Toby G. Rossman

Effects of arsenite on p53, p21 and cyclin D expression in normal human fibroblasts — a possible mechanism for arsenite’s comutagenicity

Arsenite, the most likely environmental carcinogenic form of arsenic, is not significantly mutagenic at non-toxic concentrations, but is able to enhance the mutagenicity of other agents. Evidence suggests that this comutagenic effect of arsenite is due to inhibition of DNA repair, but no specific repair enzyme has been found to be sensitive to low (<1 microM) concentrations of arsenite. To determine whether arsenite affects signaling which might alter DNA repair, this study assesses the effect of arsenite on p53-related signal transduction pathways after ionizing radiation. Long-term (14 day) low dose (0.1 microM) arsenite caused a modest increase in p53 expression in WI38 normal human fibroblasts, while only toxic (50 microM) concentrations increased p53 levels after short-term (18 h) exposure. When cells were irradiated (6 Gy), p53 and p21 protein concentrations were increased after 4h, as expected. Both long-term, low dose and short-term, high dose exposure to arsenite greatly suppressed the radiation-induced increase in p21 abundance. In addition, long-term, low dose (but not short-term, high dose) exposure to arsenite resulted in increased expression of cyclin D1. These results show that in cells treated with arsenite, p53-dependent increase in p21 expression, normally a block to cell cycle progression after DNA damage, is deficient. At the same time, low (non-toxic) exposure to arsenite enhances positive growth signaling. We suggest that the absence of normal p53 functioning, along with increased positive growth signaling in the presence of DNA damage may result in defective DNA repair and account for the comutagenic effects of arsenite.

Mutagenesis and comutagenesis by lead compounds

We have previously reported that lead(II) is weakly mutagenic to Chinese hamster V79 cells. A transgenic cell line G12 containing a single copy of the E. coli gpt gene was developed in this laboratory from Chinese hamster V79 cells. The gpt locus in the G12 cells is more mutable by radiation and oxidative agents compared with the endogenous hprt locus of wild-type V79 cells. We have investigated the mutagenicity of two lead compounds at the gpt locus in G12 cells. Only at a toxic dose is lead acetate significantly mutagenic to G12 cells. Lead nitrate is not significantly mutagenic at any dose. Although both compounds are water-soluble, lead acetate, but not lead nitrate, forms a fine white insoluble precipitate upon addition to growth medium. A nick translation assay on cells treated with lead compounds and then permeabilized indicated that lead nitrate and, to a greater extent, lead acetate causes the appearance of nicks in chromosomal DNA. Lead ions in the presence of hydrogen peroxide, but not alone, introduced nicks into supercoiled plasmid DNA in vitro, suggesting that lead ions can partake in a Fenton reaction and thereby damage DNA. At lower nonmutagenic concentrations, lead acetate enhances the mutagenicity of MNNG and ultraviolet light. DNA damage by ultraviolet light is not enhanced by lead ions in vitro. Our data support the concept that non-toxic concentrations of lead(II) can inhibit DNA repair. Thus, at biologically relevant doses, lead(II) could act as a comutagen and possibly a cocarcinogen, but is not likely to act as an initiating genotoxic carcinogen.

Comutagenesis of sodium arsenite with ultraviolet radiation in Chinese hamster V79 cells

SummarySolar ultraviolet radiation has been associated with the induction of skin cancer. Recent studies have indicated that near-ultraviolet, especially UVB, is mutagenic. Exposure to trivalent inorganic arsenic compounds has also been associated with increased skin cancer prevalence. Trivalent arsenic compounds are not mutagenicper se, but are comutagenic with a number of cancer agents. Here, we test the hypothesis that arsenite enhances skin cancer via its comutagenic action with solar ultraviolet radiation. Irradiation of Chinese hamster V79 cells with UVA (360 nm), UVB (310 nm) and UVC (254 nm) caused a fluence-dependent increase in mutations at thehprt locus. On an energy basis, UVC was the most mutagenic and UVA the least. However, when expressed as a function of toxicity, UVB was more mutagenic than UVC. Nontoxic concentrations of arsenite increased the toxicity of UVA, UVB and UVC. Arsenite acted as a comutagen at the three wavelengths; however, higher concentrations of arsenite were required to produce a significant (P < 0.05) comutagenic response with UVB. The increased mutagenicity of UVB and UVA by arsenite may play a role in arsenite-related skin cancers.

