Thomas E. Nevins

Nonadherence Consensus Conference Summary Report

This report is a summary of a ‘Consensus Conference’ on nonadherence (NA) to immunosuppressants. Its aims were: (1) to discuss the state‐of‐the‐art on the definition, prevalence and measurement of NA, its risk factors and impact on clinical and economical outcomes and interventions and (2) to provide recommendations for future studies. A two‐day meeting was held in Florida in January 2008, inviting 66 medical and allied health adherence transplant and nontransplant experts. A scientific committee prepared the meeting. Consensus was reached using plenary and interactive presentations and discussions in small break‐out groups. Plenary presenters prepared a summary beforehand. Break‐out group leaders initiated discussion between the group members prior to the meeting using conference calls and e‐mail and provided a summary afterward. Conclusions were that NA: (a) is more prevalent than we assume; (b) is hard to measure accurately; (c) tends to confer worse outcomes; (d) happens for a number of reasons, and system‐related factors including the patients culture, the healthcare provider and the setting and (e) it is not currently known how to improve adherence. This consensus report provided some roadmaps for future studies on this complicated, multifaceted problem.

The 1989 report of the North American Pediatric Renal Transplant Cooperative Study - This report is prepared under the auspices of the scientific advisory committee of the North American Pediatric Renal Transplant Cooperative Study

This report of the North American Pediatric Transplant Cooperative Study summarizes data contributed by 57 participating centers on 754 children with 761 transplants from 1 January 1989 to 16 February 1989. Data collection was initiated in October 1987 and follow-up of all patients is ongoing. Transplant frequency increased with age; 24% of the patients were less than 5 years, with 7% being under 2 years. Common frequent diagnoses were: aplastic/dysplastic kidneys (18%), obstructive uropathy (16%), and focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (12%). Preemptive transplant, i.e., transplantation without prior maintenance dialysis, was performed in 21% of the patients. Dialytic modalities pretransplant were peritoneal dialysis in 42% and hemodialysis in 25%. Bilateral nephrectomy was reported in 29%. Live-donor sources accounted for 42% of the transplants. Among cadaveric donors, 41% of the donors were under 11 years old. During the first post-transplant month, maintenance therapy was used similarly for live-donor and cadaver source transplants, with prednisone, cyclosporine, and azathioprine used in 93%, 83%, and 81%, respectively. Triple therapy with prednisone, cyclosporine, and azathioprine was used in 78%, 75%, and 75% of functioning cadaver source transplants at 6 months, 12 months, and 18 months as opposed to 60%, 63%, and 54% for live-donor procedures, with single-drug therapy being uncommon. Rehospitalization during months 1–5 occurred in 62% of the patients, with treatment of rejection and infection being the main causes. Additionally, 9% were hospitalized for hypertension. During months 6–12 and 12–17, 30% and 28% of the patients with functioning grafts were rehospitalized. Times to first rejection differed significantly for cadaver and live-donor transplants. The median time to the first rejection was 36 days for cadaver transplants and 156 days for live-donor transplants. Overall, 57% of treated rejections were completely reversible although the complete reversal rate decreased to 37% for four or more rejections. One hundred and fifty-two graft failures had occurred at the time of writing, with a 1-year graft survival estimate of 0.88 for live-donor and 0.71 for cadaver source transplants. In addition to donor source, recipient age is a significant prognostic factor for graft survival. Among cadaver donors, decreasing donor age is associated with a decreasing probability of graft survival. Thirty-five deaths have occurred; 16 attributed to infection and 19 to other causes. The current 1-year survival estimate is 0.94. There have been 9 malignancies.

Long-term quality of life after kidney transplantation in childhood.

