Virginia V.W. McIntosh

Out-patient psychological therapies for adults with anorexia nervosa: randomised controlled trial

BACKGROUND Very limited evidence is available on how to treat adults with anorexia nervosa and treatment outcomes are poor. Novel treatment approaches are urgently needed. AIMS To evaluate the efficacy and acceptability of a novel psychological therapy for anorexia nervosa (Maudsley Model of Anorexia Nervosa Treatment for Adults, MANTRA) compared with specialist supportive clinical management (SSCM) in a randomised controlled trial. METHOD Seventy-two adult out-patients with anorexia nervosa or eating disorder not otherwise specified were recruited from a specialist eating disorder service in the UK. Participants were randomly allocated to 20 once weekly sessions of MANTRA or SSCM and optional additional sessions depending on severity and clinical need (trial registration: ISRCTN62920529). The primary outcomes were body mass index, weight and global score on the Eating Disorders Examination at end of treatment (6 months) and follow-up (12 months). Secondary outcomes included: depression, anxiety and clinical impairment; neuropsychological outcomes; recovery rates; and additional service utilisation. RESULTS At baseline, patients randomised to MANTRA were significantly less likely to be in a partner relationship than those receiving SSCM (3/34 v. 10/36; P<0.05). Patients in both treatments improved significantly in terms of eating disorder and other outcomes, with no differences between groups. Strictly defined recovery rates were low. However, MANTRA patients were significantly more likely to require additional in-patient or day-care treatment than those receiving SSCM (7/34 v. 0/37; P = 0.004). CONCLUSIONS Adults with anorexia nervosa are a difficult to treat group. The imbalance between groups in partner relationships may explain differences in service utilisation favouring SSCM. This study confirms SSCM as a useful treatment for out-patients with anorexia nervosa. The novel treatment, MANTRA, designed for this patient group may need adaptations to fully exploit its potential.

The Long-Term Efficacy of Three Psychotherapies for Anorexia Nervosa: A Randomized, Controlled Trial

OBJECTIVE To evaluate the long-term efficacy of three psychotherapies for anorexia nervosa. METHOD Participants were women with broadly defined anorexia nervosa who had participated in a RCT comparing specialized psychotherapies (cognitive behavior therapy, CBT, and interpersonal psychotherapy, IPT) with a control condition (specialist supportive clinical management, SSCM), and attended long-term follow-up assessment (mean 6.7 years ± 1.2). RESULTS Forty three of the original sample of 56 women participated in long-term follow-up assessment (77%). No significant differences were found on any pre-selected primary, secondary or tertiary outcome measures among the three psychotherapies at long-term follow-up assessment. Significantly different patterns of recovery were identified for the psychotherapies across time on the primary global outcome measure. Although SSCM was associated with a more rapid response than IPT, by follow-up all three treatments were indistinguishable. DISCUSSION Potential implications for the timing of interventions to improve treatment response in anorexia nervosa are critically examined.

Interpersonal psychotherapy for anorexia nervosa.

OBJECTIVE This paper outlines the rationale for treating individuals with anorexia nervosa using interpersonal psychotherapy. METHOD We review theoretical, empirical, and psychotherapy literature relating to interpersonal functioning in anorexia nervosa. RESULTS Etiological theories emphasize interpersonal and family dysfunction in the development of anorexia nervosa. Research supports the notion that families of individuals with anorexia nervosa have dysfunctional patterns of communication. The history of treatment for anorexia nervosa emphasizes the need for resolution of interpersonal dysfunction, within the traditions of psychodynamic, family therapy, and multidimensional therapies. DISCUSSION Interpersonal psychotherapy is a time-limited psychotherapy based on the notion that regardless of etiology, interpersonal relationships are intertwined with symptomatology. The goals of the therapy are to improve interpersonal functioning and thereby decrease symptomatology. Factors identified as important in the development of anorexia nervosa are readily conceptualized within the interpersonal psychotherapy problem areas of grief, interpersonal disputes, interpersonal deficits, and role transitions.

