Wayne A. Bennett

Temperature Tolerances of North American Freshwater Fishes Exposed to Dynamic Changes in Temperature

Traditionally lower and upper temperature tolerances of fishes have been quantified in the laboratory via three different experimental approaches: the Fry or incipient lethal temperature (ILT), critical thermal (CTM) and chronic lethal (CLM) methodologies. Although these three experimental laboratory approaches generate endpoints which are quantitatively expressed as a temperature, are determined experimentally with random samples of fish acclimated to specific temperatures, and involve both time and temperature as major test variables, they do not quantify the same response. All three approaches generate valuable, albeit different, information concerning the temperature tolerance of a species. In this review we have summarized published research concerning the tolerance of North American freshwater fishes to dynamic changes in temperature, i.e., tolerance is tested by methods that gradually change temperatures until biological stress is observed. We found more than 450 individual temperature tolerances listed in 80 publications which present original dynamic temperature tolerance data for 116 species, 7 subspecies and 7 hybrids from 19 families of North American freshwater fishes. This total represents about 1/3 of the families and 1/6 of the known North American freshwater species. Temperature tolerance data were partitioned by experimental approach, i.e., critical thermal method (CTM) and chronic lethal method (CLM), and direction of temperature change. Although both CTM and CLM expose fish to dynamic changes in water temperature, these two methods differ in temperature change rates and test endpoints, and hence measure different aspects of thermal stress. A majority of the 80 studies employed CTM to assess temperature tolerance, in particular determination of CTmaxima. One or more CTmaxima has been reported for 108 fishes. Twenty-two fishes have reported highest CTmaxima of 40°C or higher. Several species in the family Cyprinodontidae have generated some of the highest CTmaxima reported for any ectothermic vertebrate. For a variety of reasons, data concerning tolerance of low temperatures are less plentiful. Low temperature tolerance quantified as either CTminima or CLminima were found for a total of 37 fishes. Acclimation temperature exerts a major effect on the temperature tolerance of most North American fish species and it is usually strongly linearly related to both CTmaxima and CTminima. Although we uncovered dynamic temperature tolerance data for 130 fishes, only a single dynamic, temperature tolerance polygon has been published, that for the sheepshead minnow, Cyprinodon variegatus.

Quantification of the Role of Acclimation Temperature in Temperature Tolerance of Fishes

The relative effect of acclimation temperature on temperature tolerance was estimated from a geometrical partitioning of the temperature tolerance polygon of a fish species into three distinct zones relative to four key tolerance temperatures. This approach yields a middle tolerance zone which is independent of acclimation temperature bounded by upper and lower acclimation dependent zones. Acclimation dependent and independent temperature tolerance zones can be quantified by either areal or linear methods. Both methods were applied to quantify the effect of acclimation temperature in 21 species of temperate fishes for which temperature tolerance polygons were available. Temperature tolerance polygon areas of these 21 species ranged from 468 to 1380°C2 and are linearly related (r2=0.93, p<0.001) to ultimate incipient upper lethal temperatures. Although areal and linear partitioning methods yielded similar acclimation independent and dependent tolerances, estimates from the areal method incorporates additional information concerning the shape of the temperature tolerance polygon, in particular lower and upper lethal temperature plateaus. Mean combined acclimation dependent and independent tolerance areas of these 21 species were not different, indicating that acclimation effectively doubles the temperature tolerance polygon. Mean lower acclimation dependent area was nearly three times greater than mean upper acclimation dependent area, suggesting that acclimation plays a larger role in tolerance of low rather than high temperatures. Among these 21 species, temperature tolerance of brook charr and sheepshead minnow were the least and most affected by acclimation temperature, respectively.

