Tarek M. Khalil

Does Nonsurgical Pain Center Treatment of Chronic Pain Return Patients to Work?: A Review and Meta-analysis of the Literature

Evidence in the literature relating to return to work as an outcome variable for nonsurgical treatment for chronic pain was examined. Study selection criteria were as follows: a detailed definition of patient work status, delineation of work status pre-treatment and at follow-up, and documentation of the proportion of patients employed at follow-up. Of 171 studies reviewed, 37 fulfilled these selection criteria. Because the data were objective in nature, they were abstracted by the senior author only. For the coded variables of time to follow-up, proportion of patients working pre-treatment and at follow-up and number of patients, descriptive statistics and correlations were calculated. Change in employment status at follow-up was significant (P < .005) for all groups examined. In addition, comparisons for work outcome between treated patients versus patients rejected due to lack of insurance, and between treated patients versus patients who dropped out of treatment were both significant (P < .001). The mean difference in employment at follow-up for treated patients versus those not treated was approximately 50%. The proportion of patients working increased from 20% to 54% post chronic pain nonsurgical treatment. Correlation analyses did not find a significant trend in percent employed with time to follow-up. These results indicate that (1) chronic pain nonsurgical treatment does return patients to work; (2) increased rates of return to work are due to treatment, and (3) benefits of treatment are not temporary.

The prediction of return to the workplace after Multidisciplinary Pain Center treatment.

The prediction of return to the workplace after Multidisciplinary Pain Center (MPC) treatment has become a major research area. To delineate the variables that predict this outcome, the authors reviewed 164 multidisciplinary outcome studies. Of these, 79 addressed work as an outcome variable. Twenty-six studies attempted to identify patient variables predicting return to the workplace. These latter studies were critically inspected for eight methodological criteria: pain location, follow-up time interval, response percentage and follow-up method, return to work subcategorization, vocational movement, univariate vs. multivariate statistics, multicolinearity and variance, and statistical treatment of dropouts. In addition, other disability studies besides those in the chronic pain area were reviewed for return to the workplace predictor variables. Of these 26 studies, only a few appeared to satisfy the criteria examined. In addition, many studies were in conflict with one another on whether a variable was predictive. The review of the nonchronic pain/disability prediction literature yielded a large number of potential predictors that related to the work area. It is unclear which variables or set of variables predict return to the workplace after MPC treatment. Chronic pain studies may be neglecting the work area as an important source of return to the workplace predictor variables.

Stretching in the rehabilitation of low-back pain patients

The major objective of this investigation was to study the effectiveness of the physical conditioning program used at the University of Miami Comprehensive Pain and Rehabilitation Center in restoring certain elements of the functional abilities of individuals suffering from chronic low-back pain and to evaluate the effectiveness of using a systematically applied, aggressive stretching maneuver as an add-on therapy in the treatment of chronic low-back pain patients. The effect(s) of the proposed stretching maneuver was evaluated. Twenty-eight chronic low-back pain patients were randomly assigned to one of two groups. The control group underwent a multimodal rehabilitation program, and the experimental group underwent the same rehabilitation program in addition to the systematic stretching maneuver under investigation. The results obtained showed that patients undergoing the multimodal rehabilitation program with and without the proposed systematic stretching maneuver showed a significant improvement in their functional abilities as seen from the significant increase in the static strength of the back extensors, with corresponding significant increase in back muscle myoelectric signals. Also, a significant decrease in their pain level was reported after 2 weeks of continuous treatment. The use of the systematic stretching maneuver enhanced the functional gains of chronic low-back pain patients compared to the control group.

Spinal compression tolerance limits for the design of manual material handling operations in the workplace

Spinal compression tolerance limits (SCTL) have been widely used by ergonomists in setting work tolerance limits for manual materials handling (MMH) operations. Thus, the effect of personal and experimental factors on spinal compression tolerance limits (SCTL) is reviewed with the aid of regression and correlation analyses performed on data compiled from the published literature. Tables of SCTL from various sources utilizing large number of specimens and personal factors are presented so that they can be accessed by ergonomists easily. Integrated biomechanical guidelines based on SCTL are provided for the design of MMH operations in the workplace. It is suggested that, in order to reduce the probability of MMH injuries, biomechanical tolerance limits should be set at the damage load instead of the load at fracture. The damage load is the weight which causes the first gross signs of damage such as tissue fluid and blood. An algorithm is described to demonstrate the use of a biomechanics approach to the design of MMH operations.

Technology management in China: a global perspective and challenging issues

Purpose – This paper reviews the framework of the management of technology (MOT) field and examines some application cases of technological development and innovation in China. It addresses various crucial issues necessary in the establishment of infrastructure, strategies, mechanisms and systems of technology management in China. It draws upon knowledge acquired from the US experience in this field for the past two decades.Design/methodology/approach – An overview and conceptual paper based on observations and research experience.Findings – This paper stresses the importance of keeping‐up with the fast pace of technological change and the emerging new global paradigms of the business environment. MOT is an important strategic instrument to improve competitiveness and create prosperity in countries that effectively apply it. The paper draws upon the experience of the US in MOT over the past two decades and projects what may be needed for China to continue its development and economic growth in the future....

