Vera Pingoud

Type II restriction endonucleases: Structure and mechanism

Abstract.Type II restriction endonucleases are components of restriction modification systems that protect bacteria and archaea against invading foreign DNA. Most are homodimeric or tetrameric enzymes that cleave DNA at defined sites of 4–8 bp in length and require Mg2+ ions for catalysis. They differ in the details of the recognition process and the mode of cleavage, indicators that these enzymes are more diverse than originally thought. Still, most of them have a similar structural core and seem to share a common mechanism of DNA cleavage, suggesting that they evolved from a common ancestor. Only a few restriction endonucleases discovered thus far do not belong to the PD...D/ExK family of enzymes, but rather have active sites typical of other endonuclease families. The present review deals with new developments in the field of Type II restriction endonucleases. One of the more interesting aspects is the increasing awareness of the diversity of Type II restriction enzymes. Nevertheless, structural studies summarized herein deal with the more common subtypes. A major emphasis of this review will be on target site location and the mechanism of catalysis, two problems currently being addressed in the literature.

Developing a programmed restriction endonuclease for highly specific DNA cleavage

Specific cleavage of large DNA molecules at few sites, necessary for the analysis of genomic DNA or for targeting individual genes in complex genomes, requires endonucleases of extremely high specificity. Restriction endonucleases (REase) that recognize DNA sequences of 4–8 bp are not sufficiently specific for this purpose. In principle, the specificity of REases can be extended by fusion to sequence recognition modules, e.g. specific DNA-binding domains or triple-helix forming oligonucleotides (TFO). We have chosen to extend the specificity of REases using TFOs, given the combinatorial flexibility this fusion offers in addressing a short, yet precisely recognized restriction site next to a defined triple-helix forming site (TFS). We demonstrate here that the single chain variant of PvuII (scPvuII) covalently coupled via the bifunctional cross-linker N-(γ-maleimidobutryloxy) succinimide ester to a TFO (5′-NH2-[CH2]6 or 12-MPMPMPMPMPPPPPPT-3′, with M being 5-methyl-2′-deoxycytidine and P being 5-[1-propynyl]-2′-deoxyuridine), cleaves DNA specifically at the recognition site of PvuII (CAGCTG) if located in a distance of approximately one helical turn to a TFS (underlined) complementary to the TFO (‘addressed’ site: 5′-TTTTTTTCTCTCTCTCN∼10CAGCTG-3′), leaving ‘unaddressed’ PvuII sites intact. The preference for cleavage of an ‘addressed’ compared to an ‘unaddressed’ site is >1000-fold, if the cleavage reaction is initiated by addition of Mg2+ ions after preincubation of scPvuII-TFO and substrate in the absence of Mg2+ ions to allow triple-helix formation before DNA cleavage. Single base pair substitutions in the TFS prevent addressed DNA cleavage by scPvuII-TFO.

Chimeras of the homing endonuclease PI-SceI and the homologous Candida tropicalis intein: a study to explore the possibility of exchanging DNA-binding modules to obtain highly specific endonucleases with altered specificity.

Homing endonucleases are extremely specific endodeoxyribonucleases. In vivo, these enzymes confer mobility on their genes by inducing a very specific double‐strand cut in cognate alleles that lack the cooling sequence for the homing endonuclease; the cellular repair of the double‐strand break with the endonuclease‐containing allele as a template leads to integration of the endonuclease gene, completing the homing process. As a result of their extreme sequence specificity, homing endonucleases are promising tools for genome engineering. For this purpose, it is desirable to design enzymes with defined new specificities. To analyse which DNA‐binding elements are potential candidates for use in the design of enzymes with modified or even new specificity, we produced several chimeric proteins derived from the Saccharomyces cerevisiae VMA1 intein (PI‐SceI) and the related Candida tropicalis VMA1 intein. Although the mature Candida intein is devoid of endonucleolytic activity, the exchange of two DNA‐binding modules of PI‐SceI with the homologous elements from the Candida intein results in an active endonuclease. The low sequence homology in these modules indicates that different protein–DNA contacts are responsible for the recognition of related DNA sequences. This flexibility in DNA recognition should, in principle, allow endonucleases to be produced with new specificities useful for genome engineering.

