Vincent Brochard

Developmental Potential of Mouse Embryos Reconstructed from Metaphase Embryonic Stem Cell Nuclei

Abstract Mice have recently been successfully cloned from embryonic stem (ES) cells. However, these fast dividing cells provide a heterogenous population of donor nuclei, in terms of cell cycle stage. Here we used metaphases as a source of donor nuclei because they offer the advantage of being both unambiguously recognizable and synchronous with the recipient metaphase II oocyte. We showed that metaphases from ES cells can provide a significantly higher development rate to the morula or blastocyst stage (56–70%) than interphasic nuclei (up to 28%) following injection into a recipient oocyte. Selective detachment of mitotic cells after a demecolcin treatment greatly facilitates and accelerates the reconstruction of embryos by providing a nearly pure population of cells in metaphase and did not markedly affect the developmental rate. Most of the blastocysts obtained by this procedure were normal in terms of both morphology and ratio of inner cell mass and total cell number. After transfer into pseudopregnant recipients at the one- or two-cell stage, the ability of metaphase to be fully reprogrammed was demonstrated by the birth of two pups (1.5% of activated oocytes). Although the implantation rate was quite high (up to 32.9% of activated oocytes), the postimplantation development was characterized by a high and rapid mortality. Our data provide a clear situation to explore the long-lasting effects that can be induced by early reprogramming events.

Developmental abnormalities of NT mouse embryos appear early after implantation.

In mammals, cloning by nuclear transfer (NT) into an enucleated oocyte is a very inefficient process, even if it can generate healthy adults. We show that blastocysts derived from embryonic stem (ES) donor cells develop at a high rate, correctly express the pluripotential marker gene Oct4 in ICM cells and display normal growth in vitro. Moreover, the majority of them implant in the uterus of recipient females. We combine embryological studies, gene expression analysis during gastrulation and generation of chimaeric embryos to identify the developmental origin (stage and tissue affected) of NT embryo mortality. The majority died before mid-gestation from defects arising early, either at peri-implantation stages or during the gastrulation period. The first type of defect is a non-cell autonomous defect of the epiblast cells and is rescued by complementation of NT blastocysts with normal ES or ICM cells. The second type of defect affects growth regulation and the shape of the embryo but does not directly impair the initial establishment of the patterning of the embryo. Only chimaeras formed by the aggregation of NT and tetraploid embryos reveal no growth abnormalities at gastrulation. These studies indicate that the trophoblast cell lineage is the primary source of these defects. These embryological studies provide a solid basis for understanding reprogramming errors in NT embryos. In addition, they unveil new aspects of growth regulation while increasing our knowledge on the role of crosstalk between the extra-embryonic and the embryonic regions of the conceptus in the control of growth and morphogenesis.

Trichostatin A treatment of cloned mouse embryos improves constitutive heterochromatin remodeling as well as developmental potential to term

BackgroundGenome reprogramming in early mouse embryos is associated with nuclear reorganization and particular features such as the peculiar distribution of centromeric and pericentric heterochromatin during the first developmental stage. This zygote-specific heterochromatin organization could be observed both in maternal and paternal pronuclei after natural fertilization as well as in embryonic stem (ES) cell nuclei after nuclear transfer suggesting that this particular type of nuclear organization was essential for embryonic reprogramming and subsequent development.ResultsHere, we show that remodeling into a zygotic-like organization also occurs after somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT), supporting the hypothesis that reorganization of constitutive heterochromatin occurs regardless of the source and differentiation state of the starting material. However, abnormal nuclear remodeling was frequently observed after SCNT, in association with low developmental efficiency. When transient treatment with the histone deacetylase inhibitor trichostatin A (TSA) was tested, we observed improved nuclear remodeling in 1-cell SCNT embryos that correlated with improved rates of embryonic development at subsequent stages.ConclusionTogether, the results suggest that proper organization of constitutive heterochromatin in early embryos is involved in the initial developmental steps and might have long term consequences, especially in cloning procedures.

Naive and primed murine pluripotent stem cells have distinct miRNA expression profiles.