Measuring residual functional capacity in chronic low back pain patients based on the dictionary of occupational titles

Study Design. This study designed and tested a functional battery based on the Dictionary of Occupational Titles (DOT). Objectives. Such a battery can be used to measure residual functional capacity (RFC) in chronic pain patients (CPP) and results can be matched against the demand minimum functional capacities (DMFC) of DOT jobs. Summary of Background Data. Physicians have difficulty translating medical impairment into functional limitation and thereby establishing the RFC of CPPs. Methods. The DOT, a USA government publication, provides information about physical demands of every USA job according to 36 factors and subfactors. The authors defined and developed a fuctional battery based on these factors/subfactors. This battery was tested on 67 consecutive CPPs to determine the percentage of CPPs able to pass specific job factors and the full battery and return to some DOT job, and evaluated the effects of pain on battery performance. The data were factor analyzed. Results. The battery determined if CPPs could perform DOT job factors and had the necessary RFC to be placed in a DOT job. The vast majority of CPPs could not pass the full battery and the presence of pain and original job classification predicted whether a CPP could perform a job factor. Factor analyses grouped the factors into four independent categories supporting the design of the battery. Conclusion. The battery can assess whether CPPs are able to return to work.

Functional capacity and residual functional capacity and their utility in measuring work capacity.

OBJECTIVE The pain physician is often asked to establish the medical impairment of the chronic pain patient (CPP) and from that determination ascertain the work capacity of the CPP. Functional capacity (FC) testing has recently been introduced as a more objective and accurate way of facilitating the determination of work capacity. However, there are conceptual problems with the measurement of FC. These will be reviewed and the relationship of FC to residual functional capacity (RFC) will be determined. Finally, a method for measuring RFC in a job-specific manner will be suggested. DATA SOURCES The literature in reference to the measurement of medical impairment, FC, and RFC was reviewed. STUDY SELECTION Studies appropriate to the objective of this review were selected for inclusion. CONCLUSIONS The FC and RFC are poorly defined. Lack of definition has interfered with design of appropriate test batteries specific to work capacity. To circumvent this problem a job-specific RFC measurement method is suggested. This method is based on the Dictionary of Occupational Titles.

Acceptable maximum effort (AME): a psychophysical measure of strength in back pain patients

A new quantitative method for measuring functional abilities of chronic low-back pain patients is introduced. The method is based upon a psychophysical model referred to as acceptable maximum effort (AME). AME is the highest level of voluntary effort that a person can achieve without inducing unacceptable pain. In the current study, the AME method was applied to strength measurement. By use of a static strength measurement procedure, arm, leg, shoulder, back, and composite strengths were assessed upon admission to and discharge from a 4-week, nonsurgical comprehensive pain treatment program. The reliability of the AME method for each strength measure was assessed. In addition, the method was used to evaluate preto post-treatment changes in strength. Results indicate the AME method to be highly reliable and useful in determining treatment outcome. Reliability coefficients for all strength measures were above .90. The results are discussed in terms of their implications for standardized functional ability measurement in the area of chronic pain.

Biofeedback in back muscle strengthening.

This study was undertaken to investigate the use of electromyography (EMG) biofeedback as an add-on therapy to standard exercise in the restoration of the functional abilities of the trunk extensor muscles in patients suffering from chronic low-back pain (CLBP). A controlled experimental investigation was conducted to study the effectiveness of using the proposed treatment modality in the management of the low-back pain problem. The results obtained indicate that the proposed methodology was an effective tool to achieve a significant improvement in the strength of lumbar paraspinal muscles of chronic low-back pain patients.

Physiological limits in lifting.

Two different experiments were conducted to study the effects of frequency, height and load of lift on computed maximal oxygen uptake and to compare the data obtained to a standard bicycle ergometer. A progressive submaximal technique was used to predict maximal oxygen uptake. The results of the present study revealed that across all heights, an increase in either the frequency of lift or load of lift was accompanied by an increase in computed maximal oxygen uptake; however, all maximal oxygen uptake values reported showed a tendency to level off beyond the frequency of five lifts/min. The results also showed that combined arm and leg lifting recorded the highest maximal oxygen uptake followed by leg lifting then arm lifting, respectively. Maximal oxygen uptake values obtained for lifting tasks were much lower than those obtained for a bicycle ergometer. It is therefore recommended that limits for continuous work for a lifting task be based on the attainable maximal oxygen uptake for that particular task and not on a maximal oxygen uptake obtained from another task such as a bicycle ergometer test.