Physiological Effects of Swim Bladder Overexpansion and Catastrophic Decompression on Red Snapper

Abstract The commercial and recreational harvests of red snapper Lutjanus campechanus in the Gulf of Mexico have declined over the past five decades, prompting strict regulations. Release mortality associated with catastrophic decompression (CD) is a possible cause for the continuing decline, although to date no physiological data exist to support this assumption. Using a flow-through high-pressure chamber, subadult red snapper were acclimated to 101.2, 405.3, 608.0, and 1,215.9 kPa, simulating depths typical of their distribution (as deep as 200 m), and then decompressed at a rate of 10.1 kPa/s. Lateral and dorsal X-ray imaging in combination with necropsy showed that swim bladders expanded in a predictable manner. Ventral expansion into the caudal body cavity space occurred at lower pressures, whereas expansion into the cranial portion of the body cavity occurred at the highest pressure. Expansion patterns resulted in over 70 different overexpansion injuries, the most severe being to vital organs. Our r...

Effects of Parturition and Feeding on Thermal Preference of Atlantic Stingray, Dasyatis sabina (Lesueur)

SynopsisTemperature is the most important and least well documented environmental entity affecting reproduction and feeding of elasmobranch fishes, but it is unclear to what extent these fish may exploit behavioral thermoregulation to optimize physiological processes. Laboratory thermal preference determinations are important to understanding behavioral processes because they provide the vital quantitative link between environment, physiology, and adaptive behavior. Temperature preference data were collected on Atlantic stingrays, Dasyatis sabina (Lesueur) to assess the fishs’ ability to behaviorally optimize feeding and reproduction. Groups of male and pregnant female Atlantic stingrays exhibited statistically higher preferred median temperatures (26.2 and 26.1°C, respectively) than non-pregnant females (25.3°C; One-Way ANOVA on ranked data, F [2,26] = 3.72, p=0.038). Median preferred temperatures in unfed stingrays of both genders ranged from 24.5 to 31.0°C, whereas, fed fish preferred temperatures between 23.5 and 27.5°C. Unfed stingrays preferred a median temperature of 24.5°C; however, after feeding fish preferred significantly warmer water temperatures of 25.7°C (Wilcoxon one-tail, matched-pairs, signed rank analysis; p<0.088). While overall differences were subtle, small preference adjustments can have important physiological consequences. For example, the 1°C increase seen in pregnant females over non-pregnant fish would reduce gestation time by as much as two weeks. Likewise, by moving to cooler water after feeding, stingrays may increase nutrient uptake efficiency by reducing evacuation rates. Our data indicate that movement and distribution of Atlantic stingrays are dictated, in part, by temperature effects on physiology.

Assessing cumulative thermal stress in fish during chronic intermittent exposure to high temperatures

Abstract As environmental laws become increasingly protective and with likely future changes in global climate, thermal effects on aquatic resources are likely to receive increasing attention. Lethal temperatures for a variety of species have been determined for situations where temperatures rise rapidly resulting in lethal effects. However, less is known about the effects of chronic exposure to high (but not immediately lethal) temperatures and even less about stress accumulation during periods of fluctuating temperatures. In this paper we present a modeling framework for assessing cumulative thermal stress in fish. The model assumes that stress accumulation occurs above a threshold temperature at a rate dependent on the degree to which the threshold is exceeded. The model also includes stress recovery (or alleviation) when temperatures drop below the threshold temperature as in systems with large daily variation. In addition to non-specific physiological stress, the model also simulates thermal effects on growth.

Comparison of methods for determining low temperature tolerance: experiments with pinfish, Lagodon rhomboides

RANDALL, J. E. 1965. A review of the razorfish genus Hemipteronotus (Labridae) of the Atlantic Ocean. Copeia 1965:487-501. , AND R. H. KUITER. 1982. Three new labrid fishes of the genus Coris from the Western Pacific. Pac. Sci. 36:159-173. ROSENBLATT, R. H., AND B. W. WALKER. 1963. The marine shore-fishes of the Galaipagos Islands. Occ. Papers California Acad. Sci. 44:97-106. THOMSON, D. A., L. T. FINDLEY, AND A. N. KERSTITCH. 1979. Reef fishes of the Sea of Cortez. John Wiley and Sons, New York, New York. VICTOR, B. C. 1986. The duration of the planktonic larval phase of one hundred species of Pacific and Atlantic wrasses (Family Labridae). Mar. Biol. 90: 317-326. . 1987a. The mating system of the Caribbean rosy razorfish, Xyrichtys martinicensis. Bull. Mar. Sci. 40:152-160.

