Sylvain Proulx

Design and Experimental Assessment of an Elastically Averaged Binary Manipulator Using Pneumatic Air Muscles for Magnetic Resonance Imaging Guided Prostate Interventions

Early diagnostic and treatment of prostate cancer could be achieved using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to improve tumor perceptibility. Nonetheless, performing intra-MRI interventions present significant challenges due to intense magnetic fields and limited patient access. This paper presents an MRI-compatible manipulator using elastically averaged binary pneumatic air muscles (PAMs) to orient a needle into a targeted region of the prostate under the command of a physician. The proposed manipulator is based on an all-polymer compliant mechanism designed to make a completely MRI-compatible positioning system. A model based on the PAMs deformation energy is used to design the manipulator so that its discrete workspace, stiffness, and size meet clinically relevant design requirements. The model is also used to study the motion of the device during a state shift. A laboratory prototype of the device shows that the covered workspace, stiffness, and size of the manipulator can meet clinical requirements. Repeatability and accuracy are also acceptable with values of 0.5 mm and 1.7 mm, respectively. Finally, the manipulator’s behavior during state shift describes a hook-shaped motion that is both analytically predicted and experimentally observed.

Design of a MRI-compatible dielectric elastomer powered jet valve

Binary Pneumatic Air Muscles (PAM) arranged in an elastically-averaged configuration can form a cost effective solution for Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) guided robotic interventions like prostate cancer biopsies and brachytherapies. Such binary pneumatic manipulators require about 10 to 20 MRI-compatible valves to control the pressure state of each PAM. In this perspective, this paper presents the design of a novel dielectric elastomer actuator (DEA) driven jet-valve to control the states of the PAMs. DEAs are MRI compatible actuators that are well suited to the simplicity and cost-effectiveness of the binary manipulation approach. The key feature of the proposed valve design is its 2 stages configuration in which the pilot stage is moved with minimal mechanical friction by a rotary antagonistic DEA made with acrylic polymer films. The prismatic geometry also integrates the jet nozzle within the DEA volume to provide a compact embodiment with a reduced number of parts. The low actuation stretches enabled by the rotary configuration minimize viscoelastic losses, and thus, maximize the frequency response of the actuator while maximizing its reliability potential. The design space of the proposed jet valve is studied using an Ogden hyperelastic model and the valve dynamics is predicted with a 1D Bergstrom-Boyce viscoelastic model. Altogether, the low friction of the pilot stage and optimized DEA dynamics provide an experimental shifting time of the complete assembly in the 200-300ms range. Results from this work suggest that the DEA driven jet valve has great potential for switching a large number of pneumatic circuits in a MRI environment with a compact, low cost and simple embodiment.

Thermodynamic model using experimental loss factors for dielectric elastomer actuator design

Dielectric Elastomer Actuators (DEAs) are a promising actuation technology for mobile robotics due to their high forceto- weight ratio, their potential for high efficiencies, and their low cost. The preliminary design of such actuators requires a quick and precise assessment of actuator energy conversion performance. To do so, this paper proposes a simple thermodynamic model using experimentally acquired loss factors that predict actuator mechanical work, energy consumption, and efficiency when operating under constant voltage and constant charge modes. Mechanical and electrical loss factors for both VHB 4905 (acrylic) and Nusils CF19-2186 (silicone) are obtained by mapping the performances of cone-shaped DEAs over a broad range of actuator speeds, capacitance ratios, and applied voltages. Extensive experimental results reveal the main performance trends to follow for preliminary actuator design, which are explained by the proposed model. For the tested conditions, the maximum experimental brake efficiencies are ~35% and ~25% for VHB and CF19-2186 respectively.

