Tim J. Fitzmaurice

The stability and aggregation of ovine prion protein associated with classical and atypical scrapie correlates with the ease of unwinding of helix-2.

Susceptibility to scrapie disease in sheep, the archetypal prion disease, correlates with polymorphisms within the ovine PrP (prion-related protein) gene. The VRQ (Val136Arg154Gln171) and AL141RQ (Ala136Leu141Arg154Gln171) allelic variants are associated with classical scrapie, whereas the ARR (Ala136Arg154Arg171), AF141RQ (Ala136Phe141Arg154Gln171) and AHQ (Ala136His154Gln171) allelic variants are associated with atypical scrapie. Recent studies have suggested that there are differences in the stability of PrPSc (abnormal disease-specific conformation of PrP) associated with these different forms of scrapie. To address which structural features of ovine PrP may contribute to this difference, in the present study we have investigated the conformational stability and susceptibility to aggregation of allelic variants of ovine PrP associated with classical or atypical scrapie. We find that the melting temperature of ovine recombinant VRQ and AL141RQ PrP is higher than that of AF141RQ, AHQ and ARR. In addition, monoclonal-antibody studies show that the region around helix-1 of VRQ and AL141RQ is less accessible compared with other ovine PrP allelic variants. Furthermore, the extent of both the structural change to copper-ion-treatment and denaturant-induced aggregation was reduced in PrP associated with atypical scrapie compared with PrP associated with classical scrapie. Through the use of molecular dynamics simulations we have found that these biochemical and biophysical properties of ovine PrP correlate with the ease of unwinding of helix-2 and a concurrent conformational change of the helix-2-helix-3 loop. These results reveal significant differences in the overall stability and potential for aggregation of different allelic variants of ovine PrP and consequently have implications for the differences in stability of PrPSc associated with classical and atypical scrapie.

Conformational variation between allelic variants of cell-surface ovine prion protein

The distribution of prion infectivity and PrPSc between peripheral lymphoid tissues suggests their possible haematogenic spread during the progression of natural scrapie in susceptible sheep. Since ovine PBMCs (peripheral blood mononuclear cells) express PrPC, they have the potential to carry or harbour disease-associated forms of PrP. To detect the possible presence of disease-associated PrP on the surface of blood cells, an understanding is required of the conformations that normal ovine cell-surface PrPC may adopt. In the present study, we have used monoclonal antibodies that recognize epitopes in either the N- or C-terminal portions of PrP to probe the conformations of PrPC on ovine PBMCs by flow cytometry. Although PBMCs from scrapie-susceptible and -resistant genotypes of sheep expressed similar levels of cell-surface PrPC, as judged by their reactivity with N-terminal-specific anti-PrP monoclonal antibodies, there was considerable genotypic heterogeneity in the region between helix-1 and residue 171. Cells from PrP-VRQ (V136R154Q171) sheep showed uniform reactivity with monoclonal antibodies that bound to epitopes around helix-1, whereas cells from PrP-ARQ (A136R154Q171) and PrP-ARR (A136R154R171) sheep showed variable binding. The region between b-strand-2 and residue 171, which includes a YYR motif, was buried or obscured in cell-surface PrPC on PBMCs from scrapie-susceptible and -resistant sheep. However, an epitope of PrPC that is influenced by residue 171 was more exposed on PBMCs from PrP-VRQ sheep than on PBMCs from the PrP-ARQ genotype. Our results highlight conformational variation between scrapie-susceptible and -resistant forms of cell-surface PrPC and also between allelic variants of susceptible genotypes.

Ovine plasma prion protein levels show genotypic variation detected by C-terminal epitopes not exposed in cell-surface PrPC

