Tuan A. Nguyen

Fluorescence Polarization and Fluctuation Analysis Monitors Subunit Proximity, Stoichiometry, and Protein Complex Hydrodynamics

Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) microscopy is frequently used to study protein interactions and conformational changes in living cells. The utility of FRET is limited by false positive and negative signals. To overcome these limitations we have developed Fluorescence Polarization and Fluctuation Analysis (FPFA), a hybrid single-molecule based method combining time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy (homo-FRET) and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. Using FPFA, homo-FRET (a 1-10 nm proximity gauge), brightness (a measure of the number of fluorescent subunits in a complex), and correlation time (an attribute sensitive to the mass and shape of a protein complex) can be simultaneously measured. These measurements together rigorously constrain the interpretation of FRET signals. Venus based control-constructs were used to validate FPFA. The utility of FPFA was demonstrated by measuring in living cells the number of subunits in the α-isoform of Venus-tagged calcium-calmodulin dependent protein kinase-II (CaMKIIα) holoenzyme. Brightness analysis revealed that the holoenzyme has, on average, 11.9 ± 1.2 subunit, but values ranged from 10-14 in individual cells. Homo-FRET analysis simultaneously detected that catalytic domains were arranged as dimers in the dodecameric holoenzyme, and this paired organization was confirmed by quantitative hetero-FRET analysis. In freshly prepared cell homogenates FPFA detected only 10.2 ± 1.3 subunits in the holoenzyme with values ranging from 9-12. Despite the reduction in subunit number, catalytic domains were still arranged as pairs in homogenates. Thus, FPFA suggests that while the absolute number of subunits in an auto-inhibited holoenzyme might vary from cell to cell, the organization of catalytic domains into pairs is preserved.

The Impact of Heterogeneity and Dark Acceptor States on FRET: Implications for Using Fluorescent Protein Donors and Acceptors

Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) microscopy is widely used to study protein interactions in living cells. Typically, spectral variants of the Green Fluorescent Protein (FPs) are incorporated into proteins expressed in cells, and FRET between donor and acceptor FPs is assayed. As appreciable FRET occurs only when donors and acceptors are within 10 nm of each other, the presence of FRET can be indicative of aggregation that may denote association of interacting species. By monitoring the excited-state (fluorescence) decay of the donor in the presence and absence of acceptors, dual-component decay analysis has been used to reveal the fraction of donors that are FRET positive (i.e., in aggregates)._However, control experiments using constructs containing both a donor and an acceptor FP on the same protein repeatedly indicate that a large fraction of these donors are FRET negative, thus rendering the interpretation of dual-component analysis for aggregates between separately donor-containing and acceptor-containing proteins problematic. Using Monte-Carlo simulations and analytical expressions, two possible sources for such anomalous behavior are explored: 1) conformational heterogeneity of the proteins, such that variations in the distance separating donor and acceptor FPs and/or their relative orientations persist on time-scales long in comparison with the excited-state lifetime, and 2) FP dark states.

Size, stoichiometry, and organization of soluble LC3-associated complexes

MAP1LC3B, an ortholog of yeast Atg8 and a member of the family of proteins formerly also known as ATG8 in mammals (LC3B henceforth in the text), functions in autophagosome formation and autophagy substrate recruitment. LC3 exists in both a soluble (autophagosome-independent) form as well as a lipid modified form that becomes tightly incorporated into autophagosomal membranes. Although LC3 is known to associate with tens of proteins, relatively little is known about soluble LC3 aside from its interactions with the LC3 lipid conjugation machinery. In previous studies we found autophagosome-independent GFP-LC3B diffuses unusually slowly for a protein of its size, suggesting it may constitutively associate with a high molecular weight complex, form homo-oligomers or aggregates, or reversibly bind microtubules or membranes. To distinguish between these possibilities, we characterized the size, stoichiometry, and organization of autophagosome-independent LC3B in living cells and in cytoplasmic extracts using fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) and fluorescence polarization fluctuation analysis (FPFA). We found that the diffusion of LC3B was unaffected by either mutational disruption of its lipid modification or microtubule depolymerization. Brightness and homo-FRET analysis indicate LC3B does not homo-oligomerize. However, mutation of specific residues on LC3B required for binding other proteins and mRNA altered the effective hydrodynamic radius of the protein as well as its stoichiometry. We conclude that when not bound to autophagosomes, LC3B associates with a multicomponent complex with an effective size of ~500 kDa in the cytoplasm. These findings provide new insights into the nature of soluble LC3B and illustrate the power of FRAP and FPFA to investigate the emergent properties of protein complexes in the autophagy pathway.

Covert Changes in CaMKII Holoenzyme Structure Identified for Activation and Subsequent Interactions.

Between 8 to 14 calcium-calmodulin (Ca(2+)/CaM) dependent protein kinase-II (CaMKII) subunits form a complex that modulates synaptic activity. In living cells, the autoinhibited holoenzyme is organized as catalytic-domain pairs distributed around a central oligomerization-domain core. The functional significance of catalytic-domain pairing is not known. In a provocative model, catalytic-domain pairing was hypothesized to prevent ATP access to catalytic sites. If correct, kinase-activity would require catalytic-domain pair separation. Simultaneous homo-FRET and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy was used to detect structural changes correlated with kinase activation under physiological conditions. Saturating Ca(2+)/CaM triggered Threonine-286 autophosphorylation and a large increase in CaMKII holoenzyme hydrodynamic volume without any appreciable change in catalytic-domain pair proximity or subunit stoichiometry. An alternative hypothesis is that two appropriately positioned Threonine-286 interaction-sites (T-sites), each located on the catalytic-domain of a pair, are required for holoenzyme interactions with target proteins. Addition of a T-site ligand, in the presence of Ca(2+)/CaM, elicited a large decrease in catalytic-domain homo-FRET, which was blocked by mutating the T-site (I205K). Apparently catalytic-domain pairing is altered to allow T-site interactions.