Predictors of rapid and sustained response to cognitive-behavioral therapy for bulimia nervosa

OBJECTIVE To examine characteristics of individuals who show a rapid and sustained response to cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) for bulimia nervosa (BN). METHOD As part of a randomized clinical trial designed to dismantle CBT for BN, we compared 19 individuals who exhibited complete abstinence from binging and purging after only eight sessions of CBT and maintained abstinence throughout the duration of treatment and the 1-year follow-up interval, to 79 individuals who had a more variable response to treatment. Demographics, baseline clinical characteristics, lifetime comorbidity, and personality disorder symptoms and profiles from the Temperament and Character Inventory were examined. RESULTS In univariate analyses, frequency of binging and purging at baseline, low scores on the Eating Disorders Inventory (EDI) Bulimia subscale, lower harm avoidance, and higher self-directedness were associated with rapid response. In multiple regression analyses, frequency of binging at baseline (OR = 0.87; 95% CI 0.77-0.98) and self-directedness (OR = 1.12; 95% CI 1.04-1.21) independently predicted rapid and sustained treatment response. CONCLUSION Frequency of binging and the character quality of self-directedness may be useful predictors of those individuals who are likely to respond positively to a brief course of CBT for BN.

Psychotherapy for depression: A randomized clinical trial comparing schema therapy and cognitive behavior therapy

BACKGROUND The efficacy of Cognitive Behavior Therapy (CBT) for depression has been robustly supported, however, up to fifty percent of individuals do not respond fully. A growing body of research indicates Schema Therapy (ST) is an effective treatment for difficult and entrenched problems, and as such, may be an effective therapy for depression. METHODS In this randomized clinical trial the comparative efficacy of CBT and ST for depression was examined. 100 participants with major depression received weekly cognitive behavioral therapy or schema therapy sessions for 6 months, followed by monthly therapy sessions for 6 months. Key outcomes were comparisons over the weekly and monthly sessions of therapy along with remission and recovery rates. Additional analyses examined outcome for those with chronic depression and comorbid personality disorders. RESULTS ST was not significantly better (nor worse) than CBT for the treatment of depression. The therapies were of comparable efficacy on all key outcomes. There were no differential treatment effects for those with chronic depression or comorbid personality disorders. LIMITATIONS This study needs replication. CONCLUSIONS This preliminary research indicates that ST may provide an effective alternative therapy for depression.

Bipolar II disorder: personality and outcome in two clinical samples

OBJECTIVE To compare the personality traits and disorders of patients with bipolar II disorder and major depression and to examine the impact on treatment outcome of a bipolar II diagnosis. METHOD Patients from two clinical trials, a depressive sample (n = 195, 10% bipolar II) and a bulimic sample (n = 135, 16% bipolar II), were assessed for personality traits using DSM-IV criteria. Patients were randomised to treatments (fluoxetine or nortriptyline for depressive sample; cognitive behaviour therapy for bulimic sample) and followed for 3 years (depressive sample) or 5 years (bulimic sample) to assess the impact on outcome of a bipolar II diagnosis. RESULTS Bipolar II patients were assessed as having more borderline, histrionic and schizotypal personality traits than patients with major depression. A baseline bipolar II diagnosis did not impact negatively on treatment outcome, and less than 5% of bipolar II patients developed bipolar I disorder during follow up. CONCLUSIONS The low rate of conversion of bipolar II to bipolar I disorder and the lack of adverse impact of the diagnosis on outcome, questions the need for antimanic or mood stabiliser medication in most bipolar II patients.

Weight suppression predicts weight gain over treatment but not treatment completion or outcome in bulimia nervosa.

