Tania H. Watts

Temporal segregation of 4-1BB versus CD28-mediated costimulation: 4-1BB ligand influences T cell numbers late in the primary response and regulates the size of the T cell memory response following influenza infection.

In this report, we demonstrate that CD28−/− mice are severely impaired in the initial expansion of Db/NP366-374-specific CD8 T cells in response to influenza virus infection, whereas 4-1BB ligand (4-1BBL)−/− mice show no defect in primary T cell expansion to influenza virus. In contrast, 4-1BBL−/− mice show a decrease in Db/NP366-374-specific T cells late in the primary response. Upon secondary challenge with influenza virus, 4-1BBL−/− mice show a decrease in the number of Db/NP366-374-specific T cells compared to wild-type mice such that the level of the CD8 T cell expansion during the in vivo secondary response is reduced to the level of a primary response, with concomitant reduction of CTL effector function. In contrast, Ab responses, as well as secondary CD4 T cell responses, to influenza are unaffected by 4-1BBL deficiency. Thus, CD28 is critical for initial T cell expansion, whereas 4-1BB/4-1BBL signaling affects T cell numbers much later in the response and is essential for the survival and/or responsiveness of the memory CD8 T cell pool.

4-1BB and OX40 Act Independently to Facilitate Robust CD8 and CD4 Recall Responses

Mice deficient in OX40 or 4-1BB costimulatory pathways show defects in T cell recall responses, with predominant effects on CD4 vs CD8 T cells, respectively. However, OX40L can also stimulate CD8 T cells and 4-1BBL can influence CD4 T cells, raising the possibility of redundancy between the two TNFR family costimulators. To test this possibility, we generated mice deficient in both 4-1BBL and OX40L. In an adoptive transfer model, CD4 T cells expressed 4-1BB and OX40 sequentially in response to immunization, with little or no overlap in the timing of their expression. Under the same conditions, CD8 T cells expressed 4-1BB, but no detectable OX40. Thus, in vivo expression of 4-1BB and OX40 can be temporally and spatially segregated. In the absence of OX40L, there were decreased CD4 T cells late in the primary response and no detectable secondary expansion of adoptively transferred CD4 T cells under conditions in which primary expansion was unaffected. The 4-1BBL had a minor effect on the primary response of CD4 T cells in this model, but showed larger effects on the secondary response, although 4-1BBL−/− mice show less impairment in CD4 secondary responses than OX40L−/− mice. The 4-1BBL−/− and double knockout mice were similarly impaired in the CD8 T cell response, whereas OX40L−/− and double knockout mice were similarly impaired in the CD4 T cell response to both protein Ag and influenza virus. Thus, 4-1BB and OX40 act independently and nonredundantly to facilitate robust CD4 and CD8 recall responses.

A Switch in Costimulation from CD28 to 4-1BB during Primary versus Secondary CD8 T Cell Response to Influenza In Vivo

4-1BBL−/− mice exhibit normal primary CD8 T cell responses to influenza virus, but show decreased CD8 T cell numbers late in the primary response as well as decreased secondary responses. In contrast, CD28−/− mice are defective in initial CD8 T cell expansion. Using agonistic anti-4-1BB Ab to replace the CD28 or 4-1BB signal, we examined the timing of the required signals for CD28 vs 4-1BB costimulation. A single dose of agonistic anti-4-1BB Ab added only during priming restores the secondary CD8 T cell response in CD28−/− mice. Once the T cell numbers in the primary response reach a minimum threshold, a full secondary response is achieved even in the absence of CD28. In contrast, anti-4-1BB added during priming fails to correct the defective secondary response in 4-1BBL−/− mice, whereas addition of anti-4-1BB during challenge fully restores this response. Thus, there is a switch in costimulatory requirement from CD28 to 4-1BB during primary vs recall responses. Adoptive transfer studies show that T cells primed in 4-1BBL−/− or wild-type mice are equally capable of re-expansion when rechallenged in wild-type mice. These studies rule out a model in which signals delivered through 4-1BB during priming program the T cells to give a full recall response and suggest that 4-1BB-4-1BBL interactions take place at later stages in the immune response. The results indicate that anti-4-1BB or 4-1BBL therapy will be most effective during the boost phase of a prime-boost vaccination strategy.

Role of ICOS versus CD28 in antiviral immunity.

