Tom Motzek

Impact of the Design of the Built Environment on People with Dementia: An Evidence-Based Review:

OBJECTIVE: In this review the impact of the design of the built environment on people with dementia in long-term care settings is systematically analyzed and summarized. Architects and designers will be provided with credible evidence on which they can confidently base their design decisions. Researchers will be able to determine which environmental aspects have been well investigated and where there are gaps in the current state of the research. BACKGROUND: A great number of studies have established a relationship between the design of the physical environment of long-term care settings and outcomes of people with dementia. However, the methods employed are heterogeneous and the results are often conflicting. Consequently, the process of integrating the best evidence available into architectural designs may be hindered. METHODS: A systematic literature search was conducted reviewing studies that meet certain inclusion criteria. Using an evidence-based approach, the methodical quality of the studies was rated. RESULTS: One hundred sixty-nine studies were found. They were thematically summarized into four main categories: basic design decisions, environmental attributes, ambience, and environmental information. The effectiveness of the interventions on the behavior, cognition, function, well being, social abilities, orientation, and care outcomes on people with dementia was illustrated by matrices. CONCLUSIONS: Results of this review indicate that, with the exception of cognition, specific design interventions are beneficial to the outcomes of people with dementia. Overall, the field of environmental design for people with dementia is well researched in many aspects and only few gaps in knowledge were identified.

How to Rate the Quality of a Research Paper: Introducing a Helpful Algorithm for Architects and Designers

KEYWORDS Decision-making, evidence-based design, methodology.

Environmental Cues in Double-Occupancy Rooms to Support Patients With Dementia.

Objective: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of different environmental cues in double-occupancy rooms of an acute care hospital to support patients’ abilities to identify their bed and wardrobe. Methods: The quasi-experiment was conducted on a geriatric ward of an acute care hospital. Patients with dementia were included (n = 42). To test the effectiveness of environmental cues, two rooms were enhanced with the environmental cue “color,” two rooms with the cue “number,” and two rooms with the cue “patient’s name”. Four rooms were not redesigned and were used as control rooms. For analysis, we pooled the intervention groups color and number (n = 14) and compared it with the control group (n = 22). Results: The environmental cues color and number were significantly effective to improve the identification of the wardrobe from the third to the fifth day after admission. However, for the 10th–12th day after admission, we found no difference in results. Furthermore, results indicate improvements in the ability to identify the bed by using the environmental cues color and number. Conclusions: As this study indicated, the environmental cues color and number are helpful for these patients to identify their bed and wardrobe. However, these cues were most effective from the third to the fifth day after admission. To sustain their effectiveness on patients’ identification abilities during their hospital stay, we discuss, whether verbal prompting and an ongoing mentioning of such cues, embedded in the daily work of nurses, could be beneficial.

Investigation of Eligible Picture Categories for Use as Environmental Cues in Dementia-Sensitive Environments.

Objectives: Environmental cues, such as pictures, could be helpful in improving room-finding and wayfinding abilities among older patients. The aim of this study was to identify picture categories that are preferred and easily remembered by older patients and cognitively impaired patients and which therefore might be suitable for use as environmental cues in acute care settings. Methods: Twelve pictures were presented to a sample of older patients (n = 37). The pictures represented different categories: familiarity (familiar vs. unfamiliar), type of shot (close-up vs. wide shot), and picture content (nature vs. animal vs. urban). We tested the patients’ votes of preference and abilities to identify and immediately recall pictures. Cognitively impaired patients (n = 14) were assessed by the abbreviated mental test and the mini mental state examination and were compared with patients without cognitive impairments (n = 23) using a repeated measures analysis of variance. Results: The results showed a main effect of familiarity on positive vote and recall of pictures. The absence of interaction effects of familiarity and group indicated an overall impact of familiarity on the sample. Within cognitively impaired patients, a significant difference in recall of picture content between urban (20%) and animal (9%) was found. Conclusions: Pictures, which patients were able to relate to in terms of familiarity and the characteristics urban and nature, seem to be suitable for use as environmental cues. Besides functioning as such, we assume, based on literature, that pictures could further enhance the ambiance or serve as prompts for communication and interaction.

Architektur für Menschen mit Demenz

Die Zahl der Menschen mit Demenz wächst kontinuierlich. 2010 lebten nach Schätzungen weltweit etwa 35.6 Millionen mit einer Demenz. Diese Zahl wird sich alle 20 Jahre verdoppeln, sodass für das Jahr 2050 etwa 115 Menschen mit einer Demenz erwartet werden (Prince et al., 2013). Für die Betro enen selbst, ihre Angehörigen und insbesondere die P egeeinrichtungen und -anbieter stellt diese Entwicklung eine große Herausforderung dar. Menschen mit Demenz benötigen zunächst zwar nur Unterstützung bei ihrer Alltagsbewältigung, wer den aber mit Fortschreiten der Krankheit sehr schnell von umfassenden P egeleistungen abhängig.