T. Horsburgh

The relative influence of delayed graft function and acute rejection on renal transplant survival

Three hundred and eight cadaveric renal transplants were analysed to establish the effects of acute rejection in the first 90 days and delayed graft function (DGF) on graft outcome. There were 120 patients (39%) with no DGF and no rejection (group 1), 101 patients (33%) with rejection but no DGF (group 2), 41 patients (13%) with DGF but no rejection (group 3) and 46 patients (15%) with both rejection and DGF (group 4). The actuarial 4-year graft survival rates for groups 1,2,3 and 40.4%, respectively. The acute rejection rate was 101/221 (46%) in patients with initial graft function compared with 46/87 (53%) for those with DGF (χ2=1.02, P=0.31). Cox stepwise logistic regression analysis demonstrated that DGF was a more powerful predictive factor for poor graft survival (P=0.001) than acute rejection occurring in the first 90 days post-transplant (P=0.034). Further efforts at improving graft outcome should concentrate on reducing the incidence of DGF.

The beneficial effects of oral nifedipine on cyclosporin-treated renal transplant recipients- a randomised prospective study

The aim of this study was to test the hypothesis that nifedipine will improve graft survival in cyclosporin A (CyA)-treated renal transplant recipients. One hundred and forty-seven patients were randomised to one of three regimens. Group A received CyA, 7 mg/kg per day, and prednisolone; group B followed the same regimen as group A plus oral nifedipine and group C received CyA, 4 mg/kg per day, prednisolone and azathioprine. Calcium channel blockers were avoided in groups A and C. The crude 2-year (P=0.0223) and 4-year (P=0.0181) graft survival was significantly better in group B (86% and 81%, respectively) than in group A (75% and 63%, respectively). Delayed initial function was seen least frequently in group B (10.2%) compared to groups A (31%) and C (28%; P<0.01). Group B also experienced fewer rejection episodes than groups A and C (P<0.05). We conclude that the combination of oral nifedipine and CyA significantly improves initial graft function, rejection frequency and long term graft survival.

The application of flow cytometry to histocompatibility testing.

Flow cytometry is a powerful technique that enables the sensitive and quantitative detection of both cellular antigens and bound biological moieties. This article reviews how flow cytometry is increasingly being used as histocompatibility laboratories for the analysis of antibody specificity and HLA antigen expression. A basic description of flow cytometry principles and standardisation is given, together with an outline of clinical application in the areas of pre-transplant cross-matching, antibody screening, post-transplant antibody monitoring and HLA-B27 detection. It is concluded that flow cytometry is a useful multi-parametric analytical tool, yielding clinical benefit especially in the identification of patients at risk of early transplant rejection.

Nifedipine improves immediate, and 6- and 12-month graft function in cyclosporin A (CyA) treated renal allograft recipients.

To investigate the effect of oral nifedipine, a calcium channel blocker known not to modify cyclosporin A (CyA) pharmacokinetics, on immediate transplant function and CyA nephrotoxicity, 68 adult renal transplant recipients were pre-operatively randomized to one of three regimes: A (high-dose CyA, initial dose 17 mg/kg per day, maintenance dose 7 mg/kg per day); B (regime A plus oral nifedipine); C low-dose CyA, initial dose 10 mg/kg per day, maintenance 4 mg/kg per day plus azathioprine 1 mg/kg per day). All three groups received identical steroid regimes. Calcium channel blockers of all types were avoided in groups A and C. Delayed graft function (dialysis dependence by day 4) was seen least frequently in group B (P < 0.02). Group B had improved graft function at 6 months compared with group A, identified by differences in serum creatinine (P < 0.05), GFR (P < 0.01) and ERPF (P < 0.05). Similar differences in serum creatinine (P < 0.05) and GFR (P < 0.05) were also identified at 12 months. Group C also had better 6- and 12-month GFR values than group A (P < 0.05 each). The three groups did not differ in donor or recipient age, HLA matching, ischaemic or anastomosis times, frequency of early rejection or whole-blood CyA levels. These results indicate that nifedipine significantly improves immediate and medium-term graft function.