The costimulatory protein ICOS is inducibly expressed on activated T cells. Previous results have shown that ICOS–/– mice are defective in germinal center formation, antibody (Ab) production and class switch as well as Th1 and Th2 cytokine production in response to protein or parasite antigens. However, ICOS‐Ig failed to block antiviral Ab responses. To date the immune response to viruses has not been examined in ICOS–/– mice. In this report we compared antiviral Ab responses to LCMV, VSV and influenza virus in ICOS–/– versus wild‐type mice. Our results show that ICOS is important in the Ab response to all three viruses, with greater effects on primary as compared to secondary responses. Although ICOS–/– mice are impaired in some immune responses following influenza infection, the effects were less severe than for CD28–/– mice. There was no defect in initial influenza‐specific CD8 T cell expansion in ICOS–/– mice or in cytotoxic effector function. However, ICOS was important in maintaining CD4 cytokine production and CD8 T cell numbers late in the primary response. Upon secondary infection, ICOS–/– mice show wild‐type levels of influenza‐specific CD8 T cells, whereas CD28–/– mice show greatly impaired secondary CD8 T cell expansion. Overall, our results show that ICOS plays a clear role in the primary response to viruses at the level of Ab production, germinal center formation and Th cytokine production, but has diminished effects following secondary viral challenge.

Endogenous 4-1BB Ligand Plays a Critical Role in Protection from Influenza-Induced Disease

A critical issue during severe respiratory infection is whether it is the virus or the host response that does the most damage. In this study, we show that endogenous 4-1BBL plays a critical role in protecting mice from severe effects of influenza disease. During mild respiratory influenza infection in which virus is rapidly cleared, the inducible costimulatory receptor 4-1BB is only transiently induced on lung T cells and 4-1BB ligand (4-1BBL) is completely dispensable for the initial CD8 T cell response and mouse survival. In contrast, during more severe respiratory influenza infection with prolonged viral load, 4-1BB expression on lung CD8 T cells is sustained, and 4-1BBL-deficient mice show decreased CD8 T cell accumulation in the lungs, decreased viral clearance, impaired lung function, and increased mortality. Transfer of an optimal number of naive Ag-specific T cells before infection protects wild-type but not 4-1BBL-deficient mice from an otherwise lethal dose of influenza virus. Transfer of T cells lacking the proapoptotic molecule Bim extends the lifespan of 4-1BBL-deficient mice by one to three days, suggesting that at least part of the role of 4-1BB/4-1BBL is to prolong effector cell survival long enough to clear virus. Intranasal delivery of 4-1BBL by recombinant adenovirus marginally improves survival of 4-1BBL-deficient mice at low dose, but exacerbates disease at high dose. These findings suggest a rationale for the evolutionary accumulation of inducible costimulatory molecules, thereby allowing the immune system to sustain the expression of molecules such as 4-1BB to a level commensurate with severity of infection.

Generation and Characterization of B7-H4/B7S1/B7x-Deficient Mice

ABSTRACT Members of the B7 family of cosignaling molecules regulate T-cell proliferation and effector functions by engaging cognate receptors on T cells. In vitro and in vivo blockade experiments indicated that B7-H4 (also known as B7S1 or B7x) inhibits proliferation, cytokine production, and cytotoxicity of T cells. B7-H4 binds to an unknown receptor(s) that is expressed on activated T cells. However, whether B7-H4 plays nonredundant immune regulatory roles in vivo has not been tested. We generated B7-H4-deficient mice to investigate the roles of B7-H4 during various immune reactions. Consistent with its inhibitory function in vitro, B7-H4-deficient mice mounted mildly augmented T-helper 1 (Th1) responses and displayed slightly lowered parasite burdens upon Leishmania major infection compared to the wild-type mice. However, the lack of B7-H4 did not affect hypersensitive inflammatory responses in the airway or skin that are induced by either Th1 or Th2 cells. Likewise, B7-H4-deficient mice developed normal cytotoxic T-lymphocyte reactions against viral infection. Thus, B7-H4 plays a negative regulatory role in vivo but the impact of B7-H4 deficiency is minimal. These results suggest that B7-H4 is one of multiple negative cosignaling molecules that collectively provide a fine-tuning mechanism for T-cell-mediated immune responses.

A critical role for TNF receptor-associated factor 1 and Bim down-regulation in CD8 memory T cell survival.

The mechanisms that allow the maintenance of immunological memory remain incompletely defined. Here we report that tumor necrosis factor receptor (TNFR)-associated factor (TRAF) 1, a protein recruited in response to several costimulatory TNFR family members, is required for maximal CD8 T cell responses to influenza virus in mice. Decreased recovery of CD8 T cells in vivo occurred under conditions where cell division was unimpaired. In vitro, TRAF1-deficient, antigen-activated T cells accumulated higher levels of the proapoptotic BH3-only family member Bim, particularly the most toxic isoform, BimS. In the presence of excess IL-15, memory phenotype T cells with similar surface phenotype and comparable levels of Bcl-2 family members could be generated from WT or TRAF1-deficient T cell receptor transgenic OT-I T cells. However, when the memory CD8 T cells were allowed to compete for survival signals in the absence of antigen in vivo, the TRAF1-deficient T cells showed decreased recovery compared with TRAF1-sufficient T cells. This defect in T cell recovery in vivo was alleviated by introduction of siRNA to down-modulate Bim in TRAF1-deficient memory T cells. These studies identify the TRAF1 signaling axis and Bim down-regulation as critical for CD8 memory T cell survival in vivo.

