Thomas J. Baker

The relationship of the superficial and deep facial fascias: relevance to rhytidectomy and aging.

Controversy persists regarding the relationship of the superficial facial fascia (SMAS) to the mimetic muscles, deep facial fascia, and underlying facial nerve branches. Using fresh cadaver dissection, and supplemented by several hundred intraoperative dissections, we studied facial soft-tissue anatomy. The facial soft-tissue architecture can be described as being arranged in a series of concentric layers: skin, subcutaneous fat, superficial fascia, mimetic muscle, deep facial fascia (parotidomasseteric fascia), and the plane containing the facial nerve, parotid duct, and buccal fat pad. The anatomic relationships existing within the facial soft-tissue layers are (1) the superficial facial fascia invests the superficially situated mimetic muscles (platysma, orbicularis oculi, and zygomaticus major and minor); (2) the deep facial fascia represents a continuation of the deep cervical fascia cephalad into the face, the importance of which lies in the fact that the facial nerve branches within the cheek lie deep to this deep fascial layer; and (3) two types of relationships exist between the superficial and deep facial fascias: In some regions of the face, these fascial planes are separated by an areolar plane, and in other regions of the face, the superficial and deep fascia are intimately adherent to one another through a series of dense fibrous attachments. The layers of the facial soft tissue are supported in normal anatomic position by a series of retaining ligaments that run from deep, fixed facial structures to the overlying dermis. Two types of retaining ligaments are noted as defined by their origin, either from bone or from other fixed structures within the face. The significance of the retaining ligaments lies in the fact that as people age, the support from this ligamentous system becomes attenuated, leading to many of the stigmata of the aging face, such as the development of jowling and prominent nasolabial folds. The anatomic changes that occur in the aging face are delineated. With an adequate understanding of the anatomic changes that occur with aging, rhytidectomy can be approached as a reconstructive procedure, restoring facial soft tissue to its original anatomic state and location.

Long-term histologic follow-up of phenol face peels.

Deep phenol peels were done on 11 middle-aged white women with severe actinic damage. Subsequently, face lifts were carried out after periods of 1.5 to 20 years. This made it possible to obtain a full-thickness specimen extending several centimeters on either side of the border between peeled and unpeeled skin. In contrast to the markedly abnormal elastotic appearance of unpeeled skin, a new band of connective tissue 2 to 3 mm in width was laid down in the subepidermal region. Fine elastic fibers formed a dense network in the band of regenerated collagen. The disarray and cytologic abnormalities of sun-damaged epidermis were also largely corrected. Melanocytes were not eliminated, but melanin synthesis was evidently impaired, accounting for the bleaching effects. The effects of a phenol peel are very long lasting and adequately account for the effacement of wrinkles and obliteration of actinic keratoses, mottling, and freckling.

Histologic effects of the high-energy pulsed CO2 laser on photoaged facial skin.

To delineate the histologic effects of laser resurfacing at photoaged skin, a protocol was designed to biopsy laser test sites in conjunction with adjacent actinically damaged skin at the time of rhytidectomy. Five patients with photodamaged skin underwent resurfacing of the preauricular region to examine the effect of increasing pulse energy and increasing number of passes on depth of dermal penetration. Histologic examination of these specimens showed that the depth of laser injury was dose-dependent. Increasing pulse energy created a deeper wound, and increasing the number of passes similarly produced a larger band of necrosis. Ten patients with photodamaged skin underwent resurfacing of the preauricular region 15 days to 6 months prior to undergoing a rhytidectomy. A comparison of the laser-resurfaced test spot with the adjacent untreated photodamaged skin demonstrated consistent histologic changes to both epidermis and dermis in all specimens examined. Following laser resurfacing, epidermal atrophy and atypia were eliminated, and all specimens exhibited a regeneration of epithelium that was normal in its morphology. Melanocytic hypertrophy and hyperplasia were corrected following treatment, although density and function of epidermal melanocytes appeared normal. All specimens exhibited a substantial amount of neocollagen formation involving both the superficial and middermis following resurfacing. In association with new collagen development within the dermis, there was noted to be a similar degree of proliferation of elastic fibers, as well as a diminution of glycosaminoglycans, which are typically present in actinically damaged elastotic dermis. To determine the effect of laser resurfacing on-black skin, laser test spots were placed in the postauricular region of three black patients. Biopsy of these test sites showed that the histologic effects of laser resurfacing were similar to those observed in Caucasian patients, with complete repopulation of epidermal melanocytes in specimens biopsied 3 months following resurfacing. The histologic effects of laser resurfacing are microscopically similar to those of phenol peeling in terms of the amelioration of photodamage. The distinction between these two treatment methods lies in their apparent effect on epidermal melanocytes, which appear to function normally following laser resurfacing.

