Timothy Debacker

The Cambrian to mid Devonian basin development and deformation history of Eastern Avalonia, east of the Midlands Microcraton: new data and a review

Abstract A review is given of recently published and new data on Avalonia east of the Midlands Microcraton. The three megasequences from Cambrian to mid Devonian described in Wales and Welsh Borderland are also present east of the Midlands Microcraton (Brabant Massif, Condroz, Ardennes, Remscheid and Ebbe inliers, Krefeld high). The three megasequences are caused by a tectonic driving mechanism and are explained by three different geodynamic contexts: an earlier phase with extensional basins or rifting and rather thick sequences, when Avalonia was still attached to Gondwana; a second phase with a shelf basin with moderately thin sequences when Avalonia was a separate continent and a later phase with a shelf or foreland basin development and thick sequences. Deformation of the megasequences 1 and 2 or 1 to 3 varies between areas. In Wales and the Lake District the Acadian phase is long-lived and active from early to mid Devonian. In the Ardennes inliers a deformation is active between the late Ordovician and the Silurian (Ardennian Phase), with a similar intensity as the core of the Brabant Massif, when present erosion levels are compared. The Brabant Massif is partly deformed by the long-lived Brabantian Phase from late Silurian till early mid Devonian. Both the Ardennes inliers and the Brabant Massif are not classic orogenic belts, only slate belts where no more than the epizone is reached at present erosion levels. Areas supposedly close to the microcraton or basement are nearly undeformed (SW Brabant Massif and central Condroz). A model of anticlockwise rotation of Avalonia of about 55° from Caradoc to Emsian is proposed to explain the deposition setting of megasequence 3 and the subsequent Acadian and Brabantian deformation. Immediately after the Avalonian microcontinent touched Baltica in Caradoc times it created a short-lived subduction magmatic event from The Wash to the Brabant Massif and soon after the magmatism ended a foreland basin developed. Possibly during and after that development a long-lived and slow compressional event occurred, leading to the deformation of the Anglo-Brabant Deformation Belt. In the early Devonian, contemporaneous with the shortening of the Anglo-Brabant Deformation Belt, extension occurred in the Rheno-Hercynian Zone, possibly caused by the same slow rotation of Avalonia. More evidence emerges that Avalonia east of the Midlands Microcraton comprises not one but probably two terranes: the remnant of the palaeocontinent Avalonia, and what is called the palaeocontinent Far Eastern Avalonia; the latter is only occasionally observed in the few deep boreholes into the Heligoland-Pomerania Deformation Belt, in southern Denmark, NE Germany and NW Poland, with scant available indirect data in between indicating only Proterozoic basement and no Caledonian deformation. For Far Eastern Avalonia a similar palaeogeographical history is postulated as Avalonia, with rifting from Gondwana in Arenig or earlier times, collision with Baltica before the mid-Ashgill and deformation between the late Ordovician and latest Silurian. The Avalonia concept might need to be expanded to an ‘Avalonian Terrane Assemblage’ with cratonic cores and small short-lived oceans as in the Armorican Terrane Assemblage.

The anisotropy of magnetic susceptibility (AMS) in low-grade, cleaved pelitic rocks: influence of cleavage/bedding angle and type and relative orientation of magnetic carriers

Abstract Cambrian and Silurian, low-grade, pelitic rocks of the single-phase deformed Brabant Massif consistently have a maximum magnetic susceptibility axis (K1) parallel to the cleavage/bedding intersection. In contrast, the minimum susceptibility axis (K3) either coincides with the bedding pole, with the cleavage pole or occupies an intermediate position. Anisotropy of anhysteretic remanence (AARM) and X-ray pole figure goniometry allow the distinguishing of the orientation distributions of the ferromagnetic and paramagnetic (white mica and chlorite) carriers, respectively. Mismatches between K3 and the poles to the macroscopic fabric elements (i.e. bedding and cleavage) are attributed to different orientations of the different magnetic (s.l.) carriers. A strong relationship exists between the cleavage/bedding angle and the shape parameter: low, respectively high angles leading to oblate, respectively prolate susceptibility ellipsoids. However, differences are observed between the Cambrian and Silurian samples in terms of the shape parameter and the behaviour of the degree of anisotropy with changing cleavage/bedding angle. This is tentatively attributed to differences in relative orientation and mineralogy of the magnetic (s.l.) carriers. These results demonstrate the influence of the relative orientation of the different carriers on AMS and suggest that, although being a petrofabric tool, AMS cannot be used as a strain gauge in the case of composite magnetic fabrics.