Experimental Validation of an Elastically Averaged Binary Manipulator for MRI-Guided Prostate Cancer Interventions

Polymer-based binary robots and mechatronics devices can lead to simple, robust, and cost effective solutions for Magnetic Resonnace Image-guided (MRI) medical procedures. A binary manipulator using 12 elastically averaged air muscles has been proposed for MRI-guided biopsies and brachytherapies procedures used for prostate cancer diagnostic and treatment. In this design, radially-distributed air muscles position a needle guide relatively to the MRI table. The system constitutes an active compliant mechanism where the compliance relieves the over-constraint imposed by the redundant parallel architecture. This paper presents experimental results for repeatability, accuracy, and stiffness of a fully functional manipulator prototype. Results show an experimental repeatability of 0.1 mm for point-to-point manipulation on a workspace diameter of 80 mm. Manipulator average accuracy is 4.7 mm when based on the nominal (uncalibrated) model and improves to 2.1 mm when using a calibrated model. The estimated stiffness at the end-effector is ∼0.95 N/mm and is sufficient to withstand the needle insertion forces without major deflection. Needle trajectories during state change appear to be primarily driven by the system’s elastic energy gradient. The study shows the manipulator prototype to meet its design criteria and to have the potential of becoming an effective and low-cost manipulator for MRI-guided prostate cancer treatment.Copyright

Design of an Antagonistic Bistable Dielectric Elastomer Actuator Using the Bergstrom-Boyce Constitutive Viscoelastic Model

Dielectric Elastomer Actuators (DEA) has great potential for low cost, high performance robotic and mechatronic devices. However, the reliability of these actuators remains an important issue when used in continuous strain applications. To improve actuators reliability, DEAs can be used in a binary or bistable manner where actuators flip between two stable positions, thus maintaining one of two equilibrium states without any electrical energy input. This paper presents an antagonistic bistable DEA concept using a single, planar polymer film that can lead to compact high force multilayered actuators. The system is made bistable by the addition of carbon fiber leaf springs designed to maximize actuator strain output. The strong viscoelastic nature of the chosen polymer film significantly affects the system’s output force and is accounted for in the Bergstrom-Boyce material model. The model shows good agreement with experimental stress relaxation curves and is used to set the leaf springs’ force curve. Experimental results have shown that the acrylic polymer film’s (VHB 4905) strong viscoelastic nature limits the actuator speed at ∼ 0.9 mm/s; at higher speeds, the leaf springs cannot be matched with the proposed concept. The study also demonstrates that the proposed antagonistic actuator configuration is an interesting solution to provide reliable bistable actuation for compact structures and that developing polymer films with low viscoelasticity is key for optimal performance.Copyright

Design of a Binary Needle Manipulator Using Elastically Averaged Air Muscles for Prostate Cancer Treatments

Affecting 1 out of 8 subjects in the U.S., prostate cancer is the most common form of cancer in men. Current medical procedures could be improved by the development of an MRI compatible (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) needle manipulator system, to precisely reach small tumors (<5 mm) inside the prostate. This paper presents and analyzes the potential of such a needle manipulator concept, based on hyper-redundant binary air muscles, all controlled by MRI compatible valves (e.g. piezoelectric or dielectric elastomer actuators). The proposed manipulator uses 12 polymer air muscles, each driven by 2 different actuation pressures, offering a total of 4096 (212 ) discrete needle positions. Based on a hyperelastic continuum mechanics air muscle model, a theoretical manipulator design is used to evaluate clinically-relevant design metrics, such as size, stiffness, workspace, accuracy and sensitivity. In this model, the manipulator’s equilibrium configuration (for a given set of input pressures and applied forces) is found by minimizing the system’s potential energy. The model capability is verified experimentally by a one degree of freedom (DOF) prototype. Simulation results show that the proposed elastically averaged air muscle concept can meet all design requirements. In particular, the needle workspace of about 70 mm by 80 mm entirely covers the prostate area, where targets are accurately reachable within 0.7 mm. Also, the pneumatic actuators can generate high forces leading to a system stiffness of ∼4.6 N/mm at the needle tip. Such stiffness can adequately sustain the needle during insertion with minimal deflection to guaranty accurate positioning.Copyright