The authors attempted to replicate previous findings that weight suppression is a significant predictor of treatment completion and treatment outcome (M. L. Butryn, M. R. Lowe, D. L. Safer, & W. S. Agras, 2006) and weight gain over treatment (M. R. Lowe, W. Davis, D. Lucks, R. A. Annunziato, & M. L. Butryn, 2006) among women with bulimic disorders. The authors also examined 2 alternative measures of weight variability. Participants were 132 women with bulimia nervosa treated with cognitive-behavioral therapy. Participants who dropped out of treatment did not have significantly higher levels of weight suppression than did treatment completers. Among those who completed treatment, weight suppression did not significantly predict binge eating and purging at post-treatment. Weight suppression did significantly predict weight change and, in particular, weight gain (>/=5 kg) over treatment. Alternative measures of weight variability did not significantly predict treatment completion or treatment outcome, but 1 measure significantly predicted weight gain over treatment. In conclusion, the authors failed to replicate the previous finding that weight suppression predicts treatment compliance and treatment outcome, but they did replicate the finding that weight suppression predicts weight gain over treatment.

Menstrual cycle irregularity in bulimia nervosa Associated factors and changes with treatment

OBJECTIVES This study determined the clinical and nutritional variables associated with menstrual disturbance in women with bulimia nervosa (BN). METHODS Eighty-two women with DSM-IV BN underwent psychiatric, nutritional and menstrual related assessments prior to an outpatient treatment programme and at 12 months follow-up. RESULTS Forty-five percent reported a current irregular menstrual cycle. A high frequency of vomiting, low thyroxine concentrations and low dietary fat intake were independently associated with irregular menses at pretreatment. At 12 months follow-up, 30.5% reported irregular menstrual cycles. A greater difference between past maximum and minimum body weight, smoking and depression were associated with menstrual irregularity at 12 months follow-up. Of those with irregular menstrual cycles at pretreatment, 56.8% became regular at 12 months follow-up. CONCLUSION Menstrual irregularity in BN is associated with indices of nutritional restriction that are not reflected by low body weight or energy intake. Depression, cigarette smoking and fluctuations in body weight may act as metabolic stresses that contribute to the perpetuation of menstrual disturbances.

Five-year outcome of cognitive behavioral therapy and exposure with response prevention for bulimia nervosa

BACKGROUND Few data exist examining the longer-term outcome of bulimia nervosa (BN) following treatment with cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and exposure with response prevention (ERP). METHOD One hundred and thirty-five women with purging BN received eight sessions of individual CBT and were then randomly assigned to either relaxation training (RELAX) or one of two ERP treatments, pre-binge (B-ERP) or pre-purge cues (P-ERP). Participants were assessed yearly following treatment and follow-up data were recorded. RESULTS Eighty-one per cent of the total sample attended long-term follow-up. At 5 years, abstinence rates from binging were significantly higher for the two exposure treatments (43% and 54%) than for relaxation (27%), with no difference between the two forms of exposure. Over 5 years, the frequency of purging was lower for the exposure treatments than for relaxation training. Rates of recovery varied according to definition of recovery. Recovery continued to increase to 5 years. At 5 years, 83% no longer met DSM-III-R criteria for BN, 65% received no eating disorder diagnosis, but only 36% had been abstinent from bulimic behaviors for the past year. CONCLUSIONS This study provides possible evidence of a conditioned inoculation from exposure treatment compared with relaxation training in long-term abstinence from binge eating at 5 years, and the frequency of purging over 5 years, but not for other features of BN. Differences among the groups were not found prior to 5 years. CBT is effective for BN, yet a substantial group remains unwell in the long term. Definition of recovery impacts markedly on recovery rates.

Bulimia nervosa, childbirth, and psychopathology

OBJECTIVE To examine whether having a baby following treatment for bulimia nervosa places women at increased risk for continuing or relapsing eating disorders or major depression. METHODS Subjects were women who had participated in a large randomized controlled trial evaluating cognitive behavior therapy for bulimia nervosa, who were prospectively followed-up over 5 years. At follow-up assessments (at least yearly), life charts were completed with patients and childbirth was recorded. The presence of eating disorders and major depressive disorder was assessed using the Structured Interview for DSM-III-R. RESULTS Childbirth was not specifically associated with increased symptomatology. This was found for both eating disorders and major depression in the same year as childbirth and for the year following childbirth. CONCLUSION Childbirth is not specifically associated with symptomatology following treatment for bulimia nervosa.