On the Divalent Metal Ion Dependence of DNA Cleavage by Restriction Endonucleases of the EcoRI Family

Restriction endonucleases of the PD...D/EXK family need Mg(2+) for DNA cleavage. Whereas Mg(2+) (or Mn(2+)) promotes catalysis, Ca(2+) (without Mg(2+)) only supports DNA binding. The role of Mg(2+) in DNA cleavage by restriction endonucleases has elicited many hypotheses, differing mainly in the number of Mg(2+) involved in catalysis. To address this problem, we measured the Mg(2+) and Mn(2+) concentration dependence of DNA cleavage by BamHI, BglII, Cfr10I, EcoRI, EcoRII (catalytic domain), MboI, NgoMIV, PspGI, and SsoII, which were reported in co-crystal structure analyses to bind one (BglII and EcoRI) or two (BamHI and NgoMIV) Me(2+) per active site. DNA cleavage experiments were carried out at various Mg(2+) and Mn(2+) concentrations at constant ionic strength. All enzymes show a qualitatively similar Mg(2+) and Mn(2+) concentration dependence. In general, the Mg(2+) concentration optimum (between approximately 1 and 10 mM) is higher than the Mn(2+) concentration optimum (between approximately 0.1 and 1 mM). At still higher Mg(2+) or Mn(2+) concentrations, the activities of all enzymes tested are reduced but can be reactivated by Ca(2+). Based on these results, we propose that one Mg(2+) or Mn(2+) is critical for restriction enzyme activation, and binding of a second Me(2+) plays a role in modulating the activity. Steady-state kinetics carried out with EcoRI and BamHI suggest that binding of a second Mg(2+) or Mn(2+) mainly leads to an increase in K(m), such that the inhibitory effect of excess Mg(2+) or Mn(2+) can be overcome by increasing the substrate concentration. Our conclusions are supported by molecular dynamics simulations and are consistent with the structural observations of both one and two Me(2+) binding to these enzymes.

PspGI, a Type II Restriction Endonuclease from the Extreme Thermophile Pyrococcus sp.: Structural and Functional Studies to Investigate an Evolutionary Relationship with Several Mesophilic Restriction Enzymes

We present here the first detailed biochemical analysis of an archaeal restriction enzyme. PspGI shows sequence similarity to SsoII, EcoRII, NgoMIV and Cfr10I, which recognize related DNA sequences. We demonstrate here that PspGI, like SsoII and unlike EcoRII or NgoMIV and Cfr10I, interacts with and cleaves DNA as a homodimer and is not stimulated by simultaneous binding to two recognition sites. PspGI and SsoII differ in their basic biochemical properties, viz. stability against chemical denaturation and proteolytic digestion, DNA binding and the pH, MgCl(2) and salt-dependence of their DNA cleavage activity. In contrast, the results of mutational analyses and cross-link experiments show that PspGI and SsoII have a very similar DNA binding site and catalytic center as NgoMIV and Cfr10I (whose crystal structures are known), and presumably also as EcoRII, in spite of the fact that these enzymes, which all recognize variants of the sequence -/CC-GG- (/ denotes the site of cleavage), are representatives of different subgroups of type II restriction endonucleases. A sequence comparison of all known restriction endonuclease sequences, furthermore, suggests that several enzymes recognizing other DNA sequences also share amino acid sequence similarities with PspGI, SsoII and EcoRII in the region of the presumptive active site. These results are discussed in an evolutionary context.

The monomeric homing endonuclease PI-SceI has two catalytic centres for cleavage of the two strands of its DNA substrate.

The monomeric homing endonuclease PI‐SceI cleaves the two strands of its DNA substrate in a concerted manner, which raises the question of whether this enzyme harbours one or two catalytic centres. If PI‐SceI has only one catalytic centre, one would expect that cross‐linking enzyme and substrate should prevent reorientation of the enzyme required to perform the second cut after having made the first cut: PI‐SceI, however, when cross‐linked to its substrate, is able to cleave both DNA strands. If PI‐SceI has two catalytic centres, one would expect that it should be possible to inactivate one catalytic centre by mutation and obtain a variant with preference for a substrate nicked in one strand; such variants have been found. The structural homology between the catalytic domain of PI‐SceI having a pseudo 2‐fold symmetry, and I‐CreI, a homodimeric homing endonuclease, suggests that in PI‐SceI active site I, which attacks the top strand, comprises Asp218, Asp229 and Lys403, while Asp326, Thr341 and Lys301 make up active site II, which cleaves the bottom strand. Cleavage experiments with modified oligodeoxynucleotides and metal ion mapping experiments demonstrate that PI‐SceI interacts differently with the two strands at the cleavage position, supporting a model of two catalytic centres.