Incorporation of 4-1BB ligand into an adenovirus vaccine vector increases the number of functional antigen-specific CD8 T cells and enhances the duration of protection against influenza-induced respiratory disease.

T cell based influenza vaccines offer the potential for cross protective immunity to multiple clades of influenza virus. Here we explored the effect of increasing CD8 T cell responses during intranasal vaccination by incorporating a T cell costimulator, 4-1BBL. Inclusion of 4-1BBL in an influenza nucleoprotein (NP)-containing adenoviral vector increased the number of NP-specific CD8 T cells and lowered the vaccine dose required for short-term protection from influenza-induced disease in mice. At higher vaccine doses, the inclusion of 4-1BBL increased the duration of protection of mice from influenza-induced mortality. Bone marrow chimera experiments revealed that the major effects of 4-1BBL were directly on αβ T cells with minor additional effects through cells other than αβ T cells. The implications of these findings are that including 4-1BBL or adjuvants that induce 4-1BBL expression may be of benefit in a vaccine setting for enhancing the magnitude and duration of T cell responses to influenza virus.

Cooperation between 4-1BB and ICOS in the Immune Response to Influenza Virus Revealed by Studies of CD28/ICOS-Deficient Mice

CD28, ICOS, and 4-1BB each play distinct roles in the CD8 T cell response to influenza virus. CD28−/− mice are severely impaired in primary CD8 T cell expansion and fail to mount a secondary response to influenza. Influenza-specific CD8 T cells expand normally in ICOS−/− mice, with only a small and transient defect late in the primary response and an unimpaired secondary response. Conversely, 4-1BB/4-1BBL interaction is dispensable for the primary CD8 T cell response to influenza, but maintains CD8 T cell survival and controls the size of the secondary response. Previous results showed that a single dose of agonistic anti-4-1BB Ab at priming allowed partial restoration of primary CD8 T cell expansion and full recovery of the secondary CD8 T cell responses to influenza in CD28−/− mice. In this study we show that anti-4-1BB fails to correct the CD8 T cell defect in CD28−/−ICOS−/− mice, suggesting that ICOS partially compensates for CD28 in this model. In support of this hypothesis, we found that anti-4-1BB enhances ICOS expression on both T cell subsets and that anti-4-1BB and anti-ICOS can synergistically activate CD4 and CD8 T cells. Furthermore, ICOS and 4-1BB can cooperate to directly stimulate isolated CD28−/− CD8 T cells. These results reveal a novel interaction between the ICOS and 4-1BB costimulatory pathways as well as unexpected redundancy between CD28 and ICOS in primary CD8 T cell expansion. These findings have implications for costimulation of human T cell responses in diseases such as AIDS or rheumatoid arthritis, in which CD28− T cells accumulate.

Immune Functions in Mice Lacking Clnk, an SLP-76-Related Adaptor Expressed in a Subset of Immune Cells

ABSTRACT The SLP-76 family of immune cell-specific adaptors is composed of three distinct members named SLP-76, Blnk, and Clnk. They have been implicated in the signaling pathways coupled to immunoreceptors such as the antigen receptors and Fc receptors. Previous studies using gene-targeted mice and deficient cell lines showed that SLP-76 plays a central role in T-cell development and activation. Moreover, it is essential for normal mast cell and platelet activation. In contrast, Blnk is necessary for B-cell development and activation. While the precise function of Clnk is not known, it was reported that Clnk is selectively expressed in mast cells, natural killer (NK) cells, and previously activated T-cells. Moreover, ectopic expression of Clnk was shown to rescue T-cell receptor-mediated signal transduction in an SLP-76-deficient T-cell line, suggesting that, like its relatives, Clnk is involved in the positive regulation of immunoreceptor signaling. Stimulatory effects of Clnk on immunoreceptor signaling were also reported to occur in transfected B-cell and basophil leukemia cell lines. Herein, we attempted to address the physiological role of Clnk in immune cells by the generation of Clnk-deficient mice. The results of our studies demonstrated that Clnk is dispensable for normal differentiation and function of T cells, mast cells, and NK cells. Hence, unlike its relatives, Clnk is not essential for normal immune functions.