Terry W. Turner

Individuality of DNA denaturation patterns in human sperm as measured by the sperm chromatin structure assay.

Eight monthly semen samples from 45 men not known to be exposed to industrial toxicants were measured by the flow cytometric sperm chromatin structure assay (SCSA). This assay determines susceptibility of sperm DNA to in situ, acid-induced denaturation and is quantitated by the metachromatic shift of acridine orange fluorescence from green (native DNA) to red (denatured DNA). The observed green versus red fluorescence scattergram (cytogram) patterns were generally unique between donors and homogeneous within a donor over time. Within a donor, the cytogram patterns were the same whether intact sperm cells or detached nuclei were measured. For some individuals the cytogram patterns differed for some months and then returned to the original pattern. Intraclass correlations for mean and standard deviation of alpha t [alpha t = red/(red + green) fluorescence] were higher (.67 to .90) than any classically measured semen variables, suggesting that SCSA results within an individual were more consistent than other measures. Furthermore, average within-donor CV of alpha t parameters expressed as a percent of any given individuals means was around 10%, which is significantly lower than those derived from common semen measures. The SCSA is an objective, technically sound, biologically stable, sensitive, and feasible measure of semen quality.

Longitudinal study of semen quality of unexposed workers: I. Study overview☆

A longitudinal study of 45 men was conducted evaluating the semen quality of monthly samples collected over 9 months. The statistical variation of sperm count, semen volume, percentage of motile sperm, sperm velocity, sperm morphology, and sperm viability, assessed by both the vital stain and the hypoosmotic swelling (HOS) assay, were each evaluated using intraclass correlations and coefficients of variation. Sperm count and semen volume had large intraclass correlations (62% and 60%, respectively), indicating that if a subject has a high count or volume he will tend to continue to have high counts or volumes. On the other hand, sperm velocity had an intraclass correlation of only 16% indicating that fluctuations within a subject were nearly as large as fluctuations from subject to subject. The remaining parameters had intraclass correlations ranging from 42% to 47%. Sperm count, percent motile sperm, and semen volume each had large coefficients of variation (both between and within subjects). These variables, especially count, had relatively poor precision. Sperm velocity, percent motile sperm, percent normal morphology, the HOS assay, and the vital stain assay had lower coefficients of variation, indicating greater precision.

LABORATORY METHODS FOR ASSESSING HUMAN SEMEN IN EPIDEMIOLOGIC STUDIES: A CONSENSUS REPORT

It is clear that additional methodologic work needs to be performed. Some data gaps described above are being actively investigated. Other standards were not addressed at this meeting; statistical handling of the data, differences among CASA machines, and factors to consider as potential confounders in analysis are just a few. These may be the subject of future workshops, which will also review progress made in the existing knowledge base. For now, this effort represents a first attempt to share information and to use it to encourage investigators in different laboratories to employ similar methods. In this way more direct comparisons among studies can be made, and our collective data base can be strengthened.

The effects of ethylene dibromide on semen quality: a comparison of short-term and chronic exposure.

Two occupational field studies were conducted to determine the effects of ethylene dibromide (EDB) exposure on male reproductive potential. The first study was a longitudinal study of 10 EDB-exposed forestry employees and 6 unexposed men conducted in Colorado in the summer of 1983. The exposure time was approximately 6 weeks. The second study was a cross-sectional study of 46 EDB-exposed papaya workers and 43 unexposed men conducted in Hawaii in December 1983 in which the average term of employment was about 5 years. In the longitudinal study, sperm velocity decreased in all 10 exposed men and in only two unexposed men. Semen volume was also decreased in 9 of the 10 exposed men (there was no change in the other man); only two unexposed men had a decrease in their semen volume. The longer term EDB exposure resulted in decreases in sperm motility and viability, suggesting that the short term exposure may slow sperm velocity, but longer exposures cause immotility and cell death. An apparent decrease in semen volume that was observed in the longitudinal study was not statistically significant in the cross sectional study of workers having chronic exposure. However, a significantly higher semen pH was observed in the exposed men compared to the unexposed men in the cross-sectional study. The results from both studies suggest that the accessory sex glands may be affected by EDB exposure.

Semen Analysis and Fertility Assessment in Rabbits: Statistical Power and Design Considerations for Toxicology Studies

Semen analysis is commonly used in evaluating human response to reproductive toxicants. Serial semen samples can be collected from rabbits and fertility assessed by artificial insemination, hence this species is potentially well suited for male reproductive toxicity studies that might be extrapolated to humans. However, the size and cost of rabbits often restricts the number of animals used, reducing the sensitivity of such studies. Therefore, it was of interest to optimize study design for semen analysis and fertility assessment in rabbits. Semen samples were collected weekly from sexually mature New Zealand white rabbits and a range of parameters was analyzed (Semen--pH, volume, osmolality; Sperm--number and concentration, morphology, viability, percentage motility, motion characteristics; Seminal plasma--fructose, citric acid, carnitine and protein concentrations, acid phosphatase activity). Male fertility was assessed by inseminating female rabbits with the minimum number of motile sperm required for normal fertility, determined to be one million. The within- and between-buck variabilities were determined for all parameters and used to calculate the statistical power of different study designs. The variability of sperm number and concentration was decreased when measured in four ejaculates collected within a short period of time rather than in a single ejaculate; this was not true of other endpoints measured. In addition, use of preexposure observations further increased the statistical power for all of the parameters. These data can be used to determine the optimum design for studies of male reproductive toxicity using rabbits, with particular regard to cost and the number of animals used.