Ovine PBMCs (peripheral blood mononuclear cells) express PrP(C) [cellular PrP (prion-related protein)] and have the potential to harbour and release disease-associated forms of PrP during scrapie in sheep. Cell-surface PrP(C) expression by PBMCs, together with plasma PrP(C) levels, may contribute to the regulatory mechanisms that determine susceptibility and resistance to natural scrapie in sheep. Here, we have correlated cell-surface PrP(C) expression on normal ovine PBMCs by FACS with the presence of PrP(C) in plasma measured by capture-detector immunoassay. FACS showed similar levels of cell-surface PrP(C) on homozygous ARR (Ala136-Arg154-Arg171), ARQ (Ala136-Arg154-Gln171) and VRQ (Val136-Arg154-Gln171) PBMCs. Cell-surface ovine PrP(C) showed modulation of N-terminal epitopes, which was more evident on homozygous ARR cells. Ovine plasma PrP(C) levels showed genotypic variation and the protein displayed C-terminal epitopes not available in cell-surface PrP(C). Homozygous VRQ sheep showed the highest plasma PrP(C) level and homozygous ARR animals the lowest. For comparison, similar analyses were performed on normal bovine PBMCs and plasma. PrP(C) levels in bovine plasma were approx. 4-fold higher than ovine homozygous ARQ plasma despite similar levels of PBMC cell-surface PrP(C) expression. Immunoassays using C-terminal-specific anti-PrP monoclonal antibodies as capture and detector reagents revealed the highest level of PrP(C) in both ovine and bovine plasma, whilst lower levels were detected using N-terminal-specific monoclonal antibody FH11 as the capture reagent. This suggested that a proportion of plasma PrP(C) was N-terminally truncated. Our results indicate that the increased susceptibility to natural scrapie displayed by homozygous VRQ sheep correlates with a higher level of plasma PrP(C).

Copper-induced structural changes in the ovine prion protein are influenced by a polymorphism at codon 112

Prion diseases are associated with conformational change in the copper-binding protein PrP. The copper-binding sites in PrP are located in the N-terminal region of the molecule and comprise a series of tandem repeats of the sequence PHGGGWGQ together with two histidines at residues 96 and 111 (human PrP numbering). The co-ordination of copper ions within the non-octapeptide repeat metal ion-binding site involves Met109 (human numbering, which corresponds with Met112 in ovine PrP) and the binding of copper to this site leads to an increase in beta-sheet formation in PrP. Here we have investigated the influence of the M112T polymorphism on copper-induced structural changes in ovine recombinant PrP. M112ARQ and T112ARQ ovine PrP show similar secondary structure although M112ARQ appears more thermostable than T112ARQ. Following treatment with copper, M112ARQ showed a greater increase in beta-sheet content than did T112ARQ when measured by CD spectroscopy and by ELISA using anti-PrP monoclonal antibodies. These biochemical and biophysical differences between M112ARQ and T112ARQ correlate with similar differences seen between allelic variants of ovine PrP associated with susceptibility and resistance to classical scrapie. These observations suggest that T112ARQ may provide a measure of resistance to classical scrapie pathogenesis compared to M112ARQ.

Antiviral activity of CTC-8 against herpes simplex virus (HSV-1) in cell culture: evidence for a selective antiviral effect via a cellular mechanism.

A synthetic programme produced a series of compounds related to natural prostaglandins, which are known to affect the growth of a number of viruses. Several of the compounds showed potent biological activity including antiviral effects. The compound CTC-8 [(S)-4-tert-butyldimethylsilyloxy-2-cyclopenten-1-one] contains the cyclopentenone ring of prostaglandin A1, but the extended side chains common to the prostaglandin family are truncated. The present study demonstrates that CTC-8 inhibits HSV-1 replication in cell culture at sub-toxic concentrations. The antiviral effect was evidenced by reduction in infectious virus yield, although the compound was not effective in the standard plaque-reduction assay. Time-of-addition studies and other experiments provide a possible explanation for these results by suggesting that the antiviral activity is confined to a single cycle. Under the standard conditions of high-multiplicity infection in BHK cells it was notable that CTC-8 is most effective when added for a short period 6–8 h post-infection. Furthermore, multiple passage of HSV-1 in the presence of CTC-8 did not result in the selection of resistant mutants. The results of these and other experiments are consistent with the hypothesis that the mechanism by which CTC-8 inhibits virus replication involves a cellular target. These results encourage further research into the therapeutic potential of this series of compounds.

Rapid expression of polymorphic ovine prion proteins and studies on their protease sensitivity.

We have used coupled and uncoupled in vitro transcription/translation to express rapidly aglycosyl ovine prion proteins from ovine genomic DNA genotyped for scrapie susceptible and nonsusceptible polymorphisms. Unlike previous in vitro studies of prion proteins, this method does not require cloning or laborious extractions. To our knowledge, this is the first report of ovine PrP expression at low (ng) levels under the control of an Escherichia coli promoter and ribosome binding site both coded for in the polymerase chain reaction primer. The rapidity of this approach could form the basis of a high throughput screening assay for PrP interactions, as proteins were expressed in a matter of hours from genomic DNA as the starting material. There was no difference observed in proteinase K sensitivity between prion translation products containing either scrapie susceptible or nonsusceptible polymorphisms.