Timo Frensing

High yields of influenza A virus in Madin-Darby canine kidney cells are promoted by an insufficient interferon-induced antiviral state

Because of their high susceptibility to infection with various influenza virus strains, Madin-Darby canine kidney (MDCK) cells have been widely used as a substrate for influenza virus isolation and vaccine production. However, MDCK cells are also interferon (IFN) competent, and the type I IFN response is commonly thought to be a factor strongly inhibiting virus replication. Therefore, the inhibition of influenza virus replication by IFN signalling was analysed for an adherent MDCK cell line used in vaccine manufacturing. Depending on the respective virus strain, different levels of IFN induction and a corresponding upregulation of the IFN-induced myxovirus resistance protein 1 (Mx1) were observed. Suppression of IFN induction by transient expression of the viral non-structural protein 1 protein enhanced replication of an influenza virus lacking NS1, but not wild-type strains. In agreement with this, stimulation of cells with MDCK cell-derived IFN prior to infection resulted only in a decrease in replication rate, and not in a change of final yields for wild-type influenza viruses. This lack of IFN-induced antiviral activity correlated with missing anti-influenza activity of MDCK Mx proteins. No inhibitory effect on viral polymerase activity was found for canine Mx1 (cMx1) and cMx2 in minireplicon assays. In conclusion, in MDCK cells, IFN expression is not a limiting factor for influenza virus replication and this might partially be caused by a lack of anti-influenza activity of canine Mx proteins.

Modeling the Intracellular Dynamics of Influenza Virus Replication To Understand the Control of Viral RNA Synthesis

ABSTRACT Influenza viruses transcribe and replicate their negative-sense RNA genome inside the nucleus of host cells via three viral RNA species. In the course of an infection, these RNAs show distinct dynamics, suggesting that differential regulation takes place. To investigate this regulation in a systematic way, we developed a mathematical model of influenza virus infection at the level of a single mammalian cell. It accounts for key steps of the viral life cycle, from virus entry to progeny virion release, while focusing in particular on the molecular mechanisms that control viral transcription and replication. We therefore explicitly consider the nuclear export of viral genome copies (vRNPs) and a recent hypothesis proposing that replicative intermediates (cRNA) are stabilized by the viral polymerase complex and the nucleoprotein (NP). Together, both mechanisms allow the model to capture a variety of published data sets at an unprecedented level of detail. Our findings provide theoretical support for an early regulation of replication by cRNA stabilization. However, they also suggest that the matrix protein 1 (M1) controls viral RNA levels in the late phase of infection as part of its role during the nuclear export of viral genome copies. Moreover, simulations show an accumulation of viral proteins and RNA toward the end of infection, indicating that transport processes or budding limits virion release. Thus, our mathematical model provides an ideal platform for a systematic and quantitative evaluation of influenza virus replication and its complex regulation.

Multiscale Modeling of Influenza A Virus Infection Supports the Development of Direct-Acting Antivirals

Influenza A viruses are respiratory pathogens that cause seasonal epidemics with up to 500,000 deaths each year. Yet there are currently only two classes of antivirals licensed for treatment and drug-resistant strains are on the rise. A major challenge for the discovery of new anti-influenza agents is the identification of drug targets that efficiently interfere with viral replication. To support this step, we developed a multiscale model of influenza A virus infection which comprises both the intracellular level where the virus synthesizes its proteins, replicates its genome, and assembles new virions and the extracellular level where it spreads to new host cells. This integrated modeling approach recapitulates a wide range of experimental data across both scales including the time course of all three viral RNA species inside an infected cell and the infection dynamics in a cell population. It also allowed us to systematically study how interfering with specific steps of the viral life cycle affects virus production. We find that inhibitors of viral transcription, replication, protein synthesis, nuclear export, and assembly/release are most effective in decreasing virus titers whereas targeting virus entry primarily delays infection. In addition, our results suggest that for some antivirals therapy success strongly depends on the lifespan of infected cells and, thus, on the dynamics of virus-induced apoptosis or the hosts immune response. Hence, the proposed model provides a systems-level understanding of influenza A virus infection and therapy as well as an ideal platform to include further levels of complexity toward a comprehensive description of infectious diseases.