Over the last years, the microRNA (miRNA) pathway has emerged as a key component of the regulatory network of pluripotency. Although clearly distinct states of pluripotency have been described in vivo and ex vivo, differences in miRNA expression profiles associated with the developmental modulation of pluripotency have not been extensively studied so far. Here, we performed deep sequencing to profile miRNA expression in naive (embryonic stem cell [ESC]) and primed (epiblast stem cell [EpiSC]) pluripotent stem cells derived from mouse embryos of identical genetic background. We developed a graphical representation method allowing the rapid identification of miRNAs with an atypical profile including mirtrons, a small nucleolar RNA (snoRNA)-derived miRNA, and miRNAs whose biogenesis may differ between ESC and EpiSC. Comparison of mature miRNA profiles revealed that ESCs and EpiSCs exhibit very different miRNA signatures with one third of miRNAs being differentially expressed between the two cell types. Notably, differential expression of several clusters, including miR290-295, miR17-92, miR302/367, and a large repetitive cluster on chromosome 2, was observed. Our analysis also showed that differentiation priming of EpiSC compared to ESC is evidenced by changes in miRNA expression. These dynamic changes in miRNAs signature are likely to reflect both redundant and specific roles of miRNAs in the fine-tuning of pluripotency during development.

Polycomb function during oogenesis is required for mouse embryonic development

In mammals, totipotent embryos are formed by fusion of highly differentiated gametes. Acquisition of totipotency concurs with chromatin remodeling of parental genomes, changes in the maternal transcriptome and proteome, and zygotic genome activation (ZGA). The inefficiency of reprogramming somatic nuclei in reproductive cloning suggests that intergenerational inheritance of germline chromatin contributes to developmental proficiency after natural conception. Here we show that Ring1 and Rnf2, components of Polycomb-repressive complex 1 (PRC1), serve redundant transcriptional functions during oogenesis that are essential for proper ZGA, replication and cell cycle progression in early embryos, and development beyond the two-cell stage. Exchange of chromosomes between control and Ring1/Rnf2-deficient metaphase II oocytes reveal cytoplasmic and chromosome-based contributions by PRC1 to embryonic development. Our results strongly support a model in which Polycomb acts in the female germline to establish developmental competence for the following generation by silencing differentiation-inducing genes and defining appropriate chromatin states.

Synergic reprogramming of mammalian cells by combined exposure to mitotic Xenopus egg extracts and transcription factors

Transfer of somatic cell nuclei to enucleated eggs and ectopic expression of specific transcription factors are two different reprogramming strategies used to generate pluripotent cells from differentiated cells. However, these methods are poorly efficient, and other unknown factors might be required to increase their success rate. Here we show that Xenopus egg extracts at the metaphase stage (M phase) have a strong reprogramming activity on mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs). First, they reset replication properties of MEF nuclei toward a replication profile characteristic of early development, and they erase several epigenetic marks, such as trimethylation of H3K9, H3K4, and H4K20. Second, when MEFs are reversibly permeabilized in the presence of M-phase Xenopus egg extracts, they show a transient increase in cell proliferation, form colonies, and start to express specific pluripotency markers. Finally, transient exposure of MEF nuclei to M-phase Xenopus egg extracts increases the success of nuclear transfer to enucleated mouse oocytes and strongly synergizes with the production of pluripotent stem cells by ectopic expression of transcription factors. The mitotic stage of the egg extract is crucial, because none of these effects is detected when using interphasic Xenopus egg extracts. Our data demonstrate that mitosis is essential to make mammalian somatic nuclei prone to reprogramming and that, surprisingly, the heterologous Xenopus system has features that are conserved enough to remodel mammalian nuclei.

Efficient derivation of bovine embryonic stem cells needs more than active core pluripotency factors

Pluripotency can be captured in vitro, providing that the culture environment meets the requirements that avoid differentiation while stimulating self‐renewal. From studies in the mouse embryo, two kinds of pluripotent stem cells have been obtained from the early and late epiblast, embryonic stem cells (ESCs) and epiblast stem cells (EpiSCs), representing the naive and primed states, respectively. All attempts to derive convincing ESCs in ungulates have been unsuccessful, although all attempts were based on the assumption that the conditions used to derive mouse ESCs or human ESC could be applied in other species. Pluripotent cells derived in primates, rabbit, and pig strongly indicate that the state of pluripotency of these cells is, in fact, closer to EpiSCs than to ESCs, and thus depend on fibroblast growth factor (FGF) and Activin signaling pathways. Based on this observation, we have tried to derive EpiSC from the epiblast of bovine elongated embryos as well as ESCs from Day‐8 blastocysts. We here show that the core transcription factors Oct4/Sox2/Nanog can be used as markers of pluripotency in the bovine since their expression was restricted to the developing epiblast after Day 8, and disappeared following differentiation of both the ESC‐like and EpiSC‐like cultures. Although FGF and Activin pathways are indeed present and active in the bovine, it is not sufficient/enough to maintain a long‐term pluripotency ex vivo, as was reported for mouse and pig EpiSCs. Mol. Reprod. Dev. 79:461–477, 2012.