Nonsurgical breast enlargement using an external soft-tissue expansion system.

Less than 1 percent of the women interested in having larger breasts elect to have surgical augmentation mammaplasty with insertion of breast implants. The purpose of this report is to describe and test the efficacy of a nonsurgical method for breast enlargement that is based on the ability of tissues to grow when subjected to controlled distractive mechanical forces. Seventeen healthy women (aged 18 to 40 years) who were motivated to achieve breast enlargement were enrolled in a single-group study. The participants were asked to wear a brassiere-like system that applies a 20-mmHg vacuum distraction force to each breast for 10 to 12 hours/day over a 10-week period. Breast size was measured by three separate methods at regular intervals during and after treatment. Breast tissue water density and architecture were visualized before and after treatment by magnetic resonance imaging scans obtained in the same phase of the menstrual cycle. Twelve subjects completed the study; five withdrawals occurred due to protocol noncompliance. Breast size increased in all women over the 10-week treatment course and peaked at week 10 (final treatment); the average increase per woman was 98 ± 67 percent over starting size. Partial recoil was seen in the first week after terminating treatment, with no significant further size reduction after up to 30 weeks of follow-up. The stable long-term increase in breast size was 55 percent (range, 15 to 115 percent). Magnetic resonance images showed no edema and confirmed the proportionate enlargement of both adipose and fibroglandular tissue components. A statistically significant decrease in body weight occurred during the course of the study, and scores on the self-esteem questionnaire improved significantly. All participants were very pleased with the outcome and reported that the device was comfortable to wear. No adverse events were recorded during the use of the device or after treatment. We conclude that true breast enlargement can be achieved with the daily use of an appropriately designed external expansion system. This nonsurgical and noninvasive alternative for breast enlargement is effective and well tolerated.

Tissue-engineered breast reconstruction with Brava-assisted fat grafting: a 7-year, 488-patient, multicenter experience.

Background: The ability of autologous fat transfer to reconstruct an entire breast is not established. The authors harnessed the regenerative capabilities of external expansion and autologous fat transfer to completely reconstruct breasts. Methods: The authors performed 1877 Brava plus autologous fat transfer procedures on 616 breasts in 488 women to reconstruct 99 lumpectomies, 87 immediate breast reconstructions, and 430 delayed total breast reconstructions. After 2 to 4 weeks of Brava expansion, which increased volume by 100 to 300 percent, the authors diffusely grafted the breasts with 100 to 400 ml (225 ml average) of 15 g–sedimented, manually harvested lipoaspirate. The procedure was repeated every 8 to 14 weeks until completion. The authors compared costs of this reconstruction with established deep inferior epigastric artery perforator/transverse rectus abdominis musculocutaneous flaps and implant procedures. Results: Follow-up ranged from 6 months to 7 years (mean, 2.5 years), with 0.5 percent locoregional recurrence. Four hundred twenty-seven women completed the reconstruction, whereas 12.5 percent dropped out (2.5 percent medical, 10 percent personal reasons). Completion required 2.7 procedures for nonirradiated and 4.8 procedures for irradiated mastectomies. Patients recovered soft, natural appearing breasts with nearly normal sensation. Complications included five pneumothoraces and 20 ulcerative infections. Radiographically recognized benign palpable masses were observed in 12 percent of nonirradiated and 37 percent of irradiated breasts. The cost of Brava plus autologous fat transfer is 47 percent and 66 percent that of current reconstruction alternatives. Conclusion: Brava plus autologous fat transfer is a minimally invasive, incisionless, safe, economic, and effective alternative for breast reconstruction. CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic, IV.