Single-cell analysis and stochastic modelling unveil large cell-to-cell variability in influenza A virus infection

Biochemical reactions are subject to stochastic fluctuations that can give rise to cell-to-cell variability. Yet, how this variability affects viral infections, which themselves involve noisy reactions, remains largely elusive. Here we present single-cell experiments and stochastic simulations that reveal a large heterogeneity between influenza A virus (IAV)-infected cells. In particular, experimental data show that progeny virus titres range from 1 to 970 plaque-forming units and intracellular viral RNA (vRNA) levels span three orders of magnitude. Moreover, the segmentation of IAV genomes seems to increase the susceptibility of their replication to noise, since the level of different genome segments can vary substantially within a cell. In addition, simulations suggest that the abortion of virus entry and random degradation of vRNAs can result in a large fraction of non-productive cells after single-hit infection. These results challenge current beliefs that cell population measurements and deterministic simulations are an accurate representation of viral infections.

Continuous Influenza Virus Production in Cell Culture Shows a Periodic Accumulation of Defective Interfering Particles

Influenza viruses are a major public health burden during seasonal epidemics and a continuous threat due to their potential to cause pandemics. Annual vaccination provides the best protection against the contagious respiratory illness caused by influenza viruses. However, the current production capacities for influenza vaccines are insufficient to meet the increasing demands. We explored the possibility to establish a continuous production process for influenza viruses using the duck-derived suspension cell line AGE1.CR. A two-stage bioreactor setup was designed in which cells were cultivated in a first stirred tank reactor where an almost constant cell concentration was maintained. Cells were then constantly fed to a second bioreactor where virus infection and replication took place. Using this two-stage reactor system, it was possible to continuously produce influenza viruses. Surprisingly, virus titers showed a periodic increase and decrease during the run-time of 17 days. These titer fluctuations were caused by the presence of defective interfering particles (DIPs), which we detected by PCR. Mathematical modeling confirmed this observation showing that constant virus titers can only emerge in the absence of DIPs. Even with very low amounts of DIPs in the seed virus and very low rates for de novo DIP generation, defective viruses rapidly accumulate and, therefore, represent a serious challenge for continuous vaccine production. Yet, the continuous replication of influenza virus using a two-stage bioreactor setup is a novel tool to study aspects of viral evolution and the impact of DIPs.

Impact of defective interfering particles on virus replication and antiviral host response in cell culture-based influenza vaccine production

During the replication of influenza viruses, defective interfering particles (DIPs) can be generated. These are noninfectious deletion mutants that require coinfection with a wild-type virus but interfere with its helper virus replication. Consequently, coinfected cells mainly produce DIPs. Little is known about how such noninfectious virus particles affect the virus yield of cell culture-based influenza vaccine production. We compared infections of Madin-Darby canine kidney cells with two seed virus preparations of the influenza virus strain A/Puerto Rico/8/34 that contain different amounts of DIPs. A combination of conventional RT-PCR, RT-qPCR, and flow cytometry revealed that DI genomes indeed strongly accumulate in coinfected cells and impede the viral RNA synthesis. Additionally, cells infected at the higher DIP concentration showed a stronger antiviral response characterized by increased interferon-β expression and apoptosis induction. Furthermore, in the presence of DIPs, a significant fraction of cells did not show any productive accumulation of viral proteins at all. Together, these effects of DIPs significantly reduce the virus yield. Therefore, the accumulation of DIPs should be avoided during influenza vaccine production which can be achieved by quality controls of working seed viruses based on conventional RT-PCR. The strategy for the depletion of DIPs presented here can help to make cell culture-based vaccine production more reliable and robust.

Defective interfering viruses and their impact on vaccines and viral vectors

Defective interfering particles (DIPs) have been found for many important viral pathogens and it is believed that most viruses generate DIPs. This article reviews the current knowledge of the generation and amplification of DIPs, which possess deletions in the viral genome but retain the ability to replicate in the presence of a complete helper virus. In addition, mechanisms are discussed by which DIPs interfere with the replication of their helper virus leading to the production of mainly progeny DIPs by coinfected cells. Even though DIPs cannot replicate on their own, they are biologically active and it is well known that they have a huge impact on virus replication, evolution, and pathogenesis. Moreover, defective genomes are potent inducers of the innate immune response. Yet, little attention has been paid to DIPs in recent years and their impact on biotechnological products such as vaccines and viral vectors remains elusive in most cases. With a focus on influenza virus, this review demonstrates that DIPs are important for basic research on viruses and for the production of viral vaccines and vectors. Reducing the generation and/or amplification of DIPs ensures reproducible results as well as high yields and consistent product quality in virus production.