Semen analysis of military personnel associated with military duty assignments

A collaborative study between the U.S. Army Biomedical Research and Development Laboratory (USABRDL) and the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) was designed to assess fecundity of male artillery soldiers with potential exposures to airborne lead aerosols. Potential exposure assessment was based upon information provided in an interactive questionnaire. It became apparent from extensive questionnaire data that many soldiers in the initial control population had potentially experienced microwave exposure as radar equipment operators. As a result, a third group of soldiers without potential for lead or microwave exposures, but with similar environmental conditions, was selected as a comparison population. Blood hormone levels and semen analyses were conducted on artillerymen (n = 30), radar equipment operators (n = 20), and the comparison group (n = 31). Analysis of the questionnaire information revealed that concern about fertility problems motivated participation of some soldiers with potential artillery or microwave exposures. Although small study population size and the confounding variable of perceived infertility limit the reliability of the study, several statistically significant findings were identified. Artillerymen who perceived a possible fertility concern demonstrated lower sperm counts/ejaculate (P = 0.067) and lower sperm/mL (P = 0.014) than the comparison group. The group of men with potential microwave exposures demonstrated lower sperm counts/mL (P = 0.009) and sperm/ejaculate (P = 0.027) than the comparison group. Variables used to assess endocrine, accessory sex gland, and sperm cell function were not different than the comparison group. Additional studies, incorporating larger numbers of individuals, should be performed in order to more optimally characterize potential lead and microwave exposure effects on male fecundity.

Male reproductive effects of lead, including species extrapolation for the rabbit model.

The effects of elevated blood lead on semen quality were evaluated in the rabbit model and compared to published effects in humans. Mature, male rabbits were given lead acetate by subcutaneous injection in the dose range of 0 to 3.85 mg/kg on a Monday-Wednesday-Friday basis. In each of eight treatment groups, a dosing regimen was developed to produce blood lead levels of 0, 20, 40, 50, 70, 80, 90, and 110 microg/dL. A 5-week pre-exposure period was followed by a 15-week exposure testing period allowing for response through six cycles of the seminiferous epithelium. Semen analyses revealed that increased blood lead levels were associated with adverse changes in the sperm count, ejaculate volume, percent motile sperm, swimming velocities, and morphology. Hormonal responses were minimal. Testicular pathology revealed a dose-dependent inhibition of spermiation. For six measures of semen quality, threshold estimates ranged from 16 to 24 microg/dL. Using the species extrapolation factor derived in this study, a rabbit dose would have to be divided by 1.56 to obtain the equivalent human dose for an equal percentage decrease in sperm concentration; however, rabbits are 3.75 more sensitive in terms of absolute decrease in sperm count for a given blood lead level.

Semen Quality and Hormone Levels Among Radiofrequency Heater Operators

Approximately 9,000,000 US workers are occupationally exposed to radiofrequency (RF) radiation; over 250,000 operate RF dielectric heaters. Our purpose was to determine whether male RF heater operators experience increased adverse reproductive effects reflected in reduced semen quality or altered hormone levels. We measured incident RF heater radiation exposures and RF-induced foot currents at four companies. For 12 male heater operators and a comparison group of 34 RF-unexposed men, we measured 33 parameters of semen quality and four serum hormones. Despite wide variation in individual exposure levels, near field strengths and induced foot currents did not exceed current standard levels and guidelines. We observed minor semen quality and hormonal differences between the groups, including a slightly higher mean follicle-stimulating hormone level for exposed operators (7.6 vs 5.8 mIU/mL). Further occupational studies of RF-exposed men may be warranted.

Measuring male reproductive hormones for occupational field studies.

As part of our longitudinal study of unexposed workers, we drew blood samples and analyzed the individual endocrine profiles for 45 men. The blood collection was between 8 AM and 8 PM, and three blood samples were drawn 20 minutes apart on three occasions during the course of the study (June, October, and February). Serum concentrations of follicle-stimulating hormone, luteinizing hormone, testosterone, and prolactin were determined. A component of variance model was used to estimate variability between the 20-minute blood draws. Statistical power analysis using this component showed that three blood draws provide a marginal improvement over a single blood draw in detecting population shifts. Also, if the prospect of three blood draws reduces subject participation by 10 to 20%, the increase in power would be negated.

Pubertal delay in male nonhuman primates (Macaca mulatta) treated with methylphenidate

Juvenile male rhesus monkeys treated with methylphenidate hydrochloride (MPH) to evaluate genetic and behavioral toxicity were observed after 14 mo of treatment to have delayed pubertal progression with impaired testicular descent and reduced testicular volume. Further evaluation of animals dosed orally twice a day with (i) 0.5 mL/kg of vehicle (n = 10), (ii) 0.15 mg/kg of MPH increased to 2.5 mg/kg (low dose, n = 10), or (iii) 1.5 mg/kg of MPH increased to 12.5 mg/kg (high dose, n = 10) for a total of 40 mo revealed that testicular volume was significantly reduced (P < 0.05) at months 15 to 19 and month 27. Testicular descent was significantly delayed (P < 0.05) in the high-dose group. Significantly lower serum testosterone levels were detected in both the low- (P = 0.0017) and high-dose (P = 0.0011) animals through month 33 of treatment. Although serum inhibin B levels were increased overall in low-dose animals (P = 0.0328), differences between groups disappeared by the end of the study. Our findings indicate that MPH administration, beginning before puberty, and which produced clinically relevant blood levels of the drug, impaired pubertal testicular development until ∼5 y of age. It was not possible to resolve whether MPH delayed the initiation of the onset of puberty or reduced the early tempo of the developmental process. Regardless, deficits in testicular volume and hormone secretion disappeared over the 40-mo observation period, suggesting that the impact of MPH on puberty is not permanent.