic factor VIII/factor IX (FVIII/FIX) activity. However, it is known from clinical experience, that some haemophilia patients, despite similar FVIII/FIX plasma levels, could exhibit different bleeding phenotype. After determining preanalytical test conditions, we evaluated the thrombin generation capacity from haemophilia plasma samples in various conditions and the potential usefulness of thrombin generation test (TGT) in haemophilia patients. In a series of 46 haemophilia patients (34 haemophilia A and 12 haemophilia B patients), we found a significant correlation between plasmatic FVIII/FIX levels and endogenous thrombin potential (ETP), peak and time to peak obtained by thrombin generation measurement. In addition, a correlation was found between severe clinical bleeding phenotype and ETP. Our results suggest that TGT could be a promising tool to evaluate haemostasis capacity in patients with haemophilia. Our ex vivo results, obtained 24 hours after FVIII concentrate administration, showed that in patients presenting similar plasmatic FVIIII levels, thrombin generation capacity may be significantly different. These results suggest that in patients with haemophilia, TGT could be useful for individually tailoring prophylactic regimens as well as for adapting clotting factors infusions in surgical situations, in addition to FVIII/FIX plasma clotting activities.

Clinical Studies and Thrombin Generation in Patients Homozygous or Heterozygous for the G20210A Mutation in the Prothrombin Gene

A genetic variation in the prothrombin gene, the G-->A transition at nucleotide 20210, is a risk factor for venous thrombosis in heterozygotes and is associated with increased prothrombin activity. The homozygous phenotype and the extent of thrombin generation in heterozygous and homozygous subjects are unknown. We investigated a family that included 2 homozygous and 5 heterozygous carriers of the 20210 A allele. The homozygous propositus and his presumably heterozygous father suffered from deep-vein thrombosis. His presumably heterozygous mother and his homozygous sister had recurrent phlebitis at a young age. The remaining 5 affected family members are still asymptomatic. We studied thrombin generation in the family and in 22 unrelated carriers of the 20210 A allele by measuring (1) prothrombin fragment F1+2 (F1+2) as an index of ongoing thrombin generation and (2) the endogenous thrombin potential (ETP) as an index of the possible thrombin-forming capacity. Their F1+2 levels were not different from those of age-matched controls, and thus, ongoing hemostatic system activation was not detectable. A significantly increased ETP was found in the heterozygous carriers of the 20210A allele compared with the controls (527.8+/-114.9 versus 387+/-50.1 nmol/L x min, P<0.0001). In the 2 homozygotes, the ETP was almost twice (639 and 751 nmol/L x min, respectively) as high as in the controls. We conclude that homozygosity for the G20210A mutation in the prothrombin gene is associated with a severe, albeit more benign, thrombotic diathesis compared with homozygosity for deficiencies of antithrombin, protein C, or protein S. In carriers of the 20210 A allele, the pathomechanisms leading to thrombosis should be sought in the higher amounts of thrombin that may be formed once thrombin generation is triggered, rather than in ongoing thrombin generation in vivo.

Thrombin generation assays: accruing clinical relevance

Purpose of reviewAfter decades of near oblivion, thrombin generation is being revived as an overall function test of the plasmatic coagulation system in platelet-poor plasma (PPP). In platelet-rich plasma (PRP) it assesses platelet procoagulant functions as well. Recent findingsThe recently developed use of special fluorogenic thrombin substrates allows monitoring of thrombin concentration in clotting PPP and PRP on line in up to 24 parallel samples. Studies in model systems stress the importance of cell-bound thrombin generation such as measured in PRP. SummaryThe method can be profitably applied to various hitherto unyielding problems such as the control of (low-molecular-weight) heparin therapy, the detection of lupus anticoagulant, and various forms of thrombomodulin and activated protein C resistance (including the use of oral contraceptives) as well as monitoring the treatment of hemophiliacs by factor VIII bypassing therapy. In PRP it reflects the abnormalities encountered in von Willebrand disease and Glanzmann and Bernard-Soulier thrombopathy as well as the action of antiplatelet drugs.

Factor XI–Dependent Reciprocal Thrombin Generation Consolidates Blood Coagulation when Tissue Factor Is Not Available

Objective—Feedback activation of factor XI by thrombin is a likely alternative for tissue factor-dependent propagation of thrombus formation. However, the hypothesis that thrombin can initiate and propagate its formation in a factor XI-dependent and platelet-dependent manner has not been tested in a plasma milieu. Methods and Results—We investigated thrombin generation in recalcified platelet-rich plasma activated with varying amounts of thrombin or factor VIIa. Thrombin initiates and propagates dose-dependently thrombin generation only when platelets and plasma factor XI are present. Incubation of thrombin-activated platelets with a tissue factor neutralizing antibody had no effect on thrombin formation, indicating that platelet-associated tissue factor, if present at all, is not involved. In the absence of factor VIII, thrombin could not initiate its own formation, whereas factor VIIa-induced thrombin generation was reduced. Collagen strongly stimulated both thrombin-initiated and factor VIIa-initiated thrombin generation. Conclusions—These findings support the notion that platelet-localized feedback activation of factor XI by thrombin plays an important role in maintaining normal hemostasis as well as in sustaining thrombus formation when the TF pathway is inhibited by tissue factor pathway inhibitor.

Fixed dosage of low-molecular-weight heparins causes large individual variation in coagulability, only partly correlated to body weight.