The importance of E-selectin as a marker for renal transplant rejection

Vascular endothelial cells express membrane bound adhesion molecules which play a direct role in the localization and subsequent movement of leucocytes from the blood into sites of inflammation. E-Selectin is a cytokine induced adhesion molecule, known to be expressed by endothelial cells in inflammatory conditions, which binds to various leucocyte subpopulations. In a prospective study we have investigated the expression and distribution of E-selectin on renal allograft needle biopsies taken from 16 pretransplant kidneys and 119 post-transplant kidneys. Post-transplant biopsies were taken at times of graft dysfunction and at times of normal graft function. Formal histology was also performed and assessed independently. E-Selectin was found predominantly on the intertubular endothelium and on the endothelium of larger vessels. E-Selectin was present, at low intensity, in some pretransplant biopsies and also some post-transplant biopsies which were reported histologically as normal. In post-transplant biopsies taken for dysfunction E-selectin was present in the majority of cases. Expression was strong in biopsies showing acute cellular rejection and this was associated with a CD4 positive cellular infiltrate. Biopsies showing other causes of dysfunction, in particular acute tubular necrosis, also were E-selectin and CD4 positive with lower intensity than those with acute cellular rejection. These results suggest that E-selectin is a good marker for endothelial activation in renal transplant biopsies. Its presence in histologically apparently normal biopsies suggests that its in vivo kinetics may differ from previously reported in vitro kinetics. E-Selectin may be a potential target for therapeutic intervention.

Lack of correlation and soluble E-selectin level with renal transplant rejection

E-Selectin is a 115-kDa cell surface glycoprotein transiently expressed on vascular endothelium in response to interleukin-1 and tumour necrosis factor-alpha with a peak in expression at four hours. Its distribution in transplant biopsies has been associated with inflammatory events such as allograft rejection. Recently, a soluble isoform of E-selectin has been detected in the culture medium of cytokine activated endothelial cells by an ELISA method. In this study soluble E-selectin levels in renal allograft recipients were compared with the incidence of rejection, acute tubular necrosis (ATN), cyclosporin A (CyA) toxicity, and use of orthoclone OKT3 (muromonab-CD3) to establish whether early endothelial activation and inflammatory damage could be detected. The mean soluble E-selectin level in normal volunteers was 89 ng/ml serum compared to 120 ng/ml for a group of chronic renal failure patients. Soluble E-selectin levels declined upon transplantation but this was not significant, nor was the difference in samples from patients experiencing rejection, ATN or CyA toxicity. A dramatic and sustained rise in soluble E-selectin levels was found within 24 hours of the first dose of OKT3 treatment. This study shows that soluble E-selectin does not provide early unequivocal indication of pathological sequelae in renal transplantation, although extensive endothelial activation can be demonstrated with OKT3 treatment.

A simple, rapid, reliable reverse haemolytic plaque assay and positive quality control test for routine use.

A simple, rapid, reliable protein A reverse haemolytic plaque assay is described. Monolayers of protein A-coupled sheep red blood cells, in liquid medium, are formed in shallow 15 mm diameter chambers of the type commercially available for leucocyte migration inhibition assays. No agarose is necessary and the chambers are quick and easy to use, economical of reagents, and of a constant size and volume. Results compare favourably with those obtained using Cunningham chambers. The assay is ideal for clinical studies in which large numbers of samples are assayed daily. A positive quality control test for the protein A reverse hemolytic plaque assays is described. Spleen cells are stimulated with pokeweed mitogen to give high numbers of secreting cells. The cells are harvested on day 6 of culture and stored in aliquots at -70 degrees C. When thawed and tested in the protein A assay, these secreting cells form a sensitive and reproducible monitor of the day-to-day performance of the assay. Variation between operators and between batches of reagents may also be checked if desired, with little additional time, effort or expense.

The relevance of anti-A549 antibody in adult renal transplantation

Sera from 228 individuals were examined for cytotoxic antibodies against the cultured lung epithelial cell line A549. All samples were screened by the conventional complement mediated cytotoxicity assay. The pattern of the anti-A549 reactivity in normal volunteers (n = 12) was 42% negative, 30% weak positive and 25% strong positive. The overall incidence of anti-A549 antibody in chronic renal failure patients (n = 84) was 7% weak positive and 7% strong positive. In 132 patients with a functioning renal allograft the frequency of anti-A549 reactivity increased (19% weak positive, 27% strong positive) and was comparable to that found in normal controls. The presence of anti-A549 antibody did not correlate with panel antibody allosensitization, cytomegalovirus status, age, mode of dialysis, rejection episodes, or with subsequent graft survival. We conclude that in adult renal transplantation the presence of anti-A549 antibody is not a contra-indication to transplantation.

Renal tubular epithelial cells tolerate prolonged warm ischaemia in vitro.

AS INCREASING numbers of expanded criteria and non–heart-beating donor kidneys are procured, the need for a reliable, accurate test of viability prior to transplantation becomes more acute. An in vitro model of renal cellular ischaemia would facilitate the study and assessment of viability tests and renoprotective compounds. An experimental system for anoxic culture and manipulation of cultured cells has been established and used to study renal cell viability after an ischaemic insult.