V. I. Efremov

Long-period oscillations of the line-of-sight velocities in and near sunspots at various levels in the photosphere

New observational data on long-period oscillations of the line-of-sight velocities detected via the Doppler shifts of spectral lines observed at various heights in and near sunspots are presented. The sunspots and nearby magnetic elements oscillate with periods ranging from 40 to 80 min. The oscillations in the line-of-sight velocities persist over the entire observation session (up to four hours). These results support theoretical models in which this phenomenon represents natural long-period oscillations (vertical-radial displacements) of entire magnetic elements (sunspots, pores, and magnetic knots) about some stable equilibrium positions.

Artifacts of SDO/HMI data and long-period oscillations of sunspots

Aims. The artifacts of SDO/HMI magnetograms that may affect the low-frequency power spectrum of sunspot oscillations are analyzed. Methods. Several examples are given that present false (artificial) harmonics, which are produced by Doppler shifts in the power spectra of long-period oscillations of sunspots. This arises from peculiarities in the orbital movements of SDO. Results. It was found that those artifacts with periods of 12 and 24 h, as revealed even in variations of weak background magnetic fields, are actually present in SDO/HMI magnetograms. However, the quantitative impact of artifacts remains quite weak and does not change the picture of sunspot oscillations dramatically for as long as the magnetic field in the spot is less than about of 2000 Gauss. When the magnetic field strength is greater than 2000 G, the influence of these artifacts increases sharply to become the dominant factor. One can suggest that the amplification of noise components of these artifacts has a highly nonlinear character with the growth of the magnetic field, and the field strength of about 2000 G then takes on meaning of a threshold value.

Long-Period Oscillations of Sunspots Observed by SOHO/MDI

We processed magnetograms that were obtained with the Michaelson Doppler Imager onboard the Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO/MDI). The results confirm the basic properties of long-period oscillations of sunspots that have previously been established and also reveal new properties. We show that the limiting (lowest) eigenmode of low-frequency oscillations of a sunspot as a whole is the mode with a period of 10 – 12 up to 32 – 35 hours (depending on the sunspot’s magnetic-field strength). This mode is observed consistently throughout an observation period of 5 – 7 days, but its amplitude is subject to quasi-cyclic changes, which are separated by about 1.5 – 2 days. As a result, the lower mode with a period of about 35 – 48 hours appears in the power spectrum of sunspot oscillations. But this lowest mode is apparently not an eigenmode of a sunspot because its period does not depend on the magnetic field of the sunspot. Perhaps the mode reflects the quasi-periodic sunspot perturbations caused by supergranulation cells that surround it. We also analyzed SOHO/MDI artifacts, which may affect the low-frequency power spectra of sunspots.

Sunspot oscillations as derived from the SOHO/MDI magnetograms

As a result of processing long (up to 144 h) series of sunspot magnetograms obtained on the SOHO (Solar and Heliospheric Observatory) spacecraft with the MDI (Michelson Doppler Imager) instrument it is shown that the mode with a period of 800–1300 min is a limiting low-frequency oscillation mode of the magnetic field of a sunspot as a whole. Its period is essentially and nonlinearly depends on the sunspot magnetic field strength. In addition to this mode, higher harmonics are also revealed in the sunspot oscillation spectra in the bands 40–45, 60–80, 135–170, 220–250, and 480–520 min. The oscillation power in these bands monotonically and rapidly decreases with increasing frequency, which is characteristic for overtones arising due to the nonlinear nature of oscillations. The limiting oscillation mode stably exists in sunspots for 1.5–2 days, which coincides with the average lifetime of a supergranular cell. The mode with the period of 35–48 h observed in the power spectrum is not an eigen mode of sunspots, because its period is independent of its magnetic field strength. Probably, it occurs as a quasiperiod of an external exciting force caused by disturbances from supergranular cells surrounding the sunspot.

Synchronism of long-period oscillations of the magnetic field in sunspots

It is shown that long-period (T = 10–20 h) oscillations of the magnetic field in sunspots, combined in bipolar groups, are excited synchronously in the main and tail spots of a group. At the same time, there is no correlation between long-period oscillations of the field of sunspots which are in different active regions, i.e., spaced sunspots oscillate independently. This fact eliminates the question about the apparatus nature of the oscillations of interest (if there is an artifact, oscillations of all sunspots on the visible solar hemisphere would be synchronous!). High-resolution (0.5 angular seconds per pixel) MDI(SOHO) data show a high correlation between long-period oscillations of the magnetic field at isolated points of the sunspot shadow. This points to the fact that the sunspot shadow participates in long-period oscillations as a quite integral physical formation.