Large-scale slumping deduced from structural and sedimentary features in the Lower Palaeozoic Anglo-Brabant fold belt, Belgium

Distinguishing slump folds from tectonic folds in poorly exposed areas can be difficult, especially when the scale of the slump folds exceeds outcrop scale. In the southeastern part of the single-phase deformed, Lower Palaeozoic Anglo-Brabant fold belt a comparison of cleavage/fold relationships and stratigraphic polarity shows that a 200 m thick interval of middle Caradoc fine-grained turbidites in the core of a large synform was overturned prior to tectonic deformation. This overturning is attributed to large-scale slumping, which was most likely a result of middle Caradoc seismic activity. The exposed portion of the large slump sheet contains only a few small slump folds and intraformational breccias, making up less than 5% of the exposed thickness. If the beds were not overturned, large-scale slumping would never be suspected and the small slump folds would probably be interpreted as localized features in an overall ‘stable’ sedimentary pile. This may explain why so few ancient large-scale slides and slumps have been reported: the small amount of internal deformation makes them very difficult to recognize, especially when dealing with poorly exposed areas. As such, large ancient slides and slumps may be more common than suggested by the geological literature.

Fluid flow, alteration and polysulphide mineralisation associated with a low-angle reverse shear zone in the Lower Palaeozoic of the Anglo-Brabant fold belt, Belgium

Abstract In the Lower Palaeozoic rocks of the Brabant Massif (Belgium), a recently discovered polysulphide mineralisation is related to a low-angle reverse shear zone. This shear zone has been attributed to the main early Devonian deformation event. Data from boreholes and outcrops allow a detailed investigation of the alteration pattern and palaeofluid flow along this shear zone. Macroscopic observations of the mineralogy and quantitative changes in the phyllosilicate mineralogy indicate that this shear zone is characterised by an envelope of intense sericitisation and silicification. In addition, chloritisation is associated with this alteration. The alteration zone may reach a thickness of 250 m. Ore mineralisation occurred synkinematically and is spatially related to the shear zone. The mineralisation consists of pyrite, marcasite, arsenopyrite, pyrrhotite, chalcopyrite, sphalerite, galena, stibnite and smaller amounts of tetrahedrite and other sulphosalts. It is concentrated in quartz–sulphide veins or occurs diffusely in the host rock. The mineralising fluids have a low-salinity H 2 O–CO 2 –CH 4 –NaCl–(KCl) composition and a minimum temperature of 250–320 °C. The δ 18 O values of quartz vary between +12.3‰ and +14.5‰ SMOW, and δ D compositions of the fluid inclusions in the quartz crystals range from −65‰ to −35‰ V-SMOW. The δ D and the calculated δ 18 O values of the mineralising fluids fall in the range typical for metamorphic fluids and partly overlap with that for primary magmatic fluids. The δ 34 S values, between +4.7‰ and +10.6‰ CDT, fall outside the interval typical for I-type magmas. Important migration of likely metamorphic fluids, causing a widespread alteration and a polysulphide mineralisation along a low-angle shear zone, has, thus, been identified for the first time in the Caledonian Anglo-Brabant fold belt.

Cleavage/fold relationships in the Silurian metapelites, southeastern Anglo-Brabant fold belt (Ronquières, Belgium)

The presence of convergent cleavage fans in folded Silurian pelitic deposits along the southern extremity of the Brabant Massif has commonly been considered as an indication for a polyphase deformation history. Recent field work on the classic section at Ronquières shows, however, that all the structural elements can be explained by a single progressive deformation, taking place at gradually higher structural levels. This deformation is considered to have occurred at the time of the Acadian orogeny. The section under study contains a fold train of five gentle to open first-order folds, unconformably overlain by gently S-dipping Givetian rocks. Although the Silurian turbidite deposits are predominantly pelitic, the folds are characterized by convergent cleavage fans. The trend of the cleavage fan axes remains constant in the various folds throughout the section. In contrast, the trend of the folds hinge lines gradually changes along the section from a clockwise relation with the cleavage fan axis in the northern part (anticlockwise cleavage transection) towards an anticlockwise relation in the southern part (clockwise cleavage transection). Individual fault/fault intersections have a constant trend throughout the section, parallel to the cleavage fan axes and the mean fold hinge line. Small kink bands and small transverse joints reflect the same structural trend. The coaxial disposition of the structural elements seems at first sight incompatible with the presence of both clockwise and anticlockwise cleavage-transected folds. This disposition may, however, be explained by an en-echelon periclinal nature of the fold train, possibly formed in a slightly constrictional deformation environment.