Transplantation is the treatment of choice for children with end-stage renal disease. However, the long-term quality of life and socioprofessional outcome for those with successful transplants have not previously been reported. We studied these factors in patients transplanted when<18 years old who currently have ≥10 years of graft function. A total of 57 questionnaires were sent out; 57 (100%) responded [24 female and 33 male patients; average (±SD) age at tx = 10±5 years (0.9–17.7); average f/u = 15.6±3 years (10–26); current age = 26±5 years (12–38); 26 had < 1 transplant]. Of the 57 respondents, 9 are<18 (all are in school); 48 are ≥18 (7 in school, 37 employed, 4 unemployed); 12 are married, 1 engaged, and 2 divorced; and 9 have children. While in school, 43 (75%) had participated in sports, 37 (65%) in other extracurricular activities; 7 (12%) were A and 33 (58%) B students; 15 (26%) received awards or scholarships. For those working, the range of occupations is broad (average work week = 41±5 hr). Health-related absence from work has been nonexistent for 93%. Health is rated as good to excellent by 91% and fair by 9%. The future is regarded as hopeful or promising by 80%. Similarly, 89% are satisfied with life in general; 95% said health never or seldom interferes with family life; 95% feel health and drug side effects are of no or minor concern in sexual relationships. Only 3% feel health is a problem in maintaining a sexual relationship (41% are not sexually active). Only 4% stated that health often interferes with social life; 98% meet with friends on a regular basis; 76% are satisfied with personal relationships and 8% dissatisfied; 91% are satisfied with their ability to perform at work or school and 5% dissatisfied. Of note, 32% are dissatisfied with body appearance. Major concerns are short stature and brittle bones. Major suggestions include education/support groups to deal with teasing at school and peer problems. We conclude that transplanted children with long-term graft function have a favorable social and professional outcome. Overall, quality of life seems excellent.

Renal transplantation in infants.

The timing of renal transplantation in infants is controversial. Between 1965 and 1989, 79 transplants in 75 infants less than 2 years old were performed: 23 who were 12 months or younger, 52 who were older than 12 months; 63 donors were living related, 1 was living unrelated, and 15 were cadaver donors; 75 were primary transplants and 4 were retransplants. Infants were considered for transplantation when they were on, or about to begin, dialysis. All had intra-abdominal transplants with arterial anastomosis to the distal aorta. Sixty-four per cent are alive with functioning grafts. The most frequent etiologies of renal failure were hypoplasia (32%) and obstructive uropathy (20%); oxalosis was the etiology in 11%. Since 1983 patient survival has been 95% and 91% at 1 and 5 years; graft survival has been 86% and 73% at 1 and 5 years. For cyclosporine immunosuppressed patients, patient survival is 100% at 1 and 5 years; graft survival is 96% and 82% at 1 and 5 years. There was no difference in outcome between infants who were 12 months or younger versus those who were aged 12 to 24 months; similarly there was no difference between infants and older children. Sixteen (21%) patients died: 5 after operation from coagulopathy (1) and infection (4); and 11 late from postsplenectomy sepsis (4), recurrent oxalosis (3), infection (2), and other causes (2). Routine splenectomy is no longer done. There has not been a death from infection in patients transplanted since 1983. Rejection was the most common cause of graft loss (in 15 patients); other causes included death (with function) (7), recurrent oxalosis (3), and technical complications (3). Overall 52% of patients have not had a rejection episode; mean creatinine level in patients with functioning grafts is 0.8 + 0.2 mg/dL. Common postoperative problems include fever, atelectasis, and ileus. At the time of their transplants, the infants were small for age; but with a successful transplant, their growth, head circumference, and development have improved. Transplantation in infants requires an intensive multidisciplinary approach but yields excellent short-and long-term survival rates that are no different from those seen in older children or adults. Living donors should be used whenever possible. Patients with a successful transplantation experience improved growth and development, with excellent rehabilitation.