Specific features of long-period oscillations of sunspots and photosphere according to the MDI (SOHO) data

Long-period oscillations of the magnetic field and the line-of-sight velocity have been detected in sunspots based on the synchronous 90-h time series of magnetograms and dopplergrams obtained with the MDI(SOHO) device. The sunspot eigenmode (12–30 h), the periods of which nonlinearly depend on the magnetic field strength, predominates in the magnetic field oscillation spectrum. The mode, which is probably induced by motions of supergranulation cells (33 h), predominates in the sunspot line-of-sight velocity oscillation spectrum. A strong mode (33 h), which indicates that long-period quasi-oscillations of supergranulation exist, was also detected in the velocity power spectrum for a quiet photosphere, together with the known 5-min mode.

Long-period oscillations of sunspots according to simultaneous ground-based and space observations

An analysis of oscillatory processes with periods not shorter than several tens of minutes in three isolated sunspots, which were observed during identical periods in the optical and radio bands, is illustrated. SDO/HMI magnetograms at an interval of 45 s and radio maps at a wavelength of 1.76 cm, obtained using a Nobeyama radioheliograph (NoRH), have been used. The time profiles, which were constructed based on the NoRH and SDO/HMI data, indicate that the oscillations of the radioemission correlate with those of the sunspot magnetic field. The wavelet spectra and cross-wavelet transform reveal common oscillation periods of 30–40, 70–100, and 150–200 min. The identical oscillation periods, found using fundamentally different methods from ground-based and space observations, confirm the solar nature of these oscillations, which can be interpreted as oscillations of a sunspot as a whole.

Long-term oscillations of sunspots and a special class of artifacts in SOHO/MDI and SDO/HMI data

A specific type of artifacts (named as “p2p”), that originate due to displacement of the image of a moving object along the digital (pixel) matrix of receiver are analyzed in detail. The criteria of appearance and the influence of these artifacts on the study of long-term oscillations of sunspots are deduced. The obtained criteria suggest us methods for reduction or even elimination of these artifacts. It is shown that the use of integral parameters can be very effective against the “p2p” artifact distortions. The simultaneous observations of sunspot magnetic field and ultraviolet intensity of the umbra have given the same periods for the long-term oscillations. In this way the real physical nature of the oscillatory process, which is independent of the artifacts have been confirmed again. A number of examples considered here confirm the dependence between the periods of main mode of the sunspot magnetic field long-term oscillations and its strength. The dependence was derived earlier from both the observations and the theoretical model of the shallow sunspot. The anti-phase behavior of time variations of sunspot umbra area and magnetic field of the sunspot demonstrates that the umbra of sunspot moves in long-term oscillations as a whole: all its points oscillate with the same phase.

Analysis of a 12-Hour Artifact in LF Oscillations of the Magnetic Field of Sunspots According to SDO/HMI Data

The properties of the 12-h artifact in the data of the SDO/HMI instrument (Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager) caused by the nonzero radial velocity of the station relative to the Sun are investigated. The study has been carried out with respect to long-period oscillations of the magnetic field of sunspots for different station positions in the Earth’s orbit by the alternative spectral method of singular decomposition of the signal CaterPillarSSA. Features of artifact filtering, both in special positions of the station (at the points of aphelion and perihelion) and at arbitrarily selected orbital points, are considered. It is shown that the 12-h artifact mode can be completely filtered from the time series of the observed variable, not only at these two orbital points (because of the symmetry of the station’s radial velocity with respect to the zero mean here) but also at any others. It is shown that only a 12-h mode is physically justified, while the 24-h harmonic appears only as an artifact in the Fourier decomposition of the amplitude-modulated signal. It is emphasized that the values of the magnetic field measured with SDO/HMI are sensitive only to the station’s radial velocity absolute values with respect to the Sun and do not depend on its direction. It has been noted that the periods of sunspot oscillation as a whole obtained from SDO/HMI data after orbital artifact filtration fit well into the dependence diagram of the period of sunspot oscillations on the value of its magnetic field strength constructed earlier by SOHO/MDIdata.

Free Oscillations of the Facula Node at the Stage of Slow Dissipation

A solar faculae having an appearance of quite long-lived magnetic nodes can perform (as well as sunspots, chromospheric filaments, coronal loops) free oscillations, i.e., they can oscillate about the stable equilibrium position as a single whole, changing quasi-periodically magnetic field averaged over the section with periods from 1 to 4 hours. Kolotkov et al. (2017) described the case in which the average magnetic field strength of the facula node considerably decreased during observations of SDO magnetograms (13 hours), and, at the same time, its oscillations acquired a specific character: the fundamental mode of free oscillations of the facula considerably increased in amplitude (by approximately two times), while the period of oscillations increased by three times. At the end of the process, the system dissipated. In this work, we present the exact solution of the equation of small-amplitude oscillations of the system with a time-variable rigidity, describing the oscillation behavior at which the elasticity of the system decreases with time, while the period and amplitude of oscillations grow.