Refinements in face lifting : Enhanced facial contour using Vicryl mesh incorporated into SMAS fixation

As we have gained experience with the extended superficial musculoaponeurotic system (SMAS) technique in face lifting, refinements in our procedure have led to increased consistency in results. The important factors that have led to our technical modifications include the following: (1) the significance of the retaining ligaments of the midface, which determine the degree of surgical dissection required for both skin and SMAS in rhytidectomy; (2) the changes in facial shape that occur with aging, secondary to the descent of facial fat; (3) the possibility of modifying facial shape through the repositioning of facial fat in an extended SMAS face lift; (4) the improved longevity of result to be obtained by incorporating Vicryl mesh into SMAS fixation; (5) the artistic nuances of incision design that help to minimize scar perceptibility. Understanding these factors enables surgeons to use the extended SMAS technique successfully with more challenging cases, enhancing facial appearance while minimizing signs that the patient has undergone a surgical procedure.

A controlled evaluation of dermabrasion versus CO2 laser resurfacing for the treatment of perioral wrinkles.

Facial skin treatments with laser resurfacing, dermabrasion, and chemical peels were responsible for a significant portion of the 2.7 million cosmetic procedures performed in 1998. Perioral wrinkles are a common problem for which plastic surgical consultation is obtained. The aim of this study was to compare and quantify the advantages and disadvantages of laser resurfacing versus dermabrasion in the treatment of perioral wrinkles. Twenty female patients provided informed consent and participated in the study. Half of the perioral area was treated with dermabrasion and half was treated with the UltraPulse CO2 laser. The two procedures were compared using high-quality photographs; a biophysical evaluation of skin color, hydration, and mechanical properties; and patient evaluation of outcomes. Photographs were evaluated by 10 board-certified plastic surgeons who were blinded to the treatment methods. The laser treatment had a significantly higher erythema score at 1 month and a small but significantly greater improvement in perioral wrinkles at 6 months. Thirteen subjects selected the laser treatment as producing the best result, despite the greater intraoperative pain for this procedure. Biomechanical measurements suggest that the laser treatment produced a skin state more similar to skin in younger patients, presumably with higher levels and/or greater organization of the collagen and elastin. Patient preference was inferred from the resurfacing method that they would recommend to a friend. Although the laser was selected as the best result in a majority of cases, patient preference was equally distributed between the two treatments. The authors think that by studying and quantifying the biophysical changes that occur as a result of CO2 laser resurfacing, greater improvements in restoring actinic damage (e.g., wrinkles) can be achieved. Patients consider more than the objective skin changes from a resurfacing technique when making a recommendation to a friend.

Chemical Face Peeling and Dermabrasion

While there are many similarities between dermabrasion and chemosurgery, their indications are clearly different, and the histological changes produced are not the same.

Chemical peel: a change in the routine.

The use of occlusive taping following phenol chemical peel has become a standard technique. Many studies have demonstrated the effectiveness of tape occlusion in producing a deeper, more profound chemical peel. For the last 18 months, we have abandoned tape occlusion following phenol peel and have substituted an occlusive dressing using a thick layer of petroleum jelly (Vaseline). The occlusiveness provided by the petroleum jelly has proved to be almost as effective as the standard tape mask, and the results using this technique parallel those with a tape mask. The advantages of Vaseline occlusive dressing include greater patient comfort, the ability to evaluate the wound beneath the petroleum jelly, and the prevention of streaking, which can occur from uneven tape application. Eschar formation and crust separation are avoided after the peel by the constant use of facial lubricants, our preference being A & D ointment.

Upper lid blepharoplasty.

We reviewed, retrospectively, our upper lid blepharoplasties to critically compare our own postoperative results after (1) conventional blepharoplasty, or (2) fixation of the levator aponeurosis to the lower margin of the orbicularis, or (3) fixation of the levator to the lower margins of the orbicularis and the skin. We found no demonstrable difference in our results with these 3 techniques. It is our opinion that the standard conventional blepharoplasty (including excision of a strip of orbicularis muscle) is preferable for use in most caucasian eyelids. The results are as good, it is simple, and it is less likely to cause problems.