Growth and development in infants after renal transplantation

Between January 1, 1978, and August 31, 1985, 13 infants aged 6 to 11 months received primary renal transplants (12, living related donor; one cadaver) at the University of Minnesota. Twelve infants are alive with functioning grafts (10 primary and two second transplants) after 4 months to 7.5 years. To assess the long-term outcome, we analyzed growth and development in the first nine infants 2 to 7.5 years after receiving their first transplant. Before transplantation, head circumference and height standard deviation scores in six of nine infants were less than -2. Five had seizures; four had delayed mental development, and six delayed motor development. The mean increment in height standard deviation scores for six boys after transplantation was +1.4 (P less than 0.05), and one achieved complete catch-up growth. The mean difference in height standard deviation scores for three infant girls with primary hyperoxaluria was -2.1; nevertheless, two infants with oxalosis are currently alive 2.7 to 3.3 years later. All eight surviving children achieved normal head circumference (mean improvement +2.2 SDS, P less than 0.001), and no child had further seizures. Of seven infants reassessed with the Bayley Scales after transplantation, mental development was normal in all and motor development was normal in five. Our findings suggest that early living related renal transplantation is an important option in the management of end-stage renal disease in infants.

Recurrence of disease in patients retransplanted for focal segmental glomerulosclerosis

The natural history of focal segmental glomerulosclerosis in patients retransplanted after loss of a primary allograft is not well established. We studied 14 patients with FSGS who were retransplanted between April 1964 and September 1990 to determine if recurrence in a second or subsequent allograft could be predicted. In this group, 8 of the primary allografts were lost to recurrent disease and 6 to rejection. None of the 6 patients who lost their primary allograft to rejection without evidence of recurrent FSGS suffered recurrent disease after retransplantation. In contrast, 3 of the 8 patients who lost their primary allograft rapidly to FSGS suffered recurrent disease and loss of function in all subsequent allografts. The remaining 5 patients had prolonged function of the primary allograft ranging between 4 and 10.5 years, despite recurrence of FSGS. Of these 5 patients, 2 have excellent renal function after retransplantation without recurrence of FSGS in the secondary allograft at 9 and 10.5 years posttransplant; 2 have lost their secondary allograft to recurrent FSGS, but are free of recurrence in the third allograft at 0.5 and 5.8 years postoperatively; 1 maintains a serum creatinine level of 1.9 mg% despite recurrence of FSGS in the secondary allograft at 1 year postoperatively. Our data show that, without recurrence of FSGS in the primary allograft, further renal transplants will be free of recurrent disease. Based on this finding, we advocate use of living-related donors for second transplants in these patients. With rapid recurrence of FSGS and subsequent accelerated loss of the primary allograft, further renal transplants carry a high likelihood of recurrent FSGS and graft loss. A substantial proportion of patients with recurrent FSGS in the primary allograft will have prolonged renal function, and are likely to have excellent results with subsequent allografts.

The Synergistic Effect of Class II HLA Epitope-Mismatch and Nonadherence on Acute Rejection and Graft Survival

Predicting long‐term outcomes in renal transplant recipients is essential to optimize medical therapy and determine the frequency of posttransplant histologic and serologic monitoring. Nonadherence and human leukocyte antigen (HLA) mismatch are risk factors that have been associated with poor long‐term outcomes and may help individualize care. In the present study, class II HLA mismatches were determined at the HLA epitope level in 195 renal transplant recipients in whom medication adherence was prospectively measured using electronic monitors in medication vial caps. Recipients were grouped by medication adherence and high (≥10 HLA‐DR, ≥17 HLA‐DQ) or low epitope‐mismatch load. We found that the combination of higher epitope mismatch and poor adherence acted synergistically to determine the risk of rejection or graft loss. Nonadherent recipients with HLA‐DR epitope mismatch ≥10 had increased graft loss (35% vs. 8%, p < 0.01) compared to adherent recipients with low epitope mismatch. At the HLA‐DQ locus nonadherent recipients with HLA‐DQ epitope mismatch ≥17 had increased graft loss (33% vs. 10%, p < 0.01) compared to adherent recipients with low epitope mismatch. Subclinical nonadherence early posttransplant combined with HLA class II epitope mismatch may help identify recipients that could benefit from increased clinical, histologic, and serologic monitoring.