Faults in the Asquempont area, southern Brabant Massif, Belgium

The literature suggests that the Asquempont fault, a supposedly important reverse fault forming the limit between the Lower to lower Middle Cambrian and the Ordovician in the Sennette valley, is poorly understood. Nevertheless, this fault is commonly equated with a pronounced NW-SE-trending aeromagnetic lineament, the Asquempont lineament, and both the geometry of the Asquempont lineament and the supposed reverse movement of the Asquempont fault are used to develop large-scale tectonic models of the Brabant Massif. New outcrop observations in the Asquempont area, the “type locality” of the Asquempont fault, in combination with outcrop and borehole data from surrounding areas, show that the Asquempont fault is not an important reverse fault, but instead represents a pre-cleavage, low-angle extensional detachment. This detachment formed between the Caradoc and the timing of folding and cleavage development and is not related to the aeromagnetic Asquempont lineament. The Asquempont area also contains several relatively important, steep, post-cleavage normal faults. Apparently, these occur in a WNW-ESE-trending zone between Asquempont and Fauquez, extending westward over Quenast towards Bierghes. This zone coincides with the eastern part of the WNW-ESE-trending Nieuwpoort-Asquempont fault zone, for which, on the basis of indirect observations, previously a strike-slip movement has been proposed. Our outcrop observations question this presumed strike-slip movement. The Asquempont fault may be related to the progressive unroofing of the core of the Brabant Massif from the Silurian onwards. Possibly, other low-angle extensional detachments similar to the Asquempont fault occur in other parts of the massif. Possible candidates are the paraconformity-like contacts depicted on the most recent geological map of the Brabant Massif.

Transitional geometries between gently plunging and steeply plunging folds: an example from the Lower Palaeozoic Brabant Massif, Anglo-Brabant deformation belt, Belgium

Although many studies have dealt with markedly different fold orientations and associated cleavage–fold relationships within individual, single-phase deformed fold belts, there are very few descriptions of possible gradual, transitional fold geometries. The Lower Cambrian steep core of the single-phase deformed Brabant Massif contains steeply plunging, west-facing folds with a Z-shaped asymmetry, whereas the Ordovician–Silurian southern rim consists of gently plunging, upward facing folds. A gradual transition is observed between these end-member orientations, in a NW–SE-trending zone 1–1.5 km wide, in which the folds appear to be strongly curvilinear and locally downward facing. The structural geometries within this transition zone are described in detail and the geometric changes analysed in the light of the fold transition. The strongly variable fold orientations are tentatively attributed to a bulk oblate tectonic strain. The transition zone overlies an aeromagnetic lineament, classically interpreted as a dextral shear zone. The steeply plunging folds, the transition zone and the aeromagnetic lineaments are all attributed to a local dextral transpression, in which deformation is partitioned both vertically and laterally. The results indicate that within zones of heterogeneous transpression, the different deformation domains are not necessarily always fault bounded.

Influence of slump folds on tectonic folds: an example from the Lower Ordovician of the Anglo-Brabant Deformation Belt (Belgium)

Although it is generally accepted that buckle folds will not develop in a perfectly planar layer without the presence of some irregularity or perturbation at which the folds initiate, there are very few cases in which individual natural folds can be linked to specific irregularities. Within the Lower Ordovician Abbaye de Villers Formation, Anglo-Brabant Deformation Belt, metre-scale tectonic folds occur, of which the position and, to a certain extent, the geometry appear to be controlled by slump folds and related features. The metre-scale tectonic folds, interpreted as parasitic structures on the limb of a large-scale host fold, occur only within a stratigraphic level affected by slumping. In this level, tectonic antiforms tend to form superimposed on antiformal slump folds and on zones of abrupt, slump-related thickness increase, and tectonic synforms on synformal slump folds and on zones of abrupt thickness decrease.   The rather irregular 3D geometry of sedimentary sequences suggests that many more similar cases should exist in which folds can be linked to specific irregularities. However, possibly it is also this abundance of irregularities in sedimentary sequences, in combination with fold and outcrop scale, that makes it difficult to attribute a particular fold to a particular perturbation.

Complexity of the Anisotropy of Magnetic Susceptibility in Single-Phase Deformed, Low-Grade, Cleaved Mudstone

The anisotropy of magnetic susceptibility (AMS) is often interpreted in terms of strain. However, since AMS is controlled by all magnetic (s.l.) carriers present, an AMS interpretation is not straightforward, especially in the presence of composite magnetic fabrics. Considering the large number of factors that may influence rock mineralogy (e.g. sediment source area, metamorphism), it becomes clear that one cannot interpret AMS in terms of strain without applying additional techniques that allow determining the nature and preferred orientation of all magnetic (s.l.) carriers likely influencing the measured AMS. This is discussed using samples from the Brabant Massif (Belgium) and the Moesian Platform (E-Romania).

Alteration and fluid characteristics of a mineralised shear zone in the Lower Palaeozoic of the Anglo-Brabant belt, Belgium

Abstract In the Lower Palaeozoic rocks of the Brabant Massif (Belgium), a recently discovered polysulphide mineralisation is intimately related to a high strain zone. Data from drillings, completed with outcrop data allow a detailed investigation of mineralisation, alteration and fluid characteristics of this high strain zone, currently interpreted as a low-angle reverse shear zone and attributed to the main Early to early Middle Devonian Acadian deformation event. Ore mineralisation occurred synkinematically and was closely associated with the shear zone. Low saline H2O–CO2(–CH4)–NaCl fluids with temperatures >260°C were involved in the hydrothermal circulation, which caused alteration of the host rock and extensive sericitisation in the shear zone. Isotope data and the general setting indicate a metamorphic-driven system.