Spontaneous mutagenesis in mammalian cells is caused mainly by oxidative events and can be blocked by antioxidants and metallothionein

Little is known about endogenous processes causing spontaneous mutagenesis in mammalian cells. To study this problem, a mathematical model and method developed previously in our laboratory was used to measure the spontaneous mutation rate in mammalian cells at the transgenic gpt locus in Chinese hamster G12 cells. We found that spontaneous mutagenesis increased when cells were cultured in low (<0.25%) serum. These cells also contained higher oxidant levels, measured by dichloroflourescein (DCF) fluorescence, suggesting that the elevated spontaneous mutagenesis resulted from endogenous oxidants which are normally quenched by serum antioxidants. This was found to be the case. Spontaneous mutagenesis was significantly reduced in serum-depleted as well as control cells when catalase (100 ng/ml) or the antioxidants ascorbate (50 microg/ml) or mannitol (100-500 microg/ml) were added to the medium. Overexpression of metallothionein in these cells also suppressed spontaneous mutagenesis and mutagenesis induced by oxygen radical-generating compounds. Cells expressing metallothionein antisense RNA become mutators. Taken together, these results suggest that the major cause of spontaneous mutagenesis in mammalian cells is endogenously-generated oxidative DNA damage which can be blocked by metallothionein or by dietary antioxidants carried by the blood supply.

Muconaldehyde, A Potential Toxic Intermediate of Benzene Metabolism

The metabolite of benzene that is responsible for its hematological toxicity is unknown. Benzene is of course the parent aromatic hydrocarbon and mush attention has been focussed on classical pathways of aromatic hydrocarbon metabolism in the search for toxic benzene metabolites. Elegant studies by a number of groups, including work presented at this symposium by Snyder, Irons, and Tunek, have evaluated metabolites such as benzene oxide, catechol, phenol, hydroquinone and their derivatives (See reviews by Snyder et al, 1977; Laskin and Goldstein, 1977). While there are some interesting clues concerning potentially toxic intermediates, and much important information has been obtained, the metabolic pathway and agent(s) responsible for the hematological toxicity of benzene remains unidentified.

Modeling and measurement of the spontaneous mutation rate in mammalian cells

The study of spontaneous mutation rates in mammalian cells has been hampered by the lack of an alternative to the cumbersome Luria and Delbrück fluctuation test. A brief review of mathematical treatments of spontaneous mutagenesis, along with some of the limitations of the fluctuation test, is presented. A new experimental method and a simple mathematical model for deriving the spontaneous mutation rate are described. Data from the transgenic Chinese hamster G12 cell line growing at two different rates is analyzed according to this model. The results support the concept that, at least for growing cells, the spontaneous mutation rate is independent of the growth rate, and the mutant fraction increases in a linear fashion with the number of generations.

Reduction of spontaneous mutagenesis in mismatch repair-deficient and proficient cells by dietary antioxidants.

Cells lacking mismatch repair (MMR) exhibit elevated levels of spontaneous mutagenesis. Evidence exists that MMR is involved in repair of some DNA lesions besides mismatches. If some oxidative DNA lesions are substrates for MMR, then the excess mutagenesis in MMR(-) cells might be blocked by dietary antioxidants. Effects of the dietary antioxidants ascorbate, alpha-tocopherol, (-)-epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG) and lycopene on spontaneous mutagenesis were studied using mismatch repair-deficient (hMLH1(-)) human colon carcinoma HCT116 cells and HCT116/ch3 cells, in which normal human chromosome 3 has been added to restore mismatch repair. HCT116 cells have a 22-fold higher spontaneous mutation rate compared with HCT116/ch3 cells. HCT116 cells cultured in 1% fetal bovine serum (FBS) have twice the spontaneous mutation rate of those cultured in 10% FBS, most likely due to reduction in serum antioxidants in the low serum medium. As expected, alpha-tocopherol (50 microM) and ascorbate (284 microM) reduced spontaneous mutagenesis in HCT116 cells growing in 1% serum more dramatically than in cells cultured in 10% serum. The strongest antimutagenic compound was lycopene (5 microM), which reduced spontaneous mutagenesis equally (about 70%) in HCT116 cells growing in 10 and 1% FBS and in HCT116/ch3 cells. Since lycopene was equally antimutagenic in cells growing in low and high serum, it may have another antimutagenic mechanism in addition to its antioxidant effect. Surprisingly, EGCG (10 microM) was toxic to cells growing in low serum. It also reduced spontaneous mutagenesis equally (nearly 40%) in HCT116 and HCT116/ch3 cells. The large proportion of spontaneous mutagenesis that can be blocked by antioxidants in mismatch repair-deficient cells support the hypothesis that a major cause of their excess mutagenesis is endogenous oxidants. Blocking spontaneous mutagenesis, perhaps with a cocktail of antioxidants, should reduce the risk of cancer in people with a genetic defect in mismatch repair as well as other individuals.

