Timothy Stephen Rice

Identification of the Stability Margin Between Safe Operation and the Onset of Blade Flutter

The introduction of longer last stage blading in steam turbine power plant offers significant economic and environmental benefits. The modern trend, adopted by most leading steam turbine manufacturers, is to develop long last stage moving blades (LSMBs) that feature a tip shroud. This brings benefits of improved performance due to better leakage control and increased mechanical stiffness. However, the benefits associated with the introduction of a tip shroud are accompanied by an increased risk of blade flutter at high mass flows. The shroud is interlocked during vibration, causing the first axial bending mode to carry an increased, out of phase, torsional component. It is shown that this change in mode shape, compared to an unshrouded LSMB, can lead to destabilizing aerodynamic forces during vibration. At a sufficiently high mass flow, the destabilizing unsteady aerodynamic work will exceed the damping provided by the mechanical bladed-disk system, and blade flutter will occur. Addressing the potential for flutter during design and development is difficult. Simple tests prove inadequate as they fail to reveal the proximity of flutter unless the catastrophic condition is encountered. A comprehensive product validation program is presented, with the purpose of identifying the margin for safe operation with respect to blade flutter. Unsteady computational fluid dynamics predictions are utilized to identify the mechanisms responsible for the unstable aerodynamic condition and the particular modes of vibration that are most at risk. Using this information, a directed experimental technique is applied to measure the combined aerodynamic and mechanical damping under operating conditions. Results that demonstrate the identification of the aeroelastic stability margin for a new LSMB are presented. The stability margin predicted from the measurements demonstrates a significant margin of safety.

Numerical and Experimental Investigation of the Aerodynamic Excitation of a Model Low-Pressure Steam Turbine Stage Operating Under Low Volume Flow

The diversification of power generation methods within existing power networks has increased the requirement for operational flexibility of plants employing steam turbines. This has led to the situation where steam turbines may operate at very low volume flow conditions for extended periods of time. Under operating conditions where the volume flow through the last stage moving blades (LSMBs) of a low-pressure (LP) steam turbine falls below a certain limit, energy is returned to the working fluid rather than being extracted. This so-called “ventilation” phenomenon produces nonsynchronous aerodynamic excitation, which has the potential to lead to high dynamic blade loading. The aerodynamic excitation is often the result of a rotating phenomenon, with similarities to a rotating stall, which is well known in compressors. Detailed unsteady pressure measurements have been performed in a single stage model steam turbine operated with air under ventilation conditions. The analysis revealed that the rotating excitation mechanism observed in operating steam turbines is reproduced in the model turbine. A 3D computational fluid dynamics (CFD) method has been applied to simulate the unsteady flow in the air model turbine. The numerical model consists of the single stage modeled as a full annulus, along with the axial-radial diffuser. An unsteady CFD analysis has been performed with sufficient rotor revolutions to obtain globally periodic flow. The simulation reproduces the main characteristics of the phenomenon observed in the tests. The detailed insight into the dynamic flow field reveals information on the nature of the excitation mechanism. The calculations further indicate that the LSMB tip clearance flow has little or no effect on the characteristics of the mechanism for the case studied.

Unsteady Aerodynamics of Low-Pressure Steam Turbines Operating Under Low Volume Flow

Nonsynchronous excitation under low volume operation is a major risk to the mechanical integrity of last stage moving blades (LSMBs) in low-pressure (LP) steam turbines. These vibrations are often induced by a rotating aerodynamic instability similar to rotating stall in compressors. Currently extensive validation of new blade designs is required to clarify whether they are subjected to the risk of not admissible blade vibration. Such tests are usually performed at the end of a blade development project. If resonance occurs a costly redesign is required, which may also lead to a reduction of performance. It is therefore of great interest to be able to predict correctly the unsteady flow phenomena and their effects. Detailed unsteady pressure measurements have been performed in a single stage model steam turbine operated with air under ventilation conditions. 3D computational fluid dynamics (CFD) has been applied to simulate the unsteady flow in the air model turbine. It has been shown that the simulation reproduces well the characteristics of the phenomena observed in the tests. This methodology has been transferred to more realistic steam turbine multistage environment. The numerical results have been validated with measurement data from a multistage model LP steam turbine operated with steam. Measurement and numerical simulation show agreement with respect to the global flow field, the number of stall cells and the intensity of the rotating excitation mechanism. Furthermore, the air model turbine and model steam turbine numerical and measurement results are compared. It is demonstrated that the air model turbine is a suitable vehicle to investigate the unsteady effects found in a steam turbine.