Differential activation of host cell signalling pathways through infection with two variants of influenza A/Puerto Rico/8/34 (H1N1) in MDCK cells.

In cell culture-based influenza vaccine production, few efforts have been undertaken to characterise virus-host cell interactions in detail. Two influenza virus strains that grew to different virus titres, and differed in virus dynamics, apoptosis induction and proteome changes were observed. In order to elucidate biological mechanisms related to these differences, the induction of signalling cascades in adherent MDCK cells infected with two variants of influenza A/PuertoRico/8/34 (H1N1) was analysed. The pathways chosen for analysis are key components of the innate immune response and crucial for influenza A virus replication (NF-κB, IRF-3, PI3K-Akt, Jak-Stat, Raf/MEK/ERK, PKR/eIF2α). Interestingly, all investigated pathways were induced stronger by PR8-NIBSC than by PR8-RKI, the virus variant which results in higher virus titres. In particular, PR8-NIBSC infection lead to a higher induction of IFN-beta as well as IFN-stimulated gene expression, which was confirmed by Western blot as well as real-time PCR. Overall, results obtained clearly facilitate interpretation of observations regarding proteome changes and virus-induced apoptosis in cell culture-based vaccine manufacturing processes and support efforts towards design of improved host cell lines.

Modeling the intracellular replication of influenza A virus in the presence of defective interfering RNAs.

Like many other viral pathogens, influenza A viruses can form defective interfering particles (DIPs). These particles carry a large internal deletion in at least one of their genome segments. Thus, their replication depends on the co-infection of cells by standard viruses (STVs), which supply the viral protein(s) encoded by the defective segment. However, DIPs also interfere with STV replication at the molecular level and, despite considerable research efforts, the mechanism of this interference remains largely elusive. Here, we present a mechanistic mathematical model for the intracellular replication of DIPs. In this model, we account for the common hypothesis that defective interfering RNAs (DI RNAs) possess a replication advantage over full-length (FL) RNAs due to their reduced length. By this means, the model captures experimental data from yield reduction assays and from studies testing different co-infection timings. In addition, our model predicts that one important aspect of interference is the competition for viral proteins, namely the heterotrimeric viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) and the viral nucleoprotein (NP), which are needed for encapsidation of naked viral RNA. Moreover, we find that there may be an optimum for both the DI RNA synthesis rate and the time point of successive co-infection of a cell by DIPs and STVs. Comparing simulations for the growth of DIPs with a deletion in different genome segments suggests that DI RNAs derived from segments which encode for the polymerase subunits are more competitive than others. Overall, our model, thus, helps to elucidate the interference mechanism of DI RNAs and provides a novel hypothesis why DI RNAs derived from the polymerase-encoding segments are more abundant in DIP preparations.

Efficient influenza B virus propagation due to deficient interferon-induced antiviral activity in MDCK cells

Influenza B virus infections are mainly restricted to humans, which is partially caused by the inability of influenza B virus NS1 protein to counteract the innate immune response of other species. However, for cell culture-based influenza vaccine production non-human cells, such as Madin-Darby canine kidney (MDCK) cells, are commonly used. Therefore, the impact of cellular pathogen defence mechanisms on influenza B virus propagation in MDCK cells was analysed in this study. Activation of the cellular antiviral defence by interferon stimulation slowed down influenza B virus replication at early time points but after 48h the same virus titres were reached in stimulated and control cells. Furthermore, suppression of the antiviral host defence by transient expression of a viral antagonist, the rabies virus phosphoprotein, could not increase influenza B virus replication. Finally, canine Myxovirus resistance (Mx) proteins showed no antiviral activity in an influenza B virus-specific minireplicon assay in contrast to the murine Mx1 protein. Taken together, these results indicate that an insufficient antiviral defence in MDCK cells promotes efficient influenza B virus replication favouring the use of MDCK cells in influenza vaccine production.