Summary.  Backgrounds: Low‐molecular‐weight heparins (LMWHs) are routinely given without the control of their effect on coagulation. The endogenous thrombin potential (ETP) is a sensitive detector of the heparin effect. Question: What is the interindividual variation in TG after a fixed dose of LMWH in normal volunteers, is it explained by variation in weight? Methods: Subcutaneous (s.c.) injection, in 12 healthy volunteers, of 9000 aXa‐units of unfractionated heparin (UFH) and of three heparins with narrow MW distribution around 10.5, 6.0 and 4.5 kD. Measurement of anti‐thrombin (aIIa) and antifactor Xa (aXa)‐activities and ETP at 11 time points over 24 h. Results: The coefficient of variation (CV) of the AUCs of aXa‐ and aIIa‐activities is 50% for UFH and 22–37% for LMWHs. Because of the hyperbolic form of the dose–response curve, the CV of the inhibition of the ETP is lower: 32% for UFH and 13–21% for the LMWHs. Fixed dosage of LMWH caused under‐dosage in 10–13% of the samples and over‐dosage in 5–11%. High or low response is an individual property independent of the type of heparin injected and only partially explained by variation in body weight. Conclusion: Optimized individual dosage of LMWH is possible through recognition of high and low responders, which requires one measurement of the heparin concentration or, preferably, the heparin effect on the ETP, 2–5 h after a first injection.

Calibrated Automated Thrombin Generation in Frozen-Thawed Platelet-Rich Plasma to Detect Hypercoagulability

To enhance the practical applicability of the calibrated automated thrombogram (CAT) we investigated whether frozen-thawed platelet-rich plasma (ft-PRP) can be used to assess the function of the protein C inhibitory pathway, while preserving the natural phospholipid composition. Recalcified ft-PRP triggered with 0.5 pM recombinant human tissue factor shows a median thrombin potential of 1,779 nM·min, against 1,576 nM·min for fresh PRP. To obtain ∼70% inhibition, 6.7 nM activated protein C (APC) has to be added, instead of 25 nM in fresh PRP; so the relative APC resistance of PRP appears to depend upon the presence of intact platelets. Factor VIII, added to normal ft-PRP to obtain a concentration of 3.3 U/ml, increases the thrombin potential in the presence of APC 1.5-fold, from 524 to 808 nM·min, in keeping with previously published increases in thrombotic risk in patients with high factor VIII levels. We conclude that thrombography in ft-PRP, with and without added APC, can be used to assess known risk factors for thrombosis, which allows the design of large clinical studies aimed at proving the relationship between thrombin potential and clinical outcome.

Fibrin polymerization is crucial for thrombin generation in platelet-rich plasma in a VWF-GPIb-dependent process, defective in Bernard-Soulier syndrome.

Summary.  Defective prothrombin consumption has been reported in the proband case of Bernard–Soulier syndrome (BSS). There is no consensus, however, on whether the formation of platelet procoagulant activity (PPA) is impaired in BSS and, if so, whether this is due to the lack of GPIb‐V‐IX‐dependent binding of thrombin or of von Willebrand factor (VWF). We show thrombin generation (TG) in platelet‐rich plasma of BSS (BSS‐PRP) to be defective provided that fibrin remains present in the reaction mixture and that the giant platelets are not damaged by frequent subsampling. In BSS‐PRP addition of (thrombin‐free) fibrin did not increase TG as in normal PRP, supporting our previous hypothesis that the interaction of fibrin, VWF and GPIb triggers PPA development. Fibrin formed during the lag phase of TG by a snake venom enzyme which only removed fibrinopeptide A induced an immediate burst of TG, that was inhibited by a monoclonal antibody against GPIb (6D1) that abolishes ristocetin‐induced binding of VWF to platelets. Inversely, inhibition of polymerization decreased TG and the residual activity was insensitive to 6D1. We conclude that polymerizing fibrin interacts with VWF so as to activate GPIb.

The inhibition of blood coagulation by heparins of different molecular weight is caused by a common functional motif—the C‐domain

Summary.  Background: Heparins in clinical use differ considerably as to mode of preparation, molecular weight distribution and pharmacodynamic properties. Objectives: Find a common basis for their anticoagulant action. Methods: In 50 fractions of virtually single molecular weight (Mr), prepared from unfractionated heparin (UFH) and four low‐molecular‐weight heparins (LMWH), we determined: (i) the molar concentration of material (HAM) containing the antithrombin binding pentasaccharide (A‐domain); (ii) the specific catalytic activity in thrombin and factor Xa inactivation; (iii) the capacity to inhibit thrombin generation (TG) and prolong the activated partial thromboplastin time (APTT). We also calculated the molar concentration of A‐domain with 12 sugar units at its non‐reducing end, i.e. the structure that carries antithrombin activity (C‐domain). Results: The antithrombin activity and the effects on TG and APTT are primarily determined by the concentration of C‐domain and independent of the source material (UFH or LMWH) or Mr. High Mr fractions (>15 000) are less active, probably through interaction with non‐antithrombin plasma proteins. Anti‐factor Xa activity is proportional to the concentration of A‐domain, it is Ca2+‐ and Mr‐dependent and does not determine the effect on TG and APTT. Conclusion: For any type of heparin, the capacity to inhibit the coagulation process in plasma is primarily determined by the concentration of C‐domain, i.e. the AT‐binding pentasaccharide with 12 or more sugar units at its non‐reducing end.