Experimental and Numerical Investigation Into the Aerodynamics of a Novel Steam Turbine Valve and its Field Application

Control valves are one of the key steam turbine components that guarantee operational safety in a power plant.There are two aerodynamic aspects, which are the current focus for the development of Alstom’s valves. One is the reduction of the aerodynamic loss to increase the efficiency of the power plant. The other is operational flexibility, which is increasingly demanded to react faster to load requirements from the electric grid. This is becoming more important as power generation becomes increasingly decentralized, with a growing contribution from renewable energy sources. For this reason, a fast control loop is required for valve operation, which depends on an accurate linearization of the valve characteristic.In this paper the flow fields in an existing steam control valve have been analysed and subsequently optimized using CFD techniques. The approach specifically designed for drilled strainers is further illustrated. Following the validation of the baseline design with model testing, an improved diffuser has been designed using CFD analysis and the resulting performance benefit has been confirmed with further testing.The required grid frequency support requires control valve throttling. For this reason, an accurate prediction of the linearization table is extremely important to support the required response time limits. Further numerical work has been carried out with various opening positions of the valve, leading to an improved valve linearization characteristic. It is demonstrated that the numerical prediction of the linearization curve agrees very well with data obtained from operating power plants.Copyright

Turbulent Scale Resolving Modelling of Rotating Stall in Low-Pressure Steam Turbines Operated Under Low Volume Flow Conditions

Non-synchronous excitation under low volume operation is a major risk to the mechanical integrity of last stage moving blades (LSMBs) in low-pressure (LP) steam turbines. These vibrations are often induced by a rotating aerodynamic instability similar to rotating stall in compressors. Unsteady computational fluid dynamics (CFD) has been applied to simulate the rotating stall phenomenon in two model turbines. It is shown that the investigated flow field presents a challenge to conventional Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes equations simulations. The modelling has been enhanced by applying scale-resolving turbulence modelling, which can simulate large-scale turbulent fluctuations. With this type of simulation a qualitative and quantitative agreement between CFD and measurement for the unsteady and time averaged flow field has been achieved. The results of the numerical investigation allow for a detailed insight into the dynamic flow field and reveal information on the nature of the excitation mechanism. It is concluded that the CFD approach developed can be used to assess LSMB blade designs prior to model turbine tests to check whether they are subjected to vibration under LVF

The Characteristics of Rotating Instabilities in Low Pressure Steam Turbines at Low Volume Flow Operation

For flexible operation steam turbines may operate occasionally at low load. Operation away from the original design regime looks set to be an increasing trend mainly due to the presence of intermittently available renewable energy sources in the grid. This paper sets out an approach for considering low flow effects on turbine designs.At low load operating conditions rotating instabilities (RIS) can occur in the rear stages of LP steam turbines. The instabilities are comparable in many ways to rotating stall in compressors. Ideally the turbine blade natural frequencies should be designed to avoid the frequencies generated by the RIS system.The characteristics of RIS systems were experimentally investigated to understand the dependency with both flow coefficient and exhaust configuration. Correlations have been developed to characterize the dynamic pressure amplitudes and the fractional speed of the RIS moving around the wheel. The presented correlation based method is shown calibrated for a specific blade design.Two different test rigs provide the basis for the work presented. A low pressure model steam turbine provided detailed information for key blade/exhaust combinations. A simplified small scale air turbine was used to provide additional input for the behavior with alternative exhaust back wall position. Observations of the characteristic RIS behavior from model turbine tests are set in context with observed changes in the flow field.Copyright