Nuclear Transfer‐Derived Epiblast Stem Cells Are Transcriptionally and Epigenetically Distinguishable from Their Fertilized‐Derived Counterparts

Mouse embryonic pluripotent stem cells can be obtained from the inner cell mass at the blastocyst stage (embryonic stem cells, ESCs) or from the late epiblast of postimplantation embryos (epiblast stem cells, EpiSCs). During normal development, the transition between these two stages is marked by major epigenetic and transcriptional changes including DNA de novo methylation. These modifications represent an epigenetic mark conserved in ESCs and EpiSCs. Pluripotent ESCs derived from blastocysts generated by nuclear transfer (NT) have been shown to be correctly reprogrammed. However, NT embryos frequently undergo abnormal development. In the present study, we have examined whether pluripotent cells could be derived from the epiblast of postimplantation NT embryos and whether the reprogramming process would affect the epigenetic changes occurring at this stage, which could explain abnormal development of NT embryos. We showed that EpiSCs could be derived with the same efficiency from NT embryos and from their fertilized counterparts. However, gene expression profile analyses showed divergence between fertilized‐ and nuclear transfer‐EpiSCs with a surprising bias in the distribution of the differentially expressed genes, 30% of them being localized on chromosome 11. A majority of these genes were downregulated in NT‐EpiSCs and imprinted genes represented a significant fraction of them. Notably, analysis of the epigenetic status of a downregulated imprinted gene in NT‐EpiSCs revealed complete methylation of the two alleles. Therefore, EpiSCs derived from NT embryos appear to be incorrectly reprogrammed, indicating that abnormal epigenetic marks are imposed on cells in NT embryos during the transition from early to late epiblast. STEM CELLS 2010;28:743–75228:743–752

Early alteration of the self-renewal/differentiation threshold in trophoblast stem cells derived from mouse embryos after nuclear transfer.

Development after nuclear transfer (NT) is subjected to defects originating from both the epiblast and the trophoblast parts of the conceptus and is always accompanied by placentomegaly at term. Here we have investigated the origin of the reprogramming errors affecting the trophoblast lineage in mouse NT embryos. We show that trophoblast stem (TS) cells can be derived from NT embryos (ntTS cells) and used as an experimental in vitro model of trophoblast proliferation and differentiation. Strikingly, TS derivation is more efficient from NT embryos than from controls and ntTS cells exhibit a growth advantage over control TS cells under self-renewal conditions. While epiblast-produced growth factors Fgf4 and Activin exert a fine-tuned control on the balance between self-renewal and differentiation of control TS cells, ntTS cells exhibit a reduced dependency upon their micro-environment. Since the supply of growth factors is known do decrease at the onset of placental formation in vivo we propose that TS cells in NT embryos continue to self-renew during a longer period of time than in fertilized embryo. The resulting increased pool of progenitors could contribute to the enlarged extra-embryonic region observed in the early trophoblast of in vivo grown mouse NT blastocysts that results in placentomegaly.

Stable methylation at promoters distinguishes epiblast stem cells from embryonic stem cells and the in vivo epiblasts.

Embryonic Stem Cells (ESCs) and Epiblast Stem Cells (EpiSCs) are the in vitro representatives of naïve and primed pluripotency, respectively. It is currently unclear how their epigenomes underpin the phenotypic and molecular characteristics of these distinct pluripotent states. Here, we performed a genome-wide comparison of DNA methylation between ESCs and EpiSCs by MethylCap-Seq. We observe that promoters are preferential targets for methylation in EpiSC compared to ESCs, in particular high CpG island promoters. This is in line with upregulation of the de novo methyltransferases Dnmt3a1 and Dnmt3b in EpiSC, and downregulation of the demethylases Tet1 and Tet2. Remarkably, the observed DNA methylation signature is specific to EpiSCs and differs from that of their in vivo counterpart, the postimplantation epiblast. Using a subset of promoters that are differentially methylated, we show that DNA methylation is established within a few days during in vitro outgrowth of the epiblast, and also occurs when ESCs are converted to EpiSCs in vitro. Once established, this methylation is stable, as ES-like cells obtained by in vitro reversion of EpiSCs display an epigenetic memory that only extensive passaging and sub-cloning are able to almost completely erase.