Photocross-linking of the Homing Endonuclease PI-SceI to Its Recognition Sequence

PI-SceI is an intein-encoded protein that belongs to the LAGLIDADG family of homing endonucleases. According to the crystal structure and mutational studies, this endonuclease consists of two domains, one responsible for protein splicing, the other for DNA cleavage, and both presumably for DNA binding. To define the DNA binding site of PI-SceI, photocross-linking was used to identify amino acid residues in contact with DNA. Sixty-three double-stranded oligodeoxynucleotides comprising the minimal recognition sequence and containing single 5-iodopyrimidine substitutions in almost all positions of the recognition sequence were synthesized and irradiated in the presence of PI-SceI with a helium/cadmium laser (325 nm). The best cross-linking yield (approximately 30%) was obtained with an oligodeoxynucleotide with a 5-iododeoxyuridine at position +9 in the bottom strand. The subsequent analysis showed that cross-linking had occurred with amino acid His-333, 6 amino acids after the second LAGLIDADG motif. With the H333A variant of PI-SceI or in the presence of excess unmodified oligodeoxynucleotide, no cross-linking was observed, indicating the specificity of the cross-linking reaction. Chemical modification of His residues in PI-SceI by diethylpyrocarbonate leads to a substantial reduction in the binding and cleavage activity of PI-SceI. This inactivation can be suppressed by substrate binding. This result further supports the finding that at least one His residue is in close contact to the DNA. Based on these and published results, conclusions are drawn regarding the DNA binding site of PI-SceI.

Sequence-dependent enhancement of hydrolytic deamination of cytosines in DNA by the restriction enzyme PspGI

Hydrolytic deamination of cytosines in DNA creates uracil and, if unrepaired, these lesions result in C to T mutations. We have suggested previously that a possible way in which cells may prevent or reduce this chemical reaction is through the binding of proteins to DNA. We use a genetic reversion assay to show that a restriction enzyme, PspGI, protects cytosines within its cognate site, 5′-CCWGG (W is A or T), against deamination under conditions where no DNA cleavage can occur. It decreases the rate of cytosine deamination to uracil by 7-fold. However, the same protein dramatically increases the rate of deaminations within the site 5′-CCSGG (S is C or G) by ∼15-fold. Furthermore, a similar increase in cytosine deaminations is also seen with a catalytically inactive mutant of the enzyme showing that endonucleolytic ability of the protein is dispensable for its mutagenic action. The sequences of the mutants generated in the presence of PspGI show that only one of the cytosines in CCSGG is predominantly converted to thymine. Our results are consistent with PspGI ‘sensitizing’ the cytosine in the central base pair in CCSGG for deamination. Remarkably, PspGI sensitizes this base for damage despite its inability to form stable complexes at CCSGG sites. These results can be explained if the enzyme has a transient interaction with this sequence during which it flips the central cytosine out of the helix. This prediction was validated by modeling the structure of PspGI–DNA complex based on the structure of the related enzyme Ecl18kI which is known to cause base-flipping.

Identification of base-specific contacts in protein–DNA complexes by photocrosslinking and mass spectrometry: a case study using the restriction endonuclease SsoII

Specific protein-nucleic acid interactions are of paramount importance for the propagation, maintenance and expression of genetic information. Restriction endonucleases serve as model systems to study the mechanisms of DNA recognition by proteins. SsoII is a Type II restriction endonuclease that recognizes the double stranded sequence downward arrow CCNGG and cleaves it in the presence of Mg(2+)-ions, as indicated. SsoII shows sequence similarity over a stretch of approximately 70 amino acid residues with several other restriction endonucleases that recognize a similar sequence as SsoII (Cfr10I, EcoRII, NgoMIV, PspGI). In NgoMIV this stretch is involved in DNA recognition and cleavage, as shown by the crystal structure analysis of an enzyme-product complex. To find out whether the presumptive DNA recognition region in SsoII is indeed in contact with DNA we have photocrosslinked SsoII with an oligodeoxyribonucleotide in which the first guanine of the recognition sequence was replaced by 5-iodouracil. Following digestion by trypsin, the peptide-oligodeoxyribonucleotide conjugate was purified by Fe(3+)-IMAC and then incubated with hydrogen fluoride, which hydrolyzes the oligodeoxyribonucleotide to yield the peptide-deoxyuridine conjugate. The site of photocrosslinking was identified by MALDI-TOF-MS and MALDI-TOF-MS/MS to be Trp189, adjacent to Arg188, which aligns with Arg194 in NgoMIV, involved in recognition of the second guanine in the NgoMIV recognition sequence G downward arrow CCGGC. This result confirms previously published conclusions drawn on the basis of a mutational analysis of SsoII. The methodology that was employed here can be used in principle to identify the DNA binding site of any protein.

Affinity modification of the restriction endonuclease SsoII by 2'-aldehyde-containing double stranded DNAs.

Properties of 2′-aldehyde-containing double stranded DNAs (dsDNAs) have been studied for the first time as substrate analogs of the restriction endonuclease SsoII. These reactive oligonucleotides were successfully cross-linked to the restriction endonuclease SsoII by reductive amination, and conditions for DNA-protein conjugate trypsinolysis followed by the oligonucleotide-peptide conjugate purification were optimized. Use of MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry revealed that covalent linkage forms between the sugar moiety of the central pyrimidine nucleoside of the SsoII recognition site and Lys173 of the enzyme. The latter is probably involved in initial steps of enzyme-substrate recognition during dsDNA readout.