Arsenite induced poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation of tumor suppressor P53 in human skin keratinocytes as a possible mechanism for carcinogenesis associated with arsenic exposure

Arsenite is an environmental pollutant. Exposure to inorganic arsenic in drinking water is associated with elevated cancer risk, especially in skin. Arsenite alone does not cause skin cancer in animals, but arsenite can enhance the carcinogenicity of solar UV. Arsenite is not a significant mutagen at non-toxic concentrations, but it enhances the mutagenicity of other carcinogens. The tumor suppressor protein P53 and nuclear enzyme PARP-1 are both key players in DNA damage response. This laboratory demonstrated earlier that in cells treated with arsenite, the P53-dependent increase in p21(WAF1/CIP1) expression, normally a block to cell cycle progression after DNA damage, is deficient. Here we show that although long-term exposure of human keratinocytes (HaCaT) to a nontoxic concentration (0.1 microM) of arsenite decreases the level of global protein poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation, it increases poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation of P53 protein and PARP-1 protein abundance. We also demonstrate that exposure to 0.1 microM arsenite depresses the constitutive expression of p21 mRNA and P21 protein in HaCaT cells. Poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation of P53 is reported to block its activation, DNA binding and its functioning as a transcription factor. Our results suggest that arsenites interference with activation of P53 via poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation may play a role in the comutagenic and cocarcinogenic effects of arsenite.

Effects of sodium arsenite on the survival of UV-irradiated Escherichia Coli: INHIBITION OF A rec A-Dependent function

Epidemiological studies and clinical observation suggesting potential hazards of arsenic compounds in increasing the incidence of cancer have been in complete contradiction with experimental findings in animals. Because of the predominance of skin cancers in the epidemiological reports, we decided to investigate the possibility that arsenic compounds might interfere with DNA repair. Using Escherichia coli as a test system, we show that this is indeed the case. Sodium arsenite, at concentrations of 0.1 mM and higher, decreases the survival of ultraviolet-irradiated E. coli WP2, a strain which possesses the full complement of repair genes. The effect of the arsenite increases with increasing ultraviolet dose. Similar results were obtained with the excision repair deficient strains WWP2 (uvrA) and WP6 (polA). Sodium arsenite had no effect on the survival of a recA mutant, WP10. Survival of ultraviolet-irradiated WP5 (exrA) was enhanced by sodium ardenite, the effect being greatest at low ultraviolet doses. It is postulated that arsenite inhibits a recA-dependent step in DNA repair. To account for the increased survival of the exrA mutant, we suggest that in the absence of the exr+ gene, the arsenite-sensitive recA-dependent function is deleterious. The ability of arsenite to inhibit DNA repair may account for the clinical and epidemiological reports linking arsenicals with an increased incidence of cancer.

Human cells lack the inducible tolerance to arsenite seen in hamster cells.

Chinese hamster V79 cells and their arsenite-resistant variants were found to have an arsenite- and antimonite-inducible tolerance mechanism which protects against the subsequent cytotoxic effects of arsenate, arsenate and antimonite. Inducible tolerance requires de novo mRNA and protein synthesis, and is independent of the heat shock response. In contrast, we report that the arsenite hypersensitive variant line As/S27D lacks the inducible tolerance response. Numerous attempts were made to detect an inducible tolerance response to arsenite in a variety of human cells. An assay based on Neutral red uptake was used in order to study inducible tolerance in cells with poor clonability. Neither normal diploid cells nor human tumor cells of different origins were found to elicit an inducible tolerance response to arsenite. This finding may help to explain why rodents do not develop tumors after exposure to arsenite, while humans do. In addition, all human cell lines tested were much more sensitive to arsenite compared to Chinese hamster cells. Human keratinocytes were especially sensitive. In general, human cells resemble arsenic hypersensitive Chinese hamster As/R27D cells, which have lost a protective mechanism found in wild-type Chinese hamster cells.