Is post‐feeding thermotaxis advantageous in elasmobranch fishes?

The effects of post-feeding thermotaxis on ileum evacuation and absorption rates were examined in the laboratory using two elasmobranch species, the Atlantic stingray Dasyatis sabina, which inhabits thermally variable environments, and the whitespotted bamboo shark Chiloscyllium plagiosum, a stenothermic fish living on Indo-Pacific reefs. Experiments at temperatures similar to those experienced in nature revealed temperature change had no significant effect on C. plagiosum absorption or evacuation rates, suggesting stenothermic sharks cannot exploit temperature differences as a means to improve digestion efficiency. On the other hand, D. sabina showed significantly lower evacuation and absorption rates at lower temperatures. The relative decrease was greater for evacuation (Q₁₀ = 3·08) than absorption rates (Q₁₀ = 2·20), resulting in a significant increase in total absorption, suggesting D. sabina can benefit from using shuttling behaviour to exploit thermal variability in their environment to maximize energetic uptake.

Cold Tolerance and Potential Overwintering of the Red-Bellied Piranha Pygocentrus nattereri in the United States

Abstract Red-bellied piranhas Pygocentrus nattereri (also known as red piranhas) acclimated to 15–35°C had critical thermal minima (± SD) from 10.5 ± 0.31°C to 19.7 ± 1.25°C. The chronic thermal minimum (± SD) based on equilibrium loss of fish exposed to decreasing water temperatures of 1°C/d was 10.0 ± 0.15°C. Acclimation temperature incorporated into a second-order polynomial regression model accounted for 97% of variation in critical thermal minima. Fish in the laboratory were unable to capture live goldfish Carassius auratus at temperatures less than 14°C but accepted frozen adult brine shrimp Artemia sp. attemperatures as low as 12°C. When combined with shallow surface water temperature estimates for January, our temperature tolerance and feeding behavior data suggested that red-bellied piranhas may overwinter in nine southern states of the USA with varying degrees of success. Red-bellied piranhas would not overwinter where temperatures fall below 10°C. These fish could overwinter at temperatures of ...

Rates of Gain and Loss of Heat Tolerance in Channel Catfish

Abstract Thermal acclimation dynamics of channel catfish Ictalurus punctatus were quantified by using time-series critical thermal maximum (CTMax) estimates. Data consisted of CTMax determinations from 57 groups of 10 fish each. Respective CTMax values ranged from 30.9°C to 42.1°C for acclimation temperatures between 10°C and 35°C and increased 0.45°C for each 1°C increase in acclimation temperature. Rates of heat tolerance gain for fish transferred from low to high temperatures were not constant but decreased geometrically with respect to time until end-acclimation levels were reached. Fish transferred from high to low temperatures showed similar geometric patterns of tolerance loss; however, progressive decrease in CTMax was relatively slow and was interrupted after 24 h by a consistent 72-h acclimatory stasis. Differential patterns of heat tolerance gain and loss suggest that both processes place a premium on heat tolerance conservation. Acclimation times were influenced directly by absolute difference...

Diel temperature patterns of juvenile lemon sharks Negaprion brevirostris, in a shallow-water nursery

The relatively complex pattern of temperature selection exhibited by juvenile lemon sharks Negaprion brevirostris in the North Sound differed markedly from many previously described responses of fish preferenda. Thermal data demonstrated that juvenile N. brevirostris did not attempt to behaviourally maintain a constant eccritic temperature. Rather, juveniles selected progressively warmer temperatures throughout the day until reaching the highest temperatures available, and then moved to cooler temperatures during late evening and early morning hours. It is possible that by exploiting habitat thermal heterogeneity juvenile N. brevirostris prolong activities such as feeding or digestion well into the cooler parts of the evening. The complex pattern of temperature occupation by juvenile N. brevirostris within the thermally heterogeneous North Sound nursery is probably linked to key daily activities such as prey capture, predator avoidance and digestive efficiency.