Tom Schanz

Impacts of the use of the geological subsurface for energy storage: an investigation concept

New methods and technologies for energy storage are required to make a transitionto renewable energy sources; in Germany this transition is termed “Energiewende”. Subsurface georeservoirs, such as salt caverns for hydrogen, compressed air, and methane storage or porous formations for heat and gas storage, offer the possibility of hosting large amounts of energy. When employing these geological storage facilities, an adequate system and process understanding is essential in order to characterize and to predict the complex and interacting effects on other types of subsurface use and on protected entities. In order to make optimal use of georeservoirs, a comprehensive use planning of the subsurface is required that allocates specific uses to appropriate subsurface locations. This paper presents a generic methodology on how subsurface use planning can be conducted and how its scientific basis can be developed. Although synthetic, realistic scenarios for the use of the geological underground for energy storage are parameterized and numerically simulated, accounting for other kinds of subsurface use already in place. From these scenario analyses, the imposed coupled hydraulic, thermal, mechanical and chemical processes, as well as mutual effects and influences on protected entities are assessed and generalized. Based on these, a first methodology for large-scale planning of the geological subsurface considering different surface and subsurface usage scenarios may also be derived.

Inverse parameter identification technique using PSO algorithm applied to geotechnical modeling

This paper presents a concept for the application of particle swarm optimization in geotechnical engineering. For the calculation of deformations in soil or rock, numerical simulations based on continuum methods are widely used. The material behavior is modeled using constitutive relations that require sets of material parameters to be specified. We present an inverse parameter identification technique, based on statistical analyses and a particle swarm optimization algorithm, to be used in the calibration process of geomechanical models. Its application is demonstrated with typical examples from the fields of soil mechanics and engineering geology. The results for two different laboratory tests and a natural slope clearly show that particle swarms are an efficient and fast tool for finding improved parameter sets to represent the measured reference data.

Sensitivity analysis and parameter identification of a time dependent constitutive model for rock salt

The tendency to shift from fossil and nuclear energy sources to renewable energy carriers has increased during the past couple of decades. Subsequently, development of effective energy storage systems has become more attractive. Nowadays, caverns excavated in rock salt formations are recognized as the appropriate places for underground storage of energy in the form of compressed air or hydrogen. Accurate design of these underground cavities requires suitable numerical simulations employing appropriate constitutive models to describe the material behavior of rock salt under various geological conditions. It is obvious that to have a realistic numerical simulation, it is essential to have a comprehensive knowledge concerning the unknown material parameters and their influence on the calculation results. In this paper, a time dependent model is selected to describe the mechanical response of the rock salt around the cavern. This model is implemented in a finite element code and its application in numerical modeling of salt caverns is illustrated. In addition, global sensitivity analysis is used to investigate the influence of material parameters on the mechanical behavior of the salt cavern. Finally, inverse analysis of the synthetic data is performed to identify the material parameters of the selected model. The applied global sensitivity and inverse analysis algorithms employ metamodeling technique in order to reduce the time which is needed for these computationally expensive calculations.

Modified Pressure Plate Apparatus and Column Testing Device for Measuring SWCC of Sand

The determination of soil-water characteristic curve (SWCC) is of major concern in unsaturated soil mechanics. For decades experimental and theoretical studies are performed to investigate the constitutive relationship between soil suction and volumetric water content. The major objective of our study is to generate an extensive experimental database for sand with a relevant suction range of just a few kPa. This database enables to derive conclusions on the sensitivity of hydraulic properties regarding different experimental procedures. Further, one objective is the comparison of results for SWCC derived from steady state and transient state tests. While the first type of tests considers equilibrium states, the subsequent test is related to non-equilibrium states. Experimental results are generated from a so called homogenous element test (modified pressure plate apparatus) and an initial boundary value experiment (column testing device) considering different hydraulic loading path directions. The experiments are analysed for sand with different initial states. Finally results are presented for SWCC including initial curves, main curves, and scanning paths. Discussion is focused on transient state versus steady state flow tests. No significant dynamic effects are observed for the sand studied. Results of well controlled element tests compare very well to initial boundary value experiments implying higher experimental efforts.

Energy storage in the geological subsurface: dimensioning, risk analysis and spatial planning: the ANGUS+ project

New techniques and methods for energy storage are required for the transition to a renewable power supply, termed “Energiewende” in Germany. Energy storage in the geological subsurface provides large potential capacities to bridge temporal gaps between periods of production of solar or wind power and consumer demand and may also help to relieve the power grids. Storage options include storage of synthetic methane, hydrogen or compressed air in salt caverns or porous formations as well as heat storage in porous formations. In the ANGUS+ project, heat and gas storage in porous media and salt caverns and aspects of their use on subsurface spatial planning concepts are investigated. The optimal dimensioning of storage sites, the achievable charging and discharging rates and the effective storage capacity as well as the induced thermal, hydraulic, mechanical, geochemical and microbial effects are studied. The geological structures, the surface energy infrastructure and the governing processes are parameterized, using either literature data or own experimental studies. Numerical modeling tools are developed for the simulation of realistically defined synthetic storage scenarios. The feasible dimensioning of storage applications is assessed in site-specific numerical scenario analyses, and the related spatial extents and time scales of induced effects connected with the respective storage application are quantified. Additionally, geophysical monitoring methods, which allow for a better spatial resolution of the storage operation, induced effects or leakages, are evaluated based on these scenario simulations. Methods for the assessment of such subsurface geological storage sites are thus developed, which account for the spatial extension of the subsurface operation itself as well as its induced effects and the spatial requirements of adequate monitoring methods.

Determination of hydro-mechanical Properties of Sand

In this study the behavior of an unsaturated sand is examined. The sand used is Hostun sand from France. The Soil-Water-Characteristic Curves (SWCCs) of loose and dense specimen were determined by using the suction mode and pressure mode axis translation technique under various vertical net stresses. One dimensional compression and rebound behavior was studied for specimens at different initial matric suction values. During these tests the matric suction was maintained constant during loading and unloading processes. To study the wetting induced collapse of the sand, specimens with a known matric suction and water content were prepared and then saturated at several vertical net stresses during loading. The study showed that the SWCC is not significantly influenced by vertical net stress. However there is a influence of initial suction on the compression behavior of the material which is manifested on the stillness moduli, compression index and collapse potential of the sand used in this study. In comparison to these results, results from one dimensional compression and rebound tests, where water content was kept constant, for Quartz sand Weferlingen were added. Results from collapse potential test for Quartz sand Weferlingen are given, too.

Macroelement for Statically Loaded Shallow Strip Foundation Resting on Unsaturated Soil

AbstractThe load deformation and failure behavior of shallow footings can be described in a macroelement formulation. This paper deals with the study of the failure surface and the definition and validation of plastic load deformation by single surface hardening models. The straightforward application of the plasticity theory to the soil-foundation system makes it possible to extend the given expression for the case of unsaturated soils. This paper studies a small-scale footing test on unsaturated sand for the formulation of the elastoplastic macroelement of shallow footings under a centrally applied vertical load. The influence of soil suction on different parameters associated with the macroelement is studied and calibrated against experimental results. The presented model shows good agreement with the experimental results. Finally, the limitations and still open questions of the approach are discussed in detail.

A Column Experiment to Study the Thermo-Hydro-Mechanical Behaviour of Expansive Soils

The study of heat transfer, water flow, and swelling pressure development in engineered clay barriers and the evaluation of the influence of these phenomena on the barrier properties are important issues for predicting the performance of nuclear waste repository facilities. In this work, an experimental setup is presented especially meant to assess the response of the sand–bentonite mixture under conditions close to that of the buffer in a radioactive waste repository. A newly developed column device for laboratory testing of coupled thermo-hydro-mechanical (THM) behaviour of clay-buffer materials is introduced and its calibration, verification and the first experimental data are presented and discussed. The main features of the column device are: hydraulic and thermal gradients are possible to be applied; water content, suction and temperature development can be measured continuously at three locations along the sample height; swelling stress can be measured at top and the bottom of the sample. Measuring transient temperature, water content and suction simultaneously at the same height levels and with special care to minimise the sample disturbance is one of the advantages of the column device proposed here when compared to that previously reported in the literature. The main objectives of this paper are: (1) to describe the experimental device, (2) to introduce the sensors implemented and their calibration, and (3) to present and discuss the first experimental results obtained with the new equipment. The first experimental results show promise in the ability of the newly developed column device to provide reliable data for assessing the THM behaviour of expansive materials that are foreseen as buffer material in high level waste repositories.

Sample Disturbance in Soft and Sensitive Clays: Analysis and Assessment

Despite the sophisticated methods employed to obtain high quality samples, they are prone to disturbance, due to stress release, let apart, due to sampling tools and techniques adopted. Critical reappraisal of different methods suggest that any method of sample quality assessment involving strength and deformation parameters would enable easier implementation and correct other engineering parameters for estimated sample disturbance. In this technical paper, sample disturbance index, using merely the slopes of compression paths, (representing mechanical response), in the pre- and post-yield stress regimes under odeometric loading conditions is proposed. This method is based on single oedometer test results on samples of unknown degrees of disturbance during sampling and handling. The unique feature of this approach is that the ideal rigid plastic material behavior is taken as reference. This eliminates the need for any additional experimental data or any calculations from the relationships formulated with any set of assumptions.

Behavior of Shallow Strip Footing on Twin Voids

This paper numerically examines the bearing capacity and failure mechanism of a shallow strip foundation constructed above twin voids. The voids may refer to caves, caverns, underground aqueduct or tunnels due to water seepage, chemical reaction or deliberately excavated in soil deposit. The ability of numerical model to accurately predict the system behavior is evaluated by performing verification analyses on existing researches. Subsequently, a parametric study carried out to reveal the influence of size of footing/voids and their location (i.e. depth, spacing, eccentricity) on the bearing capacity of footing. To clarify the failure mechanism, the distribution of shear strain in the soil for different scenarios is assessed. The parametric study provided a new framework to determine the bearing capacity and the mode of failure for footings on voids. Based on the results, a criterion can be issued to avoid collapse of footing/voids regarding the shape, location and size of voids. The results can also be used to design construction of a footing on existing voids while the acquired failure mechanisms can be appointed to develop analytical solutions for this problem. Results demonstrated that a critical depth for voids and a critical distance between them exist where the influence on the ultimate bearing capacity of footing disappears.