Yi-Hsien Lu

Molecular layer of gaslike domains at a hydrophobic-water interface observed by frequency-modulation atomic force microscopy.

It was numerically predicted that dissolved gas particles could enrich and adsorb at hydrophobic-liquid interfaces. Here we observe nucleation and growth of bright patches of ∼0.45 nm high on the graphite surface in pure water with frequency-modulation atomic force microscopy when the dissolved gas concentration is below the saturation level. The bright patches, suspected to be caused by adsorption of nitrogen molecules at the graphite-water interface, are composed of domains of a rowlike structure with the row separation of 4.2 ± 0.3 nm. The observation of this ordered adlayer might underline the gas segregation at various water interfaces.

Imaging surface nanobubbles at graphite–water interfaces with different atomic force microscopy modes

We have imaged nanobubbles on highly ordered pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) surfaces in pure water with different atomic force microscopy (AFM) modes, including the frequency-modulation, the tapping, and the PeakForce techniques. We have compared the performance of these modes in obtaining the surface profiles of nanobubbles. The frequency-modulation mode yields a larger height value than the other two modes and can provide more accurate measurement of the surface profiles of nanobubbles. Imaging with PeakForce mode shows that a nanobubble appears smaller and shorter with increasing peak force and disappears above a certain peak force, but the size returns to the original value when the peak force is reduced. This indicates that imaging with high peak forces does not cause gas removal from the nanobubbles. Based on the presented findings and previous AFM observations, the existing models for nanobubbles are reviewed and discussed. The model of gas aggregate inside nanobubbles provides a better explanation for the puzzles of the high stability and the contact angle of surface nanobubbles.

Interface-Induced Ordering of Gas Molecules Confined in a Small Space

The thermodynamic properties of gases have been understood primarily through phase diagrams of bulk gases. However, observations of gases confined in a nanometer space have posed a challenge to the principles of classical thermodynamics. Here, we investigated interfacial structures comprising either O2 or N2 between water and a hydrophobic solid surface by using advanced atomic force microscopy techniques. Ordered epitaxial layers and cap-shaped nanostructures were observed. In addition, pancake-shaped disordered layers that had grown on top of the epitaxial base layers were observed in oxygen-supersaturated water. We propose that hydrophobic solid surfaces provide low-chemical-potential sites at which gas molecules dissolved in water can be adsorbed. The structures are further stabilized by interfacial water. Here we show that gas molecules can agglomerate into a condensed form when confined in a sufficiently small space under ambient conditions. The crystalline solid surface may even induce a solid-gas state when the gas-substrate interaction is significantly stronger than the gas-gas interaction. The ordering and thermodynamic properties of the confined gases are determined primarily according to interfacial interactions.

Condensation of Dissolved Gas Molecules at a Hydrophobic/Water Interface

The non-wetting phenomenon of water on certain solid surfaces has been under intensive study for decades, but the nature of the hydrophobic/water interfaces remains controversial. Here a water/graphite interface is investigated with high-sensitivity atomic force microscopy. We show evidence of nucleation and growth of an epitaxial monolayer on the graphite surface, probably caused by the adsorption of nitrogen molecules dissolved in water. The subsequent adsorption process resembles the layer-plus-island, or Stranski-Krastanov, growth mode in heteroepitaxy. This finding underlines the importance of gas segregation at various water interfaces and may unravel many puzzles, especially the nature and the high stability of so-called nanobubbles at solid/water interfaces and in bulk water. Based on the hydrophobic effect, we propose that gas molecules dissolved in water may aggregate into clusters in bulk water as well as at solid/water interfaces. As a cluster grows above a critical size, it undergoes a transition into a gas bubble, which can explain the formation or nucleation of gas bubbles in water.

Nucleation processes of nanobubbles at a solid/water interface.

Experimental investigations of hydrophobic/water interfaces often return controversial results, possibly due to the unknown role of gas accumulation at the interfaces. Here, during advanced atomic force microscopy of the initial evolution of gas-containing structures at a highly ordered pyrolytic graphite/water interface, a fluid phase first appeared as a circular wetting layer ~0.3 nm in thickness and was later transformed into a cap-shaped nanostructure (an interfacial nanobubble). Two-dimensional ordered domains were nucleated and grew over time outside or at the perimeter of the fluid regions, eventually confining growth of the fluid regions to the vertical direction. We determined that interfacial nanobubbles and fluid layers have very similar mechanical properties, suggesting low interfacial tension with water and a liquid-like nature, explaining their high stability and their roles in boundary slip and bubble nucleation. These ordered domains may be the interfacial hydrophilic gas hydrates and/or the long-sought chemical surface heterogeneities responsible for contact line pinning and contact angle hysteresis. The gradual nucleation and growth of hydrophilic ordered domains renders the original homogeneous hydrophobic/water interface more heterogeneous over time, which would have great consequence for interfacial properties that affect diverse phenomena, including interactions in water, chemical reactions, and the self-assembly and function of biological molecules.

Lateral Force Microscopy of Interfacial Nanobubbles: Friction Reduction and Novel Frictional Behavior

Atomic force microscopy is used to conduct single-asperity friction measurements at a water-graphite interface. Local mapping of the frictional force, which is based on the degree of the cantilever twisting, shows nearly friction-free when a tip scans over a nanobubble. Surprisingly, apart from being gapless, the associated friction loop exhibits a tilt in the cantilever twisting versus the tip’s lateral displacement with the slope depending on the loading force. The sign of the slope reverses at around zero loading force. In addition, the measured normal and lateral tip-sample interactions exhibit unison versus tip-sample separation. Theoretical analysis, based on the balance of forces on the tip originated from the capillary force of the nanobubble and the torsion of the cantilever, offers quantitative explanations for both the tilted friction loop and the unison of force curves. The analysis may well apply in a wider context to the lateral force characterization on cap-shaped fluid structures such as liquid droplets on a solid substrate. This study further points to a new direction for friction reduction between solids in a liquid medium.