Quantitative Patterns of Azathioprine Adherence After Renal Transplantation

Background. Renal transplant recipients regularly fail to take their prescribed immunosuppressive medications, frequently leading to adverse outcomes. Methods. Medication vials incorporating electronic monitor circuits in their caps compiled prospective data files on the azathioprine dosing patterns of 180 adult renal transplant recipients monitored up to 4 years. These patients were followed for a mean of 8.7 years posttransplantation. Results. Patients were divided into three groups by the medication doses missed during the first 6 months posttransplant. These initial dosing patterns remained remarkably consistent up to 4 years. Patients (n=47) missing the most doses (≥5%) experienced earlier and more frequent acute rejection episodes (P=0.025). This group also demonstrated significantly longer interdose intervals (P=0.005), with more frequent (P<0.001) and longer (P<0.001) “drug holidays.” A patient subgroup with early declining medication adherence (n=23) experienced dramatically poorer outcomes, with significantly increased acute rejection (P<0.001), chronic rejection (P=0.034), graft loss before death (P<0.001), and death (P=0.04). In all tertiles there was a trend toward missing more medication over time. Conclusions. Excellent posttransplant medication adherence is critical to improved outcomes. Individual dosing patterns are established early after hospital discharge and remain remarkably consistent, despite gradual erosion in adherence over time. The later consequences of medication nonadherence, especially early declines in adherence, include increased frequencies of rejection, graft loss, and death.

Effects of growth hormone on kidney function in pediatric transplant recipients

Recent evidence suggests that treatment with recombinant human growth hormone (rhGH) after a successful kidney transplant improves the growth rate of children with short stature. We prospectively investigated eight children (6 boys, 2 girls), focusing on acute rejection episodes and changes in serum creatinine levels during rhGH treatment. The children (mean age 11.6±3.4 years) received rhGH daily (0.04–0.05 mg/kg subcutaneously). Seven patients completed at least 12 months (20±8 months) of rhGH treatment. Their mean serum creatinine level was 1.3±0.7 mg/dl 12 months before, and increased to 3.4±4.2 mg/dl after 12 months of rhGH treatment, but did not achieve statistical significance (P=0.06). Their mean calculated glomerular filtration rate was 58±20 ml/min per 1.73 m2 12 months before, and decreased to 38±21 ml/min per 1.73 m2 12 months before, and decreased to 38±21 ml/min per 1.73 m2 after 12 months of rhGH treatment, but did not achieve statistical significance (P=0.08). Of the seven patients, two developed acute rejection after 5 and 6 rejection-free years; three lost their grafts and returned to dialysis. These preliminary observations describe untoward renal events in children receiving rhGH treatment after a kidney transplant.

Hypogammaglobulinemia in uremic infants receiving peritoneal dialysis.

7. Borkowsky W, Krasinski K, Paul D~ et al. Human immunodeficiency virus infections in infants negative for anti-H1V by enzyme-linked immunoassay. Lancet 1987;1:1168-71. 8. Consortium for Retrovirus Serology Standardization. Serologic diagnosis of human immunodeficiency virus infection by Western blot testing. JAMA 1988;260:674-8. 9. Centers for Disease Control. Classification system for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection in children under 13 years of age. MMWR 1987;36:91-6. l 0. Johnson J, Davis E, Sbinaberry R, Nair P. Serologic responses to HIV infection in infants. Presented at the Fifth International Conference on AIDS, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, June 4-9, 1989. 11. Martin K, Katz B, Miller G. AIDS and antibodies to human immunodeficiency virus in children and their families. J Infect Dis 1987;155:54-9. 12. Epstein L, Boucher C, Morrison S, et al. Persistent human immunodeficiency virus type 1 antigenemia in children correlates with disease progression. Pediatrics 1988;82:919-24. 13. Ou C-Y, Kwok S, Mitchell SW, et al. DNA amplification for direct detection of HIV-1 in DNA of peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Science 1988;7:825-35. 14. Amadori A, De Rossi A, Gaguinto C, et al. In vitro production of HIV-specific antibody in children at risk of AIDS. Lancet 1988;1:852-4.