Deciphering CaMKII Multimerization Using Fluorescence Correlation Spectroscopy and Homo-FRET Analysis

While kinases are typically composed of one or two subunits, calcium-calmodulin (CaM)-dependent protein kinase II (CaMKII) is composed of 8-14 subunits arranged as pairs around a central core. It is not clear if the CaMKII holoenzyme functions as an assembly of independent subunits, as catalytic pairs, or as a single unit. One strategy to address this question is to genetically engineer monomeric and dimeric CaMKII and evaluate how their activity compares to the wild-type (WT) holoenzyme. Here a technique that combines fluorescence correlation spectroscopy and homo-FRET analysis was used to characterize assembly mutants of Venus-tagged CaMKIIα to identify a dimeric CaMKII. Spectroscopy was then used to compare how holoenzyme structure and function changes in response to activation with CaM in the dimeric mutant, WT-holoenzyme, and a monomeric CaMKII oligomerization-domain deletion mutant control. CaM triggered an increase in hydrodynamic volume in both WT and dimeric CaMKII without altering subunit stoichiometry or the net homo-FRET between Venus-tagged catalytic domains. Biochemical analysis revealed that the dimeric mutant also functioned like WT holoenzyme in terms of its kinase activity with an exogenous substrate, and for endogenous T286 autophosphorylation. We conclude that the fundamental functional units of CaMKII holoenzyme are paired catalytic-domains.

Auto-FPFA: An Automated Microscope for Characterizing Genetically Encoded Biosensors

Genetically encoded biosensors function by linking structural change in a protein construct, typically tagged with one or more fluorescent proteins, to changes in a biological parameter of interest (such as calcium concentration, pH, phosphorylation-state, etc.). Typically, the structural change triggered by alterations in the bio-parameter is monitored as a change in either fluorescent intensity, or lifetime. Potentially, other photo-physical properties of fluorophores, such as fluorescence anisotropy, molecular brightness, concentration, and lateral and/or rotational diffusion could also be used. Furthermore, while it is likely that multiple photo-physical attributes of a biosensor might be altered as a function of the bio-parameter, standard measurements monitor only a single photo-physical trait. This limits how biosensors are designed, as well as the accuracy and interpretation of biosensor measurements. Here we describe the design and construction of an automated multimodal-microscope. This system can autonomously analyze 96 samples in a micro-titer dish and for each sample simultaneously measure intensity (photon count), fluorescence lifetime, time-resolved anisotropy, molecular brightness, lateral diffusion time, and concentration. We characterize the accuracy and precision of this instrument, and then demonstrate its utility by characterizing three types of genetically encoded calcium sensors as well as a negative control.

An Introduction to Interpreting Time Resolved Fluorescence Anisotropy Curves

The decay in fluorescence anisotropy following an excitation pulse can be monitored using time-correlated single photon counting, and used to measure molecular rotation and homo-FRET in biomedical research. In this chapter we review the basis of polarized fluorescence emission, and how this emission can be detected and quantified to yield a time-resolved anisotropy curve. We then review chemical, instrumental and biological factors that can influence the shape and magnitude of anisotropy curves. Understanding the influence of these factors can then be used to aid in the interpretation of biomedical experiments using time-resolved anisotropy.

Positive Cooperativity and T286 Autophosphorylation is Observed in a Dimeric Mutant of Calcium-Calmodulin Dependent Protein Kinase II (CaMKII)

CaMKII is a multimeric enzyme that regulates long-term potentiation in the hippocampus. The assembly and organization of 8-14 subunits in a holoenzyme is thought to be required for transduction of calcium spike frequencies, cooperative binding to calmodulin, persistent activation by T286 autophosphorylation, and translocation into synaptic spines. CaMKII assembles into a holoenzyme by virtue of its unique C-terminal association domain (AD). ADs form a central hub-like structure from which regulatory and catalytic domains project. Each AD interacts tightly with three other subunits, two laterally and one transversely, to form a stable core composed of two stacked rings. FRET and analytical centrifugation has indicated that individual catalytic domains can form pairs by virtue of low affinity binding sites. But catalytic domains of the CaMKII mutant lacking AD do not form pairs in physiological conditions. We hypothesize that catalytic domain pairing is the fundamental structure that allows positive cooperativity and T286 autophosphorylation. Furthermore we postulate that high affinity AD core interactions lead to a high local concentration of catalytic domains that allows low-affinity catalytic domain pairing. To test this hypothesis, we mutated the lateral surface of the CaMKIIα AD. When expressed in HEK293 cells, the mutation generated a paired dimeric CaMKIIα. In support of the hypothesis, our study shows that the dimeric enzyme has the same affinity for calmodulin, a similar Hill coefficient for enzymatic activity, and T286 autophosphorylation comparable to that observed in the wild type holoenzyme. In contrast, the monomeric mutant CaMKII lacking AD has lower affinity, no cooperativity, and reduced T286 autophosphorylation. While catalytic domain pairing was observed in the dimeric mutant, biophysical analysis suggests